Microsoft Was Considering A Disc-Less Xbox One

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Eventually everything will be done via digital downloads but, since that isn't happening any time soon, Microsoft definitely made the right choice here.

"Obviously, after the announcement and E3, there was some feedback about what people wanted to change," Microsoft Studios boss Phil Spencer explained to OXM. "There was a real discussion about whether we should have an optical disc drive in Xbox One or if we could get away with a purely disc-less console, but when you start looking at bandwidth and game size, it does create issues."
 
Would be kind of neat if they offered a diskless version of the console at a lower price. They should be pressuring developers to offer a digital copy of new releases.
 
Would be kind of neat if they offered a diskless version of the console at a lower price. They should be pressuring developers to offer a digital copy of new releases.

Most do that now, there was a delay, with Xbox One they are supposed to all be same day.
 
Cutting out the retail middle man raises profits for both the dev and ms
There's prob long standing deals between the powers that be
 
I am all for digital downloads as long as they are not the same price as the physical copies. It would also be nice to be able to gift your game once you are done with it.
 
Cutting out the retail middle man raises profits for both the dev and ms
There's prob long standing deals between the powers that be

Don't think there is anything keeping them selling disc other than the fact that people still use disc. It was known that they were wanting to go disc less but people didn't like that.

People still like buying cheap used games (can't do that with digital).

User's didn't like the idea of pure digital content yet so they didn't go that route. However they are going the route that most if not all games will be digital day one releases so that you can go that route if you want. What is sad about that is that they are the same price as the disc version though
 
Don't think there is anything keeping them selling disc other than the fact that people still use disc. It was known that they were wanting to go disc less but people didn't like that.

People still like buying cheap used games (can't do that with digital).

User's didn't like the idea of pure digital content yet so they didn't go that route. However they are going the route that most if not all games will be digital day one releases so that you can go that route if you want. What is sad about that is that they are the same price as the disc version though
A law would need to be in place before anyone would go with digital downloads only. Specifically with the ability to resell the digital good, for whatever price we want. The reason it never would have happened with the Xbone was because Microsoft had no intention of reducing the cost of the games, and forcing customers to be checked online frequently.

Even with Steam there needs to be a way to sell your games.
 
How much does adding a drive to the Xbox 1 really cost? An extra $20 per unit maybe? (guessing at wholesale costs of BD drives).

Plus the whole idea, hell the reason the idiots named it "ONE", is because it's supposed to be ONE system to rule them all or some other Tolkien type of saying, essentially it will do everything for you, and last I checked quite a few people still use bluray discs to watch movies.
 
I am all for digital downloads as long as they are not the same price as the physical copies. It would also be nice to be able to gift your game once you are done with it.

Makes sense since disc production/distribution isn't free, but who are we kidding.
 
no more special editions :( oh, we will have "digital collector's editions" with rare dlc. whoo...
 
Makes sense since disc production/distribution isn't free, but who are we kidding.

Oh, you're one of those guys who thinks discs cost a boat load of money. CD and DVDs cost pennies to make, but I'd imagine Blu-Ray costs a few pennies more. The jewel cases for the games cost more then the game itself. While downloading games online isn't free, it's damn near close, but that's not the reason why digital downloads should be cheaper.

You lose a lot of rights by not owning a physical copy. No resale, and online services can just vanish, so the game is sorta rented. So there had better be a significant discount to get games online, to lose all that.

Before anyone says anything about inflation and how games should be more expensive. Keep in mind that games were cartridge based back in the day. If you lived during the Super Nintendo Era, then some of those games even came with CPU's and ram, besides the rom. Also gaming was relatively new back then, and like all new tech the prices start off high. Like Blu-Ray players that were over $1000, and now can be had for $50.
 
Oh, you're one of those guys who thinks discs cost a boat load of money. CD and DVDs cost pennies to make, but I'd imagine Blu-Ray costs a few pennies more. The jewel cases for the games cost more then the game itself. While downloading games online isn't free, it's damn near close, but that's not the reason why digital downloads should be cheaper.

You lose a lot of rights by not owning a physical copy. No resale, and online services can just vanish, so the game is sorta rented. So there had better be a significant discount to get games online, to lose all that.

