Monitor Dilemma

Dunno86

n00b
Joined
Aug 31, 2008
Messages
1
Hi, decided to register on here as I'm fairly sick of trying to sort this stuff out on my own...

After much prevarication as an LCD novice, I decided to buy a Samsung 226bw for around $370 (from amazon.co.uk, if that's of any interest) the other day and take my chances on the panel lottery. Well, it looks like I lost (not that the back sticker/secret menu will tell me). There's pretty heavy backlight bleed (something I can just about put up with, I think - its pretty common to have some, apparently), but more significantly, I've got a pretty heavy blue tint - something that really shows up when I'm reading, which is something I have to do quite a bit of. It leaves colours such as greys and yellows looking washed out, blurry and uncomfortable on the eye. I can partially aid it by putting the colour in 'warm mode', though - that worsens the appearance of other images, though, which is a shame as the monitor can do a lot of things very well.

Anyway, I've got options - here's where you people can help me :) First of all, I could complain and try and insist Amazon send me another monitor - demanding/hoping its a better one, as this is 'faulty' - apparently significant backlight bleed counts as a fault. However, there's no guarantee on what I'll get and doing a bit of reading on this site, I saw someone say the 226bw is now out of production and all those still available are the As and Cs.

I've also got the right (for a few more days) to cancel the contract and send the screen back no questions asked if I want. I could then buy another monitor - what's the current state of play with monitors? I've found it really hard to research the area, especially when you take panel issues into account - so many reviews are old, for example - what does 9/10 in 2006 mean in 2008? I want a 22" monitor for something in the region of £200 ($400 or so) - for general use, reading and gaming mainly.

Another option I have is to keep this monitor and set about calibrating it. Some say this can tune an A panel up to S standard - not so sure about C. If so, where should I look for info on doing this? Magic tune isn't working for some reason, and I seem to be doing something wrong with the file provided here - http://www.behardware.com/articles/667-3/samsung-226bw-a-and-s-series-the-verdict.html . Using the instructions for my Vista, I have no OK button for the final act required - after I make the profile my default, I click on the advanced tab, select the profile in the top drop down menu and then have no OK button to click. There is a close button, but nothing at all noticeable happens - either the profile makes no difference, or, more likely, there's something wrong with the process (me?).

I think that's everything. Just pretty sick of the whole business, having spent a long time (trying to) research the area prior to buying. Oh yeah, one other thing - taking my monitor through the tests on this website - http://www.lagom.nl/lcd-test/ , it largely seems fine apart from the white saturation tests, where even the second line down is almost invisible. I can just make out two of the bottom line if I turn the contrast to zero, but obviously that's a pretty unsatisfactory solution.

Anyway, that really is it. Thanks for reading and offering any assistance. Just wanting to know what my next move should be.

Dunno
 
I did a bunch of frustrating research just like you. I went with the $400 HP LP2065. It is 20" 1600x1200 and is IPS for the most part. From what I have seen that is as good as it gets in this price range. Unless you are just demanding a higher res or 24"+ inches I don't see any other reason to get anything else. But that is just me. I haven't gotten the screen yet so I can't fully comment on it but the reviews look good. :)
 
Back
Top