My planned build - Opinions?

Black300zx

n00b
Joined
Nov 25, 2009
Messages
42
After too many hours of research over the past 4-6 months and a couple different planned builds, I think I've finally settled on the setup that will be best suited for my uses (much thanks to the introduction of the Core i5-750 ;))

1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Photo editing, 3d CAD work, playing music through my stereo, and possibly some FEA. More specifically, I'll be editing RAW images in Lightroom 2, using Pro/Engineer for CAD work, and if I wind up bringing some work home in the future, I'll be doing some FEA work using Abaqus 6.8. Lightroom 2 multithreads, while Pro/E and Abaqus do not. Music will be send to my A/V receiver via Toslink.

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
For the remaining components I need, approximately $4-600

3) Where do you live?
Suburbs of Philadelphia

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
Parts that need to be purchased with the $4-600 budget include CPU, RAM, Mobo, and graphics card.

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
I already have the case, PSU, optical drive, monitor, and the internal card reader. I also have a PCI sound card with a Toslink output if it is for some reason needed (my planned mobo has one on the back panel). The mouse and keyboard will also be carried over from my current computer. The 250GB IDE HDD which I currently am using will continue to be used until I build the RAID1 setup. Specifics can be found below.

6) Will you be overclocking?
Possibly. If I do overclock, I will likely leave the voltage at stock specs.

7) What size monitor do you have and/or plan to have?
I'm using a 28" (1920x1200) as monitor and TV. Down the road I do plan on moving the computer into a different room. When that happens, I'll likely purchase a 23 or 24" monitor with 1920x1200 resolution (or whatever is the highest available resolution at that time).

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Over the next 2-3 months. Some of the components will likely be given as x-mas gift suggestions. What ever is left after the holidays will then be purchased.

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
I will be setting up a dedicated RAID 1 to store my photos on in the future. This will likely happen in 2-3 months.

10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license?
For the time being, I will be loading a 64 bit copy of Windows 7 RC1 onto the machine. I will purchase a copy sometime before the RC1 expires.


My planned build:

Case: Antec P180 mini (purchased)
Power Supply: Corsair 650TX (purchased)
CPU: Intel Core i5 (not purchased - $200)
Heatsink: Stock for now, will upgrade if I find the need to OC
Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-P55M-UD2 (not purchased - $110)
Memory: CORSAIR XMS3 4GB (2 x 2GB) DDR3 1600 (not purchased - $100) If I wind up doing alot of FEA at home, I may add a second kit for a total of 8GB
Graphics Card: ATI FireGL V3600 (not purchased - $165)
Boot HDD: 36Gb WD Raptor (carried over, may upgrade if I fill it up)
Storage HDD(s): (2) 1TB or 1.5TB drives in RAID1
Internal card reader: Rosewill RCR-IC002 (purchased)
Optical drive: Sony Lightscribe DVD/RW (purchased)

I believe this about covers it. Just to give a little background, the guts of my current computer are a Dell Dimension 4600 from 2004. It's a 2.8 P4 with 1.5Gb of mixed ram. These guts are installed in the Antec P180 mini, along with the other components which have already been purchased. The next step in this computer build will be to actually replace the guts that have been carried over from my old Dell, those being the CPU, Mobo, RAM, and graphics card. I feel like I have done adequate research on these components, but I'd like to hear some input from more experienced people, as this will be my first complete computer build.

Thanks for any input!
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
IIRC, there's a Microcenter in your city somewhere, lol. If so, they have the i5 750 for $150, the i7 860 for $230, and the i7 920 LGA1366 for $200. If you're within driving distance, I'd suggest the 920 and an MSI X58M along with 6GB of 1.5v DDR3-1333 (since you don't plan on OC'ing much if at all; if you do, get 1600, same voltage -- though I doubt you'll reach 4Ghz on stock vCore, so 1333 should suffice).

g's build + your FireGL would put you at $650 before tax and shipping. Have you investigated softmodding a GeForce card instead? Some apps get a nice boost (not equal to a pro card, but good enough boost for the cost savings), while others don't benefit at all (eg. maya).
http://www.techarp.com/showarticle.aspx?artno=539

Any X58/P55 board should come with optical out. Audio chipset won't matter since its all digital, data will be processed by your receiver.

You'll probably want to get the HDD in g's list, too, since that Raptor is very old. If you want something faster, you'll be better served by one or two SSDs.
http://ssd.alphaq.org (my SSD page)
 
I like that gigabyte/g-skill combo. I must have missed that when I was browing.

Hyper threading is one thing I don't quite understand well. I understand what it does, but do all programs benefit from it, or just multi threaded programs? The two most resource hungry programs that I'd be using (Pro/E, and Abaqus) do not multi-thread. Will hyper threading be beneficial to them? If not, wouldn't the higher turbo boost of the i5 (3.2ghz vs 2.93) be better for my applications?

With regards to the Raptor, I definitely realize it'll be the weak point of my build. My initial plans were to get a 150Gb Velociraptor, however after seeing that the new 2TB Caviar Black performs better than it in many areas, I kind of want to wait a bit to see if that technology trickles down before buying a new boot drive.


IIRC, there's a Microcenter in your city somewhere, lol. If so, they have the i5 750 for $150, the i7 860 for $230, and the i7 920 LGA1366 for $200. If you're within driving distance, I'd suggest the 920 and an MSI X58M along with 6GB of 1.5v DDR3-1333 (since you don't plan on OC'ing much if at all; if you do, get 1600, same voltage -- though I doubt you'll reach 4Ghz on stock vCore, so 1333 should suffice).

g's build + your FireGL would put you at $650 before tax and shipping. Have you investigated softmodding a GeForce card instead? Some apps get a nice boost (not equal to a pro card, but good enough boost for the cost savings), while others don't benefit at all (eg. maya).
http://www.techarp.com/showarticle.aspx?artno=539

Any X58/P55 board should come with optical out. Audio chipset won't matter since its all digital, data will be processed by your receiver.

