Mozilla Launches Thunderbird 3

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Mozilla has announced Thunderbird 3, the latest version of its open source email application.

Available in over 49 languages and works with Windows, Mac OS X and Linux, Thunderbird 3 has more than 2,000 improvements including new tabbed email, a radical new search engine, built-in message archiving and smart folders.
 
This could take off with Win7 dumping Outlook Express and many people still wanting a lightweight email client that is not cloud based.

Cheers!
 
Looks interesting, but I am not really interested in "advanced spam filtering technologies." Until Mozilla incorporates a simple whitelisting feature into their e-mail app like Windows Mail does, I will not bother using Thunderbird.
 
Looks interesting, but I am not really interested in "advanced spam filtering technologies." Until Mozilla incorporates a simple whitelisting feature into their e-mail app like Windows Mail does, I will not bother using Thunderbird.

Elaborate? Do the built in whitelisting features not do it for you, or are you looking for pure whitelisting where e-mail is classified as spam by default?
 
Elaborate? Do the built in whitelisting features not do it for you, or are you looking for pure whitelisting where e-mail is classified as spam by default?

If it works like TB2, all it does is look at your address book for a whitelist, and blacklists suspected junk e-mails using a Bayesian spam filter.

I would like it to be able to block all e-mails by default, and only allow addresses or domains for which I give specific permission to allow through to my inbox. Junk (or non-classified) e-mail is put in a separate folder, which I can look through and right click to allow. Both Qurb (under XP/Outlook Express), and Windows Mail (Vista) allow this functionality.
 
If it works like TB2, all it does is look at your address book for a whitelist, and blacklists suspected junk e-mails using a Bayesian spam filter.

I would like it to be able to block all e-mails by default, and only allow addresses or domains for which I give specific permission to allow through to my inbox. Junk (or non-classified) e-mail is put in a separate folder, which I can look through and right click to allow. Both Qurb (under XP/Outlook Express), and Windows Mail (Vista) allow this functionality.

Yeah, I thought that might've been what you were looking for. It's not really built in to the junk mail controls, but simple enough to implement yourself with the filters.
 
Awesome!!! :) :) :)

Before I heard about RC1 and RC2 the past couple weeks, I thought Mozilla had given up on TB, esp. w/ the new SeaMonkey 2.x out. Maybe Mozilla will speed up the dev.. so that they'll be in sync w/ FF around ver. 4. :cool:

Long live Thunderbird (and Firefox)! :cool:
 
Has anyone tried it yet and found it to have anything worthwhile to add on to TB2? I'm pretty content right now with TB2.
 
Has anyone tried it yet and found it to have anything worthwhile to add on to TB2? I'm pretty content right now with TB2.

I've been using it since this morning. The interface has changed quite a lot, there are improvements all over the place. Personally I think it's a lot better than it used to be, and I'm usually pretty stodgy about those kind of things. It's all tab-based now, for one. I like how smart folders work; you can have one combined Inbox for all your accounts, but it has a little pull down where you can easily get to the Inbox for each account without having to expand tons of trees. You can also switch quickly between folder views (you'll have to try this to see what I mean). The new search interface looks absolutely fantastic (haven't really used it though) and is very fast.

It seems like the majority of the improvements are in the user interface. As far as functionality, it seems largely the same. Definitely feels like a pretty major improvement to me though, I'd say it's worth a try for a few days.
 
Has anyone tried it yet and found it to have anything worthwhile to add on to TB2? I'm pretty content right now with TB2.

Compared to Thunderbird 2.x, performance has gone way down hill both UI-wise and IMAP.

Thunderbird takes a long time now to index IMAP folders. I think Tbird is using new database stuff for indexing and searching. That's probably the cause. And, I think Thunderbird caches the full message on disk for every message, where Tbird 2 did it a little bit differently. This could be causing slowdowns too.

In "tools -> options -> advanced -> general", there's an index option you can turn off. That seems to improve things. Also, in "Synchronization and storage" in the IMAP account's properties, you can turn off caching. That seems to help some too. But, Tbird doesn't seem to have an option like M2 where it only caches bodies of messages you open.

When you open the server settings for an IMAP account, the settings will be blank for a second until the settings are fully read and updated. Tbird2 didn't have this problem.

I didn't test fully to see what the causes for all the slowdowns are, but Tbird 3 is definitely slower. But, you may not be able to tell the difference on a fast computer. Once everything is full indexed and downloaded, things work better,. so there's no need to turn off the options mentioned above. M2 seems to be much faster at doing these things though.

