My HD4870 512 Woes

PoopsMacClaude

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
182
Wall of text incoming, if you want a condensed version just read the bold:

Hello,

I upgraded my system in September. I went ahead with the Radeon HD4870 knowing full-well of their cooling issues at the time with the plan to remedy them with the fan hack. That worked fine and dandy, and with the new drivers, was obsoleted, so it was even more fine and dandy. The only problem was that it wasn't actually fine and dandy. I tended to run the fan at 28-30% speed. My idle performance was pretty good, usually around 44-46C, however under heavy, extended load the temps would breach 80C and eventually hit 82C. This would cause system instability and I would recieve random BSOD's while gaming. These BSOD's ranged from error to error, but after confirming both PSU, Memory, CPU, and OS stability the problem can only be linked (and somewhat obviously) to the 4870.

A little testing confirms this, and when I run the fan at around 40% the problem goes away. However, it creates a different problem: noise. Since my old desktop (A64 San Diego) was completely passively cooled, and its successor, my laptop, also notably silent, I am not appreciating the noise caused by the little fan on the card. I tried applying AS5 to hopefully lower the temps to acceptable levels with the fan at 30%, but to no avail. I am receiving exactly the same performance from the HS/F on the 4870.

So now I'm left with looking around for an aftermarket cooler that is both silent, achieves acceptable performance (~65C load), and is quiet in operation. I haven't the slightest clue, I have not been able to pull up anything of much use in terms of reviews/research and product selection for the 4800 series cards seems scarce. Any pointers?
 
i own practically every card in the 48xx ati line and it seems that the only way to get substantial silent cooling is to go liquid. i personally don't mind hard locking all of my cards to run 40% fan speeds.
 
Im somewhat confused by the OP..If you wanted a card that was completely silent, why didn't you buy a passively cooled card in the first place? The 3800 and 4800 series cards both needed fan adjustments, and doing so causes noise.
 
So are you trying to say, Cowboy, that I should have instead bought a Geforce 4 MX 420 because I wanted it completely silent?

Anyway, the problem with the 4870's was the the fan was running BELOW 20-30% threshold (on my driver I seem to remember it being set at 3%). Running it at 40% creates a very annoying whir that only comes from a bitch fan running at high-RPM. This is not unexpected from stock cooling (whereas the GTX 260's and 9800 GTX+'s seem to have no heat/noise issues at all), but generally, at least in the past, there have been aftermarket coolers for these cards made of higher-quality materials and design that would enable one to significantly lower his temperatures and, consequently, fan noise.

I'm just asking for recommendations on such a product.

All clear now?
 
i like the scythe musashi or accelero twin turbo if you already have good case air flow.
 
Back
Top