While buying my new monitor, the HP w2207, I found out that it had a TN panel. However, the information that I could get about TN panels was lacking to say the least. This post is an attempt to point out some of the TN panel's characteristics, specifically its shortcomings and nuances. The information in here is not to be taken as fact but rather as an opinion formulated by my observations of both my own monitor, those at CompUSA, and the ones we have at my workplace. Feel free to correct me or debate my 'claims' in a constructive manner.
== BEGIN PEDANTIC INFORMATION ==
The HP w2207 is a 22-inch widescreen monitor with a glossy coat and a TN panel. I use settings that are calibrated by a Spyder2 color calibration tool. The luminance of the panel is set to 175cd/m2 (out of a maximum 300cd/m2), the recommended setting for a medium-lit room as given to me by the Spyder2 software. Therefore, the following settings are used:
Quick View: Text (only one that allows for color tweaking)
Brightness: 45
Contrast: 82
Color: R: 249, G: 224, B: 255
The monitor, uncalibrated, leans moderately towards the cool side (things appear bluer).
The Dell 1704FPV is a 17-inch monitor with a matte coat and a PVA panel. I also used the Spyder2 to calibrate this panel, but at the right color temperature, the luminance is only 150cd/m2. Maximum luminance on this monitor, when everything is cranked up to give maximum brightness, is around 200cd/m2. The following settings are used:
Brightness: 100
Color: R: 43, G: 43, B: 50
Uncalibrated, the monitor produces a very warm color with slightly washed out contrasts.
== END PEDANTIC INFORMATION ==
From my observations, TN panels have the following shortcomings:
Poor viewing angle
I could not capture this on camera, so no picture is provided. The horizontal viewing angle on TN panels is decent, not up to par with IPS or PVA, but enough to accomodate several viewers at once. The vertical viewing angle, however, is severely limited. Optimal angle would be 0-10 degrees above the monitor. If you go higher than this, the colors first look brighter, then becomes solarized as you go higher up. If you go lower, the colors become darker. This might not be an issue if you're the only one sitting at your computer and looking at the monitor head on all the time, but it might be a concern for those with a big panel that's close to their eyes, as the viewing angle will differ at the top and bottom of the screen. As a result, the screen will look different to the user on the top than on the bottom, a shortcoming exacerbated by the monitor's own tendency to create gradients from solid colors, as mentioned below.
Gradients in solid colors
The effect is much more pronounced when captured on camera and is not that bad in real life. However, the color gradient can still be clearly seen in real life. When viewing a large patch of a solid color, it will have a slightly darker shade at the top of the screen and a slightly lighter shade at the bottom. The effect is subtle but definitely noticeable, especially for darker shades. Also, with certain colors, the hue of the color itself will shift slightly. You can read about it here:
http://www.lagom.nl/lcd-test/example-purple.html
The Dell has uniform shading throughout the screen. Also notice that it has a deeper black.
Poor color saturation
One of the most commonly mentioned shortcomings with TN panels is the poor color reproduction. Lack of saturation plays a part in that, as seen in this picture:
It's very apparent that the wood is not quite a deep brown but rather a lighter, washed out brown. The gradient issue mentioned above is also seen in this picture but in real life the brightness looks uniform. It's still washed out though, compared to the deeper tone on the Dell monitor. Also, notice that the black level is much deeper on the Dell. This is a quality of PVA panels (high contrast ratio) that both TN and IPS panels lack. As a result, the TN panel's black looks more like a dark or dark-blue gray rather than a true pitch black.
Slightly blurry text when using ClearType
When using ClearType to anti-alias text, the text at the top of the screen is slightly thicker and darker than at the bottom of the screen, and goes down progressively like a gradient. This gives the impression that the text at the top of the screen is slightly blurry compared to the bottom. When not using ClearType, the text looks the same throughout the monitor. The effect is subtle (it becomes more noticeable the larger the panel size), as you can see by the picture, but if you have a keen eye, you'll notice it.
'Glowing' text when using overdrive modes
When using the overdrive modes, a.k.a. presets such as Movie, Game, etc..., text at the top of the screen will have a shadow, in this case, black text on a gray background will have a white shadow. Other colors users have reported seeing are purple and yellow, both of which I have personally seen myself, and the color of the shadow is dependent on the color of the text and the background color. Turning down the monitor brightness seems to reduce this effect, although not completely eliminating it. This effect is most prominent when not using ClearType and only appears when using presets other than text mode, although in text mode I can still detect a tinge of it at the very top of the screen. Strangely, if you look at the text at an angle from above, the shadow effect diminishes the higher you go.
The preset modes seem to 'sharpen' the image, but at the same time it makes text look like crap. This issue might be specific only to the HP w2207 but some feedback on this would be appreciated.
I've posted more pictures in this thread:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1179531&page=25
There are more pictures on the next page. I took these as I was testing the HP monitor against my old Dell one.
So what does this all mean? Yes, the image quality of a TN panel is subpar compared to an IPS or PVA panel. I provided this information as a way of educating people and making the issues known so that they can decide whether it matters to them or not. Bottom line is, if you're looking for a large LCD display for a cheap price that can give you a decent picture quality, TN panels fit the bill quite nicely and saves you a lot of money too. However, if you're a professional and want the most accurate colors, or if you're an enthusiast who wants the best picture possible, a TN panel probably won't cut it. The important thing to consider is if the poor color saturation and lack of deep blacks will really bother you and warrant paying a higher price for a somewhat better picture. The difference lies in whether you care that a monitor can simply show you a green object, or whether the monitor can show you the green object using the right shade and saturation of green.
