MSI P45 Neo - weirdness

:LJ:

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 6, 2002
Messages
1,348
OK, so I got me a new E5200, MSI P35 Neo and 4GB OCZ RAM. So, I put it all together, and it won't boot. No beeps, nothing. Connections checked, jumpers checked, reset BIOS - it starts up, fans whirring, then dead after about 5 seconds. Then it comes back to life, and dies again. On the third attempt, it actually fires up and gives me the "F1 for setup/F2 to accept BIOS defaults" option, so I go into the BIOS. The CPU has a multiplier of 12.5 and FSB of 200, but the lowest in the BIOS is 266. I futz around with it for a bit, decide to underclock just to get it booted (using a multiplier of 6), but it just won't.

Now, after hours and hours of mucking around, it seems to me that there's something severely busted about this BIOS. About 1 attempt in 5 or 6, it'll boot after a while - and, sure enough, it'll do it with the 12.5x200. However, I can't go into the BIOS - if I try to save any settings, it'll never boot again (no matter how many times I try) unless I reset the CMOS. It also seems fairly random as to what frequency I get when it does decide to boot - so far, I've had 2.18GHz, 2.50GHz and 3.2GHz. It's as though it can't understand the speed information it's getting from the CPU, so the dynamic overclocking rubbish is doing what it can to find a speed which will work, and stops when it finds one which will boot.

I've updated to the latest BIOS (which the MSI site tells me supports the CPU), but still no joy. I've reset the BIOS more times than I can count, to no avail. I can't find any info around which even remotely describes these symptoms - anybody got any ideas?

EDIT: Forgot to mention, I've tried it with multiple RAM configurations, including both single- and dual-channel with various sizes from 512MB up to 4GB total, with identical results.
 
Are you trying all OCZ ram? Have you tried a different CPU?
 
Are you trying all OCZ ram? Have you tried a different CPU?

No, on both counts. Two sticks are matched OCZ PC-6400, the others are various Kingston, Corsair and generic sticks at different speeds. And, sadly, I don't actually have any other CPUs which would fit this board. Have you seen this behaviour before?
 
My issue was caused by OCZ ram. I have used a multitude of CPU's without issue though, all the way down to a Celeron 331 which is also "unsupported" but it worked fine. My suggestion was going to be another CPU but if you don't have one, an RMA might be your only option.
 
Well, in case anyone else comes across this...today, I got fed up with the noise coming from my graphics card (Inno3D 7600GS 512MB, tagged 07/2007) and swapped it for a generic ATI X300 128MB since I don't really play games any more and it's silent. Magically, all the problems went away. Interestingly, I run Ubuntu with Gnome desktop and XFCE's window manager with composite effects, and it's actually quicker. Subjectively, my secondary display is also sharper.

Anybody got any ideas as to how a graphics card could cause such a problem? It's worth noting that, when it was booted up, there were no stability issues at all, so there was nothing obviously wrong with the original card.
 
Back
Top