Need a KVM Setup

KatalDT

2[H]4U
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
2,567
Hiya,

I do a lot of work from home (have my dev environment set up here) and it's a little unwieldy to deal with multiple keyboards/mice on my desk. I have three monitors of varying sizes mounted on my desk, and I'd like to drop it to one keyboard, one mouse, and two screens.

Preferred Setup:
A: Work/Gaming
B: Work
C: Windows Server - Primarily for VMs and batch file processing
D: Linux Server (CentOS) - Generally where I mess around with stuff. Also my personal file server, torrent box, DLNA server, SABnzbd - most of this is accessed remotely via HTTP and I shell in quite often with PuTTY, but I like to have access to the desktop anyway.

Screen 1: 27"
Screen 2: 24"

PC A will *ALWAYS* be on Screen 1
PC B, C, and D will share Screen 2

However, I still want 4 settings on the KVM. Setting 1 will only have the keyboard/mouse going to PC A, without utilizing video (ie. video straight from PC A to Screen 1).

Settings 2/3/4 will use the same mouse/keyboard, but the video will be handled via that KVM. (So PC B/C/D video -> KVM -> Screen 2)

I'd also like a really minimal delay... most of the ones I've seen have several seconds in delay for the mouse and keyboard to switch over. I'm wondering if there are any reasonable ones that are very quick - the only ones I've ever used that are very quick to swap mouse/keyboard control are the enterprise level ones, which is a bit out of my price range. :)

Thanks!
 
USB or PS2?

Well, my mouse and keyboard as USB, but I don't mind using converters for PS2 - especially if that would speed up the swapping.

I'm using VNC right now for the Linux box when I *need* desktop access (which isn't often but it happens) and even on a gigabit network VNC still feels so slow...
 
I just read your description of what you want to do three times and I still can't figure it out.

Multi-station KVMs are expensive - I use a 2 station USB KVM ($29) to switch only the mouse and keyboard and it can take up to 5 seconds for the devices to be re-activated on a system.

From the research I have done, the KVM market pretty much sucks - I wanted a USB/DVI switch that would let me swap all 3 screens (DVI) and a USB Mouse/KB between 2 computers. Sounds simple right? Never could find one that did that - they would be DVI/PS2 or VGA/USB or just 2 ports, etc.

Once you get beyond 2 stations, it can get real expensive.
 
I just read your description of what you want to do three times and I still can't figure it out.

Multi-station KVMs are expensive - I use a 2 station USB KVM ($29) to switch only the mouse and keyboard and it can take up to 5 seconds for the devices to be re-activated on a system.

From the research I have done, the KVM market pretty much sucks - I wanted a USB/DVI switch that would let me swap all 3 screens (DVI) and a USB Mouse/KB between 2 computers. Sounds simple right? Never could find one that did that - they would be DVI/PS2 or VGA/USB or just 2 ports, etc.

Once you get beyond 2 stations, it can get real expensive.

I should have mentioned a price range - $150-$200 or so, less is better obviously. Not looking for a $20 unit.

Sorry it's not very clear.. hopefully this wonderful paint image will explain it. Blue lines are mouse/keyboard, red lines are video:

illustrationk.jpg
 
hmmm, if you could live with 2 keyboards and mouses and didn't mind converting to PS2 I could hook you up for next to nothing.

To actually conform to your diagram?...I dunno, good luck
 
hmmm, if you could live with 2 keyboards and mouses and didn't mind converting to PS2 I could hook you up for next to nothing.

To actually conform to your diagram?...I dunno, good luck

That would be better than what I'm working with right now, so what's the possibilities with that? (With fast switching too, if that's possible)

PS2 converters are completely fine.
 
I have a box full of old 3 station switches...I'll try to dig it out today

as far as switching speed, no idea, my guess is that is actually a USB limitation in the systems themselves.
 
Indeed. The reason newer switches take a while to "switch" is because KVMs no longer emulate the presence of the KB/Mouse since USB is plug and play. So whenever you switch, it actually disconnects them. This is the only reason I've kept my 4-port PS2 KVM for so long. My setup was similar to yours before, but my main PC utilized both screens, not just one -- so my extended display would disappear whenever I switched. I agree the wait time for USB KVMs is annoying, but I live with it at work, since my Dell mouse does not work with a USB to PS2 converter, and also most Dells lack PS2 ports these days, lol.

People always recommend Synergy, but I've yet to try it.
 
Indeed. The reason newer switches take a while to "switch" is because KVMs no longer emulate the presence of the KB/Mouse since USB is plug and play. So whenever you switch, it actually disconnects them. This is the only reason I've kept my 4-port PS2 KVM for so long. My setup was similar to yours before, but my main PC utilized both screens, not just one -- so my extended display would disappear whenever I switched. I agree the wait time for USB KVMs is annoying, but I live with it at work, since my Dell mouse does not work with a USB to PS2 converter, and also most Dells lack PS2 ports these days, lol.

People always recommend Synergy, but I've yet to try it.

I did try Synergy, but not only did it lag, but the mouse/keyboard would mess up pretty hardcore if I was gaming. I'd be waiting on a job to finish and play a round of BF2 while waiting, then switch back to check something and my game screen would go bonkers or just completely fail to switch.
 
I did try Synergy, but not only did it lag, but the mouse/keyboard would mess up pretty hardcore if I was gaming. I'd be waiting on a job to finish and play a round of BF2 while waiting, then switch back to check something and my game screen would go bonkers or just completely fail to switch.

lol, that sux. yah, i like my metal encased DKVM-4 from D-Link. :D The only issue I have now is I have a separate mouse for gaming because my good mouse doesn't work too well with the PS2 adapter. :rolleyes:
 
I'd recommend a good remote desktop program. mRemoteNG handles multiple protocols in one interface- it's what I use to connect to Windows/Apple/Linux/Etch-A-Sketch. You can't beat the price and it's the only way I can think of to actually meet your requirements. Switching speed is as fast as switching tabs in your browser.
 
Back
Top