Microsoft Wants A Global Patent System

Really nothing else I can add but:

Fuck you, Microsoft.
 
Hey, be careful what you say about Dean Kamen. I'll venture to say that man is indirectly responsible for more patents, inventions, solutions, and engineering triumphs than any other living person.

Keep dreaming. Thomas Edison = 1093 patents.

As technology goes on and on, its harder for each patent to pass (less open area for 'easy' discovery).

The patent system at one time was to protect the individual from the big corporation (it was also cheap instead of what it is now) when he/she tries to sell the idea to companies (provisional patent) and raise startup capital... to prevent an individual's innovations from being stolen by a large company. Now, its the other way around, since most patents require massive investment and R&D that only an organization can provide. If you track this trend, you will see that in the future, patents themselves will get less and less frequent, as it will be harder and harder to develop them. They will also be more and more technical to review the applications, so more 'rubber stamping' is likely. Sure, the more we know, the less we find we do know, but at some point in the future we will see no need for a patent system anyways, as technology will hit a point where 'nothing new' will develop, at least in the sense of research, develop, design, produce, and sell to the general public (general goods and services). Most new discoveries will likely be by large organizations, government backed programs, etc. There will likely be a point where such a system is no longer needed, or the number of new (I should say 'Utility') patents per year will dwindle. The fact that this last year saw an almost record number of new patents issued makes me feel that many were 'rubber stamped' to make money. It also could mean the next 'big boom' market is on the way (like the internet boom of the 90's or the housing boom we are just getting off of)... so look at the USPTO patents (they are all published online) to see which companies to invest in...lol. But seriously, I think more and more patents are 'above the reviewers head's' these days anyways (Ive seen it 2x now this year), so they just approve it and let the judicial system sort it out later when one company files suit against another for patent infringement... the only way to enforce a patent in the end. And then the USPTO doesnt have to lift a finger... the companies have to then pay for the expert testimonials, the lawyers, etc.

Which brings me to this: What the FFFFFF do you really pay for when you file a patent then anyways? NOTHING. You pay $10,000 or more for some lawyer to submit artwork and some idiot to file it somewhere in case you need to enforce it later... maybe. Trust me, enforcing a patent doesnt mean you win... I see more and more cases where someone enforces a patent in court, and it turns out the patent should have never been given in the first place, so the initial patent is lost all together. I work in one field where a company in Germany tried to tell us here in the US that they had an 'international' patent on something we produced. I called their bluff, and asked for the patent number (since there is no such thing as an 'international patent'). Turns out, they had not even applied for it here in the US at the time. When they did, they kept saying they were going to sue when it passed... but the reviewer wouldnt pass it on several key points, and the final revision was so different it didnt even apply to the product I helped make. Not to mention, during their application process, we filed for a design patent just in case their utility patent went through and we had to go to court (if one side doesnt have a patent, judges usually side with the patent holder even if you patented something bogus). If they had taken us to court, we would have just shown that we had been producing 'said product' since before they even applied for a patent, which would mean their patent would have been voided all together by taking us to court. So now, the company that once threatened us is busy sending legal letters to all the other companies out there... leaving us alone, or they know that if they came after us, they wouldnt even be able to do that! Much better to have one competitor than dozens...lol. Still, it just goes to show you how messed up the system is.
 
Keep dreaming. Thomas Edison = 1093 patents.

As technology goes on and on, its harder for each patent to pass (less open area for 'easy' discovery).

The patent system at one time was to protect the individual from the big corporation (it was also cheap instead of what it is now) when he/she tries to sell the idea to companies (provisional patent) and raise startup capital... to prevent an individual's innovations from being stolen by a large company. Now, its the other way around, since most patents require massive investment and R&D that only an organization can provide. If you track this trend, you will see that in the future, patents themselves will get less and less frequent, as it will be harder and harder to develop them. They will also be more and more technical to review the applications, so more 'rubber stamping' is likely. Sure, the more we know, the less we find we do know, but at some point in the future we will see no need for a patent system anyways, as technology will hit a point where 'nothing new' will develop, at least in the sense of research, develop, design, produce, and sell to the general public (general goods and services). Most new discoveries will likely be by large organizations, government backed programs, etc. There will likely be a point where such a system is no longer needed, or the number of new (I should say 'Utility') patents per year will dwindle. The fact that this last year saw an almost record number of new patents issued makes me feel that many were 'rubber stamped' to make money. It also could mean the next 'big boom' market is on the way (like the internet boom of the 90's or the housing boom we are just getting off of)... so look at the USPTO patents (they are all published online) to see which companies to invest in...lol. But seriously, I think more and more patents are 'above the reviewers head's' these days anyways (Ive seen it 2x now this year), so they just approve it and let the judicial system sort it out later when one company files suit against another for patent infringement... the only way to enforce a patent in the end. And then the USPTO doesnt have to lift a finger... the companies have to then pay for the expert testimonials, the lawyers, etc.

