Microsoft Says NO Blu-ray 360…Again

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Microsoft has once again denied the rumors that there will be a Blu-ray version of the Xbox 360. I think this about cements the fact that there will be no Blu-ray on the 360, well, that and the fact Blu-ray sales figures have tanked since the format war ended.

"As we have stated, we have no plans to introduce a Blu-ray drive for Xbox 360," said a Microsoft official in an email to GamePro on Monday. "Games are what drive consumers to purchase game consoles, and we remain focused on providing the largest library of blockbuster games available."
 
To be honest, with the PS3 eating into the stand alone Blu-ray sales, having the Xbox 360 play them would probably hurt stand alone player sales that much more.
 
Blu-ray is stillborn. Let's just move on to faster net connections and just pass by this rest stop on the funeral march of physical media.:D
 
I like physical media. I own it, I can do what I want with it, legal or not, and I can take it with me.

I may be wrong, but if I buy a dvd and I want to keep the dvd at my house, and have an image on my laptop and a copy on my Creative Vision W, then I will do that. I don't share with anyone else, but I don't think I should be stopped from doing what I wish with it.
 
Blu-ray is stillborn. Let's just move on to faster net connections and just pass by this rest stop on the funeral march of physical media.:D

And how many billions would it cost to rip out all the old cable/phone lines and replace them with something suitable for a network where every user is streaming HD stuff?

I would love to see it done, don't get me wrong but changes to infrastructure are not as easy or quick as you would like them to be.

Granted the whole bs war in iraq could of covered this cost 10x over.
 
I like physical media. I own it, I can do what I want with it, legal or not, and I can take it with me.

Not only that but it looks way better than downloaded HD.

Games on the other hand, hell, I want to purchase all my games for download now. :)
 
"Games are what drive consumers to purchase game consoles..."
I personally don't know a single person who purchased a PS3 with the primary intention of playing games on it.

PS3 and Macs have quite a bit in common if you really think about it.
 
I'm sure PS3 sales are eating into standalone player sales. I would have bought a standalone player now if I didn't buy a PS3. But let's face it, when you can spend $400 on a blu ray player or $400 on a blu ray player plus game machine, which are you going to pick? It's the manufacturers of the standalones that need to bring their prices down. Sony is breaking even on the 40 gig PS3 and has been since like November, and it's WAY more technologically advanced than a standard blu-ray player.

As for Microsoft... I think it would actually help them a lot to put blu-ray in their machines, but I'm sure it's not as simple as it sounds. There's a hell of a lot that goes into a blu-ray player, above and beyond just the physical drive. Plus, changing hardware production is a huge deal.

But that's fine by me, it's just another selling point for the PS3 and more people to put on my friends list :)

-Nate
 
Yeah, let Microsoft keep telling themselves and everyone that. I dont know about you but I tried to download a couple of movies from live and it sucked. Tooo many restrictions and no extras (deleted scenes, alternate endings or even subtitles). Digital Distribution via movies suck and it will take years for it to be a major player in the HD arena.

As for Hard's take on blu rays flop, I wouldnt say that when considered that Sony PS3's sales just had a major jump in sales (thnks Rockstar). I for one bought my PS3 for the Movies and games. I went to target and also noticed that their Blu library has expanded and also BB. Blu Ray in no way has tanked despite what some of these numbers say. Numbers might be low in certain months but Blu Ray as a whole has grown..
 
They must be taking the Sony approach with this one: keep saying no even when it's actually on the way. There was an article a few days ago about someone getting the orders to manufacture it, that basically confirms a Blu-ray player is on the way.

I can't wait to see what happens. The PS3 is going to lose another 10 miles after finally gaining a few hundred yards these past two months. There will literally be *zero* reason to get a PS3, until MGS4 arrives (if it gets here before the world ends :p).
 
I personally don't know a single person who purchased a PS3 with the primary intention of playing games on it.

PS3 and Macs have quite a bit in common if you really think about it.

Hi, my name's Nate. Now you know one. I have two close friends who each own one, also primarily for games. Was it a factor in my decision that it plays Blu-Ray? Of course. That was very important. But what do I do 90% of the time with it? Play games.

