MPAA On The Offensive Again

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The MPAA has set it sights on two small websites that offer links to pirated movies. Other than being sued into oblivion, what is the attraction of running one of these sites? If traffic truly is as low as it is reported, they can’t be making any money off the website. I just don't get it.

"There are many people operating illegal Web sites like these who are profiting from the theft of protected content," John Malcolm, director of worldwide antipiracy operations for the MPAA, said in a statement. "We have every intention of shutting down these, and sites like them, for good."
 
"If traffic truly is as low as it is reported, they can’t be making any money off the website. I just don't get it."

1. Principle

2. If you don't actively protect your copyrights, then by law, you lose them.
 
"If traffic truly is as low as it is reported, they can’t be making any money off the website. I just don't get it."

1. Principle

2. If you don't actively protect your copyrights, then by law, you lose them.

He's referring to the benefit of actually RUNNING the website, not the benefit of suing it. Small sites iwth crap traffic dont bring in much revenue, but risk getting sued.
 
I'd say most people do it becouse they like it or belive in free sharing of movies etc.
I doubt if many of them are using those websites as cash cows.
 
This is not their normal pattern of attack.

I don't think they want to continue risking their image by suing individuals in risky "martyr" cases which may backfire.

I think they want to rebuild their stance/image by starting at the bottom of the website food-chain and building up from there.
 
The thing is, the MPAA is suing these websites. Yet they just put the website links up for everyone on the internet.

Personally I rent, purchase and occasionally visit the theater to see new movies but to all those that don't. The MPAA just put up new links for the ones that were already acquiring movies for free.
 
Incorrect. You're thinking of trademark law.

YOU are correct.

I will just shut-up now, except to say this:

I do not pirate, I rent DVD and blu-ray discs from netflix, rent/buy from Amazon and iTunes, and occasionally go to the theater. For me, it is a moral issue: it is wrong to copy someone else's work and use it without their permission. No, it is not stealing, but it's something else, and not as bad as stealing, but not moral, either. However, the MPAA and the RIAA are complete bastards. Every bit of DRM they've deployed has been utterly destroyed within days of coming out, so the only people that suffer from DRM issues are people like me - the paying customer who tries to do things the right way, make sure everyone involved with teh music or movie project gets their cut, etc. But these bastards have made my life MORE difficult, and have succeeding in making me spend LESS money on their products. Now, I frequently just go without. It's not as fun as pirating, but I have a clean conscience. So I am often ambivalent towards pirates; in some way, they are 'fighting back' against over-bearing DRM content. But really, DRM content is in NO way a necessity for life, is in no way an inherent right of the people, and therefore if companies want to infuse their products with DRM and lose customers, that's their perogative, but that doesn't make it ok to violate copyright law in retaliation.

I guess as a former software developer, I can appreciate the damage piracy does to the digital content businesses.

Also, piracy utterly fails to pass an important moral test for one's actions: if EVERYONE were to do what I am about to do (pirate my movies instead of pay for them), would the world be better or worse? The answer is, of course, 'worse' because there would be no funds to produce movies and other digital content. In fact, it's much worse in the software business because if EVERYONE decided piracy was moral and stopped purchasing say, PC video games like Crysis, then there would literally be no good PC games except crap people put together in their spare time. Sure, companies could attempt to ad-suppor their content, but that's even worse than DRM! I do NOT want to see any fucking ads while I am gaming or listening to music or watching a movie. No, I will pay you for the privilege of enjoying your digital content, and you will reward me with more usability and less DRM bullshit.

Peace in the Middle East.
 
Back
Top