Microsoft Gets Extension in EU Antitrust Case

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The European Commission has granted Microsoft’s request to extend the deadline to respond to allegations of antitrust violations. Both Google and Mozilla have requested “third party status” which will allow them to see documents in this case that are not otherwise available to the public.

The European Commission in mid-January notified the software giant that it objected to Microsoft bundling its Internet Explorer browser in with its operating system. Microsoft was initially given two months to respond in writing to the allegations, but requested additional time.
 
Dear EU,

Apple bundles OSX with Safari too. Linux did the same thing with Netscape and Mozilla, and now Firefox.

Show me an OS that isn't bundled with a browser and I'll show you a pig that can fly.

Sincerely Yours,

Azhar
 
I have missed just about every tidbit of info regarding this case. Can someone please explain why Microsoft can't or shouldn't bundle IE with their OS?

What is the detriment and what are the alternatives?
 
Apparently the EU thinks that bundling IE with Windows is the cause of third party browser's lack of popularity and causes people to be content with what's on the OS rather than actually going out on the internet to find another browser.

I find this laughable considering the ineptness of the average computer user installing anything on their computer, much less knowing where to get web browsers and what's out there. Besides, you sort of need a web browser to research other ones, right?
 
I have missed just about every tidbit of info regarding this case. Can someone please explain why Microsoft can't or shouldn't bundle IE with their OS?

What is the detriment and what are the alternatives?

Its the same usual shit the EU pulls. They are filing the lawsuits because Microsoft is bundling IE with Windows and they says its an unfair advantage and a monopoly. In reality they only own 67% of the browser market so I am not sure what their definition of "Monopoly" is. The EU lawsuits are complete bullshit and Mozilla and Google should be ashamed to even want to be part of this lawsuit. The whole lawsuit was filed because Opera, the redheaded stepchild of browsers, asked for it.
 
Its the same usual shit the EU pulls. They are filing the lawsuits because Microsoft is bundling IE with Windows and they says its an unfair advantage and a monopoly. In reality they only own 67% of the browser market so I am not sure what their definition of "Monopoly" is. The EU lawsuits are complete bullshit and Mozilla and Google should be ashamed to even want to be part of this lawsuit. The whole lawsuit was filed because Opera, the redheaded stepchild of browsers, asked for it.


Mozilla and google (especially google) have a vested interest in this case though. Google is often under the same pressure as micrsoft for being as big as they are, so it's understandable that they'd want to watch how this plays out very closely as they might be next on the hot seat.
 
This whole case is rediculous. Its pretty unfair to force MS to include 3rd party browsers in its OS in the first place. Secondly, I really dont see Firefox being in bad shape at all, they clearly have a huge following without forcing this unfair tactic. Firefox is the prime example of why there doesnt need to be any intervention, the market is working on its own.

If the EU was smart about this ( a real stretch I know), they would instead be going to OEM pc dealers and asking them to include 3rd party apps since they already do that. This fight should be with the OEMs, not MS. MS does not stop anyone from bundling whatever software they choose with the OS. It is not MS' responsiblity to market or support a 3rd party app, which is what would happen if they were forced to include other browsers. If the problem was only about allowing IE to be completely uninstalled, well MS made sure that wouldnt be an issue with 7.
 
All of these lawsuits are a waste of money and end up hurting the consumer vs helping them.
Let's say I buy Windows with no browser, how do I go about getting a browser.
 
All of these lawsuits are a waste of money and end up hurting the consumer vs helping them.
Let's say I buy Windows with no browser, how do I go about getting a browser.

Not for the lawyers they are not. Lawyers only care about the billable hours coming their way. Nature abhors a vacuum, but if you hear that giant sucking sound, it leads right back to a lawyers pocket.
 
/me remembers the whole bundling of a browser was actually 1st raised in court in the US and that Microsoft lost that case

/me also remembers that a Microsoft employee who was pulled into the stand to defend MS's decision to bundle IE also used Linux in MS's defence but he also didn't understand how said browsers were bundled (or that any can easily be removed) BUT the prosecution did and actually used the linux example to hurt MS more



I love it how yanks have such short memories :D:D:D:D
 
This whole case is rediculous. Its pretty unfair to force MS to include 3rd party browsers in its OS in the first place. Secondly, I really dont see Firefox being in bad shape at all, they clearly have a huge following without forcing this unfair tactic. Firefox is the prime example of why there doesnt need to be any intervention, the market is working on its own.

