Microsoft Surface 3 Vs Surface Pro 3: What's The Difference?

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Microsoft has a talent for confusing naming schemes and the latest Surface 3 and Surface 3 Pro is an excellent example of confusing the consumers, not only in name, but also in appearance. Forbes has put together a brief guide to explain the differences and similarities between the two tablets and what you should know before purchasing.

The Surface 3 is primarily a consumer device targeted at those looking for a more flexible alternative to an iPad or cheap laptop and tempted by the extra functionality offered by a full version of Windows.
 
Some other differences that weren't mentioned.

S3 has eMMC SSD whereas SP3 is SATA3 SSD but for general use it won't make a difference.

S3 has autofocus back facing camera whereas SP3 has fixed focus.

S3 is primarily targeted at the cost conscious educational market to kill off the iPad plus Macbook Air companion.
 
What is so confusing?!? Anyone will easily guess the Pro is better but pricier than the normal. The first gen was confusing with the RT (no body knew it wasn't a real windows and were disappointed after buying it) but this time its obvious.
 
So, you men people do not know the difference between an iPad 2, iPad Air 2 and iPad Mini 2? Guess folks cannot understand basic English then. :rolleyes:,
 
I tried out a Surface 3 at a Microsoft Store yesterday. Very impressive build quality. Pretty light, quite a bit lighter than the Pro 3. Microsoft reduced the size of the edges along the Type Cover compared to the Pro 3 Type Cover such that the keys feels about the same size as the Pro 3, it's a very good typing experience for a device this size. The screen is every bit as good as the Surface Pro 3's.

I think Microsoft has winner here. I know people will complain about the price and of course there's the Atom x7 and what it will bring to the table in terms of performance. Assuming the CPU speed is not much more than Bay Trail and the GPU speed is on par with the HD 4400 I think its priced reasonably for a device this think and light and battery efficient. Pre-ordered the 4GB/128GB version.
 
I tried out a Surface 3 at a Microsoft Store yesterday. Very impressive build quality. Pretty light, quite a bit lighter than the Pro 3. Microsoft reduced the size of the edges along the Type Cover compared to the Pro 3 Type Cover such that the keys feels about the same size as the Pro 3, it's a very good typing experience for a device this size. The screen is every bit as good as the Surface Pro 3's.

I think Microsoft has winner here. I know people will complain about the price and of course there's the Atom x7 and what it will bring to the table in terms of performance. Assuming the CPU speed is not much more than Bay Trail and the GPU speed is on par with the HD 4400 I think its priced reasonably for a device this think and light and battery efficient. Pre-ordered the 4GB/128GB version.

So, the big question I want to ask you is: For $500, this or a new iPad?
 
So, the big question I want to ask you is: For $500, this or a new iPad?

It depends on what you want. The iPad is a better touch consumption and entertainment tablet with is vastly larger app store. So if one is looking to use their device primarily as a tablet the iPad would probably be a better choice.

With the Type Cover and pen the Surface 3 is a better productivity device. I love my Surface Pro 3 but I wouldn't recommend a Windows hybrid unless the user really intends to use the device as a hybrid. That means using as both a tablet and laptop constantly.
 
Some other differences that weren't mentioned.

S3 has eMMC SSD whereas SP3 is SATA3 SSD but for general use it won't make a difference.

S3 has autofocus back facing camera whereas SP3 has fixed focus.

S3 is primarily targeted at the cost conscious educational market to kill off the iPad plus Macbook Air companion.

Why target iPad users? The tablet market is taking a huge nosedive. Such a confusing target for Microsoft.
 
Why target iPad users? The tablet market is taking a huge nosedive. Such a confusing target for Microsoft.

Well all those schools that bought up iPads a couple of years ago are probably looking to replace them by now.

They can replace for new iPads or swap to much cheaper Chromebooks. A lot of schools are doing this.

So MS is probably looking to say look you can buy one iPad, two Surface 3 or 3 Chromebooks.

However, only one runs full Windows...and has Office installed....like the kids will use at work.
 
Honestly, who cares about a watered down Surface 3? If you wanted that, there have been deals on the SP3 64GB model that bring it down to close to the same price point.

Where's my Surface Pro 4? I've had my SP3 for way too long now and I really want 256gb/8gb on my next Surface.
 
Like what everyone else does around here with hardware, sell, turn into hand-me-downs or repurpose.

That makes sense. I don't think one would really hold my interest for very long either if I had a more practical computer around. They're good throw away toys.
 
Honestly, who cares about a watered down Surface 3?

I'm guessing more than perhaps cared about the Surface Pro 3. I think the Surface 3 will sell better than the Pro 3 if only because of the price. It's hard for me to predict how the difference in screen size will be perceived. After playing with Surface 3 at a Microsoft Store Saturday, the smaller screen certainly doesn't feel as comfortable as the Pro 3's display. But the better battery life and significantly reduced weight and fanless design should more than make up for the screen size. The issue is mostly going to be about performance.

Base on my expereince with Bay Trail devices I think it should be fine. The first thing I'll be interesting in trying is Visual Studio and seeing how well writing code works from interacting with the UI and smaller screen to compiling and debugging. If that works well I'll be a happy camper and should mean that there's enough performance their for somewhat demanding use. Certainly modern PC games will be out of the question but if mainstream desktop performance is there the Surface 3 should do very well.

Where's my Surface Pro 4? I've had my SP3 for way too long now and I really want 256gb/8gb on my next Surface.

The Surface Pro 3 isn't even a year old yet. I think it made sense to get the Surface 3 out now to replace the Surface 2 and to end the Windows RT era. My guess is that the timing of the Surface lines will be closely aligned with Intel's latest chipsets. So once Cherry Trail was available Microsoft launched the Surface 3. When Skylake is available I'm guessing that's when the Surface Pro 4 will launch. The next Atom SoC isn't due until early next year and that's when the Surface 4 will probably launch.
 
Honestly, who cares about a watered down Surface 3?
Judging by the popularity of the stream tablets I'm going to say there are a lot of people looking for something cheap enough to displace the iPad. The cheapest SP3 is $799, add on a type cover, taxes, etc and your over a grand. That's a lot of money and an extra $200 will help ease that blow for the general consumer.

As for this vs an iPad? I'll take this all day long without question. These new Windows tablets are stunning productivity tools that make the iPad long in the tooth IMO
 
Back
Top