Microsoft Sued Over Bing Name

Status
Not open for further replies.

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Microsoft is being sued by a St. Louis, MO-based company called “Bing! Information Design LLC” over… well, I think you can figure it out. Microsoft doesn’t seem to be worried about it, judging by these comments though.

"We believe this suit to be without merit and we do not believe there is any confusion in the marketplace with regard to the complainant's offerings and Microsoft's Bing," a Microsoft spokesperson told Ars. "We have not been served with a complaint, but are aware of the suit based on media reports. We respect trademarks and other people’s intellectual property, and look forward to the next steps in the judicial process."
 
Next news about this: "Microsoft buys Bing! Information Design LLC for XXX dollars."
 
MS shoulda stuck with Kumo...

and then Kuhmo tires would have sued.

We live in a world where every word has a copyright attached to it. The best plan is to simply chose a random word, not bother looking it up and simply pray nobody ends up sueing you within the next 10 years.
 
Dear Bing! Information Design LLC,

If the BING aspect of your name is so important, and so is your presence on the internet, then why didn't you lock down www.bing.com years ago?

Regards,

Arentol
 
Exactly, i hope ms loses.

Didnt stop MS from shutting down Mike Rowe Soft.

I think that Microsoft had a VERY sound case with MikeRoweSoft. I mean, come on!
I think that Microsoft SHOULD have handled it a little better, but then Mike Rowe kind of fired back by asking for $10,000. At any rate Mike Rowe looks to have made money on the deal. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MikeRoweSoft.com

The other Bing in this case is something that most people have never heard of. Big difference.
 
It's not as good as Google...

Not necessarily. Bing will pick up stuff Goggle won't all the time for me. But its vice versa as well. Bing works fine for me as my default search engine but I still use Google as well.
 
Didnt stop MS from shutting down Mike Rowe Soft.

Exactly, i hope ms loses.

That is different. In that case I say Microsoft was valid in their claim. Mike Rowe was making web sites and named his company Mike Rowe Soft. Which while it has a different spelling is the same as Microsoft when prononounced.

He was making webbased software which is close to Microsoft's line of business. So in that case I could see it being a problem. A company coping the name of another making a similar product is infrigement.

Also they actually just told him to change the name at first, he then demanded something like $10,000 or $100,000 from them to change it. So at that point they took him to court. They only wanted him to change his company name.

That would be like somebody opening a computer shop can calling it Del Computers or making a store called Wall Mart.

In that case you are trying to take advantage of the name.

Now in this case, Microsoft made a product and its name is a word in the name of a company. There is nothing similar there. Nobody would confuse a search engine and a design company like they would a web design company and a computer that makes all types of software including some that is webbased.
 
I hate to say it, but I kind of hope Microsoft loses this one. Not because I have some kind of Microsoft hatred (which I don't), but I hate that money buys everything these days. Even if Bing! Design has a good case against them, Microsoft will most likely still win because of their status in the world economy.

That, or Microsoft will purchase the name outright.

Either way, it is money that is going to win this case, not necessarily a strong defense.
 
I hate to say it, but I kind of hope Microsoft loses this one. Not because I have some kind of Microsoft hatred (which I don't), but I hate that money buys everything these days. Even if Bing! Design has a good case against them, Microsoft will most likely still win because of their status in the world economy.

That, or Microsoft will purchase the name outright.

Either way, it is money that is going to win this case, not necessarily a strong defense.

My guess is that this will get settled out of court and the other Bing will have made some money.
 
He was making webbased software which is close to Microsoft's line of business. So in that case I could see it being a problem. A company coping the name of another making a similar product is infrigement.

Also they actually just told him to change the name at first, he then demanded something like $10,000 or $100,000 from them to change it. So at that point they took him to court. They only wanted him to change his company name.

That would be like somebody opening a computer shop can calling it Del Computers or making a store called Wall Mart.

In that case you are trying to take advantage of the name.

Actually the MS didn't have a solid defense against Mike Rowe. They only went through it to defend the Microsoft trademark. Since Mike Rowe was the actual name of the person using the name, it would be very hard to fight against that. It's very hard to successfully challenge people using their names. MS was just going through the motions in that case. It didn't help that the guy was an ass and wanted money, but not everyone is nice.
 
Bing needs a new name anyway, I just can't get myself to like the phrase "binging." :)
 
If that little LLC wants to take on Microsoft they better lawyer up.

As for bing, don't like the name, the layout, or the search results.
 
Actually the MS didn't have a solid defense against Mike Rowe. They only went through it to defend the Microsoft trademark. Since Mike Rowe was the actual name of the person using the name, it would be very hard to fight against that. It's very hard to successfully challenge people using their names. MS was just going through the motions in that case. It didn't help that the guy was an ass and wanted money, but not everyone is nice.

That may be so, but the moment Mike Rowe opened his mouth and demanded $10,000 for the domain, he committed a felony of cybersquating. If he hadn't done that, Microsoft would only be after him for infringement and possibly lose the lawsuit.

Mike Rowe admitted in court that he added "soft" at the end because he thought it was funny that it sounded like Microsoft. So his intent to sound like "Microsoft" was there. His name is Mike Rowe, not Mike Rowe Soft.
 
