Mod Backblaze 45disks in 4U?

brutalizer

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Oct 23, 2010
Messages
1,603
The Backblaze is quite cheap, $872. However, it has nine SATA port multiplier to support its 45 disks. I mean, Norco 4224 is not really effective as it only holds 24 disks in a 4U. I prefer 45 disks in 4U. :)

I would like SAS backplanes. The same as Norco 4224, maybe. Would this be possible to mod, you reckon? Which back planes are "problem free"?

Description of the case
http://blog.backblaze.com/2009/09/01/petabytes-on-a-budget-how-to-build-cheap-cloud-storage/

Manufacturer:
http://www.protocase.com/products/index.php?e=Backblaze


Here we have the 100TB media server build. It holds "only" 50 disks but are much larger than 4U. Compare the size of this, to the 4U backblaze which holds 45 disks. Both cases almost hold the same number of disks.
http://img38.imageshack.us/img38/6039/1000chenbrorm91250l.jpg
 
I'm thinking of buying a new enclosure / chassis and I am in the same quandry. I want more than 24 hard drive bays ideally (but 24 is ok I guess). I want a good competitive price. Even though you need to add an expander and power supply, here in the UK the price between the Norco RPC 4224 and the Supermicro chassis is massive. I really dont want to buy another Norco though, their build quality is not very good imho.

On that supermicro 45 disk enclosure where does all the warm air go? Is it just through the power supply?
 
I'm thinking of buying a new enclosure / chassis and I am in the same quandry. I want more than 24 hard drive bays ideally (but 24 is ok I guess). I want a good competitive price. Even though you need to add an expander and power supply, here in the UK the price between the Norco RPC 4224 and the Supermicro chassis is massive. I really dont want to buy another Norco though, their build quality is not very good imho.

On that supermicro 45 disk enclosure where does all the warm air go? Is it just through the power supply?

The thing is.. once you add an expander and a redundant power supply to the Norco, they are basically the same price with the SMC being of much higher quality. So it all depends on your situation - for home use where you don't need things like redundant PSU's then it's fine.

I believe the warm air still blows out the back, past/through the back disks.
 
Ok, here are 60 disks in a 4U chassis.
http://www.raidinc.com/products/storage-solutions/ebod/4u-ebod/

The supermicro stuff is too expensive for me, a home user. I am considering a norco-4224, but it is quite ineffective: only 24 disks in 4U. I want higher density. Cheap.

If you're just a cheap home user, then why do you need higher density than 24 disks?

You can't have the best AND cheap at the same time. 24 drives in 4U is good. 36 is even better. 45 or 60 is amazing.
 
If you're just a cheap home user, then why do you need higher density than 24 disks?

You can't have the best AND cheap at the same time. 24 drives in 4U is good. 36 is even better. 45 or 60 is amazing.

Maybe they don't want two chassis. Or maybe they can't fit another 4U. :p
 
The Backblaze is quite cheap, $872. However, it has nine SATA port multiplier to support its 45 disks. I mean, Norco 4224 is not really effective as it only holds 24 disks in a 4U. I prefer 45 disks in 4U. :)

I don't know a lot about this stuff but ...

The number of disks is not important. The amount of disk space is.

24 4TB disks have the same storage as 48 2TB disks.
 
Actually the number of disks can be important in several differing ways:

1) Performance - higher disk count, higher potential IO (to a point of course... controller needs to be capable!)
2) Power consumption - fewer disks, lower power consumption
3) Higher capacity disks = more expensive, conversely lower capacity disks = less expensive

The last point is probably most significant here. Lets take your case of 96TB raw:

4TB disk x 24 x ~$249 (only price I could find!) = $5976
24 Bay Super Micro case = ~$1099
TOTAL: $7075

2TB disk x 48 x $79 = $3792
Case = $1000-2000 (lets be generous, plus we need to find 48bay-er for my "math" :))
TOTAL: $5792

There are pros and cons to each method (performance/price/power). Math is real rough, but you get the idea.
 
The thing is.. once you add an expander and a redundant power supply to the Norco, they are basically the same price with the SMC being of much higher quality. So it all depends on your situation - for home use where you don't need things like redundant PSU's then it's fine.

I believe the warm air still blows out the back, past/through the back disks.

