More Fermi Rumors - Not Good

I am in no rush due to fact most games are still DX 9 folks. As for video cards I have 3 gtx 280's in sli with 9800 gt 1 gig for physics. I am in no rush to buy ATI card or Nvidia. I will wait till 2 nd gen for Nvidia. Not in rush. I find usually second gen cards way better. Even though I have a 1 st gen card. Lesson I learned.
 
My guess is that the internal builds of Fermi are simply underperforming Nvidia's expectations with regard to gaming performance. They probably have the architeture basically worked out, its probably just too slow. They have been showing off the "work" side of things with Tesla, so I think its close to being done as far as the architecture goes.

I hope they don't just put out an underperforming card with a huge leaf-blower fan like the 5800 ultra (I actually owned one).

Thankfully, Nvidia has the GTX 260 trhough 295 series which actually performs quite well considering today's games. I'm playing Dragon Age, MW2, Borderlands, L4D2, all on 2500X1600 max detail with 4XMSAA and 16XAF with a GTX285 1GB. If I and the thousands like me couldn't do this, Nvidia would be hosed right now for sure.
 
My guess is that the internal builds of Fermi are simply underperforming Nvidia's expectations with regard to gaming performance. They probably have the architeture basically worked out, its probably just too slow.
Given the raw specs, though, I think GF100 is probably pretty damn quick. If it's not hitting NVIDIA's expectations, that would mean one of two things:

A) The clocks they're achieving are below what they had planned and expected. This is probably a given.

B) They're very costly, offering a lower performance/price ratio than RV870. If the card's only marginally faster than the 5870 but significantly more expensive for us, this wouldn't exactly be a resounding win for NVIDIA. And of course they still have to compete with the 5970 to some extent.
 
April, eh? This is not good, not at all. I miss the days when there were 3 or 4+ contenders in the graphics arena.
 
AMD is a company that is in business to make money. If Nvidia comes out with a "dog" (this is relative to performance obviously) then AMD will do the same thing they did to Intel when the Athlon 64 was competing against the Pentium 4 C/D: Jack up the price. Part and parcel of the industry mate. You see when your technology is second rate (i.e. not top performance holder), you drop the price to compete (as AMD has done since Core 2 came out) and when you are on top you charge through the nose for it.

Definitely a fanboi if you don't remember that. Or when ATI was last a mile ahead and abused it's position.

you need to read my post better.
I hope they do remember the consumer backlash Nvidia saw
They have been smart lately. I am hoping they stay that way. I never said they were saints or had been in the past.
 
There are still tons of things to do to make graphics in games look better / more photo-realistic yet. While I might not like the closed approach, PhysX has the possibility of making the game more fun yet too.

This may not be cool, but I was think along the lines of: "well, they could add more polygons".

More polygons + more, higher detailed objects in the world + more detailed shaders = better looking games.

This does not seem like a waste of videocard resources to me :p

It may be cool for everyone to suck eyefinity c*$k right now, and it's surely impressive, but higher resolution/bigger screen is just one of several avenues for improvement.
 
A repeat of 2006-2007, except that instead of nvidia dominating the market and fixing prices on the same parts while they wait for ATI to play catch-up, its now flipped around.

Yay :(
 
I am in no rush due to fact most games are still DX 9 folks. As for video cards I have 3 gtx 280's in sli with 9800 gt 1 gig for physics. I am in no rush to buy ATI card or Nvidia. I will wait till 2 nd gen for Nvidia. Not in rush. I find usually second gen cards way better. Even though I have a 1 st gen card. Lesson I learned.

Because first gen DX9 and DX10 cards were horrible and not legends in their own time. :rolleyes:
 
I bet AMD still loses money this quarter.

I'll bet not as much. :cool:

I've had all Nivida cards but one since they first came out. I had one ATI..but they are really in bad shape this time. The new card better rock really hard or ATI's next card will bet it.

They are also hurting long term with both Intel and AMD putting the GPU on the processor.

I was a die hard 3DfX fan, but they got gobbled up by Nivida. i wonder who if anyone will gobble up Nivida in the near future?
 
I'll bet not as much. :cool:

I've had all Nivida cards but one since they first came out. I had one ATI..but they are really in bad shape this time. The new card better rock really hard or ATI's next card will bet it.

