Which you probably won't, since it's a LTSB-only concession^Hfeature.I'll believe it when I see it
You know, a whole lot of the whinging about telemetry etc could be easily mitigated if Microsoft took three simple steps:What I am saying is that if Microsoft puts in a switch that says "Off" and yet there's still some data being sent to Microsoft because of the time service or Windows Update, some people will freak the fuck out and say that Microsoft is "lying and/or spying". Indeed that's already happen with the Enterprise version that had an "Off" setting but that really doesn't disable able all telemetry because some of it is built into tools that have it baked in and it can't be turned off with turning off those tools. And BTW, those tools did the same thing in Windows 7.
1) Publish (and update) exactly what information is collected by each service, when it is collected, and what is done with that information. What IPs/domains are used for what, etc. For example "Telemetry Service X communicates with IP addresses A, B, and C. Each month, it sends a list of the hardware in your computer, along with driver information (version, vendor). We use this information to make sure Windows is stable on the most common hardware." or something along those lines.
2) Provide controls to allow users to actually turn it off, again with proper instructions so that those who want to, can.
3) Provide useful information with Windows Updates. No more "this KB resolves issues with Windows 7" with zero specifics.
None of these things are affected by the complexity of the software. You have toggles that set values in the registry, the software checks those values and sends/doesn't send data. Simple.
People will be a lot less upset if given the opportunity to understand the why, and the issue goes away almost entirely if you allow people to opt out. Refusing to provide that information, and forcing it upon people, is going to have a negative effect, regardless of your intentions.
And why can't we simply have a setting to prevent Cortana from updating itself? If you block it at the firewall, and it doesn't mess up the rest of Windows, then why make people jump through those extra hoops? You're right--this may indeed be a non-issue*, but it's yet another example of MS turning a deaf ear to its users.Cortana got an update about a month ago that allows for category views. To disable that you HAVE to disable Cortana at the firewall. And that's well documented.
* --this assumes that there are no buggy updates, that it doesn't suck up some poor user's mobile data, etc. None of these assumptions are reliable at this point.