Most stable Athlon MP mobo

Mournblade

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 13, 2002
Messages
366
A friend of mine has asked me to spec up a dual chip machine that will take over his database from his Dual PIII-600 that he is retiring. There'll be no-overclocking and no games playing - the whole point is to run database transactions 24/7.

I've looked around for my fav manufactuers (Abit and ASUS) but they don't appear to have any for sale in this country (UK). All I can find is Tyan, MSI, and Gigabyte. I've had good single-cpu Gigabyte boards in the past (PI & PII era), MSI have always seemed a little budget like to me and Tyan are hella expensive.

So far I have a pair of 2400+ specced up and 2GB of TwinX memory - depending if the board can use it - most use ECC (he doesn't want registered memory).

GFX card shouldn't be spectacular nor does it need sound so onboard will do. The hdd's will be coming in from another machine as will the raid controller, so that's another thing to factor out.

Really all I need are: CPUs, Mobo, & PSU.

So what are your thoughts?
 
ok,
which boards specifically? could you give us the boards names and perhaps a url to look at them?
Ok, I assume you are going Athlon MP (which will be much faster than the PIII 600's) and will be the less expensive move. The gygabyte board is a good option, so is Tyan's board... The tyan board will be higher in price, but that does not mean it is more stable/faster/etc...
Msi has improved over the recent years, but I do not have personal experience with them. I do with tyan (server up for 3 years, 24/7 with Win server 2000 - running network duties - zero down time... tyan s2466n-4m)
I believe the gigabyte model (GA-7DPXDW-P) may allow for non-ecc use - but considering what you are using the system for DO use ecc as that will be beneficial.
Here are some links to the boards I am talking about (US $$$ sorry)
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProdu...frcode=0&propertycode=&propertycodevalue=3234
You prolly know you will need a 4u or full atx case for these boards... I also recommend a psu (power supply) upgrade...
Good luck and I'd go gigabyte and spend the money saved elsewhere...
 
I was using Scan Computers for the list. My perrenial favourite OC.uk don't have any boards apart from the 940's (they sell MP's though).

The boards listed by scan are:
Gigabyte 7DPXDW+ Dual AMD SoA with Raid 10/100 Lan
MSI K7D Master-L Dual AMD Athlon Mobo DDR Lan+Audio+USB2
Tyan S2462NG Dual Athlon Mobo (w/o SCSI)
Tyan S2469GN IDE Dual MP
Tyan S2469UGN IDE Dual MP + U320 SCSI
Tyan Tiger MP Dual Athlon
Tyan Tiger MP-X Dual S2466N-4M Athlon with 10/100 Lan USB2 (2466N)-4

Dabs has just this:
SoA AMD 760MPX ATX A L

These are the main sites I have found. I will Kelkoo for them over the weekend (or try out Froogle). If you have any opinions about the ones listed about then please post them (especially not to buy ones).

The S2466N-4M is listed at scan so that looks good.
 
ok,
If memory serves, the Tyan S2466N-4M and the gigabyte are similar go with either
 
Here is a reveiw of the Gigabyte board:

http://www.2cpu.com/Hardware/GA-7DPXDW+/

Only thing I can notice is that it will only take 2GB of unbuffered DDR, or up to 3.5GB of Registered DDR. (the non registered DDR will only work in the first two DIMM slots)

Why does he not want Registered RAM?

BTW, more DP MB reviews here: http://www.2cpu.com/reviews/

edit: Per AMD, the 2GB limit for unregisted DDR is from the chipset: http://www.amd.com/us-en/Processors/ComputingSolutions/0,,30_288_1274_3734^873^1032,00.html#1394 This means that any Athlon MP motherboard will at most only be able to use 2 DIMMS of non registered DDR RAM. If you want to use all 4 DIMMS it will have to be registered DDR.


==>Lazn
 
theyre all stable as hell, even OC'ed...i had the gigabyte one...it kicked much ass. and even with OC'd hacked XP->MP's and non registered non-ECC ram modules, 100% stable.
 
Originally posted by kronchev
theyre all stable as hell, even OC'ed...i had the gigabyte one...it kicked much ass. and even with OC'd hacked XP->MP's and non registered non-ECC ram modules, 100% stable.

A friend of mine has the identical single CPU board. It uses mostly the same components, and his board is very stable with some impressive RAM bandwidth benchmarks. ;) I'd go witht he Gigabyte.
 
I have had good experience with Tyan boards, MSI and lousy experience with Gigabyte.
 
Originally posted by Sir-Fragalot
I have had good experience with Tyan boards, MSI and lousy experience with Gigabyte.