Before anyone says anything about inflation and how games should be more expensive. Keep in mind that games were cartridge based back in the day. If you lived during the Super Nintendo Era, then some of those games even came with CPU's and ram, besides the rom. Also gaming was relatively new back then, and like all new tech the prices start off high. Like Blu-Ray players that were over $1000, and now can be had for $50.
a large cut though goes to brick and motor stores.
 
In light of the Xbox ones media focus I think that having a BR drive in it was critical. If they had not done that there would have been little point in also having the HDMI in because people would be used to switching inputs to play disc based movies.
 
Yea how great would that be... oh right it wouldn't. They would have forced their original plan for heavy DRM by saying that it didn't have an optical drive so it wasn't really an option to make it less of a DRM burden. Plus 40+ GB downloads for each console? Yea right. Most people would scream bloody murder if they were forced to hit their caps in a few games.

There was no way they could possibly have done it with without alienating parts of their audience. Simply no way.
 
I think they should still offer the digital media. Some people still don't live in areas where they could download a game in a reasonable amount of time.

I say give someone the option. Besides the plastic, the optical drive is probably the cheapest part of the xbox, so there is no need to offer a diskless version, but still give people the option to get digital versions.
 
The real irony of this is back when they were pitching crap like the Phantom, all digital download gaming...games were 1 or 2 CD's tops, 1 or 2 gigs maybe. Nowadays games are 40gb. Even on fast internet that could be many hours to all night to download ONE game.

Also the whole pricing schema is just wacky. They charge the same or more for digital... stupid. Drop the price of digital content by HALF and physical media use will drop a ton before this generation is over. Physical should be the ALTERNATIVE (ie you don't have monster bandwidth or internet access at all), digital should be the mainstream and CHEAPER.

Oh well, maybe the next gen... we'll see what happens in 5-7 years.
 
I think they should still offer the digital media. Some people still don't live in areas where they could download a game in a reasonable amount of time.

I say give someone the option. Besides the plastic, the optical drive is probably the cheapest part of the xbox, so there is no need to offer a diskless version, but still give people the option to get digital versions.

They are still offering it and are giving people the option. I have bought 2/3 of my Xbox One games digitally.
 
The real irony of this is back when they were pitching crap like the Phantom, all digital download gaming...games were 1 or 2 CD's tops, 1 or 2 gigs maybe. Nowadays games are 40gb. Even on fast internet that could be many hours to all night to download ONE game.

Also the whole pricing schema is just wacky. They charge the same or more for digital... stupid. Drop the price of digital content by HALF and physical media use will drop a ton before this generation is over. Physical should be the ALTERNATIVE (ie you don't have monster bandwidth or internet access at all), digital should be the mainstream and CHEAPER.

Oh well, maybe the next gen... we'll see what happens in 5-7 years.

Shouldn't be half as they aren't saving that much money. But I would say should be about $5 or so cheaper.

And why are you guys bitching about digital downloads on a console. how the fuck do you get most steam games?
 
i dont even remotely consider DL versions because its a complete and utter rip off. not only in the cost but also in the value. I can sell or trade in a game if i buy a disc... yet these "guys" are hell bent on telling me that pirating content and buying pirate CD's is wrong and its all so bad for us stop doing it. Yet in the very same breathe they offer a digital download and yet the buck stops there. I can't on-sell MY game that i paid higher then retail for! DAFUQ!

Until these greedy, double standards are dropped... they can kiss my lily white ass!
 
Shouldn't be half as they aren't saving that much money. But I would say should be about $5 or so cheaper.

....

See this is where you are not seeing the full picture. They want to enforce double standards on the consumers. When you buy a game disc you HAVE the option... like purchasing any other item in the world... to sell it at a later date... to burn it.. to give it away.. to sell it for cheap... or to sell it at double the price you bought it for. You HAVE AN ITEM OF WORTH. These company's now want to take this basic concept of rights away from consumers (when it suits them mind you... ) and for some reason when it comes to us purchasing a digital copy of a game from them.... we get none of these options. Its an over priced one time donation for the privilege of an ass reaming!

It should be far cheaper then $5 to give up more value/rights for such a version. FAR CHEAPER! If you think otherwise... you are their ideal customer.... a very uninformed fool easily parted with their money. (not meaning to be personal.. just giving the example to not beat around the bush about the point).
 
