Microsoft Is Doing Its Own Tablet?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Microsoft is making its own tablet? Why not? Windows 8 is up to the task and Microsoft could easily put out a quality tablet for far less money than Apple. If the Kindle Fire is any indicator, people will buy a quality tablet that is prced far less than an iDevice. I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

Sources say that Microsoft concluded that it needs its own tablet, with the company designing both the hardware and software in an effort to better compete against Apple’s strengths. Microsoft’s tablets may include machines running ARM-based processors as well as models running on traditional PC processors, sources said. Online site The Wrap reported this evening that Microsoft will manufacture its own devices, something that AllThingsD sources have also heard in recent weeks.
 
I wonder if they will make it plain black, bulky and cameraless. Then 1 year later come out with a thinner model with a camera so people will be forced to upgrade.
 
Well in that market you basically have Apple and the Japanese or Koreans for higher end tablets. Seems the Japanese and Koreans (except maybe Sony to a very very small degree) don't mind making electronics complicated.

The Japanese and Koreans make electronics for technophiles while Apple makes electronics for technophobes (but will lie if asked). And no one else challenges Apple in that target market.

If MS wants to truly give Apple a run in their home market, they will need to guide tablet development directly.
 
Microsoft is capable of doing good industrial design. Not often, but on rare occasion, they're able to produce something of merit in that respect.

Really, though, I think they should just team up with Nokia for the thing. The Lumias are gorgeous-looking phones and a similar design would make for a gorgeous (and probably pretty lightweight and rugged) tablet. I suspect, though, that without a pretty good display on it, it's destined to fall flat. The Metro aesthetic really does demand a good-quality, high-density display.
 
I wonder if they'll charge themselves the $100 licensing fee.
 
I'd rather pay a little more for a powerful tablet that can connect to a keyboard dock. That way it's also a laptop, and I wouldn't feel like it was a limited purpose device.
 
Where did you read there is a $100 licensing fee? Link please.
It's basically a blind guess.

A few tablet manufacturers were asked how much more expensive Widnows 8 tablets would be than Android tablets. The response was usually between $80 and $90.

Everyone assumed "ah-hah! They must be charging $80 to $90 for licensing!" without considering that the additional cost might be due to strict hardware requirements that call for higher-end hardware...
 
...If the Kindle Fire is any indicator, people will buy a quality tablet that is prced far less than an iDevice.

My bet is that Monday's big announcement is a Nook Tablet/Reader that runs Win8 RT.
 
Would be a good idea if Microsoft wants to compete with Apple. Everyone else seems to take a design made in Taiwan and then relabel the crap out of it. Though it may piss off other manufacturers if Microsoft gets a discount on Win 8 licensing.
 
My bet is that Monday's big announcement is a Nook Tablet/Reader that runs Win8 RT.

I thinking something like this too. I really doubt that Microsoft would be going head to head with its PC OEMs, this would have to be some type of subsidized or loss leader device that wouldn't be something OEMs would do. Assuming that this is a reader device tied into B&N and the Xbox services it could be a pretty strong competitor to the Kindle Fire and Google's tablet.
 
It's basically a blind guess.

A few tablet manufacturers were asked how much more expensive Widnows 8 tablets would be than Android tablets. The response was usually between $80 and $90.

Everyone assumed "ah-hah! They must be charging $80 to $90 for licensing!" without considering that the additional cost might be due to strict hardware requirements that call for higher-end hardware...

Actually it's technically $85 dollars and that's without the hardware. It's $85 to run on a cheaper ARM-based system.

If you throw in Win8 x86 then you're talking well over $100 for the difference between a Medfield chip/x86 chip and the Microsoft license.
 
Err, can't edit but here's the link:

http://www.extremetech.com/computin...lan-to-capture-the-high-end-market-from-apple

According to VR-Zone, who quizzed multiple vendors on the convention floor, $85 was “the most commonly quoted price.” Compare this to Android (free), iOS (effectively free), Windows Phone 7 ($30), or even Windows 7 (around $50).