As for Macs and PS3s, they're not really comparable. The 360 is actually much more comparable to the Mac. Overpriced proprietary hardware and accessories, tons of DRM and restrictions, connections only to other formats also owned by the same company.

Compared to a PS3 which supports open formats, standardized interfaces, and compatibility with off the shelf components.

Anyway.... didn't mean to make this into a console war thread. On topic, I'm not surprised that MS isn't going to put blu-ray in their machines. It would probably be wicked expensive, and they're not exactly hurting for sales right now. Maybe in another year or two when blu-ray picks up, the hardware is that much cheaper, and Sony really becomes a threat.
 
When you can shop at Wal-Mart and toss a Blu Ray movie or 2 into your basket and not think twice about the cost is when Sony has captured the market. Until then, Blu Ray is a dead format. The only dvds that I look at the price before I buy are the boxset compilations. Otherwise it's like buying milk or eggs, as I love my entertainment. Blu Ray is overpriced for what you get compared to a standard dvd AND not necessary like the $70 in gas I tossed in my car to go shopping. Subaru SVX ftw!

Think about what makes dvd special. $35 players= disposable, $5 bargain bin sales= disposable children's entertainment, etc. Cheapest Blu Ray player? $399. And do you guys think my 71 y.o. mother is going to attempt to play a movie on a PS3?

Sorry Sony...
 
And how many billions would it cost to rip out all the old cable/phone lines and replace them with something suitable for a network where every user is streaming HD stuff?

I would love to see it done, don't get me wrong but changes to infrastructure are not as easy or quick as you would like them to be.

Granted the whole bs war in iraq could of covered this cost 10x over.

I knew it was Bush's fault Blu-Ray and streaming HD didn't take off somehow! :rolleyes:
 
As for Macs and PS3s, they're not really comparable. The 360 is actually much more comparable to the Mac. Overpriced proprietary hardware and accessories, tons of DRM and restrictions, connections only to other formats also owned by the same company.

Might want to put down that Kool Aid. Might be spiked or something.

Xbox contains PC hardware which is hardly proprietary. PS3 uses Cell processor which uhh... nobody else uses but the PS3? Sounds pretty proprietary to me!

Xbox Arcade is $280 and Premium is $350 while the PS3 is $399. I'm not sure where you're getting your claims from.
 
Unfortunately all the tech sites misreported "standalone Blu players suffer slack sales excluding PS3s and BR drives in PCs"

The NPD Group released some of its retail sales tracking data Wednesday that showed sales of Blu-ray standalone players (not a PlayStation 3, combo player, or PC with Blu-ray drive) had mostly decreased since the beginning of the year.

http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9932311-7.html

as "Blu-Ray sales tank." [H] is hardly alone in this reporting error.

Obviously everyone interested in Blu buys a PS3 or a PC with BR drive both for the ability to upgrade firmware to Profile 2.0 and for price (standalone = $400, PS3 = $400, tough decision...)
 
Ditto. Except for one-off songs from Amazon MP3, I buy my CDs physical. Same for movies. I now have over 700 DVD's in my collection (over 1000 actual discs).

Downloads are lower in quality. Then there's the DRM thing on movies. I don't need permission to play something I purchased, thank you.

And all it takes is the company to remove the authorization system, go out of business, suffer a catastrophic failure, etc... to render billions in purchased media useless.

I don't see anyone in congress protecting us from that!

Just ask the folks that bought Sony's proprietary DRM based music, only to be told it wouldn't work after a certain date.

I like physical media. I own it, I can do what I want with it, legal or not, and I can take it with me.

I may be wrong, but if I buy a dvd and I want to keep the dvd at my house, and have an image on my laptop and a copy on my Creative Vision W, then I will do that. I don't share with anyone else, but I don't think I should be stopped from doing what I wish with it.
 
When I buy a movie I want it to be the same experience that I am getting in the movie theatre, only without other people. To be honest, Blu ray destroys that experience. For example, I was watching Pirates of The Caribbean at my friend's house on a "46 Sony LCD + Blu ray. The picture was sharp to a fault. It looked like I was watching a BBC made for TV movie special. The contrast between set and CG was very visible and destroyed what little entertainment was left from that movie.