Which brings me to this: What the FFFFFF do you really pay for when you file a patent then anyways? NOTHING. You pay $10,000 or more for some lawyer to submit artwork and some idiot to file it somewhere in case you need to enforce it later... maybe. Trust me, enforcing a patent doesnt mean you win... I see more and more cases where someone enforces a patent in court, and it turns out the patent should have never been given in the first place, so the initial patent is lost all together. I work in one field where a company in Germany tried to tell us here in the US that they had an 'international' patent on something we produced. I called their bluff, and asked for the patent number (since there is no such thing as an 'international patent'). Turns out, they had not even applied for it here in the US at the time. When they did, they kept saying they were going to sue when it passed... but the reviewer wouldnt pass it on several key points, and the final revision was so different it didnt even apply to the product I helped make. Not to mention, during their application process, we filed for a design patent just in case their utility patent went through and we had to go to court (if one side doesnt have a patent, judges usually side with the patent holder even if you patented something bogus). If they had taken us to court, we would have just shown that we had been producing 'said product' since before they even applied for a patent, which would mean their patent would have been voided all together by taking us to court. So now, the company that once threatened us is busy sending legal letters to all the other companies out there... leaving us alone, or they know that if they came after us, they wouldnt even be able to do that! Much better to have one competitor than dozens...lol. Still, it just goes to show you how messed up the system is.

Why do you say that system is messed up? Okay, I agree that patents are way too expensive...but you're right - easy discoveries are becoming less frequent, and technology is becoming more and more complex such that we must pool our resources together into large companies and governments to continue to make progress. But I guess I don't see anything wrong with that? As long as it keeps technology moving forward.

And the patent system does still serve its original purpose of protecting the individual against large companies. How many times have we seen a huge firm pay large amounts of money to a tiny one because the tiny one happened to have that idea years ago? The "inventor" occupation is dead, but people are still compensated for bright ideas.

In reference to Kamen and Edison...I know he isn't the guy with the most patents. I said Dean Kamen is indirectly responsible for the most patents and/or innovations.
 
The U.S. patents are already de facto global (at least as far as the hydrocarbon industry is concerned).
 
Is it really harder for new patents to go thru tho? I mean, we keep seeing all these vague overreaching patents get approved by the patent office every month... Sure they might get overturned eventually but isn't that a sign that there's something inherently flawed in the approval system?
 
Why do you say that system is messed up? Okay, I agree that patents are way too expensive...but you're right - easy discoveries are becoming less frequent, and technology is becoming more and more complex such that we must pool our resources together into large companies and governments to continue to make progress. But I guess I don't see anything wrong with that? As long as it keeps technology moving forward.

And the patent system does still serve its original purpose of protecting the individual against large companies. How many times have we seen a huge firm pay large amounts of money to a tiny one because the tiny one happened to have that idea years ago? The "inventor" occupation is dead, but people are still compensated for bright ideas.

In reference to Kamen and Edison...I know he isn't the guy with the most patents. I said Dean Kamen is indirectly responsible for the most patents and/or innovations.