The Microcenter is about 30 minutes from me according to google maps, however traffic can be a bear in that area, especially during the holidays. I'll definitely grab the i5 from there if I find my self up that way. With regards to the 920/MSI combo, that combo would be about $60 more expensive than the i5-750/gigabyte combo from Newegg. If I were to grab the i5 from Microcenter, the difference would be about $100. From everything I've read, the i5-750's single threaded performance is almost equal to that of the i7-920 due to the higher clocked turbo boost. Single threaded performance is a big concern for me. Is there something I'm missing that would make the i7-920 better for me?

I haven't investigated softmodding a GeForce card, mainly because the FireGL v3600 performs well with Pro/Engineer from what I've read. This chart is one of the resources I used when making my graphics card decision. What Softmodded GeForce card would be comparable to the performance of the FireGL?
 
Last edited:
The 500gb Samsung is the fastest 500gb harddrives out there, and since its a single platter design it will be fast and quiet. The 2tb drives will be 4-500gb drives, so it will be slower due to rotational mass (have to move all disks at once).
Clock seed and turbo boost can be minimized buy a slight bump in clock speed (overclocking), and the benefit of having HT support is any program that allows multithreaded support will benefit.
 
Though, with multiple cores/threads (HT), you can run more single/multi threaded apps at once. ;) ... so faster performance while multi-tasking. LGA1366 gives you higher memory bandwidth with triple channel RAM, also allowing for 12GB via 2GB sticks vs 8GB on LGA1156 dual channel. The i7 920 also OC's higher (manually) than the LGA1156 chips. Furthermore, the upgrade path will be better on LGA1366. If you don't do a lot of multi-tasking and your apps don't take advantage of a TON of RAM, then i5 should be fine. :p

SSD would be better than any HDD for your boot drive (OS/Apps). Check my link above.

You'll want the max RAM along with a RAMDisk for your scratch disk and stuff.
http://www.ocztechnologyforum.com/forum/showpost.php?p=442160&postcount=5

RE: softmodding...
So, a genuine NVIDIA Quadro card is at least 2X faster than a soft-modded NVIDIA GeForce card. However, NVIDIA prices the Quadro cards at ridiculously high prices which are often 4-10X higher than the equivalent GeForce cards. As such, soft-modded GeForce cards definitely offer much better value for money, even if they do run much slower than the "real" things.
Since you're buying a low cost pro card, just stick with it, since a newer, higher priced, softmodded GeForce would perform just as good. :p The V3600 is on the same level as the G84, so you'll probably need at least a G92 (8800GT/8800GTS/9800GT/GTX+/GTS250/GT 240) with more power to get equiv softmodded performance... not worth it, IMO.
 
Last edited:
The 500gb Samsung is the fastest 500gb harddrives out there, and since its a single platter design it will be fast and quiet. The 2tb drives will be 4-500gb drives, so it will be slower due to rotational mass (have to move all disks at once).
Clock seed and turbo boost can be minimized buy a slight bump in clock speed (overclocking), and the benefit of having HT support is any program that allows multithreaded support will benefit.

I'll be keeping that Samsung in mind when it comes time to upgrade my hdd(s). The immediate purchase will be the cpu/mobo/ram/graphics card. After that will be the secondary (storage) drives, then the boot drive.

With my useage, I rarely have more than 2 main apps running. I might have a couple word or excel documents open at the same time but when I'm doing anything processor intensive, I usually will only have that program open. If going to the X3440 would provide a significant performance gain for my usage, I have no problem spending an extra $40, but I just don't see $40 worth of extra performance with the way I'd use it. Am I wrong?

Edit - I just read you're edit :p I'm running a SSD in my laptop, and I like it alot. When it comes time to upgrade my boot disk, I'll weigh the speed/storage space/cost factors and figure out what I want.
 
Win7 and your apps will determine if its worth it. I personally am looking forward to IE9 and having my Win7 system up and running. Programs like Quickbooks are multi threaded, so other may be also.
 
Some edits up there for me as well.

What you may want to consider is the way you work... instead of only using one program at a time, you can now use multiple programs to make your use of time more efficient (eg. render in one app while working in another).

Your system is as fast as your slowest component, and right now, that'd be your HDDs. ;)
 
Some edits up there for me as well.

What you may want to consider is the way you work... instead of only using one program at a time, you can now use multiple programs to make your use of time more efficient (eg. render in one app while working in another).

Your system is as fast as your slowest component, and right now, that'd be your HDDs. ;)

Yes, I know my HDDs are slow, however I can't upgrade them until I get a new Mobo (unless I replace my 2port sata PCI card with a 4 port :p). New mobo means a new cpu, ram, and graphics card all at the same time, and that's about all I can spend in one lump purchase. I'll see which components I get for x-mas, and then see how things are after the holidays. right now I'm spending $400 on a set of injectors for my car as well as trying to save for a down payment on a house, so I can't build this whole thing at once.

With regards to the way I work, I'm only on my computer when I have something specific to do. I'll come back from a trip and spend a few hours a night for a few days editing and uploading pictures. If I'm building something and I want to visualize it beforehand, I'll fire up Pro/E. If I wind up working from home in the future, I'll be working with a single model and perhaps emailing simultaneously.
 
Back
Top