more $$$ = better board?

Raedon

Gawd
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
797
Okay, So I have a $38 motherboard (new) that has the same features, down to the chipset, as a board that costs $100 more almost to the cent. (not talking Jetway Vs. ASUS here)

It has the same "Enthusiest" features and OC's as high as my XP chip could go in 4 boards by 25mhz differences.


Question:

Where does that extra money go?
 
Let me do a search on the board for quality control by name brands.

This board is big enough to get a solid graph from no name to brand name on quality control. first topic only I assume to keep away from, "YEA!! F THEM!! AND I LUV DOOM!1! AND EPOX SUX" :)

Give me 12 hours.. going out.
 
I don't think so.

If the price was due to added wireless integration, i don't use wireless, it's just an extra cost.

:rolleyes:

Look at the mobo reviews, and their features like does it have 1 or 2 ethernet ports, 10.100 or a gigabyte ethernet port.

Firewire and usb. Is it the faster firewire speed that gigabyte mobos seem to offer, and is it usb 2 or 1 ( 2 is better of course ).

Does it have 8 channel ? with optical coaxial etc ...

and the gaming performance roundup and etc :cool:

I don't really bother with whether you can Oc it more or not cause i don't do that.
 
Well, what I learned was that you search for mobo's with the same features but one is higher priced you find some uninteresting facts really..

1) it seems every company has about the same DOA rate.. except a few really low end boards.

2) When they work out of the box they all are close on benchmarks unless you overclock and even then the low cost boards perform well though both high and low end had BIOS issues like Vcore limits or Vdimm limits or FSB over XXX would cause problems.

3) Some "features" sound the same until you look even deeper. Slower Firewire or poor onboard audio even with the same chipset. Some boards have PCI problems, like a SATA raid card in PCI 2 would be a problem but not 3 or 4 etc.

4) Some had issues with different DDR modules being used.

5) Both high end and low end companies had real winners and loosers. Basically I learned that you just got to do your research.
 
Not every company has the same DOA rate, no matter what is bandied about. For example, I've had a lot worse luck with ECS than other brands. I won't buy them anymore. They had some good designs when they stuck with major manufacturer chipsets, but they used poor quality control in an attempt to make inexpensive boards, and that caused a lot of issues. Seeing that I wasn't the only one having these issues, I gave up on them.

A cheaper mainboard probably uses a less complex (read: less layers) PCB than an expensive board. Or, perhaps it uses 2-phase power instead of 3/4/6 phase. Or maybe it uses much cheaper electrolytic capacitors as opposed to the tantalum ones used on expensive boards. Not immediately noticeable, but can lead to flakiness if you load one with a lot of peripherals, and it often means your cheap board will have a shorter lifespan.

Most people that search for one bargain search for more. You wind up with a bargain power supply, bargain RAM, and all of a sudden it becomes really difficult to tell what's causing your problem when things go south.
 
Cheaper hardware leads to more compatibility issues and higher failure rates. Let no one tell you different.

I can't tell you how many Fry's specials I've got to repair because they've got ECS motherboards that went south. Or a Austin Power Supply that blew up. Or doesn't put out the correct voltages across the 12v rail, but is fine on the 5v rail. Companies with better QC test their parts for greater compatibility.

You get what you pay for. Computer parts are no different.
 
Back
Top