My First Unstable Computer...what a bummer

Subliminal

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 15, 2004
Messages
158
So, I've been building computers for years. My first unit was based on the AMD 1500+, which was probably about 2001(ish).

Anyway, I've had great luck with both AMD and Intel since then. Northwood, 64, Opteron, Athlon, etc.

...and then came c2d. Hailed as the greatest achievement in processors since sliced bread.

So, I built this system:

c2d e6850 3.0Ghz, 1333FSB
2GB OCZ SLI-Ready 1066Mhz, dual channel kit
Gigabyte DS3L P35 mobo
WD 640GB HD
9600GT

From the day I put this system together, I had issues. Sometimes it wouldn't post. Sometimes it would just crash. Sometimes it'd freeze.

So, I changed power supplies. I had a second one sitting in the box from a FAR sale at Frys.

That seemed to help, or maybe I just wanted to think that.

Then it was back to its old tricks.

I disconnected the PATA burner.

That seemed to help, or maybe I just wanted to think that.

Then it was back to its old tricks.

I pulled a stick of memory and it wouldn't post. I swapped for the other one and it worked fine. I switched to the first again and no post. I switched back again and it worked fine.

I talked to OCZ, sent back that initial 'bad' stick and worked with the computer with one stick. Man, she worked great. I managed to OC the system to 3.4 Ghz and never had a crash in 2 weeks.

The replacement stick came back a few days ago, and I shut the computer down and swapped it out. Posted fine, OC was the same, no issues.

So, I put both sticks in. Wouldn't post. Moved them all around in the 4 available slot and finally got it to work, but I had to clock it back down to stock speeds.

Basically, at this point I think my next option is to swap motherboards. Which sucks, because that means an entirely new formatting of the HD, and a pretty much total rebuild. Not something I cherish at this point.

Anyway, just needed to vent. And look for advice.

To date, I think the fastest Win XP system I've yet used is now my garage computer. An AOpen Cube with a 2.4C Northy running at 3.0 with 2 GB PC3200 and a 36GB Raptor.

Ahhh well, too bad it isn't PCI-E so I can play Crysis. ;)
 
They are both Ultra PSU's

The first one was a 400w which ran my Opty system overclocked from 1.8 to 3.0 Ghz with most other hardware at least similar. (2GB memory, same burner, HD, same vid card) Never had an issue, and I believe the C2D chip is supposed to use less power than that old Opty did.

The one I replaced it with was a 500w Ultra.
 
SOmeone will correct me if I am wrong, cause it happens to the best of us :p But Ultra PSU's arent the best quality if I remember right. Grab a corsair 450VX and see if that works.
 
No, they aren't reputed to be the best, but it's hard to think it's my PSU when it worked 100% stable on my last, similar build.

Not saying you're wrong...just hard to wrap my head around.

Thanks for the replies!
 
If you can, get a different brand of memory to test out in dual channel, perhaps from a friend or relative's computer. I have some Geil that works fine in my rig, and some PNY that causes all sorts of issues on the same board. Both pass MemTest86+ with flying colors, and the PNY works fine in my Dell 745.

Also, have you tried playing with the memory voltage?
 
I have played with it. Also tried using it not in dual channel mode as well.

Don't have any extra ddr2 sitting around though. :(
 
Hope you got that EA430 w/ coupon and all for the $18AR price. Otherwise, the EA500 was $44 AC. ;)

I agree with Rydawg... it may very well be your PSUs.

I keep hearing this thing about "well it worked fine before..." ... a PSU degrades over time, depending on the load it bears. if its inadequate for the job, it may fail immediately, or over a long period of time... again, depending on the electronics used and the load it must bear. you can't expect a PSU to last a very long time, especially if it was free after rebate and you're putting a heavy load on it. :p

And remember, not all PSUs are made equal.
 
Acutally, I forgot to add the coupon code, but the egg was nice enough to actually refund that money from the coupon, anyhow.
 
Eh... Ultra PSUs are as bad as they come. Bought and used one last year (naively) without looking up any reviews, and it killed my board+ram. Now have a Corsair 750tx, way overkill for my system, but I like the peace it brings (and the quiet, too)
 
Eh... Ultra PSUs are as bad as they come. Bought and used one last year (naively) without looking up any reviews, and it killed my board+ram. Now have a Corsair 750tx, way overkill for my system, but I like the peace it brings (and the quiet, too)

No, they're not all bad, and they're definitely not as bad as Apevia's and many other brands out there. They're fine for what they're rated for, but the VX series (typically FAR) are not good for high-midrange gaming systems, since those types of systems need a bit more quality power, and thats Ultra's Value line. Ultra's higher end lines aren't that bad, and are sometimes nicely priced at Fry's.
 
I doubt it will fix my problem (I'm starting to get a little jaded over the whole affair) but it certainly can't hurt matters. ;)
 
I doubt it will fix my problem (I'm starting to get a little jaded over the whole affair) but it certainly can't hurt matters. ;)

Well, either something that connects to all your parts screwed them all up (or maybe you didn't take enough ESD precautions and are now seeing the latent effects), or you just have some horrible luck. I've built several builds with all of those parts you listed except the E6850 (I used the E6750 since it was much cheaper back then, and only 333Mhz slower with the same OC potential).

What sux is, the inadequate PSU could have already damaged all the parts, though unlikely.

If you think its the board, then RMA it while its still under warranty. If you don't want to wait for the replacment, buy a new one, and sell the replacement when it comes in.

Just curious, but whats your DRAM voltage set to?
 
I think 2.2, if memory serves me correctly.

The mobo was the only thing I didn't buy new. HA!

Oh well, I'll just try the psu and keep my eye out for a cheap mobo...They come along from time to time, I've noticed.
 
You should probably lower that to 2.0-2.1 even if they are rated for it.
 
Well, the memory is supposed to run at 2.1v, rather than the stock bios setting on the mobo @ 1.8v. According to their support forums, this is very important.
 
its the MOBO !!!
I have had 3 ppl having issues with that same mobo.
From Fry's the ones that bought it of newegg (Diff Bios and revision had no issues)
But the 3 that bought it form Fry's had Booting, Posting, and random freeze issues.
 
Back
Top