MSI or Abit for socket 939

Zyzzyva100

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Feb 26, 2001
Messages
1,204
Well I have narrowed my search down somewhat, and now I am looking for opinions of people who already have or are also looking at purchasing a socket 939 board.

I would ideally like to get the MSI K8n-neo2 platinum, but I see one big problem with this board. The chipet hsf is extremely close to the agp slot, and I had hoped to replace both the chipset hsf and cooler on whatever vga card i get (probably a 6800 gt) with aftermarket cooling devices that would give better cooling with less noise. I also like the placement of the cpu socket, because it looks like there will be more than enough room to use the sp-120 i plan to order.

Another possible choice then is the MSI K8t pro whatever its called. I like the layout of this board, but am unsure if the sp-120 will fit since the cpu socket is further north.

Finally, I like the layout of the Abit AV8-3rd Eye the best, since I looks like I would be able use large coolers on the cpu, graphics card and chipset without problem, but I was leaning towards the nforce-3 chipset.

Also, I can't seem to find the K8n-neo2 board anywhere, and I know that the abit board is new, but Im also trying to find a delivery date on it as well. Im looking to build in the next week or two, but I could always wait a bit.
 
Yeah i'm not sure either when the Platinum will be out. But I think im gonna go with the VIA version which seems to be just as good if not better then the Platinum. It just came out though so i'm not really sure where to buy it at yet. It's the MSI K8T Neo2-FIR. You can read a review on it here: http://www.vr-zone.com/?i=988&s=1

Also here is the link to it on the MSI site: http://www.msicomputer.com/product/p_spec.asp?model=K8T_Neo2-FIR&class=mb

After looking at the MSI Site I also noticed a MSI K8T Neo2-F mobo. I'm not sure what the difference is between them, i'll have to take a closer look at it.

Those are just some options you can look at anyway......
 
i literally just got done installing my new Athlon 64 3800+ on the ABIT AV8 (not 3rd eye... its not out yet)

So far, it is running really well!

Prior to this - about 3 hours ago :) I was running the MSI K8N Platinum with an Athlon 64 3400+.

What I have noticed so far...

The VIA RAID controller is faster then the nForce3 - Averages 99 compared to 74
The memory runs at twice the speed (dual channel)

Other then that it appears to be pretty stable.

I will try OC'ing it a bit after I give it a night of burn in.

So far I will recommend the ABIT

Good Luck!
 
Well after a few days of burn-in running Prime 95 without any locks or issues, I tried OC'ing the thing...

No success. I tried FSB's of 216, 212, 210, & 208. If I do it in Windows, using uGuru I can get thru a few benchmarks... sometimes. If I try to reboot, it will usually blue-screen with the driver_less_then_or_equal message. At the stock speed of 204 (that is ABIT's default speed in the BIOS) it works just fine.

If I go above 210, and run 3dmark2001, it will usually blue-screen showing one of the nvidia driver files as the cause.

I haven't put a whole lot of time into it yet, but it seems to me that the AGP lock is not working. I have it set to "fixed" in the BIOS (ver 1.2) but it does not seem to be working.

Does anybody know if there is a version of clockgen that will work with the AV8. I have tried a few of them on the site, but noe will show me the clocks.
 
Monarch Computers is estimating that the MSI will be available on 07/28/ You can pr-order also for $157.
 
mdaniel said:
Monarch Computers is estimating that the MSI will be available on 07/28/ You can pr-order also for $157.

zipzoomfly has it listed at $139 , on back-order.
 
JKA Represent said:
Ive heard there are lots of problems with the abit boards...
Yep. I've seen so many problems with this Abit board. Stay away from it for now.

As for 939 boards currently available.... the choice is very narrow... MSI looks promising, thouhgh.
 
mdaniel said:
The $139 at ZipZoom is the VIA chipset and not the nForce3.

Yea, I noticed that too. :( Not that it really makes a difference. Im bound and determined to take my time as I build this machine, and not settle for parts I don't really want.

As soon as this board, and the thermalright sp120 actually hit retailers, then all I have to do is wait for a good deal on a 6800 gt and I am set. I may not be playing doom3 the day it comes out, but shit happens.
 
Monarch Computers is estimating that the MSI will be available on 07/28/ You can pr-order also for $157.
And only a few hours later, the price is now $166 with an ETA of 8/2
 
Dr_John said:
And only a few hours later, the price is now $166 with an ETA of 8/2

I noticed that too. I wonder if they are getting different shipments, or just realized that had less available, and decided to rip people off. Kinda shady as far as Im concerned.
 
I'm thinking there were a lot of people trying to pr-order, so they decided to capitalize on it by raising the price.
 
Supply and demand. Just be happy it is going to be available. :D
 
I was planning on the Abit, but now I am pretty skeptical. How about the Asus A8V Wifi? Anybody have O/C experience with this board, and how is general usage on it?
I wish that the MSI Neo2 would ship already :(
 
Monarch has revised the ETA of the MSI to 08/09 now. The price had risen from $157 to $166, but now is back to $157.
 
mdaniel said:
Monarch has revised the ETA of the MSI to 08/09 now. The price had risen from $157 to $166, but now is back to $157.

Man MSI is going to start making enemies. The reviewers at anandtech said they don't like to put products in their reccomended system guide until they are available to the public, but this was an exception since the boards should have shipped this week. Now, who knows when.
 
I have a board on preorder, and I'm not a fan of having this pushed back several times...
 
Back
Top