Not quite, at least here in the UK. A Norco 4224 + Expander (Chenbro) + decent power supply will set you back approx £730. A Supermicro with a SAS expander is circa £1300 -although funnily enough can see a few at £900 on the European market. From my perspective, one is prepared to pay more for a little quality but not double the cost. I'm also willing to pay more for a 48 bay device also but its a shame when the cost triples etc. I guess thats economics, supply and demand etc. At the prices of some of these devices I'd rather just buy a Sun x4500 (Thumper) and get a bunch of disks etc thrown in for "free".

Interesting, thanks!
 
I was thinking about trying to fill an empty 6U case with 14 of those 3x5.25" into 5x3.5" caddies,
three SAS expanders and a hefty PSU. 70 drives in 6U. I looked for 4x3.5" with 8087 connectors but didnt find any.
 
Not quite, at least here in the UK. A Norco 4224 + Expander (Chenbro) + decent power supply will set you back approx £730. A Supermicro with a SAS expander is circa £1300 -although funnily enough can see a few at £900 on the European market.
Where can you find supermicro at £900? On which web page?
 
Not quite, at least here in the UK. A Norco 4224 + Expander (Chenbro) + decent power supply will set you back approx £730. A Supermicro with a SAS expander is circa £1300 -although funnily enough can see a few at £900 on the European market.

You do mean with a compatible redundant PSU, right? There are only certain types that will fit properly into the Norco. Although, for home use it doesn't matter as much if the PSU sits loose inside the case.

I'm in Canada, however I'd put rough US pricing as:

$400 - 4224
$400 - Redundant PSU
$250 - HP Expander
$1050

vs $1250 for the 24 disk SMC - SC846E16-R1200B

Plus with the SMC you get really nice rails included which saves you $50 if you wanted to rack mount it.

So for $200 you get IMO a much higher quality chassis - and then if you extend your budget just a little more to $1550 you can get the 36 disk version:
$1550 - SC847E16-R1400LPB
 
I hard to even find those SM enclosures in the UK.
I wish they'd fit in a suitcase as easily as IBM M1015 cards do :)
 
All the Norco's I have got (4) accept standard ATX power supplies fine and screw in fine as well. I do have one fixed outside the case due to an EATX board though :)

As Tak Ne has mentioned we tend to get screwed on price over here. But sometimes the postage from the US or mainland EU isnt too bad. Issue is if you have to send it back of course... or refused support from the vendor in my case.

At the prices you quote above, the SMC approach is a no-brainer for me.
 
I do have one fixed outside the case due to an EATX board though :)

What was the problem you had there there?

I've built a 4224 using an E-ATX motherboard and didn't have any problems with the power supply fitting in.

[I had much bigger issues with the SAS cables and clearance with the center fan wall, but I did manage to eventually cram everything in there ;)]
 
My only concern with that many drives would be heat, but I guess with fast air flow it's not too much of a problem.

How do these port replicators work? It seems like it might be a cheaper solution to having multiple drives than buying many raid cards, when building a system like this. I'm personally looking at a supermicro as my next enclosure, but the expensive part is not the case, it's getting 24 or more sata ports, but it seems these guys are doing it differently.
 
What was the problem you had there there?

I've built a 4224 using an E-ATX motherboard and didn't have any problems with the power supply fitting in.

[I had much bigger issues with the SAS cables and clearance with the center fan wall, but I did manage to eventually cram everything in there ;)]

Its an X8DTN - enhanced EATX. Believe me there is little space :)

Yes I think that is badly designed, the holes put too much strain on some of the cables and how they need to fit into the mini-sas sockets. What do I know though - I'm a crap engineer at the best of times :)
 
Interesting concept, but what do you do when you need to change a failed drive? Real server hardware has the advantage here, in just being able to pop out a drive from the front, and pop in a new one. If you are serious about density and also care about response time, the market is now leaning towards using 2.5" drives. If you host for some customers, they are not going to take kindly to needing a whole box yanked and shut down because of a single failed drive.

It seems like something fun to mess around with, but I don't think it will be revolutionary in the real world.
 
That web page should be renamed to why-you-should-understand-what-you-are-getting-before-you-start :)
yeah the title is a bit misleading
I think they're referring to using one of these in an enterprise environment
This section is meant to be tongue-in-cheek since it should be clear by now that we have actually gone out and built one of these things (and had a blast doing it, pictures to follow …).
 
Back
Top