They are also hurting long term with both Intel and AMD putting the GPU on the processor.

I was a die hard 3DfX fan, but they got gobbled up by Nivida. i wonder who if anyone will gobble up Nivida in the near future?

I would not be riding them off just yet. they might be sucking wind right now and its probably going to be a bad cycle coming up but they still have a lot on the table. and their other venues are looking good
 
They aren't making "new" Intel boards anymore, Intel's new integrated chips has hurt them as well.

They better build a processor to complete, or their long term future is over.
 
AMD is a company that is in business to make money. If Nvidia comes out with a "dog" (this is relative to performance obviously) then AMD will do the same thing they did to Intel when the Athlon 64 was competing against the Pentium 4 C/D: Jack up the price. Part and parcel of the industry mate. You see when your technology is second rate (i.e. not top performance holder), you drop the price to compete (as AMD has done since Core 2 came out) and when you are on top you charge through the nose for it.

Definitely a fanboi if you don't remember that. Or when ATI was last a mile ahead and abused it's position.

Excellent post, best I've read here in a long time.

All of these companies are businesses, not charities, and they will act accordingly. Fanboys of all colors (and this place is full of them) need to keep that in mind and just focus on who has the best product at a given moment in time.
 
i really dont understand why the "company of the year" is now scrambling to stay alive. They should of had all the money in the world for R&D but now they cant deliver.
 
AMD is a company that is in business to make money. If Nvidia comes out with a "dog" (this is relative to performance obviously) then AMD will do the same thing they did to Intel when the Athlon 64 was competing against the Pentium 4 C/D: Jack up the price. Part and parcel of the industry mate. You see when your technology is second rate (i.e. not top performance holder), you drop the price to compete (as AMD has done since Core 2 came out) and when you are on top you charge through the nose for it.

Definitely a fanboi if you don't remember that. Or when ATI was last a mile ahead and abused it's position.

This is what disappoints me about the 5 series. It's not much faster than the Nvidia counter-parts but because it's new and nvidia doesn't have a new product out people are jumping all over them the new cards like its the end of the world. Call me a bottom feeder but I'm willing to bet I'm more pleased with my $165 GTX275 than everyone who just bought a $300 5850. I mean youre desperate for Eyefinity great, but people are suggesting the upgrade over in the videocard section to people playing on single 22" monitors.
 
They aren't making "new" Intel boards anymore, Intel's new integrated chips has hurt them as well.

They better build a processor to complete, or their long term future is over.

Their chipset business brought them over a billion in revenue annually, that loss will sting for a long time. Just think about it, you simply cannot make up for the loss of that revenue stream overnight.
Also they've apparently been dropped by Apple (That's why you recently saw JHH sweet talking Apple a couple of weeks ago), .and I think 1 more of their big clients (10-15% total revenue type of client), due to the bumpgate fiasco.

The effects of this will not be seen for at least a year though, but it is coming. These developments will hurt them in the long term the most, since there will be less expendable income to throw at R&D. They need an absolute explosion in the HPC market in order to make up that loss of revenue, anything less will spell tough times ahead. The delays of Fermi are the most worrisome because they cause a loss in both the consumer graphics add-in board market and the HPC market.

Another interesting fact to note is that IBM recently dropped HPC development using CELL Processors. They will most likely replace those with AMD GPU's since they've been close partners for a long, long time. That means Nvidia will now have more competition in that market, a market in which they hoped they'd be the only gpgpu offering.
 
Where is Larrabee when we need it??? :D

Seriously though, my gut really tells me that this is not the time to buy a video card unless you absolutely have to have one for a new build. Supply is low. Bide your time, people. ATI is on top and nVidia is ABSOLUTELY NOT competing by price. They intentionally ramped down their production speeds. The prices are higher now on nVidia hardware than I've seen in some time. Newegg's black Friday sale price on BFG's GTX 260 Maxcore was within $50 of what I paid for one brand new a year ago when BFG had their 6th anniversary sale.

