MSI K8N neo2?

Looks to be one of the best socket 939 boards out there right now.
 
I have the MSI K8N Neo Platinum....basically the same board but for the 754 processors, not the 939. Have had no problems at all with it, and if/when I got 939 I'll probably get the Neo2 :)
 
I had some reservations about this board (because of its many quirks: Can't lock SATA channels 1 and 2, etc.) but after having bought it and used it for the past few weeks, I love it.

I've managed to get my 3000+ to 155 MHz FSB and it's still going up. I'm very pleased.
 
155MHz FSB?

#1. A64 = No FSB...only HTT :p
#2. The stock HTT is 200MHz...what are you smoking? :)
 
tsuehpsyde said:
155MHz FSB?

#1. A64 = No FSB...only HTT :p
#2. The stock HTT is 200MHz...what are you smoking? :)


Whoops..


255 Mhz. I just switched from an Intel setup, so my mind is still in Intel land. :)
 
I personally did not have a very good experiece trying this board out.

I bought one from excaliberpc that seemed to work fine except the firewire and second lan port didn't work. It stopped working within a few days and I rma'd it. It was tested and found to be bad, so I got another one.

This one wouldn't hold it's settings in the setup. I'm not going to go into the problems specifically right now as I am at lunch right now (if you want me to break it down let me know and I will post more info tonight). I did go to the msi official forums and saw other users having the exact same problems I was with this board.

I'm using a A64 3200 and 2x 512 of Crucial 3200 Ballistix.

I returned that one and got an A8V and everything has been rock solid.
 
KJ43 said:
This one wouldn't hold it's settings in the setup. I'm not going to go into the problems specifically right now as I am at lunch right now (if you want me to break it down let me know and I will post more info tonight). I did go to the msi official forums and saw other users having the exact same problems I was with this board.

Hi, KJ43 (=

I just ordered that motherboard. Could you please specify the symptoms you've encountered so I know what to look out for in case I encounter any kind of problem when the board comes in? Most grateful (=
 
As a whole, this is a great board. For everyone that bitches about it, there's a good 10 happy customers.. And most of the reported problems, are from ppl trying to OC the hell out of it, and run into problems. Even though the board supports overclocking, you're still running it way out of spec, and are bound to have some strange problems..

IMO, it's definately one of the better 939 boards to get, as I wouldn't touch a VIA board if my life depended on it, and it's definately one of the best NF3 boards out there (good for those with AGP cards still)
 
Teg,

When I set up my second build with the Neo 2 the first thing that happened was no post. No problem, I reset the cmos with the jumper and got post and went into setup (it was the 1.3 bios). I pretty much left everything at default just took a look around, set the date and time and then f10. Then no post again. This was with a pcp&c 510 power supply (I also tried a brand new Antec true power 430. It would just do that same thing over and over again.

The other thing that was annoying is that after resetting the cmos and putting the power supply cable back in the ps the power for the system would come instantly on without hitting the power button on the case. It would do this every time.

I reseated the cpu heatsink. Tried 2 different sets of memory singly and in dual channel mode everything set to auto, no changes whatsoever (memory was some older Corsair xms c2 and another set of Corsair xms 4000 pro both sets of memory are tested good).

If you go to the official msi boards I found threads with other people having the exact same problems as I was. I'm sure I'm in the minority in regards to my experience with the neo 2, but after two in a row I wasn't willing to keep going. I'm patient and careful when I put a system together and all I expect is a system to be stable at default speeds without tinkering.

The a8v is a dream, super stable and fast. It worked perfectly with the same parts I tried to use with the neo 2.

Funny, but my most stable systems have been via systems.
 
It's a joy to work with this mobo - it works how its supposed to right out of the box, just mount it on your case, hook all your crap up, turn on and you're ready to install windows.

Unlike my Asus AV8 motherboard by VIA which give me BIOS error, it's the year two thousand fucking four, I shouldn't even be aware the bios exists unless I specifially want to get into it, much less get a freakin bios error.

This mobo is good for all the new people that dont have much experience with PC's and dont want to have to move jumpers around and other stupid shit, like I said, it just works. Even the SATA functionality is superb, no more loading up sata drivers in a floppy or any other crap, it detects your SATA drive. Period.
 
It's been a rock solid mobo for me ..had the Asus A8V deluxe too , it was a rock solid performer as well ..the MSI just had a few extras that the A8V didnt is all ..so stuck with the MSI 939 mobo
 
I had this board, and it clocked my 3200 to 2.75 GHz. That was really good news. But, where it did let me down was on how it interfaced with my 6800 Ultra. On my 875 board, my eVGA 6800UEE clocked to 515/1360. I could run benches at this as well. Now, on the MSI, it will safely detect 500/1320 via Coolbits, and pass the 515/1360, but nothing will run past 480/1280. I guess this is a well known issue. You need to disable fast writes, but that kills any performance gains from the higher GPU clock. But, if you are NOT into overclocking any 6800 Ultra on this board, or have an ATI card, then this board is great fit. It offers a very flexible BIOS, and some nice features. And, it looks nice too, with the black PCB and neon colored plastics.

