More SED goodness

the line would be there because of the shutterspeed of the camera that took the photo(like when you see footage of someone sitting next to a computer monitor and the screen looks like it has lines going down the screen), you wouldn't see it in person.
 
wow, that technology looks amazing in the final product.

Quite impressive. It's a bummer that the smallest monitor/HDTV they will offer will be 55".

I wish they could get it down to 20" Screens for computer monitors.
 
I don't understand why there's a scnaline. I didn't think SED used scanlines to draw an image...I was under the impression that an SED display used a methodology similar to LCDs, but instead of transistors behind each pixel, there was a small electron gun. If this is the case, then the monitor doesn't 'scan' the image on the screen. Can someone explain this to me?
 
El Barto said:
wow, that technology looks amazing in the final product.

Quite impressive. It's a bummer that the smallest monitor/HDTV they will offer will be 55".

I wish they could get it down to 20" Screens for computer monitors.

Why do you think that? There are no technical limitations that would keep them from producing smaller screens. Why would they not attack that share of the market as well? All of the test models have been around 32" until very recently.
 
If and when I get an HDTV this year, I'll be going for an SED. It's about time the industry decided to make a big leap in technology besides just increasing resolution.
 
logo29a said:
Why do you think that? There are no technical limitations that would keep them from producing smaller screens. Why would they not attack that share of the market as well? All of the test models have been around 32" until very recently.

Well, the pixels would have to become much smaller to produce computer displays, due to the much higher resolutions and smaller screen sizes. They need an electron gun behind every pixel. It might be more difficult to do than you think. Computer monitors are more difficult to produce than conventional TVs.
 
I don't believer there are any technical restraints that limit pixel size like there are for plasma. I could be wrong though.
 
logo29a said:
I don't believer there are any technical restraints that limit pixel size like there are for plasma. I could be wrong though.

The size of the electron gun limits how small you can make the pixels.
 
Wait, so there will be no SED computer monitors (unless you want 50")????
 
Ever take a vid shot of a CRT monitor? What you will see are 60htz scan lines. That's what you are seeing in the picture of the SED screen.
 
Leright said:
I don't understand why there's a scnaline. I didn't think SED used scanlines to draw an image...I was under the impression that an SED display used a methodology similar to LCDs, but instead of transistors behind each pixel, there was a small electron gun. If this is the case, then the monitor doesn't 'scan' the image on the screen. Can someone explain this to me?

It's simple. SEDs *do* use scanlines...LCDs do also, by the way. Matrix addressable elements (in this case, pixels) cannot all be simultaneously accessed. You can address the elements of any single line at once, but to address the entire screen, you have to strobe through the array line by line, firing each line consecutively.

Now, once you move to a new row, the pixels in the previous row are now all "off" and will start to fade. Unless, of course, you build a bistable latching mechanism into each pixel, allowing it to "remember" its on/off state.

The first LCD screens were built with a single transistor at each pixel. These were "passive matrix" displays, and were nonlatching. Due to fading between row strobe refreshes, they were much dimmer than their replacement, "active matrix" displays. These had two transistors at each pixel, allowing them to latch state.

SED's, however, will (almost definitely) not be built with latching pixels. Its really not needed in their case, since they don't block light, they generate it directly. You compensate for fade by overdriving each pixel during its duty cycle.
 
logo29a said:
I don't believer there are any technical restraints that limit pixel size like there are for plasma. I could be wrong though.

Toshiba is building the electron guns with 4-6 nm waveguide slits. That would allow insane resolutions...I would imagine the limiting factor at this point is how small they can screenprint the addressing matrix. They've already stated that 300 DPI displays are easily doable. For a 20" monitor that would work out to around 4800x3500.

The _first_ displays, however, will be 1080p 55" TVs. Monitors won't come until later.
 
Leright said:
Well, the pixels would have to become much smaller to produce computer displays, due to the much higher resolutions and smaller screen sizes. They need an electron gun behind every pixel. It might be more difficult to do than you think. Computer monitors are more difficult to produce than conventional TVs.

While I do agree with most everything you're saying, one technical limitation of LCD's was fitting three color pixels for every one pixel on the monitor. I think that the substrate for SED's and the fact it only requires the electron gun for each pixel might be just enough to allow it to be scalled down to allow high resolution computer monitors... of course that is yet to be seen.

On the other hand, many users on this forum are happy with 1080p on the Westinghouse 37" LCD, and I think SED is MORE than capeable of doing 1080 on a 37". So that being said using such a 'television' as a computer monitor might yield very impressive, immersive, and high contrast colour results!
 
Erasmus354 said:
The size of the electron gun limits how small you can make the pixels.

