MPAA Slams EFF on RealDVD

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The MPAA is pissed (when aren’t they) at the Electronic Frontier Foundation for comments they made last week about the RealDVD case. The MPAA sent an insulting open letter to the EFF that basically called them piracy advocates. This means that everyone that owns a media center PC, copies their movies to personal media players or digitized their collection of movies are pirates.

"Forgive us if we take offense when the EFF and other activist organizations that continually take the side of those who profit from widespread copyright infringement attack our industry," wrote Jim Williams, the MPAA's chief technology officer. "It's a desperate throw-back to the Napster days of old when (EFF would) pull out this tired and weathered playbook. It's not 2001 anymore. We've moved on. So should you."
 
"We've moved on." rofl .. please MPAA stop making your-self look so dumb, you haven't dropped a grudge since you started this mess.
 
They're really making people want to help them out by buying movies with this. :rolleyes:
 
Oh! What a shame they released this letter so soon, I was almost finished with my letter to them!
I'll just post what I have so far so maybe someone can help me proof-read it before I mail it off to Mr. Wiliams:

Dear MPAA,


FUCK. YOU.


Signed,

The Internet

Comments, Critiques?:p
 
I haven't purchased a movie from a retail channel that has a direct flow of money to a studio in 7 years.

All I know is that the mass public will keep buying movies new. I will keep buying them used.
 
*watches argument run in circles*

MP3s being freed from digital chains worked well. Apparently the MPAA hasn't noticed.
 
what i don't understand is why people keep buying movies new.

seriously, movies often depreciate in value almost as much as cars/pc parts do...especially if its popular.

the only two groups i can think of that defend buying new are:

people like the gf parents who have this strange like anti-used stance, never explained just hated doing it *shrug*

impulse buyers like a few friends of mine, who i could slap for paying full price for something because they can't control themselves.

fuck the mpaa (i had to get this in somewhere). i don't pirate because i know how to get movies cheap. but you know, i can fault people who do, retail prices are retarded...and for the level of quality coming out of late...i'd rather see them crumble...shit i'd rather see hollywood as a whole crumble, maybe then we can put the money we blow on producing shitty movies that dumb people down to better use...and let some low budget, fresh ideas step in.
 
Pissing on the EFF is never a good idea, remind me when I get home to send the EFF my money.
 
Just sent em $5...maybe they can buy popcorn with it while they watch the MPAA bust a nut straining to reign in technology.
 
Just sent em $5...maybe they can buy popcorn with it while they watch the MPAA bust a nut straining to reign in technology.

I'd like to clarify that as "...reign in technology that they have absolutely no fucking clue how it works, just that it's not making them the money they think it should."
 
Sounds like they are getting desperate. Must be getting the loan sharks circling to repossess their more expensive cars.

Tough shit.

If they actually cared about music and gave more share to the artist i might have sympathy.

Cut the cruft. get rid of the mpaa/riaa. Bring PROPER digital distribution that doesnt require us to buy the same music on multiple formats.
 
the only movies i buy are ones from like childhood and the odd box set i want which i know i will watch over and over

GodFather
Police acadamy
rambo
bond

but it is annoying you buy one boxset and a new version of the movie comes out, dam you bond and rambo..lol
 
May God Bless the EFF and make Satan take a Flaming shit on the MPAA/RIAA.:D

Here's
 
"Not only does the MPAA strongly deny being against innovation, but Williams wrote that Hollywood now works closely with the tech sector to deliver digital content to consumers."

If and only if those tech companies play by the MPAAs draconian rules. They are technology fascists.

Most tech companies want to play by their own rules which they believe would appeal to the consumers the most.
 
Shockingly no one is standing up for the MPAA. [/sarcasm]

The problem is they want it both ways. If I'm buying a license to watch a movie then I can't copy it, but then they need to replace scratched disks (for example). If I buy the physical media, its mine and I can do anything I want with it that doesn't violate copyright.

Its about greed and a broken business model.
 
Oh! What a shame they released this letter so soon, I was almost finished with my letter to them!
I'll just post what I have so far so maybe someone can help me proof-read it before I mail it off to Mr. Wiliams:

Dear MPAA,


FUCK. YOU.


Signed,

The Internet

Comments, Critiques?:p


Well, that kind of articulates the point very concisely, I see no need for elaboration.
 
The technology exists to distribute movies very easily at decent quality over the internet already. The problem is the MPAA just is not going to make enough money from it to really open it up.
 
Two sides in this battle... Corporate and Pirate.... I swear it's like a Gibson novel.
 
