N00B Questions about SSD's

If you are choosing between the Intel and OCZ Vertex 2, definitely go for the OCZ. I have both and the OCZ is noticeable more responsive. The Intel drives were very good when they came out, but the Sandforce based drives are simply faster. Also, the C300 is way overrated. Sequential speeds are a very poor indicator of performance, unless the only thing you to is copy large files to and from the drive. Random read/write numbers are a very good indicator of how fast a drive "feels."
 
The reason why OCZ and (to a lesser extent) Sandforce SSDs have not been recommended recently is because their real-world performance don't match their advertised speeds. Intel has been recommended on a reliability standpoint, but Crucial isn't overrated.
 
The reason why OCZ and (to a lesser extent) Sandforce SSDs have not been recommended recently is because their real-world performance don't match their advertised speeds.

Is that the main beef with OCZ? So OCZ advertises more than they can deliver, and Intel delivers what it advertises. But if we ignore what's being advertised by either company, and look solely at their actual real world performance... does either one have a noticeable edge over the other?

As someone who has no idea who advertised what, and isn't tech enough to even know how to read benchmark results... I'm really just interested in the bottom line. If the company that advertised 10x faster speeds than the competition end up delivering only 2x better, I won't boycott them out of principle over their false advertising. I just care about their bottom line. As long as they're faster, I don't really care by how much, or how inflated the numbers were in the ads. Not sure if I'm making any sense to anyone but me. :)

A lot has been written in this thread and I believe I've wrapped my head around most of it... I just want to make sure I'm not avoiding OCZ out of "principle" over false advertising. If I'm going Intel, it has to be because Intel delivers better bottom-line performance.

You and Danny agree this to be the case, right? Just as dotCapone clearly disagrees.

So we have 2 people claiming the Vertex 2 won't perform as well as the X25-M in real world scenarios, and 1 person (who has tried both) claiming the opposite. But all 3 probably agree I would benefit from waiting until the next generation (which I can't afford to do).

Not everyone will agree on everything, this is normal in a forum. I just want to make sure I understand everyone's positions.
 
Danny may have more to add, but basically, the Crucial C300 is recommended for performance and the Intel X25-M is recommended for reliability. I personally wouldn't recommend OCZ to anyone, but IIRC, SSDs using the Sandforce controllers aren't that much better than Intel's (but I need to remember the review that I saw earlier that made that point).

Seriously, though, you may want to wait (if you can) for the newer SSDs from Intel and Crucial to arrive.
 
I don't suppose anyone here would know where I can find the Asus U3S6 card in Canada? I've looked everywhere.
 
I don't suppose anyone here would know where I can find the Asus U3S6 card in Canada? I've looked everywhere.

The card is pretty bad.

Read a few reviews to find out if it will meet your needs.

I used mine for 1 day and put it back in the box.

I haven't found any cheap SATA 6 Gb/s solution and went with an LSI 9240-4i card.
 
Hi Hippie,

I have no idea what that LSI card is, even after clicking the link. I'm still new to most of this, I'm afraid.
 
Hi Hippie,

I have no idea what that LSI card is, even after clicking the link. I'm still new to most of this, I'm afraid.

The card offers faster SATA ports like the Asus U3S6 but doesn't hinder performance like the Asus U3S6.

I thought you wanted the Asus card for the SATAIII ports and it doesn't work well for that.
 
So you're suggesting I'd also get better throughput with this same card, then? How much of a difference are we talking about? I'm intrigued.
 
It seems like you are starting to overthink this. You have been given some great advice but 'paralization through analization" has occured.

Get the C300 128GB drive and use it with your motherboard SATA II connectors for now. The speed will blow you away and the drives are very reliable too (intel are slightly more reliable but not as fast. OCZ pulled a stunt and put the 25nm memory in their drives and the speeds dropped significantly but they advertised the old higher read/write speeds - that is why everyone is saying avoid OCZ)

You can put in a SATA III ad on card later if you feel like you want to.

You will not regret getting the C300 at all.
 
I'm receiving my C300 128GB tomorrow. My first SSD and I'm replacing a WD 6400AAKS. I'll post back my thoughts.
 
You're right, cmanser. But this is really the only way I sleep easy at night. ;) Once I make a purchase, I never second guess myself... because I did plenty of it in the days leading up to said purchase.

I fully intend to get the C300 soon as the order comes in at my closest brick & mortar (they expect to get it tomorrow).

Does anyone have any tips regarding installation and/or firmware updating? The plan right now is to just bring it home, plug it in, and immediately install Windows 7 64b on it. Is this the right way to do it, or should I look at updating the firmware BEFORE installing the OS? I've heard rumors that some firmware updates are destructive (ie, force you to format the drive) which just sounds crazy to me... I'd hate to have to format after installing all my programs there.
 
Back
Top