My XP-120 review

lopoetve

Extremely [H]
2FA
Joined
Oct 11, 2001
Messages
34,263
0/10

That's right, ZERO. Zilch, nada, zip.

Why? Because Thermalright claims it works on an Abit AV8, but it does not. There is no way to get it to make the appropriate contact, or something else is seriously wrong with the design, because installing it on my system makes the system no longer boot.

And if that wasn't bad enough, mine came with a defective Retention Module that had a cracked fan hooking place, and it came right off 5 min into testing. Just popped off and flew out at me.


Oh, and the screws they ship with it are the wrong length as well. Totally useless.


Sounds like a good product to me. I'm back on my Retail HSF from AMD and loving it. I can't OC worth a damn, but booting > OCing.

Sigh... why can't this fucking computer just work right? I'm about 2" from buying a dell... I just want a system that works so I can do my work...
 
lopoetve said:
0/10

That's right, ZERO. Zilch, nada, zip.

Why? Because Thermalright claims it works on an Abit AV8, but it does not. There is no way to get it to make the appropriate contact, or something else is seriously wrong with the design, because installing it on my system makes the system no longer boot.

...

Oh, and the screws they ship with it are the wrong length as well. Totally useless.

Take it off and try again.

The problem is with your installation, not with the heatsink itself, and assuming that it is is really very arrogant.

I had no problems getting the heatsink on my Asus A8V. Neither were the screws 'the wrong length'.

Have another go, chuck, then try reviewing it when you've actually managed to use it properly.



Sigh... why can't this fucking computer just work right? I'm about 2" from buying a dell... I just want a system that works so I can do my work...

Then maybe you should have bought a pre-built system? If you're not up to putting it together, then don't try?
 
Arseface said:
Take it off and try again.

The problem is with your installation, not with the heatsink itself, and assuming that it is is really very arrogant.

I had no problems getting the heatsink on my Asus A8V. Neither were the screws 'the wrong length'.

Have another go, chuck, then try reviewing it when you've actually managed to use it properly.





Then maybe you should have bought a pre-built system? If you're not up to putting it together, then don't try?

The installation is per their instructions. the screws are physically not long enough for the AV8 backplate. You've got a totally different system, buddy.

The fact remains: They advertized it as working with this combination, and it does not

As for the prebuilt, I'm leaning that way. It appears that there are fewer and fewer decent parts makers out there as time goes by. I miss the days of the PII and PIII's, where everything just WORKED.
 
lopoetve said:
The installation is per their instructions. the screws are physically not long enough for the AV8 backplate. You've got a totally different system, buddy.

The fact remains: They advertized it as working with this combination, and it does not

As for the prebuilt, I'm leaning that way. It appears that there are fewer and fewer decent parts makers out there as time goes by. I miss the days of the PII and PIII's, where everything just WORKED.

both of you are using asus AV8..
 
lopoetve said:
No. He is using an Asus A8V.

I'm using an Abit AV8

Confusing, eh?
Damn, confusing as fuck. I had to look twice at those names before they registered as different. Although I don't see it listed on Thermalright's site as compataible but I don't see alot of A64 boards either.... oh wait I found it. Where does it say that the AV8 is supported?

You should have read some reviews on it, this was the first from a Google search.
There will be some potential clearance issues with the XP-120 that you should be aware about depending on the motherboard layout. On our MSI K8N motherboard, using Corsair ProSeries ram we were not able to fit the heatsink as the ends of the heatpipes would bump into the ram modules preventing heatsink installation. Standard ram modules corrected this issue.

Outside of the ram, motherboard compatibility may be another concern depending on the design of the board. We had problems with an ABIT KV8-MAX3 board, where the capacitors interfered with installation. It would be a good idea to read over Thermalright's compatibility list for Pentium 4s and Athlon 64/FX boards on their site. There is also a possibility that PSU placement in some cases may interfere with installation, especially if the motherboard tends to be flush with the PSU.

I don't think you should really blame Thermalright for Abit building the board.
 
I, too, found that the screws that came with it were too short. But then again, I have a totally different motherboard type manufacturer. But my problem probably was because of ASUS's stack cool on the bottom.
 
It worked great with my Abit AV8. I can't use my first dimm slot.

I wasn't to impressed with the temps tho. It didn't really do much more than my stock heatsink. I'm going to give it another chance with a better fan tho.
 
lopoetve said:
No. He is using an Asus A8V.

I'm using an Abit AV8

Confusing, eh?

Believe it or not, I have both :p

I bought the Abit while the Asus was in RMA.

I've got to sell the Abit now though, as I'm using the Asus.
 
Well I am getting one in a few days...I'll post my outcome, but then again I have a MSI board..
 
CrimandEvil said:
Damn, confusing as fuck. I had to look twice at those names before they registered as different. Although I don't see it listed on Thermalright's site as compataible but I don't see alot of A64 boards either.... oh wait I found it. Where does it say that the AV8 is supported?

