Microsoft is the Anti-Desktop

Guys help me here. I am just trying to make sense of something.

  • Yes I'll buy win8. And I have been using pc's since Ms-Dos!

    Votes: 38 43.7%
  • No I won't buy win8. And I have been using pc's since Ms-Dos days.

    Votes: 45 51.7%
  • Yes, I'll buy win8. And I have been using pc's since Windows Xp.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No I won't buy win8. And I have been using pc's since Windows Xp.

    Votes: 3 3.4%
  • I don't even know what a CRT is?!

    Votes: 1 1.1%

  • Total voters
    87

AndreRio

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
1,240
This is a simple poll about windows 8. I am trying to find out what kind of people that like windows 8.
 
too many annoyances in new microsoft operating systems
i'm definitely gonna use windows 7 for the next 5-10 years
 
I'm not going to buy it. (Didn't buy Win7 either) But if I can get it for free as well I'll probably use it.
 
Dude, noone comes to bite your fingers off if you write two capital letters in a row. It's PCs, MS-DOS, Windows XP...

And why do you make the second poll already?
 
I'll buy it, and I've been using PCs since MS-DOS 4.x. Win 8 fixes a number of issues I was having in Win 7, I'm currently testing Storage Spaces, if that works out, that'll be another reason, and I like the start page and other interface changes even on a desktop with kb/m. Not much of a fan of current metro apps, but that may change as 3rd parties start to make more sophisticated metro apps, also they load slow for what they do, but maybe that'll be the excuse I need to finally get a SSD.
 
The obvious #1 answer to this poll will be

"Yes I'll buy win8. I have never used a PC before."
 
This poll is both informative and scientifically accurate.
 
I answered with the first choice, but instead, I won't be buying it as my job will get VLs included in their subscription. Will I use it? Sure.
 
If you guys don't support Microsoft, Windows will die. Buy it even if you don't like it.
 
I have nothing against Win 8 except Metro, and even then, only on the desktop and non touch laptops.
It is extremely unlikely that I will buy it on a desktop or laptop. On a Surface like device, I may, provided I actually find myself wanting or needing a touch enabled ultra book. For tablets and phones, I will be sticking with Motorola powered devices running Android.
 
If you guys don't support Microsoft, Windows will die. Buy it even if you don't like it.

"You guys"? Who's "You guys"? You forget that the type of people who saturate this forum (or other forums alike) are a very small minority. Get real... Windows isn't going anywhere for a long time. Suggestion someone to waste money on a product they don't like is idiotic.

Consider the average Joes, the enterprise, government institutions, and other companies who rely on Windows. If Window 8 fails, Microsoft still has a shit load of Market share to sit on - it'll be a slap on the wrist. They're willing to sacrifice a bit of their desktop market dominance in exchange to tackle the mobile and SaaS market, where it's growing exponentially. It doesn't hurt to think outside of your little [H] box every now and then.

I don't like M$, but this... this is just ridiculous.
 
I've been using PCs since MS-DOS, currently running Win7 x64 primarily on my laptop, but have it dualbooting with Win8 as well. The more I use and get familiar with Win8, the less I find myself "disliking" it. Just like anything else, it's a big change, so you have to give it time and get used to it IMO. I don't hate metro at all - it caters pretty much to how I used Win7, just with a new face. I rarely used my start menu anyway in Win7.
I will be buying Win8 once it launches, and will at that point likely switch to it full time on my laptop.
 
Well, I've been using it since 3.1 not DOS. I won't be using it on desktop unless a rig dies, and I get an OEM that has it pre-installed.

I have however decided to put it on a netbook. $40 is cheap.
 
Windows 8 is malicious software that is designed to take over your computer and allow Microsoft to control it.

So, to answer the poll, no, I do not intend to purchase or install Windows 8.

1.Windows 8, in concert with restricted boot, allows Microsoft to dictate what operating systems you can and cannot run on your own computer. While the option to disable it remains FOR NOW, the average user will be dissuaded from trying out alternative operating systems because they think they are disabling the "security" on their computer.

In addition, the mechanism remains for the ability to disable this antifeature to be revoked in the future.

2.Windows 8's Metro environment allows Microsoft to dictate what you can and cannot install on your own computer. In addition, Microsoft has the ability to remotely uninstall programs via a killswitch, without your consent.

