Microsoft: This Isn't Your Dad's Windows

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I sure hope Microsoft didn't actually say "this isn't your Dad's Windows" at its annual Build developer conference. What a dumb thing to say.

"Windows 10 is not just another release of Windows, but a new generation of Windows," Nadella said onstage. "The tech business is about being able to know before it is conventional wisdom that that is where the market is going ... and knowing that you can get there first, get there with the best innovation."
 
satya-nadella-microsoft-ceo-10_zpsg6c2gjdk.jpg
 
A "new generation of Windows", that's still based on NT 6...

Oh marketing people, when will you learn?
 
"The tech business is about being able to know before it is conventional wisdom that that is where the market is going ... and knowing that you can get there first, get there with the best innovation."
Cos MS got that right with Windows 8 and 8.1.
Makes you wonder why they think windows 10 is necessary.
And makes us wonder if they can make a worthwhile OS any more.
After all, what the consumer wants doesnt matter right?
 
My Dad's version of Windows didn't try to lock me into Microsoft's ecosystem. It allowed me to install software from ANY source, and didn't require me to shop for "apps" from a "Windows Store". It also had an intuitive UI, and didn't have "live tiles" cluttering up my desktop.

Also, my Dad's hardware didn't lock me into using just Windows. I could boot into Linux or any other OS I chose, unlike "designed for Windows 10" hardware, which will have the option (let's not kid ourselves, most hardware WILL be locked!) to lock down the SecureBoot so only Windows 10 can be installed!

Nope, not my Dad's Windows...
 
If these preview builds are any indication of Win10 then it fuckin sux. The whole os feels like an add serving web browser designed for cell phones. The configuration settings are purposely nebulous with ridiculous catch phrases designed to lull you into a false sense of control. It feels like it was designed to give a user the experience MS wants you to have, not one you can configure to your liking. All the cloud integration stuff is just plain scary. I have my own cloud thank you very much, I don't want bots going through all my shit. Every time I load it up I feel like one of those fat people in Wall-E sitting in a chair with my 40oz slurpee with nothing to worry about cause everything's been decided for me. No wonder this pos will be free.
 
If these preview builds are any indication of Win10 then it fuckin sux. The whole os feels like an add serving web browser designed for cell phones. The configuration settings are purposely nebulous with ridiculous catch phrases designed to lull you into a false sense of control. It feels like it was designed to give a user the experience MS wants you to have, not one you can configure to your liking. All the cloud integration stuff is just plain scary. I have my own cloud thank you very much, I don't want bots going through all my shit. Every time I load it up I feel like one of those fat people in Wall-E sitting in a chair with my 40oz slurpee with nothing to worry about cause everything's been decided for me. No wonder this pos will be free.

Nailed it

Windows 10 is a Microsoft product designed to sell additional Microsoft products while turning the user and their data into a product.
 
If these preview builds are any indication of Win10 then it fuckin sux. The whole os feels like an add serving web browser designed for cell phones. The configuration settings are purposely nebulous with ridiculous catch phrases designed to lull you into a false sense of control. It feels like it was designed to give a user the experience MS wants you to have, not one you can configure to your liking. All the cloud integration stuff is just plain scary. I have my own cloud thank you very much, I don't want bots going through all my shit. Every time I load it up I feel like one of those fat people in Wall-E sitting in a chair with my 40oz slurpee with nothing to worry about cause everything's been decided for me. No wonder this pos will be free.

"We've got these idiots locked into our magical cloud shit like its new and improved Tide!"
 
Your dad's windows??? Windows only first came out in 85 and only became popular in 95... Jeez how old do you think we are!?!? lol
 
The configuration settings are purposely nebulous with ridiculous catch phrases designed to lull you into a false sense of control. It feels like it was designed to give a user the experience MS wants you to have, not one you can configure to your liking. All the cloud integration stuff is just plain scary.

Wait, isn't there an OS that already has done this for decades?

(ahem, Apple?)

Seriously, though, this is *exactly* why I will never, ever buy an Apple product.
 
Nailed it

Windows 10 is a Microsoft product designed to sell additional Microsoft products while turning the user and their data into a product.

Microsoft is always way behind everyone else. Google has been exploiting the end user and turning their data into a product for over a decade now. It's shameful that MS is only just starting to catch up.
 
I think non-technical dads like tablet crap. I'm not sure what he means.
 
