Microsoft Working on Touchscreens with One Millisecond Lag

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The responsiveness of touchscreen displays nowadays is pretty good but Microsoft's Applied Sciences Group has a different vision of where touch input delay needs to be. Microsoft wants touch responsiveness to take no more than one millisecond to respond to a tap or gesture. Paul Dietz is part of the research group that's been looking into the technology which could potentially be used to bring this vision to existence. Dietz believes that 1ms is a great benchmark to aim for, as it reduces the lag between touch input and display response to a pretty much imperceptible level.
 
Last edited:
Wow...that will be incredible on tablets/phones.
 
According to Sinorfsky soon will all we be using touch screen on our desktops too.They have lost touch with reality. Ever try to sit at your desk with your arm raised in the air all day? It gets painful very quickly.
 
According to Sinorfsky soon will all we be using touch screen on our desktops too.They have lost touch with reality. Ever try to sit at your desk with your arm raised in the air all day? It gets painful very quickly.

If I am not mistaken, I think that actually has a name. I think it is called gorilla arm.
 
I went searching for info on what the touch responsiveness on my iPhone 4 is, because I've never noticed any lag whatsoever. I couldn't find any. What I found was a lot of complaints that Android has touch lag while iPhones and iPads are perceived to have none.
 
According to Sinorfsky soon will all we be using touch screen on our desktops too.They have lost touch with reality. Ever try to sit at your desk with your arm raised in the air all day? It gets painful very quickly.

It more than likely will be a hybrid of technologies, like gestures on a trackpad, and the capability to touch the screen for things that need a more precise touch. Touch is going to be a part of the future, just not in the way that a lot of people expect.
 
well i have enough trouble with using a mouse since i had frozen shoulder, so i wouldnt be able to use a monitor with a touch screen even if you only had to touch the screen from time to time. plus wouldnt the price of a monitor increase substantially? nevermind the fingermarks that would drive me batty.
 
So if current touch devices have a 100 ms lag according to Paul Dietz, does it mean that Windows 8 will be released at a time when no 1 ms acceptable devices will be on the market?

Touch makes no sense for desktops, but it might find a niche as a replacement for mouse and maybe keyboard, with a non-touch monitor used for display. Unfortunately, the Metro design does not seem to allow this kind of scenario. It is so strict in its requirements (full screen, 2 apps shown max, fixed docking) that it seems to be blocking any such creative uses.
 
Please tell me this is for a new generation of Microsoft Courier development.
 
Touch could be an interesting addition to desktop but I would hate to see it replace the keyboard/mouse.

But first they need to make a LCD screen that can actually be easily cleaned and is not so fragile to pressure. This technology would be called glass. I don't get why LCDs don't have glass over them like CRTs did. Is it because it's hard to make a flat glass panel that is strong, while CRTs were concave and made it stronger?
 
@Red Squirrel - A single screen is a barrier to physical touch, there's no pressure point.
A different technology like conduction might work with a screen, but I suppose much less precisely, or we would have it already.

Flat glass panels can be strong, look at the hail resistant glass covering solar panels. Some resist a ball of steel dropped from 1 meter.
 
I went searching for info on what the touch responsiveness on my iPhone 4 is, because I've never noticed any lag whatsoever. I couldn't find any. What I found was a lot of complaints that Android has touch lag while iPhones and iPads are perceived to have none.

Most people using iPhones and iPads I would consider to be the type of people who wouldn't use paint programs or have an interface with a lot movable objects like Android.

Here's a video I found where someone is moving icons on their iPhone. You can clearly see the icon lags behind, just like in the Microsoft demo. It's not like the person is moving their finger relatively fast either.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oKrKJnW0FV0

It's much more notable on Android cause the interface is very customizable, and most things are movable. It's much less noticeable when an icon is barely larger then your finger, as opposed to a widget which can take up a huge portion of the screen.
 
Touch could be an interesting addition to desktop but I would hate to see it replace the keyboard/mouse.