The appstore allows for unprecedented levels of censorship, both at the hands of Microsoft as well as from the governments of the world. For example, Apple has already conspired with the Chinese government to censor apps on the Dalai Lama in China and I have no doubt that Microsoft would do the same.

I've already switched over to GNU/Linux and it does everything I need except gaming (and it does it better at that). It does what I want it to do, not what Microsoft wants it to do. The only thing I have Windows on is my Wintendo, for playing games, and that may not last much longer with the rapid improvements to WINE as well as Valve throwing their support behind GNU/Linux.
 
really...

Windows 8 will not stop your computer form using another OS, period, they cant.

format
install what ever OS you want, done.

and if they do stop it, class action lawsuit coming in no time!

Metro 8 does not stop you from installing anything..

Where are you getting your info from!

killswitch?

really...

hows that tinfoil hat fit..
 
1.Windows 8, in concert with restricted boot, allows Microsoft to dictate what operating systems you can and cannot run on your own computer. While the option to disable it remains FOR NOW, the average user will be dissuaded from trying out alternative operating systems because they think they are disabling the "security" on their computer.

This is just nonsense. Microsoft has imposed no control over UEFI on x86 machines other than Windows 8 machines have to have it. Windows RT does require secure boot, but that's a whole different story, And the average user can't figure out Metro but somehow gets the notion of installing a non-Windows OS their computer but is then dissuaded because they think that's less secure? WTF?

2.Windows 8's Metro environment allows Microsoft to dictate what you can and cannot install on your own computer. In addition, Microsoft has the ability to remotely uninstall programs via a killswitch, without your consent.

The appstore allows for unprecedented levels of censorship, both at the hands of Microsoft as well as from the governments of the world. For example, Apple has already conspired with the Chinese government to censor apps on the Dalai Lama in China and I have no doubt that Microsoft would do the same.

With a zillion iPads sold everyday not a fuck seems to have been given about any of this except for open source folks who don't seem to mention these things about iOS.

I've already switched over to GNU/Linux and it does everything I need except gaming (and it does it better at that). It does what I want it to do, not what Microsoft wants it to do. The only thing I have Windows on is my Wintendo, for playing games, and that may not last much longer with the rapid improvements to WINE as well as Valve throwing their support behind GNU/Linux.

Interesting, all of my Windows machines seem to e cable of doing everything I need and want, including gaming.
 
hows that tinfoil hat fit..

Yes, he does love Reynolds Wrap but he is correct in theory though technically Microsoft can't impose secure boot on OEMs, just UEFI, which is what Apple has had on Macs for years and people seem to have no problem with running other OSes on Macs for some time.
 
really...

Windows 8 will not stop your computer form using another OS, period, they cant.

format
install what ever OS you want, done.

and if they do stop it, class action lawsuit coming in no time!

Metro 8 does not stop you from installing anything..

Where are you getting your info from!

killswitch?

really...

hows that tinfoil hat fit..

+1

I'm already using Windows 7 on my laptop and Vista on my other computer. Both aren't really too bad. Vista is really pretty solid even though it got so much bad press. Windows 8 will take getting used to but in the end, it probably won't be that bad either. Some people love to hate on Microsoft. They've been around a long time and have made some mistakes. I'm not a fanatic, I look at both sides and make my own decision. People just hate change. Windows 8 boots a lot faster then 7. After people figure out that they can get to their pron that much more quickly, they will embrace Windows 8.
 
This is just nonsense. Microsoft has imposed no control over UEFI on x86 machines other than Windows 8 machines have to have it. Windows RT does require secure boot, but that's a whole different story, And the average user can't figure out Metro but somehow gets the notion of installing a non-Windows OS their computer but is then dissuaded because they think that's less secure? WTF?

You are mistaken. Microsoft requires all Windows 8 computers to ship with restricted boot enabled. Thus, they are requiring that antifeature to be in all shipping Windows 8 computers.

The average user will do far better with a GNU/Linux operating system like Ubuntu than with Metro. I have actual experience with this as I converted a computer lab from Windows to GNU/Linux with KDE back in high school (and this was before Ubuntu was around). The users had no problem adapting; some of them didn't even realize it wasn't Windows anymore.