One item to note, if you want to keep the AGP/PCI bus at a fixed frequency, you need to plug in the SATA drives via ports 3/4, not 1/2.

If you want to maximize your 6800 performance via overclocking, however, look at an alternative like the ASUS A8V. I am rebuilding my system with this board. I will see if it does better with the 6800.
 
Have this board and love it. Layout is decent, documentation is excellent, comes with absolutely everything, and I've had no problems with it.
 
looking to get this mobo for xmas and got a question about it...

Does it have PCI/AGP lock and if not how much does that affect ocing?

Planning to pair it with a 90nm 3000+ that id like to OC somewhat...
 
Yeah, I'm in the same boat as kilik here. Hopefully ordering a nice new rig later on today wiht the Neo2, a 90nm 3000+ and a gig of xms3200 c2. I've read the [H] review that just went up and they say that theres no PCI/AGP lock option. Could it be that it's locked by default ? I woulda thought that their overclocking efforts woulda bombed without a lock, but they seem to have gotten along fine. Am I gonna have any trouble OCing this baby ?

-Side note, sorry to hijack, Im gonna have an Antec Tru380. Will this run my A64 and a 6800GT ok ? I know its not too powerful but I cant find anything else remotely affordable. (www.komplett.ie if u wanna give me a hand ;))

Thanks guys
 
You have to set the AGP frequency to 67 MHz in order to engage the lock. I've gotten to 255 MHz x 4 HT on this motherboard with absolutely no problems on my 3000+. It still even has room to go higher, but I haven't had a chance to tinker with it yet. And this is at 1.4V :eek:.
 
KJ43 said:
When I set up my second build with the Neo 2 the first thing that happened was no post.

Thanks for the info, KJ43. Most of the problems I've read relates to the mobo not liking the memory. Yours is a new one for me. Glad to know you're enjoying your alt mobo (=

* crosses fingers and hope I won't encounter any problem with the mobo.
 
Demon_of_The_Fall said:
Yeah, I'm in the same boat as kilik here. Hopefully ordering a nice new rig later on today wiht the Neo2, a 90nm 3000+ and a gig of xms3200 c2. I've read the [H] review that just went up and they say that theres no PCI/AGP lock option. Could it be that it's locked by default ? I woulda thought that their overclocking efforts woulda bombed without a lock, but they seem to have gotten along fine. Am I gonna have any trouble OCing this baby ?

-Side note, sorry to hijack, Im gonna have an Antec Tru380. Will this run my A64 and a 6800GT ok ? I know its not too powerful but I cant find anything else remotely affordable. (www.komplett.ie if u wanna give me a hand ;))

Thanks guys

If it didn't have a PCI/AGP lock on it then people wouldn't be able to get anywhere near 300Mhz HTT and yet they are. Anandtech had theirs clocked at 290Mhz when they reviewed the board.

You may want to upgrade your PSU to something a little more beefy. That Antec 380w is descent but doesn't have a real heavy 12v rail which is a big concern for the latest video cards and CPU's, especially if you plan on overclocking.
 
While there may be not option to select the AGP/PCI lock, it does so by default. The only bug is that you need to plug in your SATA devices via ports 3/4, not 1/2.

I ran my Neo2 at 275 FSB, 1:1 memory, 2.5-3-3-7, 1 T and 4xHTT. It gets around 13,300 on the CPU score on AM3, which beats my old 3.4E running at 4.2 GHz, which scored around 12,800 or so. Even with the lower video card clocks, I was able to best my old Intel 3.4E AM3 score.
 
burningrave101,

You are right about the power requirements for newer motherboards. On the msi forums some of the locals were saying that you needed to have a minimum of 28A on the 12v rail to ensure stability with the neo2. Hell, my Truepower 430 only has 26A on the 12v rail. That's why I was glad to have my pcp&c 510 around to make sure that it wasn't my "cheapo" Antec ps that was at fault.
 
Just ordered my rig, but I ended up with an Epox EP-9NDA3+ instead coz the Neo2 went out of stock minutes before I made my order :mad:. So the consensus is that a 380w is going to cripple my OC ? 24A on the 12v.... Time to start stripping out my opticals and HDs... :confused:
 
It'll work, I have a 6800 in mine. The big ol' BFG fan shroud overlaps the little MSI NB fan, but it doesn't touch.
 
KJ43 said:
burningrave101,

You are right about the power requirements for newer motherboards. On the msi forums some of the locals were saying that you needed to have a minimum of 28A on the 12v rail to ensure stability with the neo2. Hell, my Truepower 430 only has 26A on the 12v rail. That's why I was glad to have my pcp&c 510 around to make sure that it wasn't my "cheapo" Antec ps that was at fault.