In addition the price of Blu ray is outrageous. Especially since I already own most of the movies that I intend to buy. Any other time its a $10 impulse buy from the bargain bin at Walmart.

I think its silly to think that physical format will be replaced by digital. People like to own things. People like to have something to hold in their hand. Wasn't there some prediction about retailers being doomed by Amazon.com about 10 years ago?

Blu-ray = Laserdisk
 
I like having the media and the ablity for file system storage, esepcially with such large capaticy media.

BluRay discs have got to come down in price, period. Until that happens its dead in the water. And it wouldn't hur for the players to come down as well. I think somebody had it in their head that people would be willing to pay a premimum for HD content. Don't think so.
 
Good, there's no money in it for Microsoft anyway. How much would they make on each unit sold at this point? Not enough to start selling them, I'd guess.
 
And how many billions would it cost to rip out all the old cable/phone lines and replace them with something suitable for a network where every user is streaming HD stuff?...

Granted the whole bs war in iraq could of covered this cost 10x over.
I was under the impression that the data lines were already being slowly upgraded. Let's be honest DVD is got a lot of life left in it. HD TVs are a long way to go before they have enough market saturation to drive a new medium.

I was think more like a decade down the road.

Wont happen till DRM is dead.
Except for small fraction of the market, DRM is not even on the radar. Convenience would be the driving force not whether they use KY or not.:p

...Blu-ray = Laserdisk
Bhamm! That pretty much could cap or end any discussion of Blu-ray. Stick a fork in it.
 
Blu-ray is stillborn. Let's just move on to faster net connections and just pass by this rest stop on the funeral march of physical media.:D

That wont happen for a long time. As some others have said, physical media is nice for a lot of reasons. You can let a friend borrow it, you can play it anywhere you want to, not just your main TV room. Even more so, years down the road when blu ray players get to be as cheap as dvd players are now. What happens if you upgrade your media player, where do all those movies go? To a movie collector, I cant imagine having 50+ HD movies in a media player, too much space.

Nothing like injecting politics where no injecting was required.

Not to mention, ignorance.
 
I was under the impression that the data lines were already being slowly upgraded. Let's be honest DVD is got a lot of life left in it. HD TVs are a long way to go before they have enough market saturation to drive a new medium.

I was think more like a decade down the road.

And why do you think that people who rent movies, all have highspeed internet? The fact is, most do not. Not even close, yet. Even that is a long way away.
 
I still think this may be part of the fact that Sony may not to license Blu Ray to the 360 so that standalone players wont be hurt.
 
Let's not forget that Microsoft repeatedly denied the 360 Elite rumors up until the day it came out

Microsoft likes to blow smoke up asses
 
When I buy a movie I want it to be the same experience that I am getting in the movie theatre, only without other people. To be honest, Blu ray destroys that experience. For example, I was watching Pirates of The Caribbean at my friend's house on a "46 Sony LCD + Blu ray. The picture was sharp to a fault. It looked like I was watching a BBC made for TV movie special. The contrast between set and CG was very visible and destroyed what little entertainment was left from that movie.

In addition the price of Blu ray is outrageous. Especially since I already own most of the movies that I intend to buy. Any other time its a $10 impulse buy from the bargain bin at Walmart.

I think its silly to think that physical format will be replaced by digital. People like to own things. People like to have something to hold in their hand. Wasn't there some prediction about retailers being doomed by Amazon.com about 10 years ago?

Blu-ray = Laserdisk

I agree, but lets face it. The movie theaters these days are beyond trash. Last night I watched Iron man at a rave theater. I was so excited. 1080p, giant screen. The freaking movie was out of focus! not only that but there where apparent roller marks on the screen. And to top it off the bulb in their $60,000 was past it's prime and the movie was horrible dim. For $16, it was a waste. I am spoiled by my 42" westing house I guess. It was probably the worst theater experience I have ever had. The PQ of just a DVD upsampled to 1440p at my house is 1000 times better. I will never go to another theater. I'm done with them.
 