I've had just the opposite... hardware is odd that way. Every Tyan board I've built a system with, issues. MSI has been unstable for me, yet Gigabyte has always been rock solid. Maybe the air is different here. Honestly, Tyan and MSI make great motherboards and do reccomend them.

Back on thread - the Tyan dually is a good board from what I've seen / read. Haven't personally built a system using one, but know some who have and they are stable and reliable.

For DB transactions, don't scrimp on memory or drive speed - cram as much RAM in there as you can, and the fastest HD's for the DB.

If you want flat out performance for DB's build what we have at work - our SQL servers are dual 2.4 GHz P4 Xeons, 3 GB uber fast RDRAM and 15,000 RPM SCSI drives (RAID 10 for performance and redundancy ), and we have 7 of them now. Spendy as all get out tho.

Peace,
Tim
 
Originally posted by somecallmeTim
I've had just the opposite... hardware is odd that way. Every Tyan board I've built a system with, issues. MSI has been unstable for me, yet Gigabyte has always been rock solid. Maybe the air is different here. Honestly, Tyan and MSI make great motherboards and do reccomend them.

Back on thread - the Tyan dually is a good board from what I've seen / read. Haven't personally built a system using one, but know some who have and they are stable and reliable.

For DB transactions, don't scrimp on memory or drive speed - cram as much RAM in there as you can, and the fastest HD's for the DB.

If you want flat out performance for DB's build what we have at work - our SQL servers are dual 2.4 GHz P4 Xeons, 3 GB uber fast RDRAM and 15,000 RPM SCSI drives (RAID 10 for performance and redundancy ), and we have 7 of them now. Spendy as all get out tho.

Peace,
Tim

I agree with the bit on the DB server. I personally would get something AthlonXP 2000+ or faster with loads of RAM and a SCSI RAID array. :)

No experience with MSI or Gigabyte. I have a Tyan Tiger 100 and it's pretty good. It doesn't take PIII 133 CPU's, which is a drag. :(
 
Since he is upgrading his old server he already has RAID controller - I think he mentioned RAID 5. Hence the reason why onboard SCSI wasn't needed - the harddrives and controllers are already in place.

The reason for not wanting ECC ram is that it used to cost too much - remember the last time he built this machine a dual chip PIII-600 was top of the range. However Registered seems the only way to go.

This is my shopping list:
CPU A: AMD Athlon MP 2400+ £89.58
CPU B: AMD Athlon MP 2400+ £89.58
Motherboard: Tyan Tiger MP-X Dual S2466N-4M £168.03
PSU: 470W HiperPower Dual Pro. £52.88
Memory A: Corsair 512Mb ECC Reg.PC2100 £93.41
Memory B: Corsair 512Mb ECC Reg.PC2100 £93.41
Total from Scan: £586.89

Unfortunately I can't seem to find a case that can support 6 hdd's (without resorting to drive rails) that will take the cost well into the £800+ range. I dunno whether his current case would take the new bits - it should do.

Also the FONT tag doesn't work (at least it doesn't in Preview).

Edit - forgot to include memory in costs.
 
Database Server = ECC RAM - period.

You can not afford to lose data in anyway shape or form. Believe it or not, your "non-ECC" ram in your gaming rig messses up data quite a bit, but you'll never notice (is that pixel black or dark grey like it's suppossed to ?) :). Yes , it costs more, but you gotta have it.

Specs look good - I have a friendn who does heavy PHP development and he has that Tyan Mobo for his MySql database and it's been up and running 24/7 for a looooong time. Other than some reboots for kernal patches - stable.
 
Originally posted by somecallmeTim
Database Server = ECC RAM - period.

You can not afford to lose data in anyway shape or form. Believe it or not, your "non-ECC" ram in your gaming rig messses up data quite a bit, but you'll never notice (is that pixel black or dark grey like it's suppossed to ?) :). Yes , it costs more, but you gotta have it.

Specs look good - I have a friendn who does heavy PHP development and he has that Tyan Mobo for his MySql database and it's been up and running 24/7 for a looooong time. Other than some reboots for kernal patches - stable.

I have some PC 100 ECC RAM and it doesn't work very well in my standard PC100/PC133 boards. I need a board that requires ECC? It's a 256 meg chip and some boards only see half of it...
 
Originally posted by ’m‚³‚ñ
I have some PC 100 ECC RAM and it doesn't work very well in my standard PC100/PC133 boards. I need a board that requires ECC? It's a 256 meg chip and some boards only see half of it...

Yah - ECC Ram is different (same but different) - there's an extra chip for the check sum. A Byte has 8 bits, and with the ECC there is a "ninth" - and unless the chipset / mobo is designed to support ECC, it has issues with it because it's seeing something it can't understand.

That's the 2 cent summary, there's actually a lot more going on behind the scenes.

Peace,
Tim
 
Back
Top