I thought I wrote it well enough, but you are stating almost the same thing... the response to your question is right in what you wrote really (not being mean or sarcastic). The patent system was once intended to protect the small from the large. Now its more often used by the large to protect from the small. Sometimes, even if the patent is bogus, the larger company can simply threaten a smaller one, and the legal fees alone would make the smaller company close its doors. This last year, a lighting company in Madison, WI, called Orbitech took another lighing company, PFO, to court. Orbitech's claim is that they have a patent on LED lighting for aquariums (or rather, on the controls which result in 'simulation of sunlight for growth of marine organisms'). The patent is bogus right off the bat, its just that nobody in the aquarium lighting industry knew about it... because Orbitech doesnt actually have a product. LED's have been used over aquariums long before Orbitech came around, but the whole 'new tech' spin on an old idea, as well as a lazy USPTO allowed it to pass. If you compared the systems as well... you would see how different they are. The Orbitech system has seperate red and blue LED's that are not natural looking, but provide some of the peak (supposed) growth that corals and plants use. Their systems are intended for studies in space. PFO's system uses full spectrum LED's as well as blue ones (not a combo of red and blue), and their research is based on actual hobbyist use as well as Marine Biologist supplied information. Overall, PFO's system was far ahead of Orbitech's, but they are actually IN a working market with lots of established experience. Their controls were not to simulate natural sunlight even, but to control the seperate amounts of red and blue light (a color control system). PFO's controls were more 'visual', changing the intensity of various LED's in the system to simulate cloud cover and the waves of the ocean but keeping the color the same. PFO's system used the latest in high efficiency high-output LED's and was cutting edge where Orbitech's looked like it was a science project. Orbitech's lawyers took PFO to court unless PFO paid a crazy royalty fee, and with all that NASA grant money that Orbitech has for lawyers, it came down to a pocketbook comparison. PFO just closed its doors. Orbitech doesnt even have a product out on the market, let alone something that an individual would want to buy, and had they actually gone to court, the would have likely lost their patent... but PFO would have run out of money to pay legal fees long before. So, as it stands right now, every aquarium lighting maker in the US is afraid to put out a LED lighting system. Right now the most advanced systems being used by people with reef aquariums are those they made themselves!

When patents that are bogus get approved just to generate income, by engineers that are not familiar with the technology enough to make an informed decision, then bogus patents get enforced by lawyers where it becomes more about 'who has deeper pockets' than what the truth is. There are so many bogus, 'junk-science', and otherwise useless patents getting approved by the USPTO right now that its more of a game than a useful system. The USPTO is so 'hands off' its not funny. I called a reviewer of one patent to try to 'educate' him about how a patent he was reviewing was bogus, if not patented already by a company 15-20 years prior. His response was along the lines of 'well, you can file an injunction if you think it violates a patent of yours'. My response was 'its not my patent or anyone's patent, its been common information and design in the industry for over 20 years'. His response was 'well, after it gets approved, if there are any problems, then its for the courts to figure out if they decide to still go after you'. There are so many things wrong with that response that its not even funny.
 
Why do you say that system is messed up? Okay, I agree that patents are way too expensive...

How many times have we seen a huge firm pay large amounts of money to a tiny one because the tiny one happened to have that idea years ago? The "inventor" occupation is dead, but people are still compensated for bright ideas.

In reference to Kamen and Edison...I know he isn't the guy with the most patents. I said Dean Kamen is indirectly responsible for the most patents and/or innovations.[/QUOTE]
It's messed up for a number of reasons:
1) It's not clear whether abstract patents covering soft methodologies, software patents, etc. actually benefit society more than they hurt it.

2) The cost of acquiring patents makes it easy for wealthy companies to file for copious numbers of frivolous patents, some of which get passed, and very difficult for individuals to patent anything but a short-term highly profitable invention. This is a pretty big inequity that drastically favours wealthy organizations or individuals.

3) The patent office is understaffed and under-qualified for reviewing many of the applications put forth. I don't see an obvious solution for this, but nonetheless you it's messed up that you have reviewers passing patents on claims in fields like quantum mechanics, when they only have a cursory knowledge of the subject.

4) Patent durations were set when the lifespan of inventions were longer. Given that technological inventions become obsolete in a comparatively short amount of time, it makes sense for the patent duration to similarly reflect this, so that society can benefit from harnessing the idea.

Those are just some obvious things that come to mind; the deficiencies of modern patent systems have been commented on quite extensively.


And the patent system does still serve its original purpose of protecting the individual against large companies.
I'd say this is an ancillary purpose, and even there is not being served well by the current patent system.
The primary purpose, is similar to that expressed in the copyright clause: to promote useful progress in invention for the benefit of society.
 
Yes, it was the underlying goal of Reagan's patent "reforms" to shift from a system that protects the little guy, the garage inventor, from the major corporate powers (known as the "vested interests" back in the 1700's).

