Motherboard and Proc Fried

Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
28
So my fiance calls me from work, she was working on her computer and the wall outlet made a snap-pop sound, and now the computer won't POST.

It's an ASUS Commando, where the rear diagnostic display doesn't appear to work correctly, and a dual core 2.66. At least, that's what I remember the processor being...I built it about two years ago for her.

I've been too busy to keep up with current trends. What would be a good bang for the buck equivalent to the ASUS Commando? (this is assuming it's the mobo and not power supply or processor or all of the above).

As it stands now, I can get the system to spin up (which makes me think the Corsair PS is good), but no post. I've swapped out processor, video card, and memory, same thing...system turns over, but no POST.

So all that said, and with the diagnostic display not working...I'm leaning towards buying her a new motherboard.

So what's good these days?
 
Probably easier for folks to help if you describe what your / her primary use will be; gaming, internet only, video editing, etc.

Also, guestimate your budget.

If you're looking for a solution in best value gaming, try the Intel E8400 and then decide whether you're looking for an SLI / Crossfire solution (big gaming $$) or a single card solution - which may help determine what mobo to match it to...
 
You might check voltages from the PSU first...
+1. What would make the wall outlet 'snap and pop'? Excessive draw from a blown PSU? There's nothing in there otherwise that would blow and the outlet still work, especially given there was no fire. Perhaps the PSU was what popped.
 
I cant see that the PSU was the problem.
The PSU has not been reported to smell of anything bad (so hasnt shorted) and its fuse isnt blown.
Mains sockets arent easily killed, it takes a lot of current (to burn the contacts) or a short circuit in itself.
Assuming none of the PC's fuses have blown (ie high current didnt travel down the mains wire), this leaves a short circuit in the socket.
Therefore if only the socket has suffered massive current damage, the socket itself must have been the problem.

The electrical noise generated by the sockets destruction will be what has damaged the PC.
 
From my experience, it's very, very, very hard to kill a CPU, and I would be very surprised if it's indeed dead. Maybe try it in another board?
 
I was right, it was the motherboard. Typically I would have thought Power Supply, but the goofy display on the Diagnostic LCD biased me towards Mobo.

My fiance decided to splurge a bit, and we got another high end board. The ASUS P5Q3 Deluxe, with some nice OCZ Platinum memory. So it looks like I need to get her a processor upgrade for X-mas.

As for why the socket would go snap-pop. I think it's the aluminum wiring in the 35 year old building. It's going to be a long winter project for me to pull all the Al and install Cu.

Darkside...if she had an Asus Commando, and I'm looking for something comparable, what does it matter what she's using it for?
 
Back
Top