Sorry if this post seems incongruent or even nonsensical. It's 5:30 AM and I've been up all day...
== BEGIN PEDANTIC INFORMATION ==
The HP w2207 is a 22-inch widescreen monitor with a glossy coat and a TN panel. I use settings that are calibrated by a Spyder2 color calibration tool. The luminance of the panel is set to 175cd/m2 (out of a maximum 300cd/m2), the recommended setting for a medium-lit room as given to me by the Spyder2 software. Therefore, the following settings are used:
Quick View: Text (only one that allows for color tweaking)
Brightness: 45
Contrast: 82
Color: R: 249, G: 224, B: 255
The monitor, uncalibrated, leans moderately towards the cool side (things appear bluer).
The Dell 1704FPV is a 17-inch monitor with a matte coat and a PVA panel. I also used the Spyder2 to calibrate this panel, but at the right color temperature, the luminance is only 150cd/m2. Maximum luminance on this monitor, when everything is cranked up to give maximum brightness, is around 200cd/m2. The following settings are used:
Brightness: 100
Color: R: 43, G: 43, B: 50
Uncalibrated, the monitor produces a very warm color with slightly washed out contrasts.
== END PEDANTIC INFORMATION ==
From my observations, TN panels have the following shortcomings:
Poor viewing angle
I could not capture this on camera, so no picture is provided. The horizontal viewing angle on TN panels is decent, not up to par with IPS or PVA, but enough to accomodate several viewers at once. The vertical viewing angle, however, is severely limited. Optimal angle would be 0-10 degrees above the monitor. If you go higher than this, the colors first look brighter, then becomes solarized as you go higher up. If you go lower, the colors become darker. This might not be an issue if you're the only one sitting at your computer and looking at the monitor head on all the time, but it might be a concern for those with a big panel that's close to their eyes, as the viewing angle will differ at the top and bottom of the screen. As a result, the screen will look different to the user on the top than on the bottom, a shortcoming exacerbated by the monitor's own tendency to create gradients from solid colors, as mentioned below.
Gradients in solid colors
The effect is much more pronounced when captured on camera and is not that bad in real life. However, the color gradient can still be clearly seen in real life. When viewing a large patch of a solid color, it will have a slightly darker shade at the top of the screen and a slightly lighter shade at the bottom. The effect is subtle but definitely noticeable, especially for darker shades. Also, with certain colors, the hue of the color itself will shift slightly. You can read about it here:
http://www.lagom.nl/lcd-test/example-purple.html
The Dell has uniform shading throughout the screen. Also notice that it has a deeper black.
Poor color saturation
One of the most commonly mentioned shortcomings with TN panels is the poor color reproduction. Lack of saturation plays a part in that, as seen in this picture:
It's very apparent that the wood is not quite a deep brown but rather a lighter, washed out brown. The gradient issue mentioned above is also seen in this picture but in real life the brightness looks uniform. It's still washed out though, compared to the deeper tone on the Dell monitor. Also, notice that the black level is much deeper on the Dell. This is a quality of PVA panels (high contrast ratio) that both TN and IPS panels lack. As a result, the TN panel's black looks more like a dark or dark-blue gray rather than a true pitch black.
Slightly blurry text when using ClearType
When using ClearType to anti-alias text, the text at the top of the screen is slightly thicker and darker than at the bottom of the screen, and goes down progressively like a gradient. This gives the impression that the text at the top of the screen is slightly blurry compared to the bottom. When not using ClearType, the text looks the same throughout the monitor. The effect is subtle (it becomes more noticeable the larger the panel size), as you can see by the picture, but if you have a keen eye, you'll notice it.
'Glowing' text when using overdrive modes
When using the overdrive modes, a.k.a. presets such as Movie, Game, etc..., text at the top of the screen will have a shadow, in this case, black text on a gray background will have a white shadow. Other colors users have reported seeing are purple and yellow, both of which I have personally seen myself, and the color of the shadow is dependent on the color of the text and the background color. Turning down the monitor brightness seems to reduce this effect, although not completely eliminating it. This effect is most prominent when not using ClearType and only appears when using presets other than text mode, although in text mode I can still detect a tinge of it at the very top of the screen. Strangely, if you look at the text at an angle from above, the shadow effect diminishes the higher you go.
The preset modes seem to 'sharpen' the image, but at the same time it makes text look like crap. This issue might be specific only to the HP w2207 but some feedback on this would be appreciated.
I've posted more pictures in this thread:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1179531&page=25
There are more pictures on the next page. I took these as I was testing the HP monitor against my old Dell one.
So what does this all mean? Yes, the image quality of a TN panel is subpar compared to an IPS or PVA panel. I provided this information as a way of educating people and making the issues known so that they can decide whether it matters to them or not. Bottom line is, if you're looking for a large LCD display for a cheap price that can give you a decent picture quality, TN panels fit the bill quite nicely and saves you a lot of money too. However, if you're a professional and want the most accurate colors, or if you're an enthusiast who wants the best picture possible, a TN panel probably won't cut it. The important thing to consider is if the poor color saturation and lack of deep blacks will really bother you and warrant paying a higher price for a somewhat better picture. The difference lies in whether you care that a monitor can simply show you a green object, or whether the monitor can show you the green object using the right shade and saturation of green.
Sorry if this post seems incongruent or even nonsensical. It's 5:30 AM and I've been up all day...