It would also be nice to be able to gift your game once you are done with it.

If you think really hard you might realize why publishers might not be interested in having one $60 game shared freely by an infinite number of people.
 
I'd still rather use a disc. Save the bandwidth for other stuff ;)
 
I would love for everything to be all digital, but ISP's and their bandwidth caps are holding everything back. It would be a choice of do I watch Netflix this weekend or do I download that game I really want to play, and I cant do both or i have to pay an extra $20 for another 30GB.
 
Stupid ass idea considering they were marketing the Xone as your all in one media device. I still prefer watching blu rays and dvds over the shitty netflix selections out there.
 
See this is where you are not seeing the full picture. They want to enforce double standards on the consumers. When you buy a game disc you HAVE the option... like purchasing any other item in the world... to sell it at a later date... to burn it.. to give it away.. to sell it for cheap... or to sell it at double the price you bought it for. You HAVE AN ITEM OF WORTH. These company's now want to take this basic concept of rights away from consumers (when it suits them mind you... ) and for some reason when it comes to us purchasing a digital copy of a game from them.... we get none of these options. Its an over priced one time donation for the privilege of an ass reaming!

It should be far cheaper then $5 to give up more value/rights for such a version. FAR CHEAPER! If you think otherwise... you are their ideal customer.... a very uninformed fool easily parted with their money. (not meaning to be personal.. just giving the example to not beat around the bush about the point).

The only double standard I see are people bashing console digital downloads while most of the same people would praise steam for being the best thing ever. And yet you don't get games for 1/2 price retail unless they happen to be on sale some week. I have actually found some steam games to be up to $10 more than retail versions.

You can't sell most PC games anymore, most require you to enter a key that once activated ties it to you. Or at least the last few I have purchased required me to lock it to an account through some other service, most I have purchased the last few years have been digital through steam which are locked to that forever.

If you want to consider me a fool then that is fine. I just don't view everything I buy as being a pile of cash. Regardless of how I buy a game, movie or music once I own it I keep it. I have spent $60 on a game to realize after an hour or two it wasn't what I thought it would be. Just toss the game on the shelf and consider it a learning experience. Sure I could drive to gamestop and sell it for $5 or whatever they give, but it would twice as much in gas to drive there as what I get. Same for trying to sell it used online myself. Any game that I would have used and would want to sell, first have to assume that places have it for about 2/3 the price to start with, then need to subtrack whatever shipping would be to make it seem to somebody like a reasonable deal. So at best can try to sell a boring / crappy game for $15 or so, then would have to pay whatever fees you are charged from paypal or whatever other platform you use. So I might come away with $10 for something that I spent $50+ on. Not worth it, my time has more value than that. I am not in a position where I need to worry about a few bucks here or there. So when I buy something good, bad or indifferent it is mine forever.

As for some of those rights, you would have had some of those to a degree on the xbox one. But the 24 hour check in being removed killed that off. Otherwise you would have been able to trade digital games, you could have shared digital games. Which they are looking into figuring out a way to add that back in. This is a feature that steam is looking at adding also. So some of these rights are things that are in the works for different platforms to start trying to add back.
 
no more special editions :( oh, we will have "digital collector's editions" with rare dlc. whoo...

The upside is we can all be in the dark and game companies can no longer be so brazen as having the DLC on the disc, just not activated :D
 
Before anyone says anything about inflation and how games should be more expensive. Keep in mind that games were cartridge based back in the day. If you lived during the Super Nintendo Era, then some of those games even came with CPU's and ram, besides the rom.

I hadn't heard of this as I thought they were all ROMs, but this is interesting the architecture allowed for coprocessors. It allowed them to use a cheaper CPU in the Super Nintendo.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Super_NES_enhancement_chips
 
The general trend here is people like to complain about things. But somewhere out there is the people who actually solve problems not just cry about them. And then there is the whole thing were no one wants to accept their own responsibility.

The real irony of this is back when they were pitching crap like the Phantom, all digital download gaming...games were 1 or 2 CD's tops, 1 or 2 gigs maybe. Nowadays games are 40gb. Even on fast internet that could be many hours to all night to download ONE game.