At this point, we’re not entirely sure what Microsoft’s plan for Windows RT is. As we’ve covered before, it is virtually impossible for Microsoft and its OEMs to compete with Android or iOS devices on build cost and market price. We (and other publications) have reached out to Microsoft, plaintively pleading for a rebuttal — a damning condemnation of these rumored Windows RT license fees — but so far Redmond is resolutely refusing to comment.

The only real answer seems to be that Microsoft doesn’t want to flood the markets with cheap Windows RT tablets. At this rate, we would expect the cheapest Windows RT tablets to hit the market at around $600, with top-spec models (if they exist) in the $800-900 range. Compare this to $399 for the low-end iPad 2 (or an Asus Android tablet), or $499 for the basic iPad 3. We can only assume that Microsoft doesn’t want to go head-to-head with iOS and Android.

Win8 was dead before it hit the water as far OEMs are concerned. What MS is attempting to do is what Apple has done and Google is doing with the Nexus tablet: build it all yourself. But where Apple and Google differ is that their operating systems are free and they don't make money off the software whereas MS relies on licensing so if this doesn't go well... MS is fucked.
 
Win8 was dead before it hit the water as far OEMs are concerned.
That article still doesn't clarify weather or not they were talking about additional cost due to software or additional cost due to software + hardware.

It's just a rehash of the same vague information. They also note that Microsoft hasn't confirmed any licensing fees with them.
 
Licensing fee = just the software. That's it. It's always been this way. What you're referring to is the cost of the platform on x86 and that's another matter that is more costly. ARM operates in margins of 5-7% for their chips while Intel operates on 30%+ margins on already far more expensive chips. So you're adding an x86 tax to the $85 for the Microsoft Win8/WinRT license.
 
That article still doesn't clarify weather or not they were talking about additional cost due to software or additional cost due to software + hardware.

It's just a rehash of the same vague information. They also note that Microsoft hasn't confirmed any licensing fees with them.

I kind of doubt it, since Microsoft tends to be pretty lenient with licensing when they are playing catchup to a competitor. When they're in a tight spot like they are now with tablets, they tend to care more about carving out market share than immediate profits.
 
Licensing fee = just the software. That's it. It's always been this way. What you're referring to is the cost of the platform on x86 and that's another matter that is more costly. ARM operates in margins of 5-7% for their chips while Intel operates on 30%+ margins on already far more expensive chips. So you're adding an x86 tax to the $85 for the Microsoft Win8/WinRT license.
The originating VR-Zone article never actually says licensing, it just says "price" and "cost" for using Windows 8. That doesn't tell us if it's the cost of the software alone or the cost of the software and additional hardware required for the software.
 
Nonono, it says this exactly

During our meetings with multiple vendors on the Computex Taipei, we were talking about pricing options for taking the Windows RT route instead of (free) Android from Google. While it was rumored that Microsoft decided to change their ways and offer a price of about 35 dollars – the reality is that Windows RT will cost staggering USD$80-95 dollars, with $85 being the most commonly quoted price.

Microsoft provides no hardware and only software. The cost of the hardware doesn't change as that's windows RT, an ARM-based platform (like every other tablet). The cost of the platform DOES change when you're talking win8 x86 and it's not in the down direction but in the up with Intel's chips costing more than ARM-based alternatives along with the x86/Intel tax on top of that so that platform would cost well over $100 more than a competing ARM-based Android tablet.

Intel sells software. Their products will always be more expensive than Android/iOS because those two are free.

http://vr-zone.com/articles/microsoft-charges-tablet-oems-a-whopping-85-for-windows-rt/16250.html#
 
Nonono, it says this exactly
the reality is that Windows RT will cost staggering USD$80-95 dollars, with $85 being the most commonly quoted price.
Yup, exactly. That just says it costs the OEM an additional $85 to produce a tablet that runs Windows RT.