That wasn't the point. The electron emiters can be made just a few nanometers in size. This would allow individual pixels to be as small or smaller than current lcd pixels.
 
BillR said:
Ever take a vid shot of a CRT monitor? What you will see are 60htz scan lines. That's what you are seeing in the picture of the SED screen.

SED's do NOT scan like a CRT. They are illuminated in much the same way as a plasma or lcd.
 
logo29a said:
SED's do NOT scan like a CRT. They are illuminated in much the same way as a plasma or lcd.
This is incorrect; scroll up where I posted an explanation. CRTs, SEDs, *and* LCDs all use scanlines to update. Why don't you see scanlines when taking pictures of LCDs? Because they latch the display.

The electron emiters can be made just a few nanometers in size. This would allow individual pixels to be as small or smaller than current lcd pixels.
Once again, scroll up. Emitters 4nm in size are not "as small" than current LCD pixels, they would be several thousand times smaller. The emitters aren't the limiting factor at present.
 
darkhorse said:
the line would be there because of the shutterspeed of the camera that took the photo(like when you see footage of someone sitting next to a computer monitor and the screen looks like it has lines going down the screen), you wouldn't see it in person.


i never get lines when taking pictures of my LCD screens
 
cost should be astronomical to start. probably over 10,000. might be a year (hopefully less) before the price drops by 50% and more.
 
Will SED HDTVs be better than Plasma in terms of contract and other picture quality related attributes? Also, will it be as thin (I don't think so) ?
 
SED picture quality exceeds plasma in most respects. And yes, the form factor is pretty much identical. They aren't substantially thicker.
 
Hmm we were going to buy a nice 50 or 55 inch plasma HDTV around Q1 2007 but maybe it would be a good idea to wait for SED HDTV :confused:
 
Exciting news.
Kind of.

Been reading here and there about this display technology for a while now. Most of it was about this replacing LCD and CRT computer monitors (maybe because I only read about computers and not TV's). This was supposed to be the best of both worlds and CHEAPER to make to boot. We'll spit em out for half the price they say.

Now all of a sudden it's here and not a word on any of the write-ups (I've read) about this technology being used in computer monitors.( funny though, I found this thread on a pc hardware sight in the monitors section)

My old 19" CRT might make it another year. Gettin a little dim but I can still adjust gamma in drivers..........washes out contrast though...........anybody see anything on when I will be able to buy my new 21"-24" SED computer monitor for $200-$250? Not interested in a $10,000 55" TV.
 
logo29a said:
That wasn't the point. The electron emiters can be made just a few nanometers in size. This would allow individual pixels to be as small or smaller than current lcd pixels.

The limiting factor is most likely the current density. If you think of the "guns" as needle poits behind the screen, as you go smaller the current increases proportionaly, so does the heat, and in the end it would probably burn out the gun (dull niddle point) in very short time
 
alexpronko said:
The limiting factor is most likely the current density. If you think of the "guns" as needle poits behind the screen, as you go smaller the current increases proportionaly, so does the heat, and in the end it would probably burn out the gun (dull niddle point) in very short time
Good thinking...but incorrect. You forget that as you shrink the emitter size, you also shrink the phosphor area you need to excite. So the current/area ratio remains constant. Furthermore, a smaller emitter means a narrower separation distance needed from the phosphor layer (since your required divergence is less), and therefore your driving current per unit area goes DOWN slightly as your resolution rises.

Toshiba has already said the limiting factor at present is screenprinting the control matrix...and they aren't even coming close to this limit at present. They're limiting resolution now by market demand, not the innate technology.
 
wrangler said:
Now all of a sudden it's here and not a word on any of the write-ups (I've read) about this technology being used in computer monitors
That's because, although it will be substantially cheaper than LCDs in the long run, in the short term they need to amortize R&D costs, and spinup production to mass-market levels. The first market they can hit is big-screen flat-panel TVs, since those are already astronomicallly priced. Still, I think $10K is too high. I'd guess the first ones hit North America at the $5K range.

Long-term, SED will supplant LCD in price as well as image quality. But don't expect SED monitors until some factory capacity gets built...possibly late 2007.
 
bump ign got hands on too

http://gear.ign.com/articles/679/679235p1.html

ces-2006-toshibas-plasmalcd-killer-20060105074419031.jpg
 
SEDs look totally awesome but I'm bummed that there will be a native resolution. Hopefully they interpolate better than LCDs do.
 
powerade said:
bump ign got hands on too
Nice link, thanks. A truly amazing display, isn't it? 100,000 contrast, 1080p native res, sub 1ms response time.

powerade said:
Hopefully they interpolate better than LCDs do.
Interpolation is a function of pixel size and the scaling algorithms used, not the innate technology. The first SEDs will be 1080p and probably use the same scalers present on most TV sets...so don't expect any miracles here.
 
for those still curious about the lines:

"One thing we did notice was that the displays looked like they had extremely low refresh rates. You could see the screen refreshing much like a CRT set to 60Hz. Granted the technology is still pre-production so that could explain the issue."

