Microsoft Sues Salesforce.com Over Patents

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Whew, that was close! We almost made it through a whole day without a patent lawsuit. Thankfully Saleforce.com decided to get themselves sued by Microsoft before the end of the news day.

The lawsuit, filed in federal court in Seattle (PDF), seeks both monetary damages as well as temporary and permanent injunctions. Specifically, the company seeks a jury trial and also asks that the damages be tripled and that Salesforce be ordered to pay legal fees and other costs, arguing that the company's patent infringement is willful.
 
The patents cover a variety of back-end and user interface features, ranging from one covering a "system and method for providing and displaying a Web page having an embedded menu" to another that covers a "method and system for stacking toolbars in a computer display."

ummmm.. ok. Sounds kinda like one auto manufacturer suing another auto manufacturer for using round steering wheels.
 
The patents cover a variety of back-end and user interface features, ranging from one covering a "system and method for providing and displaying a Web page having an embedded menu" to another that covers a "method and system for stacking toolbars in a computer display."

ummmm.. ok. Sounds kinda like one auto manufacturer suing another auto manufacturer for using round steering wheels.

"system and method for providing and displaying a Web page having an embedded menu" deals with pop-up menus in Java applets on webpages, and was patented by SIG in 1996. Somehow I think the concepts we take for granted today may not have been "common sense" back then.

geocities-1996.gif

mcd2.jpg


The problem with software patents isn't their broadness, it's their duration. These patents need 5-10 year lifespans. If this patent had expired in 2003 it wouldn't seem so unreasonable.
 
Some of these tech patents are just ridiculous. I think the patent office needs to relook at how they evaluate patents for technology, since it's such a different animal than everything else. Giving certain things longer protection makes sense, but tech evolves and gets adapted so rapidly that 10+ year patents just seem ridiculous.
 
Some of these tech patents are just ridiculous. I think the patent office needs to relook at how they evaluate patents for technology,...

That would require them to do some actual work. You forget that they work for the government. ;)
 
Wow, from the sound of it they could sue anyone. The Patent system in the country sucks.
 
That would require them to do some actual work. You forget that they work for the government. ;)

Good point. When I was in high school some of the smartest kids wanted to be patent lawyers. Wonder why those smarties never made it into the office itself. Maybe there's just more money in litigating stupid patents than approving them. The system sucks.
 
Good point. When I was in high school some of the smartest kids wanted to be patent lawyers. Wonder why those smarties never made it into the office itself. Maybe there's just more money in litigating stupid patents than approving them. The system sucks.

wow, those are some smart kids if they wanted to be patent lawyers all the way back in high school....lotta wedgies and swirlies running around saying that. I wanted to be a gigolo when I was in high school :D
 
wow, those are some smart kids if they wanted to be patent lawyers all the way back in high school....lotta wedgies and swirlies running around saying that. I wanted to be a gigolo when I was in high school :D

I don't want to perpetuate stereotypes, but I was in a largely higher middle-class neighborhood with too many stay at home parents who were more than happy helicopter parenting. Everyone was going to be a doctor or a lawyer, I swear...
 
. Maybe there's just more money in litigating stupid patents than approving them. The system sucks.

You do understand that to litigate "stupid patents" that it would be best to use a lawyer who specializes in patent law also right?
 
Man, I picked the wrong course of studies. Some of these high schooler's aspiring to be patent lawyer must be too smart for their own good.

You do understand that to litigate "stupid patents" that it would be best to use a lawyer who specializes in patent law also right?

Someone's gotta hire the lawyers. ;) Sure they advertise on TV for lawsuits to hire but they can't operate in a vacuum. Of course sometimes it's the other way around.... lawyers pick an individual to do the suing.
 
I don't want to perpetuate stereotypes, but I was in a largely higher middle-class neighborhood with too many stay at home parents who were more than happy helicopter parenting. Everyone was going to be a doctor or a lawyer, I swear...

actually so did I, blue ribbon schools, wealthy kids, almost idyllic (?) surroundings...going on to college was pretty much a given for all students with the exception of those who insisted on being on the lower rung of learning but geez, we were still trying to be cool and whatnot...nobody wanted to be like their parents certainly :D of course I graduated HS in '97 and different demos/regions have different kinds of kids. wish I had been a little more thoughtful of my career paths...
 
Back
Top