More Patent Lawsuits Hit Microsoft

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
East Texas not only has punishing humidity, it apparently also has punishing courts when it comes to patent infringement. Two more lawsuits were filed against Microsoft in the same court district that features the Word case. One filing against MS includes Southwest Airlines and Scottrade. Like to argue about words? Maybe a patent law career is in your future. ;)

Patent-infringement lawsuits against larger companies have a history of being won in that part of the Texas court system. In 2006, Microsoft and Nintendo were ordered to pay $21 million to Anascape, a small IT outfit, for violating a patent related to game controllers; as recently as July, another tiny company,Tsera, sued Microsoft, Apple and 21 other tech companies over a touch-screen patent.
 
BRB, patenting "a way for humans to remove waste from their bodies."
Get your wallets ready bitches, I'm coming for you.
 
I would like to walk in a courtroom and argue over what the word "the" means. :p
 
PATENT 1

United States Patent 7,020,845
Gottfurcht , et al. March 28, 2006

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Navigating internet content on a television using a simplified interface and a remote control


Abstract
A method and apparatus of simplified navigation. A web page is provided having a link to a sister site. The sister site facilitates simplified navigation. Pages from the sister site are served responsive to actuation of the sister site link. In one embodiment, the sister site includes matrix pages to permit matrix navigation.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Inventors: Gottfurcht; Elliot A. (Pacific Palisades, CA), Gottfurcht; Grant E. (Pacific Palisades, CA), Long; Albert-Michel C. (Irvine, CA)
Appl. No.: 09/518,015
Filed: March 3, 2000


Patent 2

United States Patent 7,441,196
Gottfurcht , et al. October 21, 2008

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apparatus and method of manipulating a region on a wireless device screen for viewing, zooming and scrolling internet content


Abstract
A method and apparatus of simplified navigation. A web page is provided having a link to a sister site. The sister site facilitates simplified navigation. Pages from the sister site are served responsive to actuation of the sister site link. In one embodiment, the sister site includes matrix pages to permit matrix navigation.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Inventors: Gottfurcht; Elliot A. (Pacific Palisades, CA), Gottfurcht; Grant E. (Pacific Palisades, CA), Long; Albert-Michel C. (Irvine, CA)
Assignee: Gottfurcht; Elliot (Pacific Palisades, CA)
Marlo Longstreet 2003 Irrevocable Trust (Pacific Palisades, CA)
Grant Gottfurcht 2003 Irrevocable Trust (Pacific Palisades, CA)

Appl. No.: 11/373,324
Filed: March 13, 2006


Why are patents like this even legal, how can you posibly interpret something so broad

Get ready, no more web browsing on TV's
 
*sighs* Facepalm

I'm not the biggest MS Fan out there, but even I can see that this i just getting out of hand.
 
I don't understand who approves these patents. There is nothing being invented in those statements.

Plus there is prior art with both of those patents. For instance, plenty of sites had versions of there sites compatible with WEP browsers on phones and such.
 
Microsoft have been patent trolls for a long time. Karma, if you will. I can only hope that Apple soon gets stung by patents as bad as Microsoft.

Or just abolish patents; that would be better.
 
Patent trolling is the new home of web domain name squatters. All you have to do is come up with some broad and vague idea that encompasses something almost common sense or common place. Sit on said patent for 2 to 5 years and BAM profit from doing nothing while another company develops a working model of your broad and vague idea.
 
Earning interest on an investment in technology using a simplified form submission.

Abstract
A method for filing patents that exclude as many details and words as possible. These broad patents collect interest on one or more companies which develop new software or hardware that infringe the patent. Patent owners file a lawsuit against infringing company a few years later to collect this interest.
 
Lawsuits should only be allowed to be filed in the city of either the plantiff's or defendants headquarters. Tyler, TX by acting like the backwards country hicks they appear to be regarding technology will now have their court system clogged with patent lawsuits from all over the country.
 
Lawsuits should only be allowed to be filed in the city of either the plantiff's or defendants headquarters. Tyler, TX by acting like the backwards country hicks they appear to be regarding technology will now have their court system clogged with patent lawsuits from all over the country.

It already is (in)famous for making pro-patent holder rulings.

And there are limitations on where cases can be filed already.
 
