mixing SIMM &DIMM DDR ram???

D14JEFF

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
201
a friend has a stick of 256 pc 2700 that is a simm(chips on one side only).can she add a 512 stick of pc 2700 dimm (chips on both sides and will she have issues if she does?ive seen issues using simm and dimm pc 133 ram but didnt know if the same problem exhist with ddr ram.she either has an asus or abit board.thanks.

p.s.befor anyone complains yes i did use the memory FAQ and didnt find my answer in there and i read back several pages and didnt find my answer and the search function wasnt operational ....
i find it really ironic the flaming and rudeness that occures in here sometimes to people not familar with forums and looking for answers here..if some peoples lives are so busy that the cant read the same subject headder or question hear a few times then they need to unplug and go do something else.
mmmmmmm....did i just flame????oh well..i have on my fire proof jock strap
i guess im just unhappy at feeling i need to qualify my question as being un answered and being a rational questional

thanks
 
A SIMM is a much older memory slot standard, back in the EDO and FP RAM days. It stands for single in-line memory module. It doesn't have anything to do with memory chips being on one or two sides.

There can be issues depending on the board. The best way to find out is to read the manual. It has a section on memory that tells you. If you don't have the manual, you can download it off the manufacturer website.
 
what VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVI said - SIMM is a completely different type of ram... as far as the question goes - I'm running 2 modules (one has mem chips only on one side while the other has mem chips on both) - both are different speed, size (one 512 the other one 256) and brand, and run perfectly fine on my AOpen mobo...
 
As long as you are adding a full memory bank you are fine. What i mean is that a memory bank is the amount of memory that equals the same number fo bits as the data bus. Example being that if your SIMM is 72 pins wide that means it will put out 32 bits of data. So if Pentium is a 32 bit system then you need one of these to fill up one bank. With DIMMs they have twice as many pins or they might just have higher capacity chips, either way they put out 64 bits at a time so with the newer 64 bit pentium's each DIMM is one bank of memory and you will not have to worry about adding half a bank and so forth until the 128 bit systems come out. Adding a DIMM to a 32 bit system would be like adding two banks...let me know if this confusing or if someone wants to word it better go ahead.
 
agreed, they are not backwards compatible with eachother, but there are still SIMMs that do fit in DIMM slots
 
WRONG! There is no such thing as a DDR SIMM. You're confusing Single/double sided and the SIMM/DIMM difference. SIMMs are extinct.

I have the exact same memory configuration as you're mentioning, and it works in most configurations. I have found that it didnt want to work with the 256 in slot3 and the 512 in slot four, but about anything else works. The only real way to see if it works is to try it.
 
Originally posted by CoolEthan
agreed, they are not backwards compatible with eachother, but there are still SIMMs that do fit in DIMM slots

Wrong.

SIMMs, as the appropriate definition (you were off in your original post), came in 40 and 72 pin styles. They were installed at an angle, then snapped up into place. All DIMMS have been 168pin or more. The two are MUCH different in size (a DIMM is over 2x the size of a 40pin SIMM, and almost 2x the size of a 72pin). If you want pics, I can get them. They are not even remotely pin compatible.

The SIMMS almost always (with the exception of some strangely wired AMD 586 boards I found) had to be installed in pairs. All DIMMS can be installed singly. RIMMs are like SIMMs, and have to be installed doubly.
 
SIMMS were 30pin(not 40) and 72 pin. They came in EDO and FPM, never DDR. DIMMS are 168 pin and 184 pin(right?). The 168 pin are SDRAM and the 184 pin are DDR.
 
Originally posted by jpmkm
SIMMS were 30pin(not 40) and 72 pin. They came in EDO and FPM, never DDR. DIMMS are 168 pin and 184 pin(right?). The 168 pin are SDRAM and the 184 pin are DDR.

Whoops. I was looking at RTR memory for the 40 pin. My bad :p

Yep, on the Dimm count. I'm not with it this morning (corporate party last night.)
 
thanks for the info and for showing me my mistake.also thanks so much for the politeness of your answers......take care
 
Originally posted by D14JEFF
thanks for the info and for showing me my mistake.also thanks so much for the politeness of your answers......take care

i'd like to politely point out that your sig is over the 10 line maximum.;)
 
Back
Top