There are some low-mid to low end cards to be found at fair prices, and some power efficiency and HD functionality benefits to be gained in such cards, but the upper midrange to high end market is sparse of product to meet current demand. Unless we as consumers somehow reduce the demand, the prices will remain high and product sparse with little to compete. Like others have said, nVidia and ATI are both in it for the money, just like you would by. And like any consumer, we actually have some power - we can vote with our wallets.

ATI's highest offerings make little sense right now for anyone but those with large multi-monitor setups or a special need for Eyefinity. I have been a big tracker of bang/buck over the years since I got into the enthusiast market, and you've got to buy when it makes sense financially, especially if you're in a situation where money's tight.

Some recent examples include ATI's 4850. It hit the upper midrange market right in the teeth, offering unparalleled performance for the dollar as a single card or in crossfire with nearly the best crossfire scaling capability that ATI had ever provided up until then. One 4850 beat anything nVidia had in that price range. Two 4850's in CF beat nVidia's top offerings in many titles, again for much less cost. In my opinion, the GTX 295 was also killer bang for buck in the high end on its release date. When I bought mine, it cost less than two 260's (not to mention the SLI motherboard if you didn't have one) provided more performance across the board, and consumed less power than two 260's in SLI. With an MSRP of $500 it's one of the cheapest top end cards on its release date, if you'll remember such offerings as the 8800GTX and Ultra that could cost around $700 in the day. Now look at AMD's top end: "The 5970 still offers a good performance boost over the 5870 even with a single monitor, but with the 5870’s outstanding performance, it’s not $200 better." (from Anand). They also said, " In our benchmarks the 5970 is practically tied with the 5850CF, and a pair of such cards would sell for $600 at this time." So far the 5970 might be held back by drivers, but it might mature into killer bang/buck for the extreme enthusiast as well.
 
This is what disappoints me about the 5 series. It's not much faster than the Nvidia counter-parts but because it's new and nvidia doesn't have a new product out people are jumping all over them the new cards like its the end of the world. Call me a bottom feeder but I'm willing to bet I'm more pleased with my $165 GTX275 than everyone who just bought a $300 5850. I mean youre desperate for Eyefinity great, but people are suggesting the upgrade over in the videocard section to people playing on single 22" monitors.

what is eyefinity? cards have supported dual displays for centuries, is this just adding a third? maybe its more complex than that... anyway i agree with what piscian is saying. i havent seen any dx11 demos yet and probably wont (in person, where you can actually make a judgement) for a while. but it seems like the performance improvement isnt especially great over the last gen of nvidia cards. whats the 5XXX equivalent of a 295GTX? how bout 285GTX for single-gpu? sorry, i cant find any good comprehensive comparison charts.
 
what is eyefinity? cards have supported dual displays for centuries, is this just adding a third? maybe its more complex than that... anyway i agree with what piscian is saying. i havent seen any dx11 demos yet and probably wont (in person, where you can actually make a judgement) for a while. but it seems like the performance improvement isnt especially great over the last gen of nvidia cards. whats the 5XXX equivalent of a 295GTX? how bout 285GTX for single-gpu? sorry, i cant find any good comprehensive comparison charts.

what
the
fuck
 
This is what disappoints me about the 5 series. It's not much faster than the Nvidia counter-parts but because it's new and nvidia doesn't have a new product out people are jumping all over them the new cards like its the end of the world. Call me a bottom feeder but I'm willing to bet I'm more pleased with my $165 GTX275 than everyone who just bought a $300 5850. I mean youre desperate for Eyefinity great, but people are suggesting the upgrade over in the videocard section to people playing on single 22" monitors.
yeppers. The 5850 is an improvement over the 275, but at most it's 20% (if that). Lets go spend double the money for a 20% gain! Besides, if I were going eyefinity I sure wouldn't be buying a 5850 as the min resolution is really 3150x1680. (3x 1680x1050)

what is eyefinity? cards have supported dual displays for centuries, is this just adding a third? maybe its more complex than that... anyway i agree with what piscian is saying. i havent seen any dx11 demos yet and probably wont (in person, where you can actually make a judgement) for a while. but it seems like the performance improvement isnt especially great over the last gen of nvidia cards. whats the 5XXX equivalent of a 295GTX? how bout 285GTX for single-gpu? sorry, i cant find any good comprehensive comparison charts.
Is this troll or stupidity? I can't tell.
 
Back
Top