Most Complex Hubble Repair Task Underway

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Today’s the day the astronauts working on the Hubble Space Telescope perform the most complex spacewalk of the repair mission. Things have been going well so far so here’s hoping today is another success.

For the first time ever, spacewalkers John Grunsfeld and Drew Feustel will be attempting to fix a scientific instrument while in orbit. Before, Hubble repair crews have just swapped one instrument for another. The effort to revive the Advanced Camera for Surveys, which was crippled by a short circuit two years ago, involves new tools and dozens of pieces that could fly around and do damage to Hubble.
 
i clicked on the slide show on the right - was worth the 15-20 minutes it took.

The hubble is awesome. I'm glad they are keeping it going.
 
i clicked on the slide show on the right - was worth the 15-20 minutes it took.

The hubble is awesome. I'm glad they are keeping it going.

I wish they would just let it die and send in a much more advanced telescope in its place.
 
I thought that they were abandoning the Hubble for a new telescope soon... why are they undergoing such expensive repairs on it now?
 
I guess they could bring it back in a shuttle if they wanted too, but of course that would cost lots of money. its obvious they would rather plunge it down into the ocean

Shame though, it's probably one of the most important men-made hardware that was put up in orbit
 
I guess they could bring it back in a shuttle if they wanted too, but of course that would cost lots of money. its obvious they would rather plunge it down into the ocean

Shame though, it's probably one of the most important men-made hardware that was put up in orbit

I'm sure they would like to bring it back, but it does cost several hundred million to get teh shuttle there and back.

Not to mention the fact by the time the Hubble is retired NASA won't be using the shuttle anymore.
 
I thought that they were abandoning the Hubble for a new telescope soon... why are they undergoing such expensive repairs on it now?

The universe is a big place. A single telescope could only ever truly explore a tiny tiny fraction of it.
 
I thought that they were abandoning the Hubble for a new telescope soon... why are they undergoing such expensive repairs on it now?

The James Webb telescope won't be ready until at least 2013. Plus, the instrumentation suite will be different than what Hubble has. Why not get more use out of the Hubble?
 
I thought that they were abandoning the Hubble for a new telescope soon... why are they undergoing such expensive repairs on it now?
Despite being the official successor to the HST, the JWST is an infrared only telescope. The HST functions from the IR to the UV. In the UV spectrum the HST's successor is the GALEX telscope (launched in 2003). There's not a general purpose optical successor on the drawing boards; nor is there likely to be one in the near to mid future. The JWST and GALEX are both observing at frequencies that are blocked by the atmosphere. Rapid improvements in adaptive optics and interferometry are resulting in ground based optical telescopes approaching and begining to surpass the HST. This will only continue as time goes by, and until orbital launch costs drop by an order of magnitude or three; building a space telscope that can out perform ground based ones isn't going to be economically feasible.
 
Rapid improvements in adaptive optics and interferometry are resulting in ground based optical telescopes approaching and begining to surpass the HST.

The same improvements can be applied to space based units as well.

Space based units have the advantage of no disturbing air to peer through or vibrations from earth based activities.

Very big bucks though, in the case of the Hubble well worth the investment IMHO.
 
The same improvements can be applied to space based units as well.

Space based units have the advantage of no disturbing air to peer through or vibrations from earth based activities.

Very big bucks though, in the case of the Hubble well worth the investment IMHO.

But what is the point if the technology is obsolete 10 years after you spend $4B putting it in orbit? I think the point is... If you spent the same money on ground based telescopes, which are far more easily updated and maintained, you could still get the same average performance for a far lower cost.
 
if the economics really did outweigh the performance benefits of space telescopes, why do they continue to plan for more space observation? as far as i know, using a telescope from the ground is hundreds of times more limited...
 
if the economics really did outweigh the performance benefits of space telescopes, why do they continue to plan for more space observation? as far as i know, using a telescope from the ground is hundreds of times more limited...

That was discussed 4 posts ago.

The atmosphere attenuates attenuates different frequencies differently. For many ranges a space telescope using immensely outdated technology is still superior, but not for all.
 
Despite being the official successor to the HST, the JWST is an infrared only telescope. The HST functions from the IR to the UV. In the UV spectrum the HST's successor is the GALEX telscope (launched in 2003). There's not a general purpose optical successor on the drawing boards; nor is there likely to be one in the near to mid future.

There is the ATLAS Telescope, but they don't plan on launching it until at least 2020. If Hubble is still operating in 2013 NASA will probably try for another servicing mission. They could boost the telescope with an unmanned vehicle and do the servicing mission whenever the Orion spacecraft/Ares rockets are ready.
 
The fact that the HST is still operational in any sense after 19 years of operation can be considered a miracle of some sort....
 
The fact that the HST is still operational in any sense after 19 years of operation can be considered a miracle of some sort....

Not really there have been several service missions.

I'd consider Voyager far more amazing in that respect, after flying through a system full of junk and hostile radiation both are still operating and generating data.

http://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/mission.html
 
Back
Top