Also the whole pricing schema is just wacky. They charge the same or more for digital... stupid. Drop the price of digital content by HALF and physical media use will drop a ton before this generation is over. Physical should be the ALTERNATIVE (ie you don't have monster bandwidth or internet access at all), digital should be the mainstream and CHEAPER.

Oh well, maybe the next gen... we'll see what happens in 5-7 years.

StarCraft 2 and other games can get you playing in a short download and then download the other content in system idle time. In fact I think this feature is coming to the new gen consoles. One could have made the same argument for digital movies but you can stream in.

no more special editions :( oh, we will have "digital collector's editions" with rare dlc. whoo...

If companies find a market for special editions they will certainly produce them. This already happens in the music industry where tons of people only get songs digitally now but they offer CDs, and vinyl special editions.

A law would need to be in place before anyone would go with digital downloads only. Specifically with the ability to resell the digital good, for whatever price we want. The reason it never would have happened with the Xbone was because Microsoft had no intention of reducing the cost of the games, and forcing customers to be checked online frequently.

Even with Steam there needs to be a way to sell your games.

No law ever needed to be passed steam already proved that. Its up to the consumers to factor in what a game is worth and actually have the self control to not buy it until it hits that price. This is the responsibility thing, seems like everyone wants the government to fix their inability to control their spending habits now days, amazing. It's a game, not water people.

How much does adding a drive to the Xbox 1 really cost? An extra $20 per unit maybe? (guessing at wholesale costs of BD drives).

Plus the whole idea, hell the reason the idiots named it "ONE", is because it's supposed to be ONE system to rule them all or some other Tolkien type of saying, essentially it will do everything for you, and last I checked quite a few people still use bluray discs to watch movies.

I will say that it probably cost more than $20. The cheapest BR drives now days still go for $40, hard to find anything decent for less than 60. Its not just the hardware they have to pay to license the ability to play them too. And lets just say I highly doubt Sony wants to cut MS of all companies any sort of deal. Trying to put a BR drive into something that is computer like and SONY does not like is so expensive that to my knowledge it is still not in any version of windows or mac. Often the software cost at least $50 on top of the drive. And don't tell me its free, they break that software a year later.

And no more ultra rare yard sale/flea market gems worth far more than you paid for them. :(

There are many things that you consume and don't have a product to show off, if it bugs you so much print your receipt.
 
Digital is coming people, this generation, they will use sales and other methods to move you off the disc, Sony will push it just as hard as MS too.
 
The only double standard I see are people bashing console digital downloads while most of the same people would praise steam for being the best thing ever. And yet you don't get games for 1/2 price retail unless they happen to be on sale some week. I have actually found some steam games to be up to $10 more than retail versions.

You can't sell most PC games anymore, most require you to enter a key that once activated ties it to you. Or at least the last few I have purchased required me to lock it to an account through some other service, most I have purchased the last few years have been digital through steam which are locked to that forever.

If you want to consider me a fool then that is fine. I just don't view everything I buy as being a pile of cash. Regardless of how I buy a game, movie or music once I own it I keep it. I have spent $60 on a game to realize after an hour or two it wasn't what I thought it would be. Just toss the game on the shelf and consider it a learning experience. Sure I could drive to gamestop and sell it for $5 or whatever they give, but it would twice as much in gas to drive there as what I get. Same for trying to sell it used online myself. Any game that I would have used and would want to sell, first have to assume that places have it for about 2/3 the price to start with, then need to subtrack whatever shipping would be to make it seem to somebody like a reasonable deal. So at best can try to sell a boring / crappy game for $15 or so, then would have to pay whatever fees you are charged from paypal or whatever other platform you use. So I might come away with $10 for something that I spent $50+ on. Not worth it, my time has more value than that. I am not in a position where I need to worry about a few bucks here or there. So when I buy something good, bad or indifferent it is mine forever.

As for some of those rights, you would have had some of those to a degree on the xbox one. But the 24 hour check in being removed killed that off. Otherwise you would have been able to trade digital games, you could have shared digital games. Which they are looking into figuring out a way to add that back in. This is a feature that steam is looking at adding also. So some of these rights are things that are in the works for different platforms to start trying to add back.