Microsoft is always way behind everyone else. Google has been exploiting the end user and turning their data into a product for over a decade now. It's shameful that MS is only just starting to catch up.

I am well aware of Google's unethical and borderline illegal spying and privacy violating business practices. Google cannot be trusted and their advertising, analytics, and tracking presence is polluting the internet.

The main difference here between Google and Microsoft is the price of the product/service; most users have paid Microsoft for their Windows or Office license (one way or another).
As a direct result of purchasing their products Microsoft is actively forcing cloud services and connectivity onto them for further monetization, spying, and analytics.
 
The main difference here between Google and Microsoft is the price of the product/service; most users have paid Microsoft for their Windows or Office license (one way or another).
As a direct result of purchasing their products Microsoft is actively forcing cloud services and connectivity onto them for further monetization, spying, and analytics.

Compared to Apple and Google, Microsoft is more diversified and as a result a very interesting paradox is occurring. You see a lot of old time Windows users bemoaning the cloud yet the cloud, Azure using Microsoft's parlance, is there faster growing business by far. Nothing comes close. And while they are well behind Amazon at this point they are a solid #2 with more growth than Amazon. And we're talking about a business that's projected to be worth $200 billion dollars in the next 4 to 5 years.

Part of the issues that Windows 8 faced and Windows 10 is facing are generational. There are those that just want a desktop OS that's really not different in any way from the 90's. Local programs and storage and limited connectivity. The notion of apps and services and the cloud is just wrong, flat wrong to them. But we're past that for the average computer user in 2015.

Microsoft can put all the options and switches possible to turn all of that stuff off. But would that ultimately lead a growing number of people to but copies of Windows, directly or indirectly? In the age of PC lasting longer than ever and smartphones and smartwatches the answer is more than likely no.

The computing world is vastly different that is was when even Windows 7 was released. Even in a place like this, look at all of the stories related to mobile computing and the cloud vs local centric PC computing. It's simply a different time. Microsoft has recognized that but is obviously having trouble adapting to it, at least with their traditional products. When not constrained by decades of conceptions Microsoft is actually doing very well, i.e. thing like Azure. Hell even the Surface line, a device that runs Windows is doing pretty well because they figured out how to make a super mobile and flexible PC.
 
My Dad's version of Windows didn't try to lock me into Microsoft's ecosystem. It allowed me to install software from ANY source, and didn't require me to shop for "apps" from a "Windows Store". It also had an intuitive UI, and didn't have "live tiles" cluttering up my desktop.

Also, my Dad's hardware didn't lock me into using just Windows. I could boot into Linux or any other OS I chose, unlike "designed for Windows 10" hardware, which will have the option (let's not kid ourselves, most hardware WILL be locked!) to lock down the SecureBoot so only Windows 10 can be installed!

Nope, not my Dad's Windows...

Please, show me a version of Windows that forces you to buy something from Microsoft's ecosystem? Or a version of Windows that does not let you install from any source. (Including malware sources.) Interesting, I have Windows 8.1 and I can also boot into Ubuntu Linux on 2 different computers with Secure Boot enabled. FUD!
 
Cos MS got that right with Windows 8 and 8.1.
Makes you wonder why they think windows 10 is necessary.
And makes us wonder if they can make a worthwhile OS any more.
After all, what the consumer wants doesnt matter right?

Because they move on and improve things. I sure hope you do not wear the same cloths you bought in the 90's.
 
Nadella is a PR talker. When we asked him questions at the MVP summit, he answered them just as a PR agent would. Not directly answering them, but giving the fluff answer and skirting around the issue. He'd make a good politician. I like the guy, but he's hard to take serious when he's talking. Even under NDA, he couldn't answer straight.

So, I don't really pay much attention to what he has to say. Not unless I'm enjoying the Kool-Aid that day.
 
Please, show me a version of Windows that forces you to buy something from Microsoft's ecosystem? Or a version of Windows that does not let you install from any source. (Including malware sources.) Interesting, I have Windows 8.1 and I can also boot into Ubuntu Linux on 2 different computers with Secure Boot enabled. FUD!

Indeed, you could by a device like a Surface 3/Pro 3, install DuOS and live in Google's ecosystem and never buy or run a Windows Store app. From a consumer perspective Windows is probably too flexible and powerful compared to the other major platforms. And in this case no, desktop Linux isn't Android. The thing is you'd have to install some type of emulator like Bluestacks or what I consider the superior DuOS and DuOS is only a Windows x86 app currently. Irony.
 
