Microsoft Wants $15 Per Android Handset

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Microsoft is asking fifteen bucks per Android handset? Well, before you laugh at that figure, you should probably know Samsung is already offering ten per handset. :eek:

Microsoft Corp has demanded that Samsung Electronics Co Ltd pay $15 for each smartphone handset it makes based on Google Inc's Android operating system as the software giant has a wide range of patents used in the mobile platform, local media reported on Wednesday. Samsung would likely seek to lower the payment to about $10 in exchange for a deeper alliance with Microsoft for the U.S. company's Windows platform.
 
Not a bad deal for MS. Get 10$ for each 3.5 million SII's and thats a good chunk of change for doing nothing but holding a patent!
 
This is one of the reasons Google wanted Android to be free and open source--let the manufacturers take the heat for the patent violations.

Now, MS will settle with all the handset makers for a cash payment all while saying "you know what you can make even cheaper? WP7 phones."
 
lol, I think $15 is what MS was going to charge Nokia per Windows Phone 7 license as part of the deal it made.
 
Didn't microsoft do this a few genz ago as well? Im sure the companies have to be expecting this by now.
 
I do think $15 is about what it is to get WinPhone7. So Android is now effectively the same prices as WinPhone7. Brilliant ( and evil) move on Microsofts part.

The whole patent system needs a massive overhaul.
 
Microsoft is really trying to take out of everyone's ass lately. It's almost like they're trying to be as irritating as Apple.
 
Microsoft is really trying to take out of everyone's ass lately.
Well, I'm sure that if MS violated anyone else's patents that they would ignore it and NOT march straight to East Texas, rite? :p
 
I wish they would be more public about these patents. The fact that extremely large companies like HTC and General Dynamics are taking Microsoft up on the licenses makes me think that perhaps they're legitimate...but still, I'm not so sure.

Either way, Google could end this quickly if they would just offer indemnification for all of its OEM partners, but this non-action by Google during all this can't help their Android ecosystem at all. So not only are the OEMs responsible for issuing their own Android updates, but now they have to pay a licensing fee to use Android (which the lack of one was a major asset for hardware OEMs)? What's the perk then to using that?

It's a brilliantly evil plan by Microsoft, and Google is letting them get away with it.
 
It's a brilliantly evil plan by Microsoft, and Google is letting them get away with it.

I am sorry, how is it an "evil plan"? Microsoft is asking companies to pay for using services that Microsoft developed or owns the patent for. Under the current system, that is exactly how the patent and licensing world works and companies have been paying licensing fees for decades based on that model. So how is it all of a sudden "evil" to do it?

If you don't like the patent/licensing structure, that is understandable, I don't either. However to say someone or a company is evil for using the system in place, as it was designed to work, is pretty ridiculous imho.
 
I am sorry, how is it an "evil plan"? Microsoft is asking companies to pay for using services that Microsoft developed or owns the patent for. Under the current system, that is exactly how the patent and licensing world works and companies have been paying licensing fees for decades based on that model. So how is it all of a sudden "evil" to do it?

If you don't like the patent/licensing structure, that is understandable, I don't either. However to say someone or a company is evil for using the system in place, as it was designed to work, is pretty ridiculous imho.

It was a joke. I actually use a Windows phone and quite like it. I have no problem with a company protecting its IP.

So long as it's actually legitimate. The more companies I see sign on, the more legitimate it seems, but I'd still like to see Microsoft announce which patents they're referring to.
 
Microsoft is really trying to take out of everyone's ass lately. It's almost like they're trying to be as irritating as Apple.

Microsoft doesn't need lessons on screwing over competitors. This is like a return to form for them. I remember in the late 80's, early 90's, MS worked their licensing deals so that PC vendors had to pay them for a windows license on ever PC, even if it shipped with OS/2, Linux or whatever. It was a sure fire way to stifle competition then and it will probably work well today.

Once you are paying the same price as a Microsoft license, there is no additional cost to just going with Microsoft.
 
There's a huge perk called "Android phones outsell WP7 by eleventy to one". A sale on a profitable smartphone is better than no sale. :p

And yet if they end up paying the same amount of licensing fees with both Android and WP7...but WP7 costs less in the long run since the OEMs aren't responsible for issuing the updates, you really don't think that won't damage the Android ecosystem?

It discourages companies from using it.
 
It discourages companies from using it.
I disagree. It's a bitter pill that goes along with participating in the Android handset market, which has been very good to several manufacturers entering the higher end smartphone market.

The options at first glance are:
1) don't pay, get sued and possibly get an injunction that prevents sales in several geographic regions.
2) don't pay and get out of Android handsets (+ tablets?) business.
3) pay and still make money on Android business.

The handset makers must have known #3 was a possibility since Google offered no indemnity. To think that handset makers didn't consider that is naïve.
 
Aw MS, upset that your precious WP7 isn't selling as well as you'd like? :rolleyes:
 
Microsoft doesn't need lessons on screwing over competitors. This is like a return to form for them. I remember in the late 80's, early 90's, MS worked their licensing deals so that PC vendors had to pay them for a windows license on ever PC, even if it shipped with OS/2, Linux or whatever. It was a sure fire way to stifle competition then and it will probably work well today.

Once you are paying the same price as a Microsoft license, there is no additional cost to just going with Microsoft.