The people who have the most difficulty with GNU/Linux are the Windows power users. They are the ones who are afraid of change.

With a zillion iPads sold everyday not a fuck seems to have been given about any of this except for open source folks who don't seem to mention these things about iOS.

Really? I think plenty has been said about the iBad. I despise Apple because they are a company of shysters (lawyers) who do nothing but sue and use government-sanctioned violence against other people who dare to compete with them.

Interesting, all of my Windows machines seem to e cable of doing everything I need and want, including gaming.

Interesting, my Wintendo doesn't do what I want. For example, I can't install some drivers because they are free software and the author doesn't have the money to get them signed.

Windows days as a gaming platform are numbered. EA has started venturing into the GNU/Linux waters. Valve has already thrown their support behind GNU/Linux (Gabe Newell is horrified at the direction Microsoft is going with Windows 8). More and more indie games are coming out that support GNU/Linux. In addition, the OUYA console has already raised 5 million dollars on Kickstarter (setting a receord) which shows the demand for an open gaming platform where the user is in control of their hardware.
 
You are mistaken. Microsoft requires all Windows 8 computers to ship with restricted boot enabled. Thus, they are requiring that antifeature to be in all shipping Windows 8 computers.

Nonsense and NOT TRUE: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/09/22/protecting-the-pre-os-environment-with-uefi.aspx

A demonstration of this control is found in the Samsung tablet with Windows 8 Developer Preview that was offered to //BUILD/ participants. In the screenshot below you will notice that we designed the firmware to allow the customer to disable secure boot. However, doing so comes at your own risk. OEMs are free to choose how to enable this support and can further customize the parameters as described above in an effort to deliver unique value propositions to their customers. Windows merely did work to provide great OS support for a scenario we believe many will find valuable across consumers and enterprise customers.

Many will call me a Microsoft shill and whatnot, but the flat out BAD information about Windows 8 is beyond belief. I'm convinced that the most vocal opponents of Windows 8 mostly just make shit up and don't use the OS and haven't research shit because of the continuously bad information they espouse.

It's shocking how so many people who claim to be knowledgeable about technology make so many egregious errors and have not even the simplest understanding of Windows 8.
 
Nonsense and NOT TRUE: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/09/22/protecting-the-pre-os-environment-with-uefi.aspx



Many will call me a Microsoft shill and whatnot, but the flat out BAD information about Windows 8 is beyond belief. I'm convinced that the most vocal opponents of Windows 8 mostly just make shit up and don't use the OS and haven't research shit because of the continuously bad information they espouse.

It's shocking how so many people who claim to be knowledgeable about technology make so many egregious errors and have not even the simplest understanding of Windows 8.

Wrong.

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/hh852377.aspx

Q: How do I run the “Secure Boot Logo Test”?

Secure Boot is a required feature for Windows 8. To run this test, you must first enable Secure Boot in its default (shipping) configuration in the BIOS. Next, run the test. When the Prepare for Secure Boot Out-of-Box Tests dialog appears on the target system, select Yes to indicate that you have properly configured your BIOS. The test will not pass if you click No on this popup or fail to click it before a timeout expires.
 
If Windows 8 is bad for desktop, then so is Windows 7. Its pretty much identical except for better "guts" and the start menu.
 

You like totally didn't even bother to read that blog did you? In fact you just totally ignored the post I made that totally contradicts your misinformation:

A demonstration of this control is found in the Samsung tablet with Windows 8 Developer Preview that was offered to //BUILD/ participants. In the screenshot below you will notice that we designed the firmware to allow the customer to disable secure boot. However, doing so comes at your own risk. OEMs are free to choose how to enable this support and can further customize the parameters as described above in an effort to deliver unique value propositions to their customers. Windows merely did work to provide great OS support for a scenario we believe many will find valuable across consumers and enterprise customers.

So yeah, Microsoft is scaring people. And the reason is that if can't figure and Metro on a desktop and you fuck up your machine putting an OS on it that less market share than Vista then go to hell. Some of you will bitch about anything and we really don't give a fuck,
 
You are mistaken. Microsoft requires all Windows 8 computers to ship with restricted boot enabled. Thus, they are requiring that antifeature to be in all shipping Windows 8 computers.

