Missed the boat on nVidia again?

Prizef1ghter

Weaksauce
Joined
Jun 10, 2004
Messages
105
I've got a few large to burn and was gonna build me a new rig. I hung tough with my old ass TI500 and was hoping that I could get another nVidia card that was top shelf.

Looks like ATI is king for the forseeable future and I should just get the x800XT. Oh well, guess I'll hit nVidia up in another 2 years or so.
 
The X800XT is old technology, it's faster right now, but if you're planning on keeping the card for a couple years, I would get a 6800Ultra...it's a bit slower, but not by much...and when ps30 games start coming out, you won't need to replace your card...

Now if Nvidia would just start selling the damned things...

-eMpTy
 
You still have to. Believe me you don´t want to play Unreal 3 on a 6800 ULTRA ;) It´s well below recommended specs
 
Was it 15 FPS? I thought it ran fine when I read the reviews... hmm, better go check again.

-Logiks
 
And that wasn't even the max detail level the game is going to run when it ships. The only thing SM3.0 is good for is speed optimizations, and I'd find it hard to believe that within this generation's lifespan you would ever be forced to replace a X800 because a game "required" SM3.0 support.

However, you can't go wrong with the 6800 series. While it's extremely overpriced right now due to extremely limited quanity, performance and image quality is superb, and it will delivery more than satisfactory results for a good one to two years. Last generation and my opinion would have been different though. I would have advised you get an ATI R3XX card instead of an NVIDIA FX card. But they've come a long way in a short time since then, and their new series, just like ATI's, kicks ass. I'd just wait until they're available in large quanities first. ;)
 
Cybercat said:
performance and image quality is superb, and it will delivery more than satisfactory results for a good one to two years

One to two years? Then why not just buy the X800 XT PE. Games that mainly run off PS3.0 won't be out for 2 - 3 years anyway. Why not buy the cream of the crop now (X800 XT PE) and have the fastest card on the market. ATI's driver program has really come along in the past year or two. I have the X800 Pro and I'm amazed with this card. I've since sold the X800 Pro and pre-ordered the X800 XT PE.

Go with the X800 XT PE and you won't be disappointed. Plus you will probably upgrade your video card in the next 2 - 3 years anyway; the XT PE should last that long easily.
 
Nvidia will be back, they may be down a little right now, but they will be back.
 
[BB] Rick James said:
No question in my mind that they will be back; just a matter of when.

If they could just get the bugs/performance worked out in farcry I would consider them just to have something new to play with.
 
get niether, save 300$ and get a radeon 9800 pro thats modable to an xt
 
nVidia IS back!!

I don´t see why people se the 6800 ULTRA as a failure since it do offer just about equal image quality in just about every game except Far Cry but I bet that will be fixed there shouldn´t be any doubts about that and it is very close in performance to the X800XT PE and in some games it even beats it.
So though the X800XT PE is faster in the majority of games that don´t make the 6800 ULTRA a failure in my eyes.

I sure won´t flame people who buy the 6800 ;)

Can people explain why nVidia aren´t back with their 6800 series???
 
I'm waiting for pci-e, meanwhile I’m sticking with my 5900xt.

I can't see much wrong with buying a 9800pro or a 5900xt and waiting for the drivers/games to catch up.


Unless you absolutely have to play @ 1600x1200 with all the goodies turned on.
 
creedAMD said:
If they could just get the bugs/performance worked out in farcry I would consider them just to have something new to play with.

It's just that ATI is just so solid right now. They are releasing 1 new driver a month; much more then what I can say for nVidia; their hardware runs faster and IMO the IQ is better. I wish nVidia would raise the bar a couple more notches; that might lower prices. But as it stands right now nVidia is trailing ATI and their stuff is still more expensive. For Example the 6800 Ultra is running anywhere from $500 - $600 when the X800 XT PE is pre-orderable for around $450.00.
 
oqvist said:
nVidia IS back!!

Can people explain why nVidia aren´t back with their 6800 series???

It's not that they are not back; it's that their product is a bit slower and is much more expensive. Case in point why buy a slower card when you could buy a faster card that you know will have really good IQ in pretty much every game on the market.

Some will argue that "that 6800 Ultra has PS3.0 so I'm going to buy that and then in 2 - 3 years upgrade cards." In 2 - 3 years that's when PS3.0 will just start to become really big! Why not buy the best card that will hit the streets very soon (X800 XT PE) and have that card for 2 - 3 years and then see where the PS3.0 market is.