But first they need to make a LCD screen that can actually be easily cleaned and is not so fragile to pressure. This technology would be called glass. I don't get why LCDs don't have glass over them like CRTs did. Is it because it's hard to make a flat glass panel that is strong, while CRTs were concave and made it stronger?

im doubting the keyboard/mouse will be going away, im guessing it will still be working alongside touch, and im betting with the advent of kinect, it will be a included as well.
 
It's much more notable on Android cause the interface is very customizable, and most things are movable. It's much less noticeable when an icon is barely larger then your finger, as opposed to a widget which can take up a huge portion of the screen.

It's not really a OS problem, it's more because of various spots where lag can occur such as the screen refresh interval, input gathering time, frame buffer and so forth. Good programming can reduce it, and if you aren't careful it can be extremely noticeable on both platforms. In the end, it's likely is just more noticeable sometimes on Android just because of the differences between Objective-C and Java, where the fact that OC isn't as forgiving for sloppy code.
 
im doubting the keyboard/mouse will be going away, im guessing it will still be working alongside touch, and im betting with the advent of kinect, it will be a included as well.

A lot of old the cliché when all you have is a hammer every problem is a nail going on around here. You can use keyboards, mice, touch and pen simultaneously in Windows 7 even and on my convertible Tablet PCs I'll tap buttons all the time, it's just natural for time to tap to simply tap the screen rather than reposition the mouse and click. When you get use to it it's pretty damn cool and I find myself tapping screens of laptops that aren't touch all of the time now, it's just become a habit. But that in no way interferes with keyboard and mouse operation, it's simply another input method that's available.
 
There are a few things that have to be solved for this, which is obviously why he's pushing it 10 years down the road, but here are some important things to remember:

  • Most applications on tablets, especially higher quality applications only run at 30-60FPS. He's looking for an improvement of about 15-30x.
  • These improvements can come from two places: faster hardware and slimmed down software.
  • Let's assume we can get a major improvement with some optimization around which pieces get re-rendered and there's no cascading effects. Basically spoofing the higher FPS.
  • This significantly limits the scope of the app if you choose to be very strict about re-rendering. Things like basic drawing would be trivially accomplished. Other uses would require most of the boost to come from hardware.
  • So you're still looking for some hardware improvements. Let's say we still need to get 10x out of hardware power. Given Moore's law, this means we're looking at about 5 years before hardware is capable of the increase.
  • We also need to factor in that screen sizes are increasing, so let's assume we have to get another 10x out of hardware, this puts us firmly at the 10 year mark.
  • AMOLED screens are theoretically capable of 100khz and many are already 1khz+ at the screen level; they aren't pushed at those speeds. Either way, screen technology will not be the issue unless there's another paradigm shift.

Overall, seems feasible and likely that within 10 years we'll have some applications making use of 1khz rendering.
 
I notice lag here and there on my iPad 2 and Motorola Photon 4G but I was under the assumption that it was caused by overall system sluggishness not screen lag. This
faster touchscreen development makes me a lot more interested in Windows Phone 10/11.
Though I think first iterations of this for the commercial public will be with Microsoft Surface.
 
According to Sinorfsky soon will all we be using touch screen on our desktops too.They have lost touch with reality. Ever try to sit at your desk with your arm raised in the air all day? It gets painful very quickly.

That's why you'd probably see something like MS Surface where your monitor becomes your desk. So your nt really lifting your arm all day but resting your arm on the table and just moving your fingers. Much the way you rest your arm on your keyboard stand and move your fingers on your keyboard today.
 
Yea, that may work well for the receptionist in an office but not a PC gamer. Well, they can do what they want but I am not drinking the grape Kool-Aid.
 
once orifice touch mods are here, there will be no looking back...............or will there? hmmmmmm
 
According to Sinorfsky soon will all we be using touch screen on our desktops too.They have lost touch with reality. Ever try to sit at your desk with your arm raised in the air all day? It gets painful very quickly.

Not sure about desktops, but from using my Asus Transformer, a touchscreen laptop makes things a lot easier as opposed to using the touchpad. So much so that a lot of transformer users (presumably the ones that got the dock) are also poking their laptops.
 
I guess I'm the only one who had the urge to yell "Norm!" when he first came on screen.
 
Back
Top