I hate to say it, but I kind of hope Microsoft loses this one. Not because I have some kind of Microsoft hatred (which I don't), but I hate that money buys everything these days. Even if Bing! Design has a good case against them, Microsoft will most likely still win because of their status in the world economy.

That, or Microsoft will purchase the name outright.

Either way, it is money that is going to win this case, not necessarily a strong defense.

Ok you have this completely backwards. The adage "money buys everything these days" is usually used to indicate that someone is getting pushed around by someone larger, more established. This doesn't apply here. Microsoft isn't pushing anyone around, nor are they trying to. Bing!Design is. They're trying to profit off of the similarity between its name and Microsoft's Bing. You're right that it is all about money, but wrong in defending the little guy without examining what the little guy is doing. Bing! Design is taking Microsoft to court, on a case so frivalous they did not even try to settle it out of court. Microsoft is finding this out through the media. How crazy is that? If this case had any merit, Bing! Design would have tried to arbitrate an agreement. They're just scumbags in this one.
 
Im a pretty big audio geek and Monster Cable is a company that makes RCA cables and various other interconnects. These scumbags will sue ANYBODY with the "monster" in their name. They sued Disney over Monster Inc., they sued Monster Transmission, they sued Blue Jeans Cable. Too bad you cant be shot for frivolous lawsuits.
 
Ok you have this completely backwards. The adage "money buys everything these days" is usually used to indicate that someone is getting pushed around by someone larger, more established. This doesn't apply here. Microsoft isn't pushing anyone around, nor are they trying to. Bing!Design is. They're trying to profit off of the similarity between its name and Microsoft's Bing. You're right that it is all about money, but wrong in defending the little guy without examining what the little guy is doing. Bing! Design is taking Microsoft to court, on a case so frivalous they did not even try to settle it out of court. Microsoft is finding this out through the media. How crazy is that? If this case had any merit, Bing! Design would have tried to arbitrate an agreement. They're just scumbags in this one.

You have a point. But my argument still applies to other cases like this where why argument would be more relevant.

Basically, I'm sick of the fact that anyone can sue anyone for anything. There should be a law that you aren't allowed to waste the court's time with bullshit cases.
 
and then Kuhmo tires would have sued.

We live in a world where every word has a copyright attached to it. The best plan is to simply chose a random word, not bother looking it up and simply pray nobody ends up sueing you within the next 10 years.

um, its a lot dirtier then that. they actually called KUMHO tires. yes, cum ho. i know because i have 4 of them on my truck... and yes, they do make me the kum ho king. in all seriousness though, they are pretty awesome tires so long as you can find a set of round ones that balance out.
 
That may be so, but the moment Mike Rowe opened his mouth and demanded $10,000 for the domain, he committed a felony of cybersquating. If he hadn't done that, Microsoft would only be after him for infringement and possibly lose the lawsuit.

Mike Rowe admitted in court that he added "soft" at the end because he thought it was funny that it sounded like Microsoft. So his intent to sound like "Microsoft" was there. His name is Mike Rowe, not Mike Rowe Soft.


Actually MS demanded he cease and desist and he told them he would if they paid his expenses to transfer to a new domain. They offered him $10 for the cost of registering his original domain and he countered with the $10K demand out of pique at their lowball (and scumbag) offer.

As far as I'm aware, making a counter offer is NOT a felony. If he'd been smart he'd have changed it to MikeRoweSoftware and told MS to pound sand.
 
Actually MS demanded he cease and desist and he told them he would if they paid his expenses to transfer to a new domain. They offered him $10 for the cost of registering his original domain and he countered with the $10K demand out of pique at their lowball (and scumbag) offer.

As far as I'm aware, making a counter offer is NOT a felony. If he'd been smart he'd have changed it to MikeRoweSoftware and told MS to pound sand.

Lowball? Domain names cost $25 every 2 years. He demanded to be reimbursed. Microsoft said ok, here's your $10. It was a court battle, not a brother and sister family spat. Mike should have remained professional and either take the reimbursement or refuse it, or simply changed the name. Instead he had to be all gung ho and demand $10,000. It wasn't a counter offer. It was pure childishness, just like the actions of Pirate Bay.
 
Lowball? Domain names cost $25 every 2 years. He demanded to be reimbursed. Microsoft said ok, here's your $10. It was a court battle, not a brother and sister family spat. Mike should have remained professional and either take the reimbursement or refuse it, or simply changed the name. Instead he had to be all gung ho and demand $10,000. It wasn't a counter offer. It was pure childishness, just like the actions of Pirate Bay.

Really? So the guys wanting to sell me madmat.com for $1800 are just full of shit? The fact of the matter is that if he owns the domain he has the right to ask what he wants for it as long as he's actively using the domain and he was. I'm sure that had M$ made a fair offer to reimburse him for his time spent in changing all of his media over to a different URL he would've been fine but they didn't, did they? No, the made an insultingly insipid offer and he took offense and told them to fuck off by making a similarly insultingly high offer.

What if someone wanted to buy [H]ardOCP.com and told Kyle that they'd give him $10 for it and he told them they could have it for umpteen thousand, would that make him a felon? No, it's HIS domain and his bread and butter so he's within his right to ask for it what he wants and what it's worth to him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top