Well, one thing I was worried about when building mine was my power supply. I have an one of those older antec cases with the Swing-out doors, that came with a 350 watt power supply. I guarantee that thing doesnt put out anywhere close to 28A on the 12v line, yet I've had no problems at all with this things stability, and this is while also running it with a 9800 Pro! And yes, I am planning on getting a bigger PS anyway though.

Edit: Just looked up Antec's specs..... 16A on 12v line. Again though, not a single bit of instability here, but then again, I'm not overclocking.
 
Remember, when selecting a PSU, you want to load up to around 70% of the maximum on the 12V power rail. Using 18 amps of 20 amps is not a good idea. The PSU will run very hot, and may start to lose power as the heat rises. A good quality PSU has 30 amps plus on the 12V rail, and some of the newer releases actually have two 12V rails available.

BTW, I measured the wattage used on my system, and it was close to 380 Watts. If you look at the fact I have a 520 Watt PSU, you would think I was well within the limits. But, that was with USB disabled, so that reduced the 5V draw a bit. So, it was mostly 12V draw. So, even with 34 amps and a 520 watt PSU, you can really push the limits quite easily with a well loaded gaming rig.
 
HeavyH20 said:
I had this board, and it clocked my 3200 to 2.75 GHz. That was really good news. But, where it did let me down was on how it interfaced with my 6800 Ultra. On my 875 board, my eVGA 6800UEE clocked to 515/1360. I could run benches at this as well. Now, on the MSI, it will safely detect 500/1320 via Coolbits, and pass the 515/1360, but nothing will run past 480/1280. I guess this is a well known issue. You need to disable fast writes, but that kills any performance gains from the higher GPU clock. But, if you are NOT into overclocking any 6800 Ultra on this board, or have an ATI card, then this board is great fit. It offers a very flexible BIOS, and some nice features. And, it looks nice too, with the black PCB and neon colored plastics.

One item to note, if you want to keep the AGP/PCI bus at a fixed frequency, you need to plug in the SATA drives via ports 3/4, not 1/2.

If you want to maximize your 6800 performance via overclocking, however, look at an alternative like the ASUS A8V. I am rebuilding my system with this board. I will see if it does better with the 6800.


Did you ever get a chance to go into the hidden options in the bios, and make sure the vid card boost feature was disabled? For some reason it might've been enabled, and was already overlocking your vid card. So when you when to go OC the card, it was already OC'ed, so it seemed like you hit the max sooner..

Normally this isn't a problem, but there have been some threads about it..
 
are any of you running an SATA hard drive as your primary boot drive? I am looking at getting this board preatty soon when I upgrade but a guy I work with got this board and it will not let him boot off of his SATA Raptor drive. It will install windows and everything but when it goes to reboot it just sits there and does nothing. But it works fine on his 200gb IDE hard drive. Reason I want to know is that my primary drive is a SATA drive.
 
Does he have SCSI or SATA or RAID somewhere in his list of boot devices ?
I have an MSI K7N2 Delta IFSR and I have to put SCSI as my first boot device. It just calls the sata controller scuzzy for some reason. Hope thats a help to him/you
 
hmm Ill have him check that out. I know there was some sort of option if I recall to boot off the SATA first but that didnt seem to help. but I will have him look into that. There are tons of reviews on this board and none of them even mention this issue.
 
There is so much conflicting information about SATA drives, RAID, Windows XP, it'll drive ya crazy! I know!

I have a 74GB Raptor, a K8N Neo 2 Platinum, Windows XP, etc.

I have done a clean install of XP with a single SATA drive both with the SATA drivers (the ones on the floppy) and without them (don't hit F6 when prompted, just let it slide...). Right now I'm running fine with a SATA drive on SATA port 3 and a 250GB SATA on SATA 4....and didn't use the SATA drivers on the floppy.

I wish there was a definitive "SATA Drives for Idiots" thread someplace, I'd be the first in line to read it. Trouble is, I've read the "Definitive SATA Drives for Idiots" threads at several places and without exception there will be conflicting information.

As it is now, I have no idea if my drives are living up to their potential, or if by being installed this way I am impeding them. I know the appear to work very smooth, quiet, happy, and fast compared to my (very) old last rig.

Good luck, I hope you guys get it sorted out. I'm still running pretty bare bones, I'm gonna run some benches and see what sort of performance I'm getting in this configuration. I'm not too far along to clean it all out and go again..
 
I use only SATA drives, and it boots fine. I so use ports 3/4 instead of 1/2, but that was for overclocking. I never tried to boot 1/2, so I cannot confirm that functionality. But, it definitely boots to a SATA drive.
 
Back
Top