Going back to form? Is this a microsoft only thing to ask for money from companies using their pantents?
 
these companies are getting annoying, they dont make what people want and they sue the companies who do to get income... they need to update the patent system somehow to prevent the insane numbers we see these days
 
I am sorry, how is it an "evil plan"? Microsoft is asking companies to pay for using services that Microsoft developed or owns the patent for. Under the current system, that is exactly how the patent and licensing world works and companies have been paying licensing fees for decades based on that model. So how is it all of a sudden "evil" to do it?
Because it's more likely a patent on something stupid, like using Fat32 or using a touch screen to dial a phone number. As we all know, Windows Mobile has been around long before iPhone or Android.
If you don't like the patent/licensing structure, that is understandable, I don't either. However to say someone or a company is evil for using the system in place, as it was designed to work, is pretty ridiculous imho.
It's not being used as intended. Companies are using it to discourage other companies, or just make a boat load of money. Look at Apple vs Samsung.

And yet if they end up paying the same amount of licensing fees with both Android and WP7...but WP7 costs less in the long run since the OEMs aren't responsible for issuing the updates, you really don't think that won't damage the Android ecosystem?

It discourages companies from using it.
That's probably Microsoft's goal, but it won't discourage cell phone manufacturers from making Android phones, or to start making WP7 phones.

#1 Google puts a lot of money behind something that's free. This off loads a lot of cost to manufacturers.
#2 Google has no limits to what you can do with a phone, physically. You can put as many buttons, cameras, or anything else.
#3 No limit to what you can do with the OS. Custom keyboards, UI's, and all sorts of other stuff. Not very popular with some people, but a lot of people do like it.
#4 Google provides a lot of free services that don't exist on WP7, or are just terrible in comparison. I have yet to see someone provide a better GPS then the one included with Android.
 
#4 Google provides a lot of free services that don't exist on WP7, or are just terrible in comparison. I have yet to see someone provide a better GPS then the one included with Android.

Honestly? OVI Maps (or what's it called now; Nokia Maps) has always looked far better to me than Google Maps. Especially since you can cache locally and don't require a data signal. It also has better turn by turn and better walking directions via turn by turn.

That's coming to WP7. It's not here right now, and while I agree that Google Maps is probably the best I've seen so far on a smartphone, it won't be that way for much longer.
 
Honestly? OVI Maps (or what's it called now; Nokia Maps) has always looked far better to me than Google Maps. Especially since you can cache locally and don't require a data signal. It also has better turn by turn and better walking directions via turn by turn.

That's coming to WP7. It's not here right now, and while I agree that Google Maps is probably the best I've seen so far on a smartphone, it won't be that way for much longer.

You can cache a route locally on Android as well.
 
I remember reading somewhere that MS is already getting $10 from HTC for every droid phone sold. And HTC also makes the Win7 phone. The sad thing is MS is making more money off the Droid phones than their own.
 
Microsoft doesn't need lessons on screwing over competitors. This is like a return to form for them. I remember in the late 80's, early 90's, MS worked their licensing deals so that PC vendors had to pay them for a windows license on ever PC, even if it shipped with OS/2, Linux or whatever. It was a sure fire way to stifle competition then and it will probably work well today.

Once you are paying the same price as a Microsoft license, there is no additional cost to just going with Microsoft.


And how exactly is Microsoft "screwing over competitors" by making them pay for Microsoft patents the competitors are unlawfully using.
 
There is no incompatibility. Both suck. Apple screws its users, Microsoft screws its competitors.

Honestly, Microsoft treats its competitors in an entirely different light. You may not like what they're doing, but if these were patents held by Apple, they wouldn't be looking for licensing. They would try to stop Android from ever being used period.

Microsoft just wants licensing deals. I honestly can't remember the last time Apple has ever willingly sought to license its IP to those that it believes are infringing upon it.
 
And how exactly is Microsoft "screwing over competitors" by making them pay for Microsoft patents the competitors are unlawfully using.

Well the "patents" I've seen listed here are incredibly vague and open ended. If its a legitimate development then I have no problem but if its something that's ridiculously broad, its a crock.

That being said, even if Android phones were $15 more, Id still buy them over a WP7 or iPhone because they're simply better.
 
If you don't like the patent/licensing structure, that is understandable, I don't either. However to say someone or a company is evil for using the system in place, as it was designed to work, is pretty ridiculous imho.

Things are not good or ill based on their legal status. Something which is legal in a country or several countries can rather easily be ill or if you prefer it "evil".

That is unless you think anti-miscegenation laws, public stonings, and chopping off peoples' hands for stealing are all just fine because they're legal in places.
 
Microsoft is really losing touch...All they will end up being is a patent troll type company in a few years.
 
You can cache a route locally on Android as well.

For a particular, pre-determined route yes. But you can't preload an entire country (or even the world if you have almost 8gb memory spare). Necessary if you don't like paying over the odds for data or get crappy 3g speeds (Hello Orange)
 
To those who think MS is the evil for doing this, what are there options? You have a competitor using there patents and giving it away for free so much so you cant even sell your own stuff! If Google IS using MS's patents then they are the evil and MS is just protecting its rights. Just like Palm, Black Berry, and now iOS, Android will apex soon. Sure its easy to sell 10x1 Android phones with there are 15x1 Android phones at the store! Anyone go into AT&T recently? Its wall 2 wall Android! Why? Because the phone makers thought they were getting a free OS!
 
Free advertisement for Samsung imo. I wonder if Samsung will still turn a profit even with this "licensing" fee.
 
How much time has an IP validity ? Till end of days ? Those patents never expire ?
Patents in the US originally had a 14 year term from issue date. The term has changed over the years, and it's currently 20 years from the earliest filing date for those filed in the past 16 years, or 17 years from date of issue for those filed prior to that. Certain other patents have a 14 year term.

Copyright term is a complete joke. This graphic shows it best: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2f/Copyright_term.svg
 
Since when? Last I remember reading that was the reason why HTC introduced its own GPS system to use in its Sense enabled Android phones.

For a long time now. Ever since I got my Android phone (which was more than half a year ago) Google Maps has had that caching feature.
 
Back
Top