By shifting the system to one of pay to play, it gave the advantage to those with resources over those without.

By making the PTO have to generate it's own funding, it assured the proclivety to approve on sight (get paid) and let the courts sort it out later. It was to both make it harder for pion's to innovate and to undermine the entire system, moving it from educated professionals approving inventions to courtroom battles deciding based on financial resoources who has the rights to an idea.

I currenty have an innovation that will revolutionize the electric car concept, but I face having to pay close to $10,000 in fee's to get the patent filed and covered in the major world markets, and then face having to defend it against whatever multinational corporation(s) choose to try and wrestle control from me..... not the most inviting system for a garage inventor.

I save the costs of a patent attorney as I've written many myself previsouly, and am doing all the work myself. The ultimate success of being able to benfit from this would have rested 99% on the quality of the patent itself, but with the current system it matters less how god the patent is and more on whether you will be able to defend it in court... if challenged OR if trying to enjoin blatent violators.

BTW, I actually know Dean Kamen, I worked for a company he was an investor in and he was good freinds with my boss (who himself was a principle inventor of the fax machine), and we rented space from DEKA in the same building, and yes he commuted to work in his little black helicopter, landing on the roof. It is the infusion pump that is his true claim to fame and one of the most critical inventions of the 20th century. For that alone he is one of the great inventors of our time. He's also a really nice person.
 
In reference to Kamen and Edison...I know he isn't the guy with the most patents. I said Dean Kamen is indirectly responsible for the most patents and/or innovations.

I like your open statement, you could get a job with the patent office.:D
 
Of course they do: it just increases their power.

It will be a sad day for Human society if this ever goes through.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
I thought I wrote it well enough, but you are stating almost the same thing... the response to your question is right in what you wrote really (not being mean or sarcastic). The patent system was once intended to protect the small from the large. Now its more often used by the large to protect from the small. Sometimes, even if the patent is bogus, the larger company can simply threaten a smaller one, and the legal fees alone would make the smaller company close its doors. This last year, a lighting company in Madison, WI, called Orbitech took another lighing company, PFO, to court. Orbitech's claim is that they have a patent on LED lighting for aquariums (or rather, on the controls which result in 'simulation of sunlight for growth of marine organisms'). The patent is bogus right off the bat, its just that nobody in the aquarium lighting industry knew about it... because Orbitech doesnt actually have a product. LED's have been used over aquariums long before Orbitech came around, but the whole 'new tech' spin on an old idea, as well as a lazy USPTO allowed it to pass. If you compared the systems as well... you would see how different they are. The Orbitech system has seperate red and blue LED's that are not natural looking, but provide some of the peak (supposed) growth that corals and plants use. Their systems are intended for studies in space. PFO's system uses full spectrum LED's as well as blue ones (not a combo of red and blue), and their research is based on actual hobbyist use as well as Marine Biologist supplied information. Overall, PFO's system was far ahead of Orbitech's, but they are actually IN a working market with lots of established experience. Their controls were not to simulate natural sunlight even, but to control the seperate amounts of red and blue light (a color control system). PFO's controls were more 'visual', changing the intensity of various LED's in the system to simulate cloud cover and the waves of the ocean but keeping the color the same. PFO's system used the latest in high efficiency high-output LED's and was cutting edge where Orbitech's looked like it was a science project. Orbitech's lawyers took PFO to court unless PFO paid a crazy royalty fee, and with all that NASA grant money that Orbitech has for lawyers, it came down to a pocketbook comparison. PFO just closed its doors. Orbitech doesnt even have a product out on the market, let alone something that an individual would want to buy, and had they actually gone to court, the would have likely lost their patent... but PFO would have run out of money to pay legal fees long before. So, as it stands right now, every aquarium lighting maker in the US is afraid to put out a LED lighting system. Right now the most advanced systems being used by people with reef aquariums are those they made themselves!

