MSI Getting Sued For Faulty Caps

cisco guy

2[H]4U
Joined
Jul 23, 2002
Messages
2,277
A hardware and software service company from Vermont filed a legal class-action suit against Microstar International accusing one of the leading mainboard makers in the world of intentionally using low-quality components on its mainboards.

A report from Reuters claims that the suit, filed in Los Angeles Superior Court last Thursday by Electronic Connection Services Corporation claims that MSI has knowingly used capacitors, devices used to regulate the power supply to microchips, that can leak or even explode and cause mainboards to short-circuit. The suit, which seeks to cover any person or company in the United States who has made a wholesale or retail purchase of an MSI mainboard since 1999, seeks unspecified damages and restitution and other relief.

Leaking, exploding and deforming capacitors on conventional mainboards is an issue that has been around for years. However, in the last 12 to 36 months the problem has become pretty big as modern chips consume a lot of energy and the risk of capacitors’ failure became extremely serious.

~~snip~~

http://www.xbitlabs.com/news/mainboards/display/20040602153002.html
 
Yep, thats what happened with my Delta-L. Never bought MSI again.
 
I see a lot of popped caps on Gigabyte boards.

Also ECS, PCChips, (list of all crappy manufacturers)

I rate MSI just above gigabyte in terms of quality.
 
I had an Abit a shuttle and an aopen go south.
kinda sneeks up on you, with stuff going wrong more and more.
paging errors, blue screens, printer wont recognize etc
 
My MSI-6337 PRO server mobo had lots of them problems from the caps...as soon as i seen every other one start to dimple i replaced them with good highend yellow caps that they use in SoundStream car amps,same rating and all just a lot better cap..no problems so far and runs happy when i oc the shiznit out of it..can touch 1ghz under a peltier :)
 
the caps popped on my epox 8kha+ :( (long time ago now)

was it msi or gainward who had a ton of bad geforce 3s or 4s that had bad caps which fuxxored a lot of people?
 
was it msi or gainward who had a ton of bad geforce 3s or 4s that had bad caps which fuxxored a lot of people?
And PNY..I had a ti4200 that died from a vreg frying through a trace on it, but it suffered from a bulging cap or two as well.
[edit] Also ECS owns and probably manufactures PC Chips boards now.. Had no problems w/ an 810LMR though - traded up to a KG7-R when the o/c bug hit me however.
 
ive used 5 or 6 msi boards in last couple of years and never had a problem with any of them , including the one in my sig.
 
silentnight3985 said:
My MSI-6337 PRO server mobo had lots of them problems from the caps...as soon as i seen every other one start to dimple i replaced them with good highend yellow caps that they use in SoundStream car amps,same rating and all just a lot better cap..no problems so far and runs happy when i oc the shiznit out of it..can touch 1ghz under a peltier :)


Would you have any pics of the mobo currently? I'd love to see a before and after shot of it.
 
I've replaced at least 6 ATX & Microatx MSI boards with bad caps. Also had a gigabyte, ABIT and ECS with bad caps.
 
From the list of complaints here, why don't we just sue all the mobo manufacturers. :rolleyes:

Please, this whole thing is ridiculous. I hope they don't get a dime.
 
I have never not had a problem with motherboards. They are all shit IMHO.

My List

ABIT BE6, pos
ASUS A7V, pos
ASUS A7V133, pos (no I did learn, it was the replacment for the above which also got replaced again)
MSI - undecided, whilst this board has been ok for the price, it has started to show it's age after only 11 months.
 
I hope they get sued, and go bankrupt.

these companies dont give a damn about us.

enron, martha stewart, mci, charles schwabb, eds.....list goes on and on.
 