It's not called "restricted boot". If you're able to cite any reputable sources to backup your claims, please do so.

This explains what Secure Boot does.

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/09/22/protecting-the-pre-os-environment-with-uefi.aspx

As far as gaming goes on Linux...... Microsoft spends a fair amount of time and resources (money) helping out game developers and graphics card manufacturers. Until the Linux community can do the same in some kind of substantial way, it won't become a common gaming platform. Microsoft already has a huge market share for PC gaming. Unless Microsoft really messes up, it won't happen.
 
You like totally didn't even bother to read that blog did you? In fact you just totally ignored the post I made that totally contradicts your misinformation:



So yeah, Microsoft is scaring people. And the reason is that if can't figure and Metro on a desktop and you fuck up your machine putting an OS on it that less market share than Vista then go to hell. Some of you will bitch about anything and we really don't give a fuck,

+1

I have a feeling even if he did read the article, he would pick and choose sentences out of it to support his claim without taking the whole thing in context. It not worth anyone's time to try to convince him otherwise. I find this kind of attitude and fanaticism humorous and kinda sad in a way. I never bother to get angry about it though. It's quite common.

And FWIW, if I can get the discounted rate for updating to Windows 8, I most likely will. I think Media Center is a free download for limited time with the upgrade.
 
Well, I've been using it since 3.1 not DOS. I won't be using it on desktop unless a rig dies, and I get an OEM that has it pre-installed.

I have however decided to put it on a netbook. $40 is cheap.

Does you netbook have at least a 1366 x 768 screen? The only reason I ask is because, if you were not previously aware, the 1024x 600 screen on many of the netbooks are to small to support Windows 8 Metro apps. (Just saying just in case.)
 
I think secure boot is a way Microsoft is combating SLP hacking. If an OEM enables it and does not give you the option to disable it in the BIOS, then that's one more step to load a cracked OS.
 

Berger's justification for that assessment is that “Extremely important menus in Windows 8 are hidden off screen, easily brought in when using a touch and swiping with your thumbs, are absent when using a mouse … Prior to this incident, I can’t tell you the last time I had to ask someone how to do something in a client OS.”

See the part in red. This is fundamental issue that Windows 8 faces, resistance to change and the fear that one's skills are now out of date. If this guy is so smart why couldn't he have just read a little info like I did and just start using Windows 8 like I did? And when were these important menus ALWAYS on the screen in any version of Windows? At the very least you had to click the Start Button or hit the Windows key. Some of these comments about Windows 8 are so egregiously wrong it's hard to give them a lot of credence.
 
The register is notoriously anti-microsoft.

+1, they are the embodiment of anti-Microsoft. Windows 8 could have been the greatest desktop and keyboard and mouse in the history of the universe and they still wouldn't like it.
 
The register is notoriously anti-microsoft.

And we are all having such a huge MS Windows 8 love fest here at [H]?:rolleyes:

Been a Reg reader for years, they give credit where its due and slag folks off when it's not.

Never seen too much favouritism either way there.

Besides it the GARTNER part that's the meat and spuds in that article.
 
Hardforums is one of the more honest sources of information on the whole as far as attempting to avoid stupid biases like the fanatics from the open source, apple, and microsoft communities. While there are people here who are critical of some of the changes in Win8, the crazies like damicatz generally get shot down quickly. I have never gone to The Register without immidiately seeing highly biased, and often fallacious articles.
 
You like totally didn't even bother to read that blog did you? In fact you just totally ignored the post I made that totally contradicts your misinformation:



So yeah, Microsoft is scaring people. And the reason is that if can't figure and Metro on a desktop and you fuck up your machine putting an OS on it that less market share than Vista then go to hell. Some of you will bitch about anything and we really don't give a fuck,

You are misrepresenting my position and attempting to set up a straw man argument.

I am fully aware that for right now, restricted boot can be disabled. However, the mechanism exists, IN THE FUTURE, for this to no longer be the case. How long until some OEM decides to start charging for the ability to disable this anti-feature? Can you guarantee that in 5 or 10 years, restricted boot will not be locked down on new PCs? The infrastructure is being set up for this kind of thing to exist.

Other questions :
1.Will I have the ability to change what keys are trusted? I'd prefer my computer not assume that Microsoft software is trustworthy.