PS3.0 is not a compelling enough argument to shell out $100 - $150 more on a slower card.
 
you would get 1fps in unreal 3 with friggin 30 of those things running around in multiplayer
 
ATI's image quality is questionable, and certainly not the clear winner in any case.

Personally, I know that ATI dropped thier real R420 design for the more conservative one you now see which is nothing more than 2 radeon 9800s slapped together with their filtering optimizations tossed in. Sure it's fast, but it has to be the most unimaginative and least forward looking piece of silicon they have ever produced.

I'm generally annoyed with the way ATI handled the whole optimizations debate, openly lying to reviewers.

I just wish to god Nvidia would get some new drivers out the door to bring thier performance up, not to mention getting the actual cards out the door to bring prices down. I think the 6800 is an amazing card, but it IS overpriced right now, which is even more annoying.

I just don't get why Nvidia would put 60 million extra transistors on their card to produce heat and bring down both top speed and yield. Why did they choose this route instead of just revising the nv35 series. If they had dropped the PS3.0 support, they would have been able to clock the card to the moon and would be way ahead right now instead of the all-to-familiar position of being slightly behind.

-eMpTy
 
Dont forget the ATI rage theater chip on board the XTPE. The dvd playback is unquestionably the best in the business making the ATI more versatile.
 
Cybercat said:
...performance and image quality is superb, and it [Geforce 6800 Ultra] will delivery more than satisfactory results for a good one to two years.

eMpTy said:
ATI's image quality is questionable, and certainly not the clear winner in any case.

To me, it already looks like the Geforce has shitty IQ. But that's just me...

1083564189888Adk70te_4_4_l.jpg


How can you say that ATI has poor IQ when the Geforce 6800 looks like that?
 
jacuzz1 said:
Dont forget the ATI rage theater chip on board the XTPE. The dvd playback is unquestionably the best in the business making the ATI more versatile.

That's pretty cool. I also heard ATI has better HD support...but that was just a rumor...stupid nvidia is good at everything that doesn't matter
 
I really don't think either card is "future proof". New games will come out, new cards will come out, and the 6800/x800 will be old news. Buy the fastest one right now: x800xt.
 
mantastic said:
To me, it already looks like the Geforce has shitty IQ. But that's just me...

1083564189888Adk70te_4_4_l.jpg


How can you say that ATI has poor IQ when the Geforce 6800 looks like that?

Is this Farcry?

Let's try to remember Nvidia is working with a new architecture and their WHQL drivers aren't out yet.

Have you seen an X800 running halo? Anistropic looks like garbage.

-eMpTy
 
AcneBrain said:
I really don't think either card is "future proof". New games will come out, new cards will come out, and the 6800/x800 will be old news. Buy the fastest one right now: x800xt.


Nothing is ever future proof. If they were companies would be out of business. I think that for the performance and the time frame that the enthusiasts keep their cards the X800 Pro and XT PE are the better choices.
 
You obviously are a moron and dont realize that is a bug with farcrys patch like they even state themselves
 
eMpTy said:
Is this Farcry?

Let's try to remember Nvidia is working with a new architecture and their WHQL drivers aren't out yet.

Have you seen an X800 running halo? Anistropic looks like garbage.

-eMpTy

Don't give nVidia excuses to suck. If they release hardware without drivers, that's no reason to consider buying into an architecture that may be "better than the X800 when games using its features come out in a year and a half, if and when its perfect drivers are released."

And no, I have not seen an X800 running Halo. Post some screenshots please.
 
I've talked to people who actually own 6800 Ultras and they have not seen any glitching like that in FarCry. *shrug*
 
creedAMD said:
If they could just get the bugs/performance worked out in farcry I would consider them just to have something new to play with.


Farcry is one game and to judge on ONE game is just not right.
And the bugs in Farcry are not JUST NVs fault crytek plays a part in that as well man...when will people realize this?
 
okay I think I have to take the nVidia fanboy costume on me to make this thread more balanced.

The screenshot you posted is indead Far Cry and the 6800 Ultra is still running the NV3X path with lower precision and more 1.1 shaders. This is an issue that definiatly will be fixed I would guess as soon as the 1.2 patch arrives. Also there is a shader model 3 patch coming out for Far Cry that won´t take 2-3 years to arrive ;)

True those improvements aren´t solely for shader model 3 cards and since dx 9.0c doesn´t look to arrive until september it will take a while but I will eat my hat if nvidia and Crytek haven´t sorted out these issues before that.

