Multimonitor Support - Who First SLI/CrossFire

cnick79

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Messages
1,836
Who can we expect to have multimonitor support first, ATI or NVIDIA or neither? I'm hoping one Christmas Day we will wake up and see drivers supporting this.
 
Doesn't crossfire support dual display? I could be mistaken but I'm pretty sure when I was running dual 3870's it support 2 monitors. Unless you were looking to run 3 or 4 displays...
 
I was thinking 2 displays. I didn't think SLI and CrossFire could output to different displays at once.
 
SLI supports it too, been running that way for close to 2 years. Buy Quadros.
 
CrossFire already supports multimonitor displays with CrossFire enabled. SLI currently does not support it. Look for dual-display support with SLI this fall.
 
CrossFire already supports multimonitor displays with CrossFire enabled. SLI currently does not support it. Look for dual-display support with SLI this fall.

Hey Brent, when did this happen? When I enable CF on my 3007wfPHC, it disables my two 2007WFPs.
 
He meant for regular desktop GPU's, and not Quadros which cost way more and are for other uses.

CF should support multi-monitors, strange it doesnt for you
 
It was added in Cat 8.3 I believe 2 monitors max.


Update: Vista only
Another interesting feature of the Catalyst v8.3 drivers brings added flexibility to multi-monitor users under Windows Vista. In the past, users were required to disable CrossFire to watch certain types of video or to utilize additional monitors. But with the Catalyst v8.3 release, that is no longer the case. With cards from the X1800 series on up to today’s HD 3000 series, utilizing an extended desktop in a multi-monitor configuration does not require CrossFire to be disabled.
 
Why doesn't/can't SLI support multi-displays anyway?
I always thought it was strange when SLI has been around for some years already and ATi can manage it with their CF.
 
Why doesn't/can't SLI support multi-displays anyway?
I always thought it was strange when SLI has been around for some years already and ATi can manage it with their CF.

Nvidia just has it disabled so that their quadro cards can boast the feature.
 
It was added in Cat 8.3 I believe 2 monitors max.


Update: Vista only
Another interesting feature of the Catalyst v8.3 drivers brings added flexibility to multi-monitor users under Windows Vista. In the past, users were required to disable CrossFire to watch certain types of video or to utilize additional monitors. But with the Catalyst v8.3 release, that is no longer the case. With cards from the X1800 series on up to today’s HD 3000 series, utilizing an extended desktop in a multi-monitor configuration does not require CrossFire to be disabled.


I have to have Vista? Are you f**king kidding me?
 
Unfortunately, Vista is the solution to this problem.
Of course, you may have other problems with Vista...
 
He meant for regular desktop GPU's, and not Quadros which cost way more and are for other uses.

CF should support multi-monitors, strange it doesnt for you

They're not that expensive on the lower end and they game just as well as their geforce equivalents.
 
It was added in Cat 8.3 I believe 2 monitors max.


Update: Vista only
Another interesting feature of the Catalyst v8.3 drivers brings added flexibility to multi-monitor users under Windows Vista. In the past, users were required to disable CrossFire to watch certain types of video or to utilize additional monitors. But with the Catalyst v8.3 release, that is no longer the case. With cards from the X1800 series on up to today’s HD 3000 series, utilizing an extended desktop in a multi-monitor configuration does not require CrossFire to be disabled.

Sorry, but where does it say 2 monitors max? The way I see it, 2 mons = dualview\dualmon
2+ mons = multimon

I hope you are wrong, because I was hoping to go ATI, because of their support for multimon support with CrossfireX (ie 3 monitors or more).
 
They're not that expensive on the lower end and they game just as well as their geforce equivalents.

I suppose you wouldn't have a problem spending $1,500 on an 8800GTX then? http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814133213

I realize you said lower end, but that is an even more pointless. Cheapest Quadro newegg caries is $60, and it tops out at DX7 support (I don't know how the models compare, but that has got to be pre geforce4). I can get an 8600GT for $60. Of course, since this is about SLI, once we limit the search to only cards that support SLI, the cheapest ends up being $800 for what looks like a 7-series card (cooler would suggest 79xxGT, but I'm not sure).

And from what I've seen of "workstation" cards, they rarely game as well as their equivalents as the drivers aren't optimized for games, and as such often take a performance hit.
 
I may be wrong ASUS sells a 3870x2 with 4 DVI. Since ytou can not turn off Crossfire with a 3870x2 it would be useless to have 4 DVI. Maybe it is more than 2. I have never tried more than 2
 
I suppose you wouldn't have a problem spending $1,500 on an 8800GTX then? http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814133213

I realize you said lower end, but that is an even more pointless. Cheapest Quadro newegg caries is $60, and it tops out at DX7 support (I don't know how the models compare, but that has got to be pre geforce4). I can get an 8600GT for $60. Of course, since this is about SLI, once we limit the search to only cards that support SLI, the cheapest ends up being $800 for what looks like a 7-series card (cooler would suggest 79xxGT, but I'm not sure).

And from what I've seen of "workstation" cards, they rarely game as well as their equivalents as the drivers aren't optimized for games, and as such often take a performance hit.

Considering I have 2 4500s in SLI, no I wouldn't. I game on them, and they matched up comparably to the 7800 GTX 512 which they are based on. You may lose a frame or 2 per second, but who cares, it's not like they're severely crippled.

Also, the Quadro 540/560 are less then $150/$300 and support SLI multiview. If you're really worried about spanning multiple montiors with accelerated openGL apps, then you probably should be buying Quadro's anyway.
 
When crossfire is enabled your limited to 2 screens.

Straight from their FAQ:
Q: With CrossfireX enabled how many monitors can I use at the same time?
A: 2 currently.


ATI's is not limited to two screens. I've seen up to eight, using four cards. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A3jpG3rv4zI) XP is limited to ten screens, I assume Vista is as well, and DirectX limitations prevent you from using more than four-way SLI or Crossfire anyway.
 
I'm not going by the FAQ, I'm going by confirmed reports. I found that video through a HardOCP article, so it's not just me. :)

Also:
http://game.amd.com/us-en/unlock_radeon3800series.aspx
ATI CrossFireX™ Technology
Expand and conquer! ATI CrossFireX™ is the ultimate scalable Multi-GPU solution that allows up to four graphics units installed in a system using AMD’s motherboard.

More horsepower for game playing
Allows gamers to scale performance according to their budget
Multi-display support (up to eight monitors)
Easy plug-and-play upgradeability for even better 3D performance
 
I'm not going by the FAQ, I'm going by confirmed reports. I found that video through a HardOCP article, so it's not just me. :)

Also:
http://game.amd.com/us-en/unlock_radeon3800series.aspx

mavalpha, thanks for the post. but that video is not running CrossfireX. it is just running 4 cards without CF (notice there are no CF bridges connecting them). Also the game being played is FlightSim, which is actually a multimon game.

So in this instance it is actually FlightSim that is actually doing the multimon, not the ATI cards.

The quote you gave is the one that I had seen before that made me aske the question. However, I have yet to hear from anyone (including [H]) review that has tried this with more than 2 monitors.
 
Back
Top