My case fans continue to reverse directions...

DeathCab

n00b
Joined
Dec 17, 2006
Messages
44
:confused:
(for impatient people, feel free to skip over this part)
Hey everyone, this is my first post here at the [H], but I have been lurking for years and years. Anyway, I am a relatively competent system builder, but I always end up having the SAME problem (and it leads me to believe I might be doing something wrong, although I cant for the life of me figure out what it is!). On my previous build, and on my brand new Core2Duo Build...



(ok, here is the problem!)
the case fans eventually end up REVERSING directions, even though at some point they were flowing as an exhaust, they always switch to be an intake! I just replaced the stock case fans thinking it might be a problem with the fans, and now my brand new fans are doing the same thing! Ahhh!


Has anyone else experienced anything remotely like this? Is there a solution? I have searched far and wide and have yet to even see ANYTHING on this subject. ;) I know all of you guys on this forum are really knowledgeable and if YOU all don't know the answer then no one does!
 
what are the case fans connected to? regular power headers or to a fan controller?
 
They were first connected to the power supply and now they are connected to a fan controller. I'm not convinced it matters what they are connected to, as they run in the right direction for a while, but eventually they turn around. :mad:
 
Plug your mouse into a different usb port and see if that changes anything.
 
I use a Mx5000 bluetooth wireless desktop, and I have plugged the dongle into different ports. It didn't change the nature of my problem, case fans remained reversed. I had it plugged into my monitor for a while, but now the dongle is in the front USB port of my case because of reception issues.
 
What size are your case fans? If they are 90mm, I have a few brand new ones that are guaranteed to not be of the reversing type. I'll sell you a few for $4 each + actual shipping costs from Virginia to wherever you are located.
I am using 3 of them in my machine and they have never reversed on me.
 
Thanks man, but no thanks on that offer. My case is a p180, and the fans are 120mm. I am using Yate Loons and an Evercool on the top fan for exhaust.

Is this a common problem? Am I just going to have to go in there and turn around my fan every time this happens?
 
Do you perhaps have a black hole for a CPU? That is very strange indeed. I have seen negative air pressure in a case make a fan very inefficent, but never actually reversed the direction of the fan. Wow.
 
might be nice if you told us which fans were pointed in or out, that may be part of the problem ;)
 
Sorry about that Eclipse.


The case fans are all mounted in standard positions on the p180

p180v1_inside.jpg

Here is a picture of the p180. There are mounts for the fan in the top, and in the back. Both function to take air outside of the case. The fans are mounted in the back and top as designated to take air outside of the case- and were functioning as specified for a perioud of time. Now every time I turn on my PC the case fans are operating in the reverse direction that thye should be.

Also, I have a fan mounted in the front as well as an intake, and it has yet to reverse directions. As far as I can tell the fan in the bottom continues to function as it should as well.

Are there any other questions I can answer to help get to the bottom of this?

EDIT: Can you see the image now? I linked to one from the Antec site.
 
DeathCab said:
Here is a picture of the p180

Um, I cannot see your picture.

And that is very strange indeed, I have never seen a case fan spontaniously reverse direction for no reason...
 
Can this have anything to do with a messed PSU/motherboard and reversing the polarities on the wires?
 
That's very peculiar indeed. I'm subscribing to see why this is happening. Sorry I have no input. But GL finding this out.
 
i've not heard of this happening before either and quite interested in seeing the fix, so when u start your comp do the exhaust fan blades spin to the left or right, they should go left or at least according to the arrow on an extra fan i have.
 
Have you put a sheet of paper in front of each to make sure they are actually reversed?I have felt my 120s blowing out air instead of sucking it in but it was just the air rushing past my hands. If it doesn't stick to the fan it is blowing out of course.
 
Do the fans have directional arrows on them? And if so, are they moving the correct way? Are you using any type of fan grills? Do the fans seem to be operating at normal rpm's in reverse? If you remount them backwards from what they are now, do they reverse back the other way?
 
To everyone's questions:

The top fan just reversed direction AGAIN and is now spinning in the correct direction.

I have yet to try and reversing the case fan. I am not too sure of the RPM as the can controller I have isn't able to monitor RPM, only control the fan speed.

I am going to take some pictures and give an update tomorrow, I will investigate further as to the nature of the problem bu plugging into the mobo to see if it makes a difference.

If anyone has suggestions for how to figure out what is going on, let me know by PM or a post right here. I think with all of your help we can get to the bottom of this once and for all.
 
Are you sure it's not just looking like it's going backwards, sometimes at a certain rpm things will look like they stop moving or start moving backwards, like the wheels of a car.
 
Most case fans are of a Brushless type and have built in electronics to control the spinning of the fan. If you revers the voltage they will most likely not work, the only thing that can cause them to run backwards is a malfunction of the fan itself. My guess is you are either mistaken on the fan direction or you have a bad batch of fans.
I know from experience that it is sometimes really hard to tell which way a fan is blowing just by holding your hand up to the fan to try and feel the airflow, when your on the sucking side of the fan you can feel the air between the fan and your hand, this can feel like its blowing towards your hand when in fact it is not. The best way to tell is with a Piece of paper, if it sticks to the fan it is the input side, if you cant get it to stick then its the outside. this can be affected by case pressure so make sure to test this with the side panels off.
 
i think the OP is just pulling your guys strings.

how in the HELL will a fan run in the right direction and then somehow mysteriously switch directions at some point? WTF.
 
Do you have a multimeter?

The only way the fans should actually change directions is if the polarity is reversed. As some people have already pointed out, most fans won't even work if the polarity is reversed. So take some fans that you think will be ok, and check the polarity of the power input. Then when it reverses, check the polarity again. If it's the same, then your fan is really wierd. If it's different, then you have bigger problems...
 
EDIT: Thanks everyone for the help. What I really wanted was a little bit of assurance that I wasn't going mad, and that everything was functioning as intended. I did the paper test with the side of the case off and It turns out I was just having tricks played on me. When the case is closed it feels as if the air is rushing into the case, but with the side off, the paper is blown away just as one would expect! Yay!

Anyway, shesh, what a first post. :( I hope everyone eventually forgets about this one!
 
LOL we will never forget.. But yeah you can feel air moving infront and behind any fan. Just one side will actually have more output.
 
Sta!nless said:
LOL we will never forget.. But yeah you can feel air moving infront and behind any fan. Just one side will actually have more output.

12-17-06. Never forgot.

lol.

Glad you figured it out man.
 
Back
Top