My budget WHS server build

Joined
Apr 28, 2006
Messages
835
Early this year I built a low budget file server using inexpensive parts and was thrilled with the performance from it. I was using Windows Server 2003 at the time.


Well, I decided to sell that box off and keep only the 750 gig Seagate from it. I was really itching for some WHS action as I liked its feature set (backups, media streaming, web access and etc), so I decided to build another box. Overall pretty similiar specs with just a couple changes.


I bought all these parts from my local Microcenter:

Celeron 430 $30

MSI G31M3-F $63

1 Gig Crucial DDR2 $19

Cooler Master Elite 331 case with 350 watt PSU $50


My total out the door cost was under $180 after taxes.

I ordered from MS a couple months ago the 120 day evaluation edition of WHS. My understanding is thats fairly painless to upgrade it to a full licensed version later on.


Since I don't plan to have a optical drive in this machine, I followed these directions from Home Server Hacks on how to install WHS off a USB thumbdrive. I can attest it worked perfectly.


Now on to some pics:

DSCF0001.jpg


The parts assortment. Picked up an extra 120 MM fan for the front of the case.


DSCF0003.jpg


Look ma, no optical!


DSCF0002.jpg


The insides. Tried to keep it fairly tidy. Not too hard when there isn't a optical drive in the way.



I bought these particular parts because they were inexpensive and had the features I needed. The mobo has 4 sata ports, Realtek PCI-E gigE and used an Intel chipset. The cpu is more than enough for a basic home server. Only part I wasn't sure about was the case. Initially I didn't like the hard drive mounting locks, but after using them, they aren't too bad. Though it does suck that you need to remove both sides of the case to install or remove a HD. I added a 120 MM Antec Tri cool fan to the front of the case and the rear already has 120 MM CoolerMaster fan. A basic 350 watt PSU is included as well.



Performance wise, I seem to get about the same as my old rig. Roughly around 50 megabytes a second in each direction. My desktop machine has a similiar Asus G31 chipset board, e8400 and gigE ethernet connection. I will run the Intel NAS Performance test later on as it takes a while to run.
 
Very nice, enjoy your new WHS.
I just ordered a full version of WHS off newegg after going through *cough* two 120 day evals. Although I must warn you, 4 SATA ports which seem like plenty at first might not be all that much..
 
I just ordered a full version of WHS off newegg after going through *cough* two 120 day evals.

Did you just install over top your existing WHS install? Did it infact keep all your data in the data shares intact? Or did it wipe it all out?



I spent most of today troubleshooting why I wasn't able to get the connector software to connect to my WHS box. I was able to see the shares on the server and could connect through remote desktop to the box, but the Connector software wouldn't authenticate with my admin password. After spending hours googling and trying everything I could find, I ended up just formatting and reinstalling the OS. Works fine now. Thankfully I had only copied a couple hundred gigs to it.


Seems to me that the whole WHS experience is a little on the fragile side. On my first install after running through most of the Windows updates, for some reason several of the Windows Home Server specific Services had disabled themselves. While connected via remote desktop, I wasn't able to launch the WHS Console. I would get an error indicating that such and such service was disabled. Went in and manually set them to auto and started them up. So, that was the beginning of my troubles. I didn't have any of these problems after the reinstall.

Getting ready to fire up the Intel NPT and see what the benchmarks look like.
 
Nice, yours is close to what i have too. WHS is a great product. I got about 1.8 Tb of space right now and only using half of it.
 
No luck with benchmarking from NPT. It would either crash after some time or display an error on my Vista x64 desktop. Last time when I benchmarked my old Server2k3 rig, I think I was running XP on my desktop. Will have to look into that again.

Casual file copies in explorer indicate 50 to 60 megabytes a second copy speed. So no problem with that. Though I do expect that to drop some once I put some more drives in the WHS box and turn on file duplication.


Also forgot to mention the stock 120 MM exhaust fan included with the Elite 331 case is on the noisy side. Since the machine sits in a closet its not too big an issue to me, but definitely wouldn't cut it if it sit out in the room. Also the front bezel of the case has multiple air filters in it from top to bottom. The one that sits in front of the 120 MM intake fan seems to cut down air flow far too much. Might look into pulling that filter out.


Other observations:

I like how WHS notifies you of errors and events. It indicated via a little pop up over the Connector icon in the Sys tray that one of my machines had its firewall turned off. Another occasion it notified me antivirus was turned off on one machine.

Remote access via the web is pretty slick. The ability to access everything on the WHS box without having to use any extra third party software or services is very nice. I would like to seem more customization options in the future to what your Home Server web site looks like in the future without having to rely on extra software. Just some basic options to select other themes or templates would be nice. Not all of us are HTML kung-fu experts.

I don't care for the fact there doesn't appear to be a way to manage backups manually. Basically I want to click "Back up now", instead you have to set a schedule for auto backup. I would rather have the option to manually initiate it only. Perhaps there is an Add in for this.

Speaking of Add ins, its pretty slick how you can add software to WHS. Drop the .msi file in the Add ins folder on the Software share and then go to settings in the Console and click install. Very nice.

The celeron 430 idles around 39 degrees C and the 750 gig Seagate around 33 degrees C.
 
You wont see a great performance gain with the onboard nic on that cheaper board. I would suggest perhaps getting a better nic on both ends with a decent switch, then you will see some much better numbers :) You could easily double your performance.
 
You wont see a great performance gain with the onboard nic on that cheaper board. I would suggest perhaps getting a better nic on both ends with a decent switch, then you will see some much better numbers :) You could easily double your performance.

So, you don't think 50 to 60 megabytes/sec from single drive and single drive over gigE is any good?
 
Why would you not want WHS to automatically run back ups? Set it to run sometime when your sleeping, if you are concerned about space then change the number of copies it keeps, I have mine set to keep 1 weekly back up and 2 daily backups of all of my pc's
 
So, you don't think 50 to 60 megabytes/sec from single drive and single drive over gigE is any good?

Good, not great.

Thats 400mps, about the average of a home controller or a consumer on-boarder


You can get 800-900 via proper Server NIC's, if that gives you any idea. Server nics are about 80+ new (Intel sells the Pro 1000 PT 1 Port for 79 via newegg). Or you can ebay some used NICs for litterally pennies. A good nic will make your system seem more snappy and super fast.... I don't know about you, but double the speed is a huge time saver.

However, for on-board, the numbers are still good. This reminds me of Galaxy 1, I started this exact way.
 
I have a crappy ECS mobo in my HTPC and I just upgraded from the onboard 10/100 NIC to a $39 Intel NIC from Newegg. Went from 8-12mb/s to 40-60mb/s and fixed a stuttering issue I was having with larger video files.
 
Back
Top