Again... If these companies were truly out to protect "their product" they'd be suing everyone under the sun. Not just the biggest cash cow they see.

How patents so broad get approved is beyond me. It's obviously people that have zero experience with technology approving them.
 
None of you people understand the patent office or patent law. The patent office has always (for 100+ years) been approving basically any patent. Want to patent something stupid yourself? Then go patent it and it will 99% be approved. God the stupid patents we amusingly learned about in my first year of college. You know Uri Geller has a patent for three-legged pants? I shit you not....

An approved patent does not mean you auto-win court cases people...

The big problem is defending the patent. That is done in a court of law and different court districts have different histories, interpretations and laws. Much like how every f*cking corporation has a PO Box in Delaware so they can 'claim' that their headquarters is in DE and operate under laws that favor them. Nothing strange is going on in Texas, you people just don't know WTF you are talking about... This stuff happens everywhere all the time for everything.

And they sue the people with the largest pot of money because they believe that their patent has been violated and the company will be able to pay. Often to avoid the chance of losing the larger corporations will settle.

If the patent is idiotic and can be shown to exist prior to the company filing or can be shown to be a law of nature (i.e. math) then the patent is thrown out. The big problem comes with software. Effectively all software is just a bunch of math, and so we are walking a tightrope and figuring out our patent laws right now. If we don't let software coders patent their material then how will they benefit from their work?

Big corporations know this, just like I know this and people with some education about patents know this, and they are fighting to keep as much as they can while making sure they don't give anything away. If we don't like the way the patent system is working then we can contact our elected representatives (especially state reps if you live in TX) and let them know.

Until then I'm glad that justice is being applied against big corporations. If MS hasn't done anything wrong then they don't have anything to worry about. And they have another (and another, and another) chance to help us redefine our patent laws ergo natural laws (math/software).

And please can we not have a big pity party for Microsoft? Or any of these massive behemoth zombie 'people' who never die but have to pay taxes twice?
 
The people are patent trolls and you know it. I am betting both of them get invalidated if properly challenged. But seeing as how its in Tyler it is almost a guaranteed loss for Microsoft.
 
None of you people understand the patent office or patent law. The patent office has always (for 100+ years) been approving basically any patent. Want to patent something stupid yourself? Then go patent it and it will 99% be approved. God the stupid patents we amusingly learned about in my first year of college. You know Uri Geller has a patent for three-legged pants? I shit you not....

An approved patent does not mean you auto-win court cases people...

The big problem is defending the patent. That is done in a court of law and different court districts have different histories, interpretations and laws. Much like how every f*cking corporation has a PO Box in Delaware so they can 'claim' that their headquarters is in DE and operate under laws that favor them. Nothing strange is going on in Texas, you people just don't know WTF you are talking about... This stuff happens everywhere all the time for everything.

And they sue the people with the largest pot of money because they believe that their patent has been violated and the company will be able to pay. Often to avoid the chance of losing the larger corporations will settle.

If the patent is idiotic and can be shown to exist prior to the company filing or can be shown to be a law of nature (i.e. math) then the patent is thrown out. The big problem comes with software. Effectively all software is just a bunch of math, and so we are walking a tightrope and figuring out our patent laws right now. If we don't let software coders patent their material then how will they benefit from their work?

Big corporations know this, just like I know this and people with some education about patents know this, and they are fighting to keep as much as they can while making sure they don't give anything away. If we don't like the way the patent system is working then we can contact our elected representatives (especially state reps if you live in TX) and let them know.

Until then I'm glad that justice is being applied against big corporations. If MS hasn't done anything wrong then they don't have anything to worry about. And they have another (and another, and another) chance to help us redefine our patent laws ergo natural laws (math/software).

And please can we not have a big pity party for Microsoft? Or any of these massive behemoth zombie 'people' who never die but have to pay taxes twice?

Oh I get it now! You're the judge at the Tyler, Texas patent court!

Oh man, you almost got me going there!
 
Law does not equal Justice.

It costs Microsoft money, no matter if they settle or not. Ergo it hurts just to have these patent holders sue.

I don't believe anyone here is pitying MS. We are pitying our current "letter of the law" backwoods moron brethren in Tyler, TX. It is always sad to see fools used by slime to take money from others at the expense of still *others* (where does MS make up the money they lose just defending themselves? YOU).
 
Back
Top