It was already plugged into the PSU when I booted. I just plugged it into the mobo while I was in Windows.
Don't do that.
SATA is not a hot pluggable technology.
PS/2, IDE, and power connections are also not hot pluggable.
Don't install or remove PCI cards or video cards with the PC powered on.
Don't pour Kool-Aid on powered up parts or hit them with a hammer.
You should not be plugging or unplugging anything on the computer while it is powered up except for standard USB devices. USB is designed to be hot pluggable.