Mozilla CEO Says Apple Forcing Safari Is Wrong

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
When you have the CEO of Mozilla calling your tactics “wrong” you should take heed. Trust me, if you want your browser to be a success, you just might want to listen to what this guy has to say.

What Apple is doing now with their Apple Software Update on Windows is wrong. It undermines the trust relationship great companies have with their customers, and that’s bad — not just for Apple, but for the security of the whole Web. What they did yesterday was to use their updater for iTunes to also install their Safari Web browser –what follows is some background and analysis.
 
Yea, when I saw my iTunes say that Safari 3.1 was going to be installed, I said to myself, "Umm... no.... I don't want that crap on my computer." It isn't a total force as you can uncheck it, but I was extremely disappointed that a piece of software that I didn't even want to consider on my Windows machine, was defaulted to be installed w/ an iTunes update.
 
I saw this and promptly removed all apple software from my computer. Hardly ever use quicktime anyway, and there's always alternatives.
 
I never had their crap on my comp anyway. My phone doubles as my mp3 player with expandable mini SD so I'm straight. This is all pretty funny to see though.
 
Yet another reason why I avoid any apple products like the plague.
 
It wouldn't be so bad if the check mark was removed from the check box. This would give users a choice whether or not to install the software.
 
Apple 2008 = Microsoft 1998.

Apple is becoming the new MS when it comes to marketing tactics.
 
As long as it isn't forced and doesn't set itself as the default browser, I don't see how this is any different than all the other software bundles that so many companies do. Now if it's silently installing itself and setting it as the default web browser...
 
This is just innovation, what's the big deal :rolleyes:

Fact of the matter is, packaging other shit up when you are looking to install a particular thing is often a trait of malware...
 
When I first had vista I had originally had problems playing some media formats in my browsers, most likely because of quicktime being not ready with the new OS. So I decided to have their Apple updater installed just in case of any version changes. Instead, I got bothered every day with it asking me to download iTunes. I'm a Winamp and Foobar 2000 fan so I obviously have no real need for iTunes. Luckily, the updater is uninstallable. I still think that hiding their bundling tactics in their updating software is silly.
 
Yeah, I noticed the same thing, so I never installed it... I refuse to install software that installs other software... if I wanted that software, I'd download and install it.
 
Apple had 90+% of OS Share in 98? :confused:
Funny though, Vista has more market share in 1 year than Mac OS X in 7...

Kind of easy when Microsoft is forcing every PC manufacturer out there to bundle it with all of their new systems. At best you might get an option to install XP but with notices that say "Vista is recommended!".

Oh yeah, and including Safari in the software update box sucks.
 
Funny though, Vista has more market share in 1 year than Mac OS X in 7...
Totally owned right there...

Kind of easy when Microsoft is forcing every PC manufacturer out there to bundle it with all of their new systems.
I get so tired of hearing this crap all the time. Give me some proof how they "FORCE" Dell to use Windows. Oh wait, they don't...
 
I do see XP listed on the Inspirons. But like I said, there is a banner on the page that says recommends you install Vista.
 
Yeah, that's /[Linux]/. I don't see XP as an option when I price out a Windows notebook or desktop, only Vista.

I don't blame Dell. Making drivers for XP and Vista raises development costs and subsequently the cost of their systems. I'm glad they're thinking of real customers instead of the rebels like you.
 
Yeah, that's /[Linux]/. I don't see XP as an option when I price out a Windows notebook or desktop, only Vista.

If I recall, your exact comment was that Microsoft forced PC manufacturers to use Windows. Backpedaling much?

Any business in the world won't want to market their older products. They would rather market the newer stuff that is making them the most money. It's common business sense.

I'd also wager to bet Dell is getting better deals on the Vista licenses as well.
 
If I recall, your exact comment was that Microsoft forced PC manufacturers to use Windows. Backpedaling much?

Any business in the world won't want to market their older products. They would rather market the newer stuff that is making them the most money. It's common business sense.