The gassing electolyte problem has been known for about 2 years now. If MSI has continued to use cheap Taiwanese caps, they deserve whatever justice the jury decides. FWIW, Abit and IBM acknowledged the cap problem almost as soon as it was known, and made every effort to correct the problems.
 
kush said:
And PNY..I had a ti4200 that died from a vreg frying through a trace on it, but it suffered from a bulging cap or two as well.
[edit] Also ECS owns and probably manufactures PC Chips boards now.. Had no problems w/ an 810LMR though - traded up to a KG7-R when the o/c bug hit me however.

We purchased 32 of those cards at work and within a year we only have 4 of those cards left. All the other Ti4200's died from that same thing warped, blown and fried caps.

As far as motherboards, crap like that is exactly why I only use Asus (My game rig, Intel (For workstations/servers at work) Tyan and Supermicro (Servers). I have used MSI once in a secondary machine and I had good luck with that board.

With computer parts you get what you pay for. And although Abit and Asus boards are $130-200 depending on what your chipset your getting and what options the board has, but off brand chipsets, lower tier brands where you only save 10-30$ or so aren't worth the hassel. I'd rather pay a little bit more and know that what I buy isn't going to die on my in a year.

That's my $0.02. It doesn't surprise me when someone says, "My Epox board's PS/2 keyboard and mouse ports blew out."
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
With computer parts you get what you pay for. And although Abit and Asus boards are $130-200 depending on what your chipset your getting and what options the board has, but off brand chipsets, lower tier brands where you only save 10-30$ or so aren't worth the hassel. I'd rather pay a little bit more and know that what I buy isn't going to die on my in a year.
:rolleyes:
http://www.neoseeker.com/Hardware/faqs/kb/12,10.html

MSI is one of the top three motherboard manufacturers in the world, Tier 1
 
Not this again, This was a very bad problem about 2 years ago, The whole industry was hit with bad caps due to a suppler that was producing them. If I recall MSI was the hardest hit, but most all manufactures had a problem.

I fixed many of motherboards by replacing caps dring that time...


*EDIT*

Stolen formula for capacitors causing computers to burn out
By Charles Arthur, Technology Editor
31 May 2003
A scientist steals a secret formula for an electrical product from his Japanese employer and takes it to China. Then it is stolen again and turns up in Taiwan. But something goes wrong - and thousands, perhaps millions, of computers and electrical goods in the West begin to burn out or explode.

It sounds like the plot of a thriller, but it's reality. Thousands of computers have failed and nobody is sure how many more products might go wrong because their capacitors - essential components to control the power supply - were made with faulty materials.

"It could be all the way through to TV sets, hi-fis and even lighting power supplies," said Dennis Zogbi, president of Paumanok Publications, an expert on the market for "passive components". These are mundane electrical items such as resistors and capacitors that sell by the millions and whose reliability is essential. "People want Western quality at Chinese prices," he said. "Well, you can't have both."

The story began in 2001, when a scientist whose name is still unknown left the Rubycon Corporation in Japan and began working for the Luminous Town Electric company in China. Both companies made electrolytic capacitors. In China, the scientist developed a copy of Rubycon's electrolyte, the filling of which allows the capacitor to store and release electrical energy.

Later that year, the scientist's staff defected to Taiwan, taking with them a copy of the electrolyte formula so they could set up their own company. Taiwan supplies 30 per cent of the world's electrolytic capacitors and most of the big PC manufacturers get their machines assembled in Taiwan. But the defectors mis-copied the formula. After a few hours of operation, the electrolyte would leak hydrogen gas, before bursting the metal body of the capacitor. The electrolyte would then leak its brownish filling and could cause a fire.

"The only company that publicly confirmed it to us is IBM," Mr Zogbi said. Dell Computer, the world's biggest computer seller, has privately confirmed that the problem exists. Mr Zogbi said that even when the alarm had been raised, some companies in Taiwan were unwilling to listen.

Two questions remain: how many of the faulty capacitors are still in use, waiting to fail? And which company supplied the flawed formula? Mr Zogbi said most of the faulty parts had been tracked down. "But some of the large computer manufacturers just won't admit the problem," he said.
 