And about video decoding. nVidia has it on the chip fully programmable and hardware accelerated so to pick the rage theater chip as a reason why ATI is superior is beyond me :confused:

The X800 XT is an awesome gaming card that is why I pick it if I wan´t to do video encoding or 3D modelling I would pick the 6800 ULTRA any day.

And last I checked the X800XT PE is just as expensive as the 6800 ULTRA...
 
oqvist said:
And last I checked the X800XT PE is just as expensive as the 6800 ULTRA...

In some stores yes the X800 XT PE is just as expensive as the 6800 Ultra. I bought my X800 XT PE for around $450.00; what you CAN'T SAY is that the 6800 Ultra is as cheap as some stores that carry the X800 XT PE. ;)
 
mantastic said:
Don't give nVidia excuses to suck. If they release hardware without drivers, that's no reason to consider buying into an architecture that may be "better than the X800 when games using its features come out in a year and a half, if and when its perfect drivers are released."

And no, I have not seen an X800 running Halo. Post some screenshots please.

Fair enough...but the Farcry problems are a known issue...which are going to be fixed both by nvidia and crytek...you're right I shouldn't make excuses for nvidia...but I would like to point out the difference between a known driver issue with nvidia and all kinds of wierd goings-on with ATI...basically I've heard a hell of a lot more negative things about ATIs IQ at this point than I have Nvidia...I've seen videos of wierd shimmering effects with anistropic enabled...I've seen wierd textures in Farcry...I've read that thier anistropic in halo is abysmal...and that's cool, problems are going to happen...all I'm saying is that ATI is far from being the IQ winner at this point...

-eMpTy
 
Well it´s hard to say since they aren´t out in any numbers yet... But their listed prices are just the same.
 
I think the prices are inflated right now because availability is so limited...the MSRP for a 6800 is the same as the X800XT...499...

-eMpTy
 
eMpTy said:
I think the prices are inflated right now because availability is so limited...the MSRP for a 6800 is the same as the X800XT...499...

-eMpTy

Yeah, you can't expect the 6800 for anything less than 550 right now, cause somone has to make money off of it.
 
Thatonen00b said:
Yeah, you can't expect the 6800 for anything less than 550 right now, cause somone has to make money off of it.

Yeah there's no way it should cost that much...but there are people willing to pay that much...so naturally there are people more than happy to charge that much...

-eMpTy
 
eMpTy said:
I'm generally annoyed with the way ATI handled the whole optimizations debate, openly lying to reviewers.


-eMpTy


Like nVidia hasnt openly lied and cheated for the last 3 years?
 
The only thing they did that I would consider blatant was the optimizations they did for 3dmark that involved clipping the scene or something wierd like that...and yeah that was obnoxious...

The thing about ATI that has me pissed is that they made valid optimizations then openly and officially said, "we're doing full trilinear, see look at the colored mipmaps"...see the difference? ATI and Nvidia have both tried to sneak stuff past us before, but this is the first time I can remember either of them blatantly just lying in official public statements...it's an insult to the people who use and review these cards, ya know, like we weren't going to realize they were lying...

-eMpTy
 
I wanna see some benchmarks on some retail boards, nothing but speculation right now since nobody has a retail board to try out, the review here at [H] is the engineering sample, hope theve worked out some of the glitchs by now huh, i still think x800 pro --> Xt mod is the way to go with performance-money ratio.

EDIT: WAAAY too many threads with the same shit now. way too many.
 
aWe said:
I wanna see some benchmarks on some retail boards, nothing but speculation right now since nobody has a retail board to try out, the review here at [H] is the engineering sample, hope theve worked out some of the glitchs by now huh, i still think x800 pro --> Xt mod is the way to go with performance-money ratio.

EDIT: WAAAY too many threads with the same shit now. way too many.

The mod only works on the Saphire cards. And you when you actually see what your dealing with you'll think twice. Trust me it's a tougher mod to do.
 
corrosive23 said:
Like nVidia hasnt openly lied and cheated for the last 3 years?

I dont think he was defending nvidia, he was just making a statement about what Ati is doing right now
 
Back
Top