• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

NAS or a SFF computer

hluo87

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 19, 2011
Messages
64
Hi all
I am currently having a netgear ultra plus 2 bay NAS and i am wondering should i sell it and get a SFF computer instead?
I mainly use my NAS for downloading movies and connect to my apple tv.
any idea?
thanks.
 
Does your NAS currently do everything you want it to do?

BENEFIT OF YOUR CURRENT NAS
You already own it, so no extra cost or time involved.
Probably takes up less space, less electricity and makes less noise than a typical SFF server.

BENEFIT OF SFF COMPUTER
It is an opportunity for you to reassess your needs.
Can have storage and operational capabilities beyond your NAS.
 
Does your NAS currently do everything you want it to do?

BENEFIT OF YOUR CURRENT NAS
You already own it, so no extra cost or time involved.
Probably takes up less space, less electricity and makes less noise than a typical SFF server.

BENEFIT OF SFF COMPUTER
It is an opportunity for you to reassess your needs.
Can have storage and operational capabilities beyond your NAS.

thanks zap
since right now i want my nas also server as a HTPC, however, this nas cannot do that..
space it not an issue for mee
 
Ahhh, that's a good reason to replace it. Maybe. What you can do is to build an HTPC and still use the NAS, unless you plan to add more drives. Also, how will you use the HTPC? Will it only play back media files? Will it stream online content? HD video? For instance, if nothing will be HD, you can easily get away with an AMD E-series APU for lower cost and power savings. Otherwise you will want to go with probably the lowest end AMD A-series APU (socket FM2, since FM1 is the older platform/APU) or lowest end dual core Intel socket 1155. Either of these should be sufficient for playback of up to 1080P HD video whether from files or streaming online, unless the video has some crazy super high bitrate.

For HTPC, do you have an existing space for it? For instance, will it sit on the ground? Will it be in a typical equipment rack with an AV receiver? How many HDD bays will you eventually want to have? What's your overall budget for this whole mess?

The above paragraph will help determine the case you get. Once we know the case, we can then choose the platform/motherboard.
 
Ahhh, that's a good reason to replace it. Maybe. What you can do is to build an HTPC and still use the NAS, unless you plan to add more drives. Also, how will you use the HTPC? Will it only play back media files? Will it stream online content? HD video? For instance, if nothing will be HD, you can easily get away with an AMD E-series APU for lower cost and power savings. Otherwise you will want to go with probably the lowest end AMD A-series APU (socket FM2, since FM1 is the older platform/APU) or lowest end dual core Intel socket 1155. Either of these should be sufficient for playback of up to 1080P HD video whether from files or streaming online, unless the video has some crazy super high bitrate.

For HTPC, do you have an existing space for it? For instance, will it sit on the ground? Will it be in a typical equipment rack with an AV receiver? How many HDD bays will you eventually want to have? What's your overall budget for this whole mess?

The above paragraph will help determine the case you get. Once we know the case, we can then choose the platform/motherboard.

thanks zap!!!awesome!!1

as a nas, it will do downloading, server a blog i guess, i may do online streaming of videos stored in my nas(my favor) i used to own a synology ds212j which can do that
as a HTPC, it will play HD videos, play some games maybe(war3), no much through,
i may also want to use it as a karaoke system for my wife...(i plan to buy a Onkyo HT-S5500)
for power assumption, i hear that a nas is only 30-40watts/h, about SFFS
my budget depends on how much i can sell my NAS.....lol
around $300+100 from me
 
war3 = Warcraft III ???

Your needs aren't that demanding. Again, starting with the case choice, do you want it to match the Onkyo receiver that you plan on buying? That is, black and similar width/height so that the look of your home theater area stays congruent. One possible choice is a Silverstone GD06. It supports four HDDs, micro ATX motherboards, normal ATX PSUs (up to 150mm so short ones only).

For parts, socket 1155 with a low end dual core will give you the performance you need along with energy savings. With Warcraft III you probably don't need more than the integrated graphics.
 
war3 = Warcraft III ???

Your needs aren't that demanding. Again, starting with the case choice, do you want it to match the Onkyo receiver that you plan on buying? That is, black and similar width/height so that the look of your home theater area stays congruent. One possible choice is a Silverstone GD06. It supports four HDDs, micro ATX motherboards, normal ATX PSUs (up to 150mm so short ones only).

For parts, socket 1155 with a low end dual core will give you the performance you need along with energy savings. With Warcraft III you probably don't need more than the integrated graphics.

thanks again for your advice. :)
i like lianli better. but i will take a look at the case you mentioned.
micro atx or mini atx which one is betteR?
 
Lian Li makes the PC-C50B which costs more, but is very similar sized. In fact, I use one of these for my own HTPC. Only problem is that I'm not sure they've updated the USB 3.0 ports on it. On mine, they plug into the rear ports and not the motherboard headers, which IMO is fail. The Silverstone cases have aluminum faces so they look good, plus the updated ones have USB 3.0 that plugs into motherboard headers (according to specs).

I think you meant "micro ATX or mini ITX." Choose your case first, then choose the normal motherboard for the case. For instance the Silverstone GD04/05/06 and the Lian Li PC-C50B all can take either mini ITX or micro ATX. For these, however, I would recommend micro ATX because you will usually get more SATA ports, more RAM slots, more expansion slots, etc.

I totally don't have a problem with mini ITX. In fact I love that form factor. However, I also like matching the motherboard to the case, and I like matching the case to the use (in your case HTPC with a receiver).
 
Lian Li makes the PC-C50B which costs more, but is very similar sized. In fact, I use one of these for my own HTPC. Only problem is that I'm not sure they've updated the USB 3.0 ports on it. On mine, they plug into the rear ports and not the motherboard headers, which IMO is fail. The Silverstone cases have aluminum faces so they look good, plus the updated ones have USB 3.0 that plugs into motherboard headers (according to specs).

I think you meant "micro ATX or mini ITX." Choose your case first, then choose the normal motherboard for the case. For instance the Silverstone GD04/05/06 and the Lian Li PC-C50B all can take either mini ITX or micro ATX. For these, however, I would recommend micro ATX because you will usually get more SATA ports, more RAM slots, more expansion slots, etc.

I totally don't have a problem with mini ITX. In fact I love that form factor. However, I also like matching the motherboard to the case, and I like matching the case to the use (in your case HTPC with a receiver).

yes, i like mini itx because of this form factor. :)
so i should start to with case first....btw, how about the air flow in the case... any advice which one is better?
 
Lian Li makes the PC-C50B which costs more, but is very similar sized. In fact, I use one of these for my own HTPC. Only problem is that I'm not sure they've updated the USB 3.0 ports on it. On mine, they plug into the rear ports and not the motherboard headers, which IMO is fail. The Silverstone cases have aluminum faces so they look good, plus the updated ones have USB 3.0 that plugs into motherboard headers (according to specs).

I think you meant "micro ATX or mini ITX." Choose your case first, then choose the normal motherboard for the case. For instance the Silverstone GD04/05/06 and the Lian Li PC-C50B all can take either mini ITX or micro ATX. For these, however, I would recommend micro ATX because you will usually get more SATA ports, more RAM slots, more expansion slots, etc.

I totally don't have a problem with mini ITX. In fact I love that form factor. However, I also like matching the motherboard to the case, and I like matching the case to the use (in your case HTPC with a receiver).

also, about the power regular atx power is good or i can use ac-dc adapter which would save me more on energy. :) and the board is smaller right?
 
Back
Top