I'd also wager to bet Dell is getting better deals on the Vista licenses as well.

People buying PCs will use Windows because that is the most widely supported operating system that isn't tied to closed hardware. Linux is nice but it isn't there yet (even I won't use Ubuntu as my main OS because I don't want to deal with the hassle of Windows gaming on it). Vista is the newest version of Windows, ergo it will sell a gazillion copies because PCs, particularly HP and Dell, sell more than anybody. I'm not backpedalling at all.
 
It may just be me, but if Microsoft were forcing every PC manufacturer out there to use Windows, I wouldn't expect to see Linux anywhere in the picture...

Go back and read through the thread. I said Vista. If I said "Windows" then you would have a point, but I was specifically talking about heavily promoting sales of Vista over XP, to the point of not even offering it as an option in some cases. At best it is an option that isn't promoted.

That's two threads where you are showing really really poor debate skills. But keep grasping for straws there, kid.
 
And to be on topic and absolutely clear on my stance on Apple pushing Safari on Windows iTunes users, I think it is crap. Forget the fact that their Windows software versions aren't good (they aren't, Safari is fast as hell but IMO crap on Windows), this is a really lame thing to do.
 
Go back and read through the thread. I said Vista.

No, actually you said "it".

And even if it is Vista, and you are specific (which I'd take)... you still fail to show me how Microsoft is forcing HP or Dell to use Vista.

Hell, they still offer XP.

They even one-upped history by supporting XP for LONGER...

If we went by your logic, we'd still have Windows 98 supported and sold.
 
No, actually you said "it".

And even if it is Vista, and you are specific (which I'd take)... you still fail to show me how Microsoft is forcing HP or Dell to use Vista.

Hell, they still offer XP.

They even one-upped history by supporting XP for LONGER...

If we went by your logic, we'd still have Windows 98 supported and sold.

They've actually officially threatened to not provide XP disks to OEM's anymore. They've even had a couple of dates fixed for the actual change. Both times, customer response (especially from large businesses) was so strong that Microsoft acquiesced to the requests of manufacturers like Dell and HP along with their customers and agreed to continue providing XP. It's not like it's a big deal to them as far as money goes. If customers want XP and will pay for XP, then MS still makes its money. At least they were receptive enough to listen and meet the demand, exhibiting one rare example where the consumers (who should have the power in the first place) exerted control over what product was supplied to them.

So you're right. They are not forcing, but they are pushing really hard, and frankly I'm glad. Call me crazy, but I run Vista Home Premium on my HTPC, Vista Ultimate 64 bit on my gaming/workstation rig (see sig.), and OSX and Vista 32 bit on my Macbook. I've spent time getting used to where things are, how things work, and I've done some things to improve performance, like disabling stupid worthless processes, etc. When I go back and have to use a Windows XP computer, whatever version, it feels clunky and so yesterday. Things just aren't as smooth, fluid, and intuitive. I've had the chance to be on both sides of the coin. Vista actually brought some real world improvements to the modern OS, and VIsta 64-bit on my "mean machine" works so well and is so stable. You wouldn't believe how well it performs. It provides support for all the ram I want, and has noticeable performance gains over Vista 32-bit. I am very pleased. Yeah, I had a few issues at first, but in a short time drivers have been released and hotfixes have been downloaded. If everyone will gradually shift into Vista, the driver development process will be further streamlined and the market will slowly normalize again.

People buying XP computers are largely taking a big paranoid step backwards. Yeah, Vista takes more horsepower to run than XP, but it really does do more. Maybe not anything that some of you would ever want to do (and I admit it has some things that it could really do without, like its burdensome integrated DRM), but some will see real benefits from Vista over XP. If anything, it just feels smoother, better, and more powerful. It provides a better computing experience, and like I said, going back to an XP computer just feels clunky and inefficient. (For example, compare file searching, sorting, organizing, and backup tools, all integrated into folder browsing within Vista just a right click away - and with way more options than XP. When I go back to XP, I really do miss some of the options and configurations Vista has available.)