As I said I have used MSI once and it was a very good board. No reason to hate them. I just don't think their quality and design is up there with Asus.
 
Well i just fried one MSI board, but i think it was the P4 processor that i had been abusing for the past 2 years. Now i also had a pny geforce 4 4200 64mb that definitly died from buldging and leaking caps. i repaired that card by replacing all the caps and the 2 osilators that were fried, but this ultimatly is not the oems fault, most had no idea that there was an issue with these until there were several thousands of parts in use by users. I know even IBM had a very large issue with it, not that they have not had issues with other things, cough....deathstar.....cough.
 
Vertigo Acid said:
:rolleyes:
http://www.neoseeker.com/Hardware/faqs/kb/12,10.html

MSI is one of the top three motherboard manufacturers in the world, Tier 1

Hmm, maybe you should continue on reading your own link there, boss

If you pay close enough attention, the Tier 1 manufacturers tend to have the largest R&D teams and large OEM sales and marketing teams, and so their products come with more bells and whistles (in the form of bundled software and utilities) and with fancier boxes and manuals. However, even the tier 2 and tier 3 manufacturers today are striving to improve their packaging and their documentation and bundles, so don't make assumptions about product quality/bundle purely based on tier.

I have already been through one MSI K7N2 Delta board, and amazingly enough the one I replaced it with is a $50 refurb Delta-L from Newegg and not only has it not crapped on me, it overclocks quite well.

ALL companies cut corners, it's part of business. It only matters where they do it.
 
My point was not that they necessarily made good or bad boards; It was because the previous poster refered to MSI as a "lower tier brand" than Asus and Abit, which is false. I personally love both my MSI boards, and haven't had a problem with either of them. I don't think it's fair to go suing a company for something that isn't really their fault. As long as they stopped using the bad caps once they found out, and will repair the affected boards under warrenty, there's no problem. We'll see what evidence surfaces in the case
 
i have 2 abit kt7's that are unstable thanks to bad caps.. i would love to find a supply of them to repair the boards.. :(
 
I work for an electronics company, and from experience I can tell you that component manufacturers and suppliers carry a lot of the blame.

All electronic parts are sorted by bin and quality. They will ALWAYS send you their best samples, from bin A, top shelf. Later on, when the parts complete your own internal testing regime, and you order, they will gladly supply you from bin C and D...especially when you try and get the parts cheaper (often, it's the only way to be cost effective). Obviously the parts often look identical, and you use them, unsuspecting. It's a time bomb, and it's not the fault of the electronic designer, or even the purchaser, for that matter.

We've had to recall so many of our products (we manufacture LED Video graphic displays and messaging signs), because of bad batches, it's not even funny.
 
MSI does not replace boards with bad caps if they are out of warranty. But ABIT does :).
 
DeepFreeze: I hope they get sued, and go bankrupt. These companies dont give a damn about us. Enron, martha stewart, mci, charles schwabb, eds.....list goes on and on.

Oh boy, another Dumbocrat. Then where will we all work, or do we join the Dumbocratic party, and go on public welfare? :rolleyes:

There are some bad apples out there in business, no question about it, but there are an awful lot of people out there who aren't, who have worked very hard, happen to be a little bit smarter than someone else, or simply, are just plain damn lucky, and god forebid, if they make any mistakes. They have more laws and regulations that they have to follow, than what you can shake a stick at. Be it discrimination, pollution, safety, taxes, and on and on, as well as lawsuites, most of which as absolutely ridiculus, w/many being settled out of court, w/the costs being passed onto us, the consumers. Instead of, say a $100 motherboard, it becomes a $105 or $110 one, and so on.

Besides, the US federal government is considerably worst than those companies, and they are above the law too. :mad: They don't have the same laws to follow as private industry does.