2.Will I have the ability to use self-signed keys?

3.Will I have the ability to inspect the source code of the firmware to verify that there aren't backdoors? (I won't trust "Secure Boot" to keep my computer secure otherwise).

4.What is an "unauthorized attempt" at updating firmware? Who gets decide what that is?

It's not called "restricted boot". If you're able to cite any reputable sources to backup your claims, please do so.

This explains what Secure Boot does.

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/09/22/protecting-the-pre-os-environment-with-uefi.aspx

As far as gaming goes on Linux...... Microsoft spends a fair amount of time and resources (money) helping out game developers and graphics card manufacturers. Until the Linux community can do the same in some kind of substantial way, it won't become a common gaming platform. Microsoft already has a huge market share for PC gaming. Unless Microsoft really messes up, it won't happen.

Restricted boot is a more accurate term. The industry can call it what they want (kind of like calling a corporation a person) but that doesn't change what it is designed to do. Just what is an unauthorized firmware update? If I want to modify the firmware (say to enable more advanced configuration options), it is my computer and I have the right to do that.

Valve has a significant amount of resources as does Canonical (Ubuntu). Valve has both the resources and the influence to push game developers to develop for the GNU/Linux operating system.
 
You are misrepresenting my position and attempting to set up a straw man argument.

I am fully aware that for right now, restricted boot can be disabled. However, the mechanism exists, IN THE FUTURE, for this to no longer be the case. How long until some OEM decides to start charging for the ability to disable this anti-feature? Can you guarantee that in 5 or 10 years, restricted boot will not be locked down on new PCs? The infrastructure is being set up for this kind of thing to exist.

Other questions :
1.Will I have the ability to change what keys are trusted? I'd prefer my computer not assume that Microsoft software is trustworthy.

2.Will I have the ability to use self-signed keys?

3.Will I have the ability to inspect the source code of the firmware to verify that there aren't backdoors? (I won't trust "Secure Boot" to keep my computer secure otherwise).

4.What is an "unauthorized attempt" at updating firmware? Who gets decide what that is?



Restricted boot is a more accurate term. The industry can call it what they want (kind of like calling a corporation a person) but that doesn't change what it is designed to do. Just what is an unauthorized firmware update? If I want to modify the firmware (say to enable more advanced configuration options), it is my computer and I have the right to do that.

Valve has a significant amount of resources as does Canonical (Ubuntu). Valve has both the resources and the influence to push game developers to develop for the GNU/Linux operating system.

Calling it "GNU/Linux" instead of Linux only undermines your position and makes you sound like a fanatic. It is called Secure Boot. This is because it is the name given to it by the creators (Just like Ubuntu is called Ubuntu by Canonical) and because functionally it's goal is to secure the boot process from malicious software. Saying it's more accurately called Restricted boot is the same as saying that Ubuntu is more accurately called "Ubuntu, the Canonical Linux Fork with GNU tools".
 
Hardforums is one of the more honest sources of information on the whole as far as attempting to avoid stupid biases like the fanatics from the open source, apple, and microsoft communities. While there are people here who are critical of some of the changes in Win8, the crazies like damicatz generally get shot down quickly. I have never gone to The Register without immidiately seeing highly biased, and often fallacious articles.

I see light-hearted articles with a reasonably even bias and you see conspiracy, fine by me.

Life is tough for some I guess.
 
life is tough for those who only drink 1 flavor of koolaid.... :rolleyes:

your "what is what if what if" is irrelevant, in 5-10 years what if "gnu\linux" is taken over by some big corporation and no more GNU!..Redhat owns all! now your screwed mUAHHAHA!

see, i can do that too...
 
Just what is an unauthorized firmware update?

One that uploads all of your files to a Chinese hacker. Firmware is a target for malware and the bottom line is that customers, particularly large businesses want this technology. Bottom line, it's up to OEMs how they want to implement this, not Microsoft and if OEMs want to offer devices not running Windows without this they are free to do so.
 
I see light-hearted articles with a reasonably even bias and you see conspiracy, fine by me.

Life is tough for some I guess.

Pointing out biases is not pointing out conspiracy. Life is easy, I happily use my software of choice and laugh when others waste their time on philosophy rather than practicality.
 
Back
Top