Well for one... i have never mentioned steam. Digital Download counts for any kind of digital download... steam... condensation...which ever! Secondly... i CBF even trying there's so many contradictions! its no wonder corporations can get away with selling us far less for far more. Your time is worth so much that its not worth selling a poor game... yet you're ok with the game being poor and letting it "go by the wayside" and being gyped in the first place. All because you can afford a few bucks? Great mentality!
 
The only double standard I see are people bashing console digital downloads while most of the same people would praise steam for being the best thing ever. And yet you don't get games for 1/2 price retail unless they happen to be on sale some week. I have actually found some steam games to be up to $10 more than retail versions.
Nobody excuses Steam for this practice. Also, unlike consoles, we can all turn around and tell Steam to fly a kite. If you own an Xbox One, what can you do if it didn't come with a Blu-Ray drive? See that's the power of PC. You have your options.

Generally though, Steam games are cheaper then console, but if Half Life 3 was released today, it would be $60 for a good long time on Steam. Steam has a more realistic pricing for games then on console. Like for example Tomb Raider is not a $60, no matter what they think.

Capitalism works so much better when consumers have choices. No Blu-Ray drive would remove choices, like how no UMD drive for the PSP Go was a very bad thing. On PC, I can add a blu-ray, a red-ray, a green-ray, and use internet IPv7 if need be. But on console you are at the mercy of the corporation. If Microsoft says beg, you'll beg. If Microsoft says $60, you'll pay. Install Linux on Xbox One, but Microsoft didn't say?

If you want to consider me a fool then that is fine. I just don't view everything I buy as being a pile of cash. Regardless of how I buy a game, movie or music once I own it I keep it. I have spent $60 on a game to realize after an hour or two it wasn't what I thought it would be. Just toss the game on the shelf and consider it a learning experience.
You seem fiscally irresponsible.
Sure I could drive to gamestop and sell it for $5 or whatever they give, but it would twice as much in gas to drive there as what I get.
Ebay Amazon it. You'd get a lot more back then $5, assuming the game wasn't shit.
 
No law ever needed to be passed steam already proved that. Its up to the consumers to factor in what a game is worth and actually have the self control to not buy it until it hits that price.
A lot of people right now have a lot of self control. That's probably why the sales for games have been doing so poorly. That and shitty games.
This is the responsibility thing, seems like everyone wants the government to fix their inability to control their spending habits now days, amazing. It's a game, not water people.

That's because corporations are working with our government to work against us. If it wasn't for some government regulation, we'd all still be hunting down chargers for our cell phones, cause companies have no issue forcing us to go buy overpriced proprietary chargers for their devices. Micro usb works just fine thank you.

There are just some things you don't leave to the market, and requires some government, like health care is another.
 
They are still offering it and are giving people the option. I have bought 2/3 of my Xbox One games digitally.

That's cool. I didn't know that. That's how it should be.
 
A law would need to be in place before anyone would go with digital downloads only. Specifically with the ability to resell the digital good, for whatever price we want. The reason it never would have happened with the Xbone was because Microsoft had no intention of reducing the cost of the games, and forcing customers to be checked online frequently.

Even with Steam there needs to be a way to sell your games.

Actually the day Steam starts allowing resale of games purchased on it is the day they stop having sales like the one that is just ending so personally I'm in no hurry for them to allow resale.
 
I realize the physical cost of making a DVD, Plastic box, manuals.... maybe amounts to what? maybe a dollar or two?

Still -- if I get a digital version, charge me 58 dollars vs 60, since you aren't having to physically make anything or transport it anymore.

Also - cable/dsl companies need to lose this notion that people will get by just fine on 100GB a month before they start charging crazy fees. So after just one game and maybe a few netflix movies I now owe 100 dollars on my cable bill? Fuck you.

I have no problem with a restricted digital version that I can't resell or trade... but guess what, suddenly it's not worth 58 dollars to me anymore even if it's a AAA title and guaranteed to knock my socks off. The fact that I have to connect to your servers just to play single player means that I'm not going to "invest" 60 into a game that (more than likely) won't be around or even playable in 5 to 8 years time.

There are easy solutions to all these problems -- the thing is nobody wants to be the one to institute them because it takes power and money out of corporations hands.
 
Back
Top