You should have read some reviews on it, this was the first from a Google search.


I don't think you should really blame Thermalright for Abit building the board.

It says it's supported. First one on the list you linked to ;)
 
If there's anyway to get it working, it's great. On my K8N Neo, I can sneak my ram right underneath it...actually it's like active cooling for my memory and CPU all in one :D Once I get new memory, I might have to remove the heatspreaders tho...hope I can sneak those in as well, seems like there's plenty of room left above the bare Kingston I have now.
 
tsuehpsyde said:
If there's anyway to get it working, it's great. On my K8N Neo, I can sneak my ram right underneath it...actually it's like active cooling for my memory and CPU all in one :D Once I get new memory, I might have to remove the heatspreaders tho...hope I can sneak those in as well, seems like there's plenty of room left above the bare Kingston I have now.

The HSF completely blocks the first 2 slots for memory, but that's fine, I knew it would be that way when I bought it.

I just wish I knew why installing it made it not boot. Literally, I take it off and put the retail HSF on and it came right back. Put the XP-120 on, everything screwed down tight and full contact, and nothing...

WTF.


And why doesn't the Abit uGuru program work anymore?!? :( And why not make it so you can see temps/voltages in bios, instead of just in windows? I have no way of checking my temps now.

sigh..
 
yea the Abit mobos are REALLY shady with the XP-120, like the retention clip and the screwes dont fit, you need ot use different screwes and its stupid, abit isn't too great. So I got my self an asus A8V and the XP-120 goes ontop of teh 4-pin power thing on the mobo, so the molex form my ultra x-connect WOULD NOT FIT!!! DAMN IT! I WAS SOO PISSED OFF!, I took the cooler off just to find that it was all scratched up from the bottom. and then I had like squeeze the 4-pin molex into the the plug onto the mobo and then lap teh HSF AGAIN! and then re-apply AS5 and then THE DAMN THING BARELY FIT! but, it fit...... and temps are great on a 1200RPM fan... so can't complain i guess......
 
why dont you just get an XP-90 instead of an XP-120. I think the XP-120 is just overkill. The XP-90 performs prolly just as well for less. Plus it is a bit smaller and more compatible.
 
54YW4T said:
why dont you just get an XP-90 instead of an XP-120. I think the XP-120 is just overkill. The XP-90 performs prolly just as well for less. Plus it is a bit smaller and more compatible.

Yea i wouldn't recommend the XP-120 to anyone. Its too big and the motherboards it will fit on is limited. The XP-90 cools just as well as the XP-120. Check the reviews at www.silentpcreview.com. You would be lucky to see a couple degrees celcius difference between the two. You can install a Vantec Tornado 92mm on the XP-90 and you'll have the best aircooling solution you can buy right there.
 
I'd recommend the XP-120 to anyone that it fits for. I wouldn't purcahse a motherboard around it, but I mean I'm running a clawhammer A64 200MHz over stock w/ 1.6v and I'm loading at 45C right now and might go up to 47C max after an hour or so...and my AS5 has only been on there about 36 hours out of the '200' hour burn-in cycle. I think it's a really good cooler, but it's just REALLY big :p
 
Yea i wouldn't recommend the XP-120 to anyone. Its too big and the motherboards it will fit on is limited. The XP-90 cools just as well as the XP-120. Check the reviews at www.silentpcreview.com. You would be lucky to see a couple degrees celcius difference between the two. You can install a Vantec Tornado 92mm on the XP-90 and you'll have the best aircooling solution you can buy right there.
I have a 92mm vantec tornado on my SI-97 and it is like a hair dryer. i can barely hear myself with that damn fan on.
 
lopoetve said:
0/10

That's right, ZERO. Zilch, nada, zip.

Why? Because Thermalright claims it works on an Abit AV8, but it does not. There is no way to get it to make the appropriate contact, or something else is seriously wrong with the design, because installing it on my system makes the system no longer boot.

And if that wasn't bad enough, mine came with a defective Retention Module that had a cracked fan hooking place, and it came right off 5 min into testing. Just popped off and flew out at me.


Oh, and the screws they ship with it are the wrong length as well. Totally useless.


Sounds like a good product to me. I'm back on my Retail HSF from AMD and loving it. I can't OC worth a damn, but booting > OCing.

Sigh... why can't this fucking computer just work right? I'm about 2" from buying a dell... I just want a system that works so I can do my work...


I know EXACTLY what you mean, I've gone through HELL getting my system up.
 
54YW4T said:
why dont you just get an XP-90 instead of an XP-120. I think the XP-120 is just overkill. The XP-90 performs prolly just as well for less. Plus it is a bit smaller and more compatible.

Because I was going for silent... tired of all the 80 and 90mm fans sounding loud as fuck. My case is all ultra-silent 120's, with one side-mounted quiet 90, and I want to KEEP it that way. The stock HSF is loud compared to the others.
 
Back
Top