May everyone that works at/with the RIAA/MPAA have their crotches infested with the fleas of 1000 camels and may their arms be too short scratch, stupid freaking asshats.
 
i honestly don't understand why the MPAA/RIAA has any power whatsoever? I mean, look at this thread and any thread on other forums (i don't know if there is a website called ilovetheriaa.com to be an exception to a VERY apparent rule.. No-BODY supports the MPAA/RIAA some CORPORATIONS do, but I thought we lived in democratic countries.

if you put the vote out to the PEOPLE...

VOTE:
1) i believe the MPAA/RIAA has the right to protect its copyrighted material by any draconian implimentation of DRM it deems necessary. Including forcing legitimate manufacturers of pc/media hardware to adhere to strict MPAA guidelines, despite the cost and alienating loyal customers, who will simply look to manufacturers that arent exactly "above board".
2) the MPAA/RIAA can get a big dose of donkey cock.

why on earth do 'the people' only elect representatives to pass laws, we live in the 21st century, we have much better methods of communication and collaboration now and almost everyone would be able to participate. all these politicians are like millionaires and shit and people in the top percentile shouldn't be making laws for the other 99%.... it doesn't matter if they're left wing or right wing, they're still too wealthy to give a shit about actual regular people issues.

revolution is the key, march on your governments today!! Behead all government officials!!
 
i honestly don't understand why the MPAA/RIAA has any power whatsoever? I mean, look at this thread and any thread on other forums (i don't know if there is a website called ilovetheriaa.com to be an exception to a VERY apparent rule.. No-BODY supports the MPAA/RIAA some CORPORATIONS do, but I thought we lived in democratic countries.

if you put the vote out to the PEOPLE...

VOTE:
1) i believe the MPAA/RIAA has the right to protect its copyrighted material by any draconian implimentation of DRM it deems necessary. Including forcing legitimate manufacturers of pc/media hardware to adhere to strict MPAA guidelines, despite the cost and alienating loyal customers, who will simply look to manufacturers that arent exactly "above board".
2) the MPAA/RIAA can get a big dose of donkey cock.

why on earth do 'the people' only elect representatives to pass laws, we live in the 21st century, we have much better methods of communication and collaboration now and almost everyone would be able to participate. all these politicians are like millionaires and shit and people in the top percentile shouldn't be making laws for the other 99%.... it doesn't matter if they're left wing or right wing, they're still too wealthy to give a shit about actual regular people issues.

revolution is the key, march on your governments today!! Behead all government officials!!


lobbying.
 
Wait what? It's illegal to make a backup of a DVD you own, for your own personal use?
 
Wait what? It's illegal to make a backup of a DVD you own, for your own personal use?

Exactly. As someone has said already, we better either be allowed to make backup copies of the DVDs we buy, or get free replacements when their garbage physical media bites the dust.

I don't pay to be able to watch a DVD or play a CD until it stops working, I (apparently) pay for a (permanent) license to watch/listen to the copyrighted material. For life, or until I feel like selling or giving away that right.
 
lobbying.

Or, also: Money.

Wait what? It's illegal to make a backup of a DVD you own, for your own personal use?

Always has been. DVDs are encrypted (although with a really weak hash)... circumventing encryption is against the DMCA. That;s simplifying it to the point of potential inaccuracy, but that is the base of what the MPAA is operating on.

"We don't care how shitty our copy protection was! YOU SHALL NOT COPY A DVD FOR ANY REASON!!! WARRGGGARRRBBBLLL!!!! But instead, allow us to resell you the same movie in any number of DRM-encumbered formats that you cannot back up or use on any other device than the one we sell it to you for."

So, another one word answer that explains everything: Greed.

It used to be that technology was too expensive to allow someone to make a copy with minimal degradeation. Now that we have digital, 1:1 copies can be made. Even for purely fair use purposes, they don't want you to do it. Ripping a DVD for your netbook so you don't have to carry a DVDRom drive with you on that long train ride or flight? Illegal. Or that's how they would prefer to have it. They want to kill fair use. "Why do that when you could buy it again for your netbook!?"
 
consumer right:

once a person buys a copy of a movie (lets say a vhs of jurassic park), they should have access, for free, to the pure movie in any format/resolution/ect forever.


corporate greed:

every time a person views media, they should have to pay.
 
Dear MPAA,
Firstly, go fuck yourselves. Secondly, produce something good at a reasonable price and without 20 different versions and people will buy it; seriously, why would I buy this when next week the ultra-special-maximally-remastered-now-with-thingamajiggy#2154351.21 version comes out and I can buy last weeks version at half price?. Thirdly, you haven't moved on; you're still quoting hypothetical damages that you can't corroborate and whining over every advance in technology. Cut costs by being sensible with the budget and not spending billions on researching anti-piracy methods that are cracked before they're even on the street. Lastly, people generally dislike money-grubbing faceless corporations so man up and quit acting like some fat kid with a Napolean complex over the Halloween candy
 
Back
Top