When patents that are bogus get approved just to generate income, by engineers that are not familiar with the technology enough to make an informed decision, then bogus patents get enforced by lawyers where it becomes more about 'who has deeper pockets' than what the truth is. There are so many bogus, 'junk-science', and otherwise useless patents getting approved by the USPTO right now that its more of a game than a useful system. The USPTO is so 'hands off' its not funny. I called a reviewer of one patent to try to 'educate' him about how a patent he was reviewing was bogus, if not patented already by a company 15-20 years prior. His response was along the lines of 'well, you can file an injunction if you think it violates a patent of yours'. My response was 'its not my patent or anyone's patent, its been common information and design in the industry for over 20 years'. His response was 'well, after it gets approved, if there are any problems, then its for the courts to figure out if they decide to still go after you'. There are so many things wrong with that response that its not even funny.

Oh...sorry if I missed that in your first post, then. The massive blocks of text that are your posts are quite intimidating. ;)

But to you and everyone else: I'm not saying the patent system isn't broken or doesn't need to be fixed. I was just saying that the modern system of R&D - large firms and governments pooling together resources in long-term projects rather than individuals tinkering around - is not necessarily a bad system as long as it leads to innovation and progress.

I like your open statement, you could get a job with the patent office.

Lol you guys don't realize what I'm talking about. I'm referring to the fact that Dean Kamen founded FIRST Robotics, a program that has inspired many thousands of students to pursue engineering degrees and careers who wouldn't have otherwise - myself included.
 
I interpreted your question "Why do you say that system is messed up?" as one of extreme scepticism, and indicative of a point-of-view that the patent system isn't broken. Perhaps that was not the case, and your question was indeed genuine.

---

Newton developed modern calculus and formulated the laws of motion, both of which are used in pretty much every modern invention; therefore Newton is indirectly responsible for more patents than anyone else... or maybe his parents.

It's a pretty inane and impossible honour to be arguing about.
 
I interpreted your question "Why do you say that system is messed up?" as one of extreme scepticism, and indicative of a point-of-view that the patent system isn't broken. Perhaps that was not the case, and your question was indeed genuine.

---

Newton developed modern calculus and formulated the laws of motion, both of which are used in pretty much every modern invention; therefore Newton is indirectly responsible for more patents than anyone else... or maybe his parents.

It's a pretty inane and impossible honour to be arguing about.

I tend to be really optimistic, so you interpreting my question that way is probably not your fault.

As for Dean Kamen...umm, can we just agree that he's a very important person to the world of engineering and innovation?
 
Even if they had a patent system, there's a few things:
1) Their legal system (which is not like ours here in the US, you don't have the brances and checks and balances) would have to fine them or something. When the government is as corrupted as one like China, they'd readily accept a bribe then look the other way.
2) Their justice system, along with the first point, would have to actually impose something more than "You're guilty, let's move on".

You're implying that the Chinese government is more corrupt than the other governments in North America? That's laughable. North American public servants are very greedy taxpayer swindlers. The corruption is so great, that they are literally swimming in it, but they do put on a good show for the public and convince them that their services are well-needed, and that they work hard. There's the occasional scandal here and there to appease the public mob.
 
Who would enforce it? The majority of countries don't follow the resolutions set down by the UN and most just openly defy them. So ya this won't fly at all and only make things worse more than likely.
 
You're implying that the Chinese government is more corrupt than the other governments in North America? That's laughable. North American public servants are very greedy taxpayer swindlers. The corruption is so great, that they are literally swimming in it, but they do put on a good show for the public and convince them that their services are well-needed, and that they work hard. There's the occasional scandal here and there to appease the public mob.

What I think you mean to say is that the majority of Americans are hardworking tax paying citizens; however, there are a few who try and cheat the system for their gain. Which would probably describe every single government and country in the world, including China.
 
I currenty have an innovation that will revolutionize the electric car concept, but I face having to pay close to $10,000 in fee's to get the patent filed and covered in the major world markets, and then face having to defend it against whatever multinational corporation(s) choose to try and wrestle control from me..... not the most inviting system for a garage inventor.

I save the costs of a patent attorney as I've written many myself previsouly, and am doing all the work myself. The ultimate success of being able to benfit from this would have rested 99% on the quality of the patent itself, but with the current system it matters less how god the patent is and more on whether you will be able to defend it in court... if challenged OR if trying to enjoin blatent violators.

Then Im sure you already know that with just a few hundred dollars you can apply for a provisional patent, to secure the idea (or at least put it up on the chopping block for others to see if they want to contest it before you put in some serious money). During this time you can see if your invention is worth it by seeking investors, or if its just another 'wind powered car' idea.
 
Back
Top