Is Vista perfect? Absolutely not. Will it run well on older computers? Probably not. But I have yet to see a perfect OS. Apple's hyped Leopard that "just works" .... BALONEY. I installed Leopard over Tiger and had nothing but problems and crashes for days until apple release patches and fixes for everything. Even Apple's own iLife suite was completely unstable at first. And Leopard is noticeably more system-demanding than Tiger was, but like Vista vs. XP, Leopard has more features and does more than Tiger did. Some of the differences will seem like bells and whistles to some of you, but there really are some advancements with both new OS's that take us in the right direction and can add a noticeable degree of productivity and organization to our files, and our lives.

Sooooooooo, I don't mind MS pushing Vista a little, because for many consumers it really does more stuff, and makes a lot of things easier or more possible than they were in XP. The fact that Vista 64-bit supports the 8GB memory config. just fine makes Superfetch a very powerful tool to be reckoned with. App load times are very short on my rig. So Vista has real benefits, even for a geek like me.
 
No, actually you said "it".

And even if it is Vista, and you are specific (which I'd take)... you still fail to show me how Microsoft is forcing HP or Dell to use Vista.

Hell, they still offer XP.

They even one-upped history by supporting XP for LONGER...

If we went by your logic, we'd still have Windows 98 supported and sold.

Stop.

Here is the quote I was responding to: "Funny though, Vista has more market share in 1 year than Mac OS X in 7..."

My quote: "Kind of easy when Microsoft is forcing every PC manufacturer out there to bundle it with all of their new systems. At best you might get an option to install XP but with notices that say "Vista is recommended!"."

It = Vista. I don't see how it can be interpreted any other way unless you are just fishing for an argument.

As for me hoping for 98 to still be offered, no, there is a difference. The jump from XP to 98 was absolutely astronomical. It was just an incredible leap that words can't even describe. I still remember how awesome it was. And if we're talking about frigging ME, we might as well be talking about the jump from 3.1. :)

The jump from XP to Vista cannot compare. If you say "well, what more can they do?", just look to OS X. After that many years I wanted more from Windows, and instead they deliver a poor copy of an old version of OS X on top of Windows architecture. The original plan for Longhorn was to make it much cleaner and more comparable to the other operating systems, before they had to scrap that plan and basically throw window dressing on an old OS that runs slower on the same hardware than XP did (OS X by comparison runs slightly faster with each release due to optimizations to the kernal).

Here's hoping MS delivers with Windows 7 (from the start the emphasis seems to be on making it tight), because as long as I play Windows games I'll have to use it.
 
SirKronan - Sorry to hear you've had problems. I haven't had a single issue with Leopard since I've started using it, but then again it was a fresh install on a new machine. That is surprising though since my ancient G4 tower had upgrades from 10.2 to 10.3 to 10.4 with no formats and installs, just straight upgrades, and I had no problems, plus each update also brought a slight improvement in performance.

Maybe I'll grow to like Vista more but right now all I see is "yup, they ripped that off and it isn't as good" and "man, this is really convoluted, WTF were they thinking?". :)
 
This type of tactic isn't anything new. When it came time to install new video card drivers for my laptop, the ATi x300 drivers included STEAM, also installs Steam before the drivers actually install. At least Apple gave you guys a choice, in my case, ATi is asshole enough to force you to install Steam on a video card so old it can't even run any decent games.
 
Yeah, that's /[Linux]/. I don't see XP as an option when I price out a Windows notebook or desktop, only Vista.

And Ford wont sell you a '72 fastback either. Call the whaaaaaambulance.

Dell has good reason for not offering two very different version of Windows: supports costs and of course, drvier dev costs.

And don't forget the cost of testing all the crapletts they install across two OSs. That alone is motivation to choose one over the other.
 