As for tabs, they're. But, composing a message still opens a new window. Also, pressing enter on a message in a message list opens the message in a new window instead of a tab. Tabs should be the default for everything with options/modifiers to do window stuff. It's definitely clear that tabs are not first-class citizens in Tbird yet.

mail.check_all_imap_folders_for_new is still not set to true by default. This confuses users when summaries for all folders don't get updated automatically.

The default folder view is "Smart folders". I think it's a mess. Switching back to "All folders" restores the Tbird2 look.

With Tbird 3, when you click on an IMAP folder, the "Thunderbird mail, accounts and advanced features" page is always displayed in the pane until Thunderbird is ready to display the message list etc. This is quit annoying and make things slower. Tbird 2 did it differently.

The new account setting wizard *looks* unpolished. It works pretty good, but there are still some bugs with the server ports. It's also pretty funky to have to test/retest the servers just to be able to continue. Fortunately, you can manually edit to bypass things.

Thunderbird 3 bugs you if your server settings are not using tls. This is nice, but kind of annoying, when you already know your smtp server doesn't support tls.

When you first start Thunderbird, you have to do a lot. You have to choose whether you want to import from another client. You have to run through the wizard to set up an account. You get a warning dialog about tls. You get a "know your rights" notification. And, you get the default application dialog. Personally, I think that's too much crap to do before Thunderbird even fully starts up. I'm sure Mozilla's point in doing that is to force the user to set up everything and get all the settings out of the way. But, I think Tbird should just start up fully first and let the user click on the "create an account" link in the pane. I've already seen users get frusted with Thunderbird 3 and all the stuff they have to do right away. Thunderbird 2 was kind of annoying too, but now it's worse.

The account wizard recognizing your gmail address and automatically loading up the settings is great. However, the trash folder that's set by default would be better if it was "[Gmail]/Trash" instead of Trash. Some of the other folders are not set right by default either. Of course, if you don't know Gmail IMAP well enough and how to best use it, you probably won't care.

When you type something in the search field, you get a nice search results page. This is pretty damn cool. Of course, sometimes the page contains a little too much info (noise).

Tbird3 also has a new archive function. As a bonus, this works great for Gmail IMAP when you want to archive a message or remove a label from a message.

With all that said, I still can't recommend Tbird2 over Tbird3. Tbird3 is just better and contains lots of bugs fixes.

One thing that I hate about Tbird that's still there is that the default sorting in message lists is backwards. It should sort in descending order by date. Instead it sorts in ascending order so all your new messages are at the bottom of the message list. I have to change the sorting manually for like 40 folders every time I set up Thunderbird. M2 does the same thing though. I've never seen any average user prefer to have all their new messages at the bottom. I thought Tbird3 would fix this. (At least the fixed the up/down arrows in the message list date header. They were backwards in Tbird2)
 
I think I'll pass on upgrading to TB3 for a while. TB2 works well within my company and for my personal needs even with some more 'special' configurations. I doubt I could live without the MinimizeToTray extension either :)

*waits for 3.1 before she upgrades*
 
have they bothered to make it so it can export emails into an easy format other mail clients can import to?

How is the rule system? as easy as outlook, right click an email - create rule or still the same old, have to go to a menu option and more or less manually enter in the info?
 
have they bothered to make it so it can export emails into an easy format other mail clients can import to?

Not yet afaict. There used to be an en export extension that worked okayish for doing this, but it was stil kind of buggy and only saved each file as a separate .eml file.

As an alternative, Opera's built-in mail client M2 can import Thunderbird's mail from its profile. Then, in Opera, you can export to .mbs and use the .mbs files to import into whatever client (that supports importing mbox files of course) that you want.

I haven't tested the import with Thunderbird 3 though to see if 3 changes so much stuff that it broke Opera's importing.
 
Just installed Thunderbird 3 on a laptop. One thing I definitely like is the automatic configuration for accounts. It only took me a few seconds to set up my GMail account instead of the ten minutes or so it'd take otherwise. Pretty happy with things so far, even if the interface takes some getting used to.
 
Not yet afaict. There used to be an en export extension that worked okayish for doing this, but it was stil kind of buggy and only saved each file as a separate .eml file.

As an alternative, Opera's built-in mail client M2 can import Thunderbird's mail from its profile. Then, in Opera, you can export to .mbs and use the .mbs files to import into whatever client (that supports importing mbox files of course) that you want.