They didnt improve things, they made them worse.
Sets a precedent.

Windows 8.1 did improve things. 8.1 can run well on the equivalent of modern phone hardware. It can run much better on touch only devices than prior versions of Windows while retaining Win32 compatibility.

We can debate certain feature choices and UI decisions and that's more than fair. But Windows is used on a lot more types of devices than any other client OS. It's pretty flexible in that department even if 8.1 has keyboard and usability issues for those that just want the old stuff. And I don't mean old stuff pejoratively, I just mean what people are used to. But I doubt that anyone using Windows 7 is an iota more productive than anyone that knows 8.1. As in if you don't need Windows Store apps, use whatever desktop app you've always used. And set the defaults.
 
Indeed, you could by a device like a Surface 3/Pro 3, install DuOS and live in Google's ecosystem and never buy or run a Windows Store app. From a consumer perspective Windows is probably too flexible and powerful compared to the other major platforms. And in this case no, desktop Linux isn't Android. The thing is you'd have to install some type of emulator like Bluestacks or what I consider the superior DuOS and DuOS is only a Windows x86 app currently. Irony.

On both my home and work computers, I disconnected all but one drive, installed Ubuntu in UEFI mode and then reconnected all the drives again. I can now boot using the F11 boot menu into Ubuntu or Windows 8.1 depending on what I am in the mood to use that day or moment. Now, I love and prefer Windows but, I have always enjoyed using other Operating Systems. (I used to use OS/2 Warp exclusively and I installed Linux back in the late 90's as well.)
 
They didnt improve things, they made many things worse.
Sets a precedent.

Actually, they did improve thing greatly, just not everything and not all at once. I guess making Windows more efficient and better is not improving things then. You have a very strange definition of improving things.
 
lol.
Windows 8 and 8.1 are worse to use than Windows 7.
 
I like where Windows 10 is going but it looks a lot like what Android/Samsung Note phone UI has been doing for years. That's a good thing as I like a common UI.
 
All depends of how one uses a system. Windows 8.1 with hybrids and independent multiple monitor systems is better than 7 overall.

If thats all it was about then it wouldnt have sold so badly that microsoft need to give away the next version.
 
I like where Windows 10 is going but it looks a lot like what Android/Samsung Note phone UI has been doing for years. That's a good thing as I like a common UI.

Yes and no. I've yet to see an implementation of Android that's anywhere near what a Windows 8.1 hybrid can do with a traditional desktop. And that's not a slam, Windows is traditionally a desktop OS. Yes in that Android/Samsung have tried to create a touch enabled desktop that is better in some ways than using Windows with touch purely through touch on the desktop. But ultimately that's just windowing a bunch of sandboxed Android apps and it just isn't as flexible as a traditional desktop.
 
If thats all it was about then it wouldnt have sold so badly that microsoft need to give away the next version.

That has a lot to do with the market. Neither Apple nor Google charge for their OSes directly. 2015 isn't 1995. It's devices that consumers buy today, not operating systems. That has little to do with Windows. While Surface has had a rough road, the reason why it has life is because it's a device, a very flexible one. The OS just isn't as important as long as it's Win32 compatible.
 
If MS gave us what we wanted, we would have bought it.
We expected to pay for it and were looking forward to a new Windows.
We didnt like what we got, it wasnt worth buying.
 
lol.
Windows 8 and 8.1 are worse to use than Windows 7.

And this is really the thing. What is it that you do personally that's so much better in 7 that 8.1? Again, we can talk about aesthesis and Start Menu versus start screen and maybe you have some apps/programs that don't work in 8 or something else.

I get the issues with keyboard and mouse usability but my main personal device these days is a Surface Pro 3. I still have an ok desktop for gaming, a couple even, a couple of decent laptops but a Surface Pro 3 can go a lot more places and do pretty much everything I want outside of desktop gaming, and that too works great on my 8.1 desktops.

This is very much a personal choice debate. One where I admit a lot of people just want a keyboard and mouse and track pad and no cloud this or that and Aero and a Start Menu but at the end of the day tradeoff mobility for that and aren't a bit more productive than someone that doesn't bitch constantly about Windows 8.x/10.
 
The same as most of the population who chose not to use Windows 8.x.
 
Back
Top