"The dark bar across the screen is our camera capturing the visible refresh rate on the display"

(anandtech)

Anyone know if they'll be more or less than lcds?
 
Bop said:
SEDs look totally awesome but I'm bummed that there will be a native resolution. Hopefully they interpolate better than LCDs do.

They won't, its the same concept as an lcd as far as mapping pixel to pixel. And that is why running non-native resolution can cause IQ problems.

I don't know why people have such a problem with a native resolution. Is it because you like to run it at different resolutions for different apps? Or because hi-rez makes everything too small, haha.
 
TheTMan said:
They won't, its the same concept as an lcd as far as mapping pixel to pixel. And that is why running non-native resolution can cause IQ problems.

I don't know why people have such a problem with a native resolution. Is it because you like to run it at different resolutions for different apps? Or because hi-rez makes everything too small, haha.

When it comes to gaming I change my res on my CRT to 1280x960 or 1600x1200 depending on the performance I get. I sure don't want to be stuck playing a game at a high res and get less than 30fps.
 
Bop said:
When it comes to gaming I change my res on my CRT to 1280x960 or 1600x1200 depending on the performance I get. I sure don't want to be stuck playing a game at a high res and get less than 30fps.

but a 100" SED 1080P TV will look amazing from 10 feet away and playing doom 3 :p
 
wrangler said:
Now all of a sudden it's here and not a word on any of the write-ups (I've read) about this technology being used in computer monitors.( funny though, I found this thread on a pc hardware sight in the monitors section)

My old 19" CRT might make it another year. Gettin a little dim but I can still adjust gamma in drivers..........washes out contrast though...........anybody see anything on when I will be able to buy my new 21"-24" SED computer monitor for $200-$250? Not interested in a $10,000 55" TV.

55" will be the smallest display at first, they will expand from there. No word on making smaller displays. According to AVS Forum, and people who were at CES the SED's will be available this year, by year end. The price point will be the same as the soon to be released 1080p plasmas from Pioneer and Panasonic, ie, 7-9k range. Everything points to these displays at least replacing plasma and competing head on with LCD. I for one will probably ditch one of my plasmas if and when the SED's prove themselves a competent replacement. This has yet to be seen.
 
masher said:
Still, I think $10K is too high. I'd guess the first ones hit North America at the $5K range.

I don't. Think about LED LCDs. I've seen one thats out there and it costs about $6,5k. Sure it's a display aimed for proffesionals but still that is an ordinary dull 19" screen.

Wouldn't be suprised if SED displays goes beyond $10k to perhaps $20k in the beginning. Look at blue-ray. You have been able to buy blu-ray recorders for years now. They costed about $10k in the beginning (or was it more?). Thats an *useless* recorder that probably has incombability problems with pretty much every standard that exists :p

I really wonder if SED is worth wating for. I hope that LED will come out real soon to the mass market and that it will be good enough not to wait for SED. Because if the price range is that high it will probably be around in the middle of 2008 (or atleast beginning of 2008) before you can get a decent SED (lets say 24") monitor for a decent price. And if thats the case it will probably take atleast 6 months before you have a really solid monitor and just not the first decent one.

And thats hard to justify really. Better to get a new monitor today and get another around 2010-2015 when SED not only are common but much better than in the beginning and with _really_ high resolutions. Because the future in general will not be based on pixels. Which means that higher resolutions does not mean smaller GUI, thus you could have 25 megapixels on a 15" screen and just scale that up so it would look like normal - only with *infinite* sharpness :p

edit:
Also if there is no competition for these SED displays and only a few can make them in the beginning the prices will remain very high for a long time.
Production costs has pretty much nothing at all with the street price in the beginning.
 
masher said:
Once again, scroll up. Emitters 4nm in size are not "as small" than current LCD pixels, they would be several thousand times smaller. The emitters aren't the limiting factor at present.

I did Not say that they weren't thousands of times smaller than LCD pixels. Another individual was insinuating that they would be a limiting factor. I never said this. :rolleyes:
 
robocop974 said:
I for one will probably ditch one of my plasmas if and when the SED's prove themselves a competent replacement. This has yet to be seen.
Emitter stress testing shows only a 10% drop in brightness after 40,000 hours of use. That's a rather competent replacement. :p
 
masher said:
Emitter stress testing shows only a 10% drop in brightness after 40,000 hours of use. That's a rather competent replacement. :p

Do you have any information regarding time to 50% brightness?
 
Back
Top