They DO NOT detail the breakdown on that $85. It could be $35 for a Windows RT license and another $50 to meet a hardware requirement like storage space, memory capacity, or GPU speed over a similar Android-based tablet.

Microsoft provides no hardware and only software. The cost of the hardware doesn't change as that's windows RT, an ARM-based platform (like every other tablet). The cost of the platform DOES change when you're talking win8 x86 and it's not in the down direction but in the up with Intel's chips costing more than ARM-based alternatives along with the x86/Intel tax on top of that so that platform would cost well over $100 more than a competing ARM-based Android tablet.
Uh, I'm not talking about x86 at all. I've only been talking about ARM-based tablets this entire time. Not sure why you're going off on an intel / x86 rant...

And just because it's an ARM tablet doesn't mean it has the same hardware as Android ARM tablets. What if Microsoft has strict hardware requirements for Windows RT, such as a high-end GPU? Then that drives up the baseline cost of Windows RT tablets.

Microsoft did the same thing with 1st generation WP7 hardware, they required a minimum CPU and GPU speed, which meant OEMs couldn't produce super-cheap phones with slower SoC's, and also caused even the cheapest WP7 phones to cost more.
 
If it's a case of windows being too fat to run efficiently as every other operating system then it's still a case of Microsoft adding a fee because of cheap and bloated software. Whether it's more RAM required or a beefier CPU/GPU, in the end it doesn't matter. Whether $35 or $85, you're getting an operating system that performs dreadfully and likely won't be introduced until late '12 or early '13.

There have already been models with equal specs as current Android-based tablets so the "better hardware required" doesn't fly.

http://www.extremetech.com/computing/130449-where-are-the-windows-rt-arm-tablets
 
One thing to keep in mind, that $85 dollars for RT includes full core versions of Microsoft Office. So if the price to OEMs is $85 that $85 for Windows RT, Word, Excel, PowerPoint and OneNote. That ain't bad really but being behind I have a feeling that that price might be a bit flexible.
 
If they can make a tablet that can run win32/win64 apps just like a standard desktop install of windows, they will really have something going for them. Sadly they'll probably make it metro only, and given they will control what apps will be allowed in Metro, it will just be another ipad like device.

Imagine a engineering business being able to run their proprietary inspection/planing/etc software on a tablet or a hospital running their proprietary EHR program on a tablet. A tablet that can run a standard PC OS and PC apps would blow away ever tablet out there.

Really if a company released a PC based tablet, I don't care what OS is on it by default, now that would be pure awesome. Imagine running Linux or even Windows XP/7 on a tablet. I could see many business uses for this.
 
Imagine running Linux or even Windows XP/7 on a tablet. I could see many business uses for this.

You have this already with Ubuntu. You can run Ubuntu on an Android tablet.

The issue with windows-based tablets and legacy software compatibility is the need for laptop/desktop level throughput and you're not going to get that on a tablet. Cloud-based, sure, but then you can get the same Cloud-based services regardless of the underlying microarchitecture.

People don't use tablets for productivity and that's where the windows appeal ends. Then there's the software pool comparison as well and for a tablet the android/iOS app stores are far better than Metro will ever be.
 
If they can make a tablet that can run win32/win64 apps just like a standard desktop install of windows, they will really have something going for them. Sadly they'll probably make it metro only, and given they will control what apps will be allowed in Metro, it will just be another ipad like device.

Imagine a engineering business being able to run their proprietary inspection/planing/etc software on a tablet or a hospital running their proprietary EHR program on a tablet. A tablet that can run a standard PC OS and PC apps would blow away ever tablet out there.

Really if a company released a PC based tablet, I don't care what OS is on it by default, now that would be pure awesome. Imagine running Linux or even Windows XP/7 on a tablet. I could see many business uses for this.

There are already a number of Windows 7 tablets out there, I have the Samsung Series 7 Slate and it's a good device, and it's MUCH better with Windows 8 on it.