Sorry about this. I just get mad when I hear people like DeepFreeze. Working in industry and seeing all the laws the company I work at has to put up with, as well as the most unbelievable lawsuites we get, especially the class acton ones, where something happens that doesn't even involve our product, but we are brought in, never the less. We have a complete staff of lawyers. This gets all passed on to the cost of our product, which you, the consumer pays for.
 
being a technician for a computer store, I only recommend ASUS boards primary or Abit. I try to stay away from MSI and Gigabyte. But we do sell some of them, but I always end up changing the customer's mind to either ASUS or ABIT :D
 
One thing I don't think anyone points out here is, we push these motherboards to the EXTREME with our overclocking, and they get quite hot. The only things cooled are the cpus and chipsets. What about the rest of the components? The resistors, capitors, diodes, ics, etc.
 
Veeb0rg said:
i have 2 abit kt7's that are unstable thanks to bad caps.. i would love to find a supply of them to repair the boards.. :(

If you get in touch with Abit and RMA the boards, they most probably will waive the $25 fee. I have a friend who just did this with a KT7-R board that was 3 years old and Abit emailed him after signing up for the eRMA, waiving the $25 fee. :cool:
 
Hitokiri Batohsai said:

great link -

and no, it's not MSI"s fault, nor Gigabyte, nor ASUS, nor...

There were some bad caps that ALL mobo makers got ship ments of. Some leaked more quickly than others, but unfortuneately, they all tended to die. The Gigabyte board I have (had?) had bad caps - I RMA'd it to Gigabyte after contacting them, and they even shipped me a board with good caps AND a prepaid return label for sending the bad one back. Spiffy.

For some client, I had to swap out three MSI boards, and 5 ASUS for the same reason and was able to get replacement motherboards with no hassles what so ever. A couple other brands I had issues getting replacements, but manged to get them eventually.

So - if this computer company in VT wants to sue MSI, they are silly. I've found most manufactures to be responsive to system builders and retailers when a problme is found like this - but you have to communicate to them in non-hostile manner. I run into it all the time at work and in my side business.

Peace,
Tim
 
DeepFreeze said:
I hope they get sued, and go bankrupt.

these companies dont give a damn about us.

enron, martha stewart, mci, charles schwabb, eds.....list goes on and on.

lol those are just the expendable scapegoats. this crap is being done to you EVERY DAY by most other large corps, hmm doesssnt MCI have exclusive telecom work in Iraq? i wonder how that happened.

its not punishment for doing the crime, its punishment for doing it and letting the wrong people know.

a few bad caps on a mobo is the least of your worries compared to inflated taxes, energy prices, utilities etc.. let it go, you paid for not buying ABIT or ASUS :) jk
 
being a technician for a computer store, I only recommend ASUS boards primary or Abit. I try to stay away from MSI and Gigabyte. But we do sell some of them, but I always end up changing the customer's mind to either ASUS or ABIT

I do the same :). But the trouble with asus starts as soon as it breaks. Asus RMA takes 6 weeks at least. And most of my customers are angry when they dont immediately get a replacement for their 10 months old videocard. :(
We only recently started selling Abit so I dont know how well their RMA is handled.
 
muddocktor said:
If you get in touch with Abit and RMA the boards, they most probably will waive the $25 fee. I have a friend who just did this with a KT7-R board that was 3 years old and Abit emailed him after signing up for the eRMA, waiving the $25 fee. :cool:


i'll have to give it a try then.
 
fusionrs said:
I blew up 2 MSI motherboards...Have no clue why either.
same thing happend to me, i blew up 2 msi k7n2 delta boards by trying to raise the voltage to 1.75-1.85v
 
sent in an eRMA request for my abit kt7-raid.. got the standard reply letter back sayin denied..

but we'll see..
 
well, rubycon is known for making good capacitors, right?
Epox now uses Rubycon caps, even though they aren't a "tier 1" manufacturer like MSI...plus it sounds like their new 754 pin mobo is pretty swank :)
 
Back
Top