I still think this may be part of the fact that Sony may not to license Blu Ray to the 360 so that standalone players wont be hurt.

Sony doesn't own Blu-Ray, people really need to learn this fact before speaking. Beyond that, wasn't it Sony that gave MS an open invitation to join the BDA? There won't be a problem on that front. You people really need to stop looking at these companies as if they're three year olds playing in sandbox and refusing to share. MS and Sony only compete on one front that is far from the biggest front for either company. MGS/Xbox and SCE have little control over what their owners do.
 
But what about this article saying that the XBOX 360 is indead geeting a blu-ray drive and even mention the supplier of the drive to Microsoft, Pegatron Technology, an OEM subsidiary of Asustek Computer.
 
Microsoft has once again denied the rumors that there will be a Blu-ray version of the Xbox 360. I think this about cements the fact that there will be no Blu-ray on the 360,
That or they don't want people to stop buying the ole RRoD version because a new one might be coming out.
well, that and the fact Blu-ray sales figures have tanked since the format war ended.
Actually no. That article is about player sales and does not count the PS3.

This article covers movie sales and they are up over 351%
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr...ent/video/e3i91323da4b3be14d2f74080ce44d7b5c4

Not sure why [H] has a mad hate for Sony?
 
Xbox contains PC hardware which is hardly proprietary. PS3 uses Cell processor which uhh... nobody else uses but the PS3? Sounds pretty proprietary to me!
Some IBM servers are supposedly using Cells, or at least some are supposedly going to.
 
When you can shop at Wal-Mart and toss a Blu Ray movie or 2 into your basket and not think twice about the cost is when Sony has captured the market. Until then, Blu Ray is a dead format. The only dvds that I look at the price before I buy are the boxset compilations. Otherwise it's like buying milk or eggs, as I love my entertainment. Blu Ray is overpriced for what you get compared to a standard dvd AND not necessary like the $70 in gas I tossed in my car to go shopping. Subaru SVX ftw!

Think about what makes dvd special. $35 players= disposable, $5 bargain bin sales= disposable children's entertainment, etc. Cheapest Blu Ray player? $399. And do you guys think my 71 y.o. mother is going to attempt to play a movie on a PS3?

Sorry Sony...

You think DVD was cheap when it first came out? What new technology is cheap when it first comes out? Blueray is still in its early stage of the product life cycle especially after the format wars.
 
You think DVD was cheap when it first came out? What new technology is cheap when it first comes out? Blueray is still in its early stage of the product life cycle especially after the format wars.

You're entirely correct... up to a point. The problem for BD movies is that they're not a huge upgrade from upconverted regular DVD's for the average guy. Most people aren't going to pay twice as much for the movies and players because the 'new technology' isn't worth it.

In this case, there's little reason not to wait for the cheaper players and discs.
 
Bingo. It's the Average Guy that will determine if Bluray sinks or swims, and so far the average guy would rather pay 15-20 bucks for a DVD that gets upconverted on a $50 dvd player than pay 30-40 bucks PER bluray movie and 300-400 for a player for a $500 HDtv to play it.
 
Bingo. It's the Average Guy that will determine if Bluray sinks or swims, and so far the average guy would rather pay 15-20 bucks for a DVD that gets upconverted on a $50 dvd player than pay 30-40 bucks PER bluray movie and 300-400 for a player for a $500 HDtv to play it.
 
Bingo. It's the Average Guy that will determine if Bluray sinks or swims, and so far the average guy would rather pay 15-20 bucks for a DVD that gets upconverted on a $50 dvd player than pay 30-40 bucks PER bluray movie and 300-400 for a player for a $500 HDtv to play it.

Good point.

Bingo. It's the Average Guy that will determine if Bluray sinks or swims, and so far the average guy would rather pay 15-20 bucks for a DVD that gets upconverted on a $50 dvd player than pay 30-40 bucks PER bluray movie and 300-400 for a player for a $500 HDtv to play it.

Good point.



:p
 
Back
Top