I haven't tested the import with Thunderbird 3 though to see if 3 changes so much stuff that it broke Opera's importing.

That is , or was the biggest thing for me, i was a big thunderbird user, but i just found it's rule system so clumbsy compared to outlook and then if i moved to a new rig and went to outlook, i had to do so much just to get my emails over!
 
have they bothered to make it so it can export emails into an easy format other mail clients can import to?

Thunderbird uses the ancient mbox format for its mail store, about the simplest and most widely supported format possible. It's all just standard mbox files in the profile directory. If your mail application can't import this, you need a better mail application. If you do have odd requirements, it's all just text and you can easily parse it into whatever format you want.

Much better than the binary blob lots of clients use...
 
I am very curious to see if Thunderbird adoption takes off now that Windows doesn't come bundled with an email client.
 
Thunderbird uses the ancient mbox format for its mail store, about the simplest and most widely supported format possible. It's all just standard mbox files in the profile directory. If your mail application can't import this, you need a better mail application. If you do have odd requirements, it's all just text and you can easily parse it into whatever format you want.

Much better than the binary blob lots of clients use...

Ah yes, the files with no extensions in "C:\Documents and Settings\User\Application Data\Thunderbird\Profiles\ProfileName\ImapMail\imap.googlemail.com" (and its subfolders) are mbox files.
 
Interesting then that outlook wouldnt be able to import such a simple format since it can handle almost every other format to import emails for. i would say, myself, outlook is one of, if not the best mail client, especially when you get into a corprate environment.
 
Interesting then that outlook wouldnt be able to import such a simple format since it can handle almost every other format to import emails for. i would say, myself, outlook is one of, if not the best mail client, especially when you get into a corprate environment.

Microsoft's lack of interoperability with simple and ubiquitous text-based formats is not surprising...
 
I am very curious to see if Thunderbird adoption takes off now that Windows doesn't come bundled with an email client.

Unfortunately, I don't think so since most people (still) check their personal e-mail over the Web. :(
 
There's still no ver. 3.01, so I guess that means 3.0 is pretty stable.

For unstable versions one has to look at the Beta versions, the last few of which are often quite usable for daily use as well :)
 
For unstable versions one has to look at the Beta versions, the last few of which are often quite usable for daily use as well :)
True, but I often have this perception that a x.0 version will tend to have bugs that may not be addressed until it a "critical mass" download it and use it, since relatively few use betas.
 
True, but I often have this perception that a x.0 version will tend to have bugs that may not be addressed until it a "critical mass" download it and use it, since relatively few use betas.

Open Betas seem to be be really good at preventing the buggy x.0 version problem :) Even MSFT did it with Win7 and it seems to have paid off for them. XP SP0 was a buggy mess in comparison to Win7 RTM :)
 
Open Betas seem to be be really good at preventing the buggy x.0 version problem :) Even MSFT did it with Win7 and it seems to have paid off for them. XP SP0 was a buggy mess in comparison to Win7 RTM :)
That's true, but an open beta program w/ an official RC will still have way fewer users than when it goes gold (official release). But I'm admittedly a little old fashion in my thinking since I've been burned by x.0 releases in the past.

In related Thunderbird news: Mozilla hopes to finish Thunderbird 3.1 in April. :cool:
 
That's true, but an open beta program w/ an official RC will still have way fewer users than when it goes gold (official release). But I'm admittedly a little old fashion in my thinking since I've been burned by x.0 releases in the past.

In related Thunderbird news: Mozilla hopes to finish Thunderbird 3.1 in April. :cool:

Well, the impression I get with the Win7 Beta and current Fx/Thunderbird Betas is that lots of people are using it daily.

Can't wait to see what 3.1 gets us :)
 
Well, the impression I get with the Win7 Beta and current Fx/Thunderbird Betas is that lots of people are using it daily.

Can't wait to see what 3.1 gets us :)

Yeah, more and more people are involved w/ the beta program w/ each new release. I'll upgrade my TB 2.x to 3.0 when I return from vacation. :cool: By then, who knows, TB might even be 3.0.1. ;)
 
I finally installed TB 3.0 yesterday. Everything went fine. I updated my Enigmail. It no longer supports another one of my add-ons (something like "Remember Mismatched Domain Names), but that's not a big deal. I'm not sure if I'll keep the new GUI or go back to the old one. I'll give the tabby one a shot for a couple weeks.
 
Back
Top