One of the main reasons i dropped Safari was that with every update they wanted to give me their shitty iTunes crap which I never ever wanted to use.

Anyway I'm not going to use any of iCrap as long as I can avoid it.
 
They've It's not like it's a big deal to them as far as money goes. If customers want XP and will pay for XP, then MS still makes its money.
And that right there is where your argument fails. Microsoft is making less money on XP than Vista...

The jump from XP to 98 was absolutely astronomical. It was just an incredible leap that words can't even describe.
This is where your argument here fails: there wasn't a big jump from 98 to XP. Windows 2000 was in there, and as history and internet archives show, people had the same opinions of XP back then ("All it offers is a fancy interface"...)

Dell has good reason for not offering two very different version of Windows: supports costs and of course, drvier dev costs.
Which drives the cost of third party software up as well, to support both.
I don't know how many times I've had to call in, and the reps needed to be trained in both Vista and XP... Increases training costs, increases development costs, and increases support costs. All the while making the end product more expensive because of it.
 
See, funny thing, I was a little disappointed the Apple in regards to the auto update/let's just throw this out there and see what happens attitude, but I installed it anyways. It can be removed, and I've wanted to try it just to see what it's like.

It's a big deal that's not a big deal really. If they'd included some trojan/malware/adware, then I think that we'd have the right to be pissed, but it's a stable browser that alot of people use.

PS: I used it for 10 minutes and got rid of it. Give me Firefox any day!!!
 
This is where your argument here fails: there wasn't a big jump from 98 to XP. Windows 2000 was in there, and as history and internet archives show, people had the same opinions of XP back then ("All it offers is a fancy interface"...)

Win2K had compatibility issues that kept many of us from making the jump. It wasn't even a factor for most people and the experience that they had was from 98 to XP.

And those people who were complaining that XP was nothing but a fancy interface were complaining for the sake of complaining (gee, big surprise on the internet). The difference in OS stability and user interface was astounding. Anyone bitching about that was doing it for the sake of doing it.
 
Win2K had compatibility issues that kept many of us from making the jump. It wasn't even a factor for most people and the experience that they had was from 98 to XP.

And those people who were complaining that XP was nothing but a fancy interface were complaining for the sake of complaining (gee, big surprise on the internet). The difference in OS stability and user interface was astounding. Anyone bitching about that was doing it for the sake of doing it.
No, because it really was just a pretty interface, XP didn't add a whole lot over windows 2000 and certainly made it a bloated version at that. Vista just furthers this bloat with the requirement of 512MB of ram and all, completely out of line. Also how is it that vista needs 30GB of disk space just for its files? It's complete waste, they must have used uncompressed images for the menus inside the OS or something.
 
And those people who were complaining that XP was nothing but a fancy interface were complaining for the sake of complaining (gee, big surprise on the internet).
Sounds familiar :rolleyes:

No, because it really was just a pretty interface, XP didn't add a whole lot over windows 2000 and certainly made it a bloated version at that.
I'd agree the kernel was largely the same, but XP brought quite a few features (especially with SP 2) that 2000 lacked.

Vista just furthers this bloat with the requirement of 512MB of ram and all, completely out of line.
How so? You can't run any common/modern applications with less than 512MB of RAM anyways.


Also how is it that vista needs 30GB of disk space just for its files? It's complete waste, they must have used uncompressed images for the menus inside the OS or something.
It is a disk eater. But hard drives are cheap nowadays. Not something I like too much, but Vista caches and keeps so much "stuff", no wonder why it uses so much.
But it doesn't do it needlessly... Keeping stuff for System Restore (single example) can save user's asses sometimes.
 
loljw6.png


LOL the plan is working perfectly. :D http://www.cbronline.com/article_news.asp?guid=42F1A44B-B39F-48AE-83D2-B1A5E15D02F4
 
I really don't think Mozilla's CEO would be badmouthing Apple if they were planning on a partnership, lol :D
 
Back
Top