Need a PCI SATA II Controller Card

SAgosto

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 28, 2007
Messages
491
I have the following motherboard (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...56&cm_re=GA-MA69GM-S2H-_-13-128-056-_-Product) but only a PCI-E X4 and a PCI slot to use.

I have various SATA II Hard Drives that I need to connect and I ran out of room on the motherboard. I seem to have more options with the PCI than the PCI-E X4. Can I get some recommendations? Will PCI support the speed necessary for the SATA II Hard Drives?

Thanks.
 
Peak transfer rate of PCI is 133 MB/s. So one HDD transferring at a time should be okay. Are you doing any RAID? Two or more HDDs transferring simultaneously and the PCI bus will begin to be a bottleneck. Your PCI-e x4 slot will have a lot more bandwidth (1000 MB/s if it is version 1)
 
No RAID. Just need more ways to plug in my new SATA II HDs

It's for my HTPC so it will primarily be used just to watch movies. Perhaps some MP3s? I won't be moving much data around except for watching/listening.

I can't seem to find a fairly priced PCI-E X4 card.
 
That would be overkill unless you have SATA 6Gbps drives that you will run from the card (or need some USB 3.0 ports). But I just checked newegg, and most of the SATA 3Gbps cards are around $20. The 6 Gbps one you found for $26 looks like a pretty good deal in comparison. Note that the Asus card is PCIe Gen2. I think it should downshift to Gen1 if your motherboard does not support Gen2, but I have never tried putting a Gen2 card in a Gen1 slot myself.

By the way, you can also put a PCIe x1 card in your x4 slot. A single lane of PCIe Gen1 is 250 MB/s, so even that gives you more bandwidth than a PCI card. But from what you have written about your usage, I think even a PCI card would be sufficient.
 
Last edited:
By the way, you can also put a PCI-e x1 card in your x4 slot. A single lane of PCI-e 1.0 is 250 MB/s, so even that gives you more bandwidth than a PCI card.

I didn't know this! Would 250MB/S be perfectly capable of just watching Blu-Ray and listening to MP3? I already have the card but I didn't even try to put it in after I realized my board didn't have the slot.

I really don't care much if I have to wait longer for file transfers which will happen rarely. I am just watching movies and listening to MP3s and maybe have some pictures on it.

Also, does it make more sense to connect my Blu-Ray drive or my SATA II Hard Drive?
 
I don't think there are any Bluray players, and very few HDDs, that are capable of transferring faster than 133 MB/s. You should be fine with either. Personally, I'd probably connect the Bluray to the card, since I feel a little safer having HDDs connected to the motherboard ports.
 
So, what's the point of these specifications for SATA II that support 3GB/S if the hard drives can't push the data that fast? Unless I am missing something.

The only issue that bothers me is if the Blu-Ray drive is not available until after boot-up due to this card. I am sure I will need to use the Blu-Ray as a bootable device sometimes.
 
SATA 3Gbps, with a small 'b', meaning 3 Gigabits per second. But it uses 8b/10b encoding, so a top speed of 300 MB/s, with a large 'B', meaning 300 MegaBytes per second.

But unless you have an SSD, your devices won't be able to come close to 300 MB/s. The fastest HDDs (15K rpm) can approach 150 MB/s for large sequential transfers, but most HDDs max out around 100-120 MB/s.

Some of the SATA cards can be used to boot from an HDD or an optical drive. But why worry about it in your case? You could always switch the optical drive to a motherboard port if it does not work on the card.
 
PCI means sucky performance and high interrupt usage. Never use PCI for RAID array.
 
go with the supermicro $100 PCI-x (not PCIe) 8 port card and just use it in a PCI slot....

and what is this idea that you are more comfortable with hdds on the motherboard than a controller card?
 
Back
Top