There's going to be plenty of Windows 8 x86 tablets out there, either pure or hybrid with detachable keyboards. From Atoms to Ivy Bridge designs.
 
You have this already with Ubuntu. You can run Ubuntu on an Android tablet.

The issue with windows-based tablets and legacy software compatibility is the need for laptop/desktop level throughput and you're not going to get that on a tablet. Cloud-based, sure, but then you can get the same Cloud-based services regardless of the underlying microarchitecture.

People don't use tablets for productivity and that's where the windows appeal ends. Then there's the software pool comparison as well and for a tablet the android/iOS app stores are far better than Metro will ever be.

I have no idea what this means. Even with Windows 7 I could take my Samsung Series 7 Slate and put it in a dock with an external keyboard and monitor and have workstation. Now with Windows 8 I can still have that and with Metro a MUCH more touch friendly device. A Windows 8 tablet can do everything a laptop or desktop does (if the hardware is good enough of course) and everything an iPad or Android tablet does, given apps of course and those will come.

One can argue over Metro, but the bottom line is the complete functionality of both tablets and desktops is available on these kinds of devices in one package and one OS.
 
One can argue over Metro, but the bottom line is the complete functionality of both tablets and desktops is available on these kinds of devices in one package and one OS.

But then why in the world would you pay more for MS Windows?

I can understand the legacy/proprietary requirement. The reason I boot into win7 is for DirectX. But comparing Metro to iOS and Android outside of that? It's not even close. You'll get more and you'll get it for less money with the other two.

A tablet is defined as a media consumption device, not a media creation device. You're also comparing a $1000 Windows-based tablet to a $299 Android one and even still the environment is more robust on the tablet that costs 1/3 the price. If you need a keyboard you can buy one (Asus Transformer is a perfect example. Over 14 hours of battery life with tablet+dock).
 
If the Kindle Fire is any indicator, people will buy a quality tablet that is prced far less than an iDevice. I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

Fire sales have slowed to a crawl after people realized that you get what you pay for. Android tablets will outsell the ipad the same way the phones did, by flooding the market with extremely cheap devices. Good for short term, extremely bad for long term when people start to associate android with cheap, disposable shit.
 
Another Samsung Series 7 Slate owner here. It has an i5 core, 128GB SSD, 4GB RAM, Win7 Pro, BT, Swype, Etc.

Probably has better specs than most people's laptop.
 
A tablet is defined as a media consumption device, not a media creation device. You're also comparing a $1000 Windows-based tablet to a $299 Android one and even still the environment is more robust on the tablet that costs 1/3 the price.

The term tablet has been around a long time and so many people use it to mean so many things that all I use it to refer to is form factor.

A $300 Android device will have more tablet specific apps but to say that it's more robust is a stretch. A $1000 Windows 8 tablet will crush a $300 Android tablet, even as a tablet in performance and even some capability. You actually can run and control a fair number of desktops apps with touch. And web browsing on IE 10 with both Metro and full desktop browsers (which is touch enabled), yeah, that $300 Android tablet isn't going to be more robust there.

Ultimately that cheap Android tablets are just that. Sure they can do a lot of stuff but a lot of if isn't so great, if they were actually robust they'd be outselling iPads, like Android is in the phone space.
 
Another Samsung Series 7 Slate owner here. It has an i5 core, 128GB SSD, 4GB RAM, Win7 Pro, BT, Swype, Etc.

Probably has better specs than most people's laptop.

These are the kinds of devices that can move Windows 8 with ease, but the price is on the high side, which is why I think the hybrid/ultrabook tablet concept will be pushed. They really are no compromise devices.
 
If Microsoft is smart enough to scoop Apple on Tactile Layer, then maybe they have a shot at making a tablet that people would want to use.

But I don't think so. I think what's going on here is that MS has realized that nobody's going to make a Windows tablet that sells Win8 so they will just have to do it themselves... two years after it's been done right, and a year after everyone else flamed out trying to do it half-assed. I expect it to follow the same path as the Zune.
 
Back
Top