Mobos w/ PCI-E, 939, and DDR2???

altec_tech

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 17, 2004
Messages
175
I can't seem to find any motherboards that support PCI-E, socket 939, and DDR2!!! To be honest... I couldn't find ANY motherboards that supported DDR2? Why is that? That one 248(or something) pin DIMM. All mobos are using 184. Where can I find one with DDR2?

Also, what are some benefits of having DDR2? I noticed the ram speeds are MUCH higher on "DDR2" DIMMS, yet MUCH cheaper! So that is why I wanted to get DDR2. I was able to find speeds at 533 (4300) for under $200 (2 x 512mb) So, I want my computer to be 64-bit compliant, so I want to get DDR2 and PCI-E and AMD 64, so that I can.

So anyone have any ideas what mobos support all three of those options, AND where I can I get one? Thanks.
 
amd doesn't support ddr 2 .. because as it stands there is no benifit from it. latency is more important then mhz of the ram right now there is no bottleneck with ddr400
 
altec_tech said:
I can't seem to find any motherboards that support PCI-E, socket 939, and DDR2!!! To be honest... I couldn't find ANY motherboards that supported DDR2? Why is that? That one 248(or something) pin DIMM. All mobos are using 184. Where can I find one with DDR2?

Also, what are some benefits of having DDR2? I noticed the ram speeds is MUCH higher on "DDR2" DIMMS, yet MUCH cheaper! So that is why I wanted to get DDR2. I was able to find speeds at 533 (4300) for under $200 (2 x 512mb) So, I want my computer to be 64-bit compliant, so I want to get DDR2 and PCI-E and AMD 64, so that I can.

So anyone have any ideas what mobos support all three of those options, AND where I can I get one? Thanks.


Reason why no Socket 939 supports DDR2 is due to the on die memory controller. Since the memory controller is on the CPU proper, AMD would have to redo the CPUs themselves to support DDR2. Reason Intel could go to DDR2 when they went to Socket LGA775 and PCI-E boards is because the memory controller was in one of the bridge chips, and thus they could go to DDR2 with a chipset change.

I know that DDR2 has faster FSB ratings, but the latencys for DDR2 so far are much lower when comparing the same speed, generally speaking. Someone correct me if I am wrong on any of this, but I think DDR2 will usually benchmark at best the same if not slower, everything else being equal due to this. Or put it another way, I've seen CL 2-2-2 DDR PC 3200 memory, that's kind of common now for high end really. Maybe I'm looking the wrong place, but best DDR2 PC 3200 I've seen is CL 3-3-3. Okay, PC 3200 is slow for DDR2, but I think you see my point, the latency, another component of memory speed, just isn't there yet.

When AMD will support DDR2, I don't know. Seen some rumors of middle of this year, seen some of sometime next year. I suspect they are waiting for DDR2 latency to catch up and thus make it worth it, and/or see no need to go to DDR2 when the current CPU's are selling so well anyway.

Or to put it another way, if you're going to go AMD, DDR2 isn't that big of an issue. DDR will be around for at least a couple years. Kind of like AGP, PCI-E is coming out, but there will probably be at least one or two more high end AGP video cards, I suspect it will be the next generation of cards (a hypothetical NVidia 7xxx series, or ATI XI8xx series for instance) before all high end are PCI-E only, just guessing.
 
THe on-CPU memory controller further reduces latency which is another advantage of non-DDR2 A64s over DDR2-enabled Prescotts
 
OK, but is DDR2 required for 64-bit? Or do I just need PCI-E and an aMD 64? (of course with XP 64)
 
altec_tech said:
OK, but is DDR2 required for 64-bit? Or do I just need PCI-E and an aMD 64? (of course with XP 64)


No. Why would DDR2 be required for 64 bit? They have had a beta of Windows XP 64 bit out for over a year now. The OS, if it isn't delayed again should be out as a final release sometime this year. There has been final builds of Linux 64 bit OS's for a while now. All worked on AMD 64 systems using DDR memory.

For that matter, you don't need PCI-E for a 64 bit operating system. Know plenty of people who run as a dual boot Windows XP Pro or Home, and one of the Win XP 64 betas, and only have an AMD 64 CPU or an Opteron, and are using DDR memory along with AGP/PCI slots, no PCI-E.

Not flaming you, but where did you get the idea that one has to have DDR2 and PCI-E to use a 64 bit OS?!?
 
Arvig said:
Not flaming you, but where did you get the idea that one has to have DDR2 and PCI-E to use a 64 bit OS?!?

When I started researching at first, I also thought that DDR2 would be the way to go. Comeone, it has a 2 in the name, it has to be better. Well I quickly found out otherwise. He probably is making the same mistake I did, just assuming DDR2 is better and is used with AMD 64 since it is also the best.
 
Meh, I don't know. I just thought with all these new kinds of forms and stuff, that this new DDR2 would also be for 64 bit. Just like PCI-E and "64-bit processors". And I don't know too much about computers. I mean I know a lot more than the average. But I don't know much of the real technical stuff, such as, what does Raid 1 / 0 mean? How do you install an 2nd HDD, how do you OC a processor, and does RAM OC on it's own? Or does RAM OC by OC'ing the Procoessor? I don't get it. Never knew it actually. Tis' all.
 
altec_tech said:
Meh, I don't know. I just thought with all these new kinds of forms and stuff, that this new DDR2 would also be for 64 bit. Just like PCI-E and "64-bit processors". And I don't know too much about computers. I mean I know a lot more than the average. But I don't know much of the real technical stuff, such as, what does Raid 1 / 0 mean? How do you install an 2nd HDD, how do you OC a processor, and does RAM OC on it's own? Or does RAM OC by OC'ing the Procoessor? I don't get it. Never knew it actually. Tis' all.


LOL...well...Socket 754 AMD 64's have been out since Sept. 2003, Opterons since I think April 2003...and I think the Socket 754's were delayed, I want to say they were almost a year late. AMD was honestly expecting Microsoft to have a 64 bit Windows out sooner. So...AMD at least assumed it would work with DDR memory and AGP slot boards. :p

It's okay, we all start somewhere. Just...um...do some more research. And don't be embarassed by any question though...even if you get someone like me who half teases you while answering your questions. ;)
 
jabronidan said:
When I started researching at first, I also thought that DDR2 would be the way to go. Comeone, it has a 2 in the name, it has to be better. Well I quickly found out otherwise. He probably is making the same mistake I did, just assuming DDR2 is better and is used with AMD 64 since it is also the best.


DD2 is better than DDR. Lower voltage + much greater potential. The technology is a lot better and in a year, we won't care much about DDR1.
 
robberbaron said:
DD2 is better than DDR. Lower voltage + much greater potential. The technology is a lot better and in a year, we won't care much about DDR1.

Other then lower voltage, IMO the key point in your post is much greater POTENTIAL. DDR2 has the POTENTIAL to be much better, and in a year or two, it will catch up, and be as good if not better. But for NOW, no it isn't. The potential is there for it to be better, yes. But for now, no it isn't better technology, IMO.
 
Back
Top