If the EU was smart about this ( a real stretch I know), they would instead be going to OEM pc dealers and asking them to include 3rd party apps since they already do that. This fight should be with the OEMs, not MS. MS does not stop anyone from bundling whatever software they choose with the OS. It is not MS' responsiblity to market or support a 3rd party app, which is what would happen if they were forced to include other browsers. If the problem was only about allowing IE to be completely uninstalled, well MS made sure that wouldnt be an issue with 7.

If I recall the EU does want OEM's to have the ability to install what they want - part of the reason behind the WMP version.

And as the market showed OEM's prefered to used WMP-bundled version BUT they have a choise (saying that the the alternative? realplayer... :D)

IF the EU force MS to unbundle (and NOTE ms have already provided means for Win7 so that could be enough to satisfy the EU... note this would result in no fines... again funny how yanks just don't get EU law...) then OEM's will then be given the ability to pre-install any browser they like - whether they do or not is a different thing

MS will still be free to see a full version


Also
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/7932149.stm
Professor Barrett said part of the problem was that the US and EU operate in very different ways.
"US firms follow the Harvard school of competition: find a market, dominate that market and then use that domination to beat the competition into submission.
"US firms come here, speak the same language (especially in Britain), and think they are working in an identical environment.
"They're not, because in Europe, that type business model isn't remotely fair."
Pretty much sums it up

And before any of you EU-hating MS funboi's jump on that, note this bloke is a Profession and you are???
 
Well, I think the EU needs to stop bitching about it. Once they develop their own "Windows" they can ahead and bundle whatever the hell they want with it. This is an MS product - and people are arguing that they can't include their own piece of software in their own, err, software package? Yeah, doesn't make any sense whatsoever.

What if companies were bitching about the controller that comes in, say, an Xbox 360 package. Does it violate antitrust laws simply because there are 3rd party controllers out there that MS doesn't include in the package? No. Should MS just not include a controller in the package? :rolleyes:
 
Well, I think the EU needs to stop bitching about it. Once they develop their own "Windows" they can ahead and bundle whatever the hell they want with it. This is an MS product - and people are arguing that they can't include their own piece of software in their own, err, software package? Yeah, doesn't make any sense whatsoever.

What if companies were bitching about the controller that comes in, say, an Xbox 360 package. Does it violate antitrust laws simply because there are 3rd party controllers out there that MS doesn't include in the package? No. Should MS just not include a controller in the package? :rolleyes:

Take it up with the US Legal system then
They took MS to court over IE being bundled and found MS guilty and as such MS are still subject to the punishment the US legal system dished out

NOTE the EU hasn't found MS guilty yet, just that they believe there is enough evidence that there is case after it was raised by another company

IF MS think it is soo wrong they should just pull out... oh wait they couldn't
IF you think the EU is soo wrong I am sure that MS would love you to join their legal team... oh wait your wrong
 
In reality they only own 67% of the browser market so I am not sure what their definition of "Monopoly" is.

The issue isn't that they have a browser monopoly. The issue is that they are allegedly leveraging a monopoly in one market (OSes) to compete in another. This sort of behaviour is illegal in most western countries AFAIK.
 
The issue isn't that they have a browser monopoly. The issue is that they are allegedly leveraging a monopoly in one market (OSes) to compete in another. This sort of behaviour is illegal in most western countries AFAIK.

Yes it is. And the US legal system has found MS guilty.
 
/me remembers the whole bundling of a browser was actually 1st raised in court in the US and that Microsoft lost that case

/me also remembers that a Microsoft employee who was pulled into the stand to defend MS's decision to bundle IE also used Linux in MS's defence but he also didn't understand how said browsers were bundled (or that any can easily be removed) BUT the prosecution did and actually used the linux example to hurt MS more



I love it how yanks have such short memories :D:D:D:D

Who said we've forgotten? This is a case of two wrongs not making a right. The US courts were fucktards too, just as is the EU courts.

We "yanks" as you're fond of calling us (in just about every EU posts too) aren't the government. Try and remember THAT.
 
Who said we've forgotten? This is a case of two wrongs not making a right. The US courts were fucktards too, just as is the EU courts.

We "yanks" as you're fond of calling us (in just about every EU posts too) aren't the government. Try and remember THAT.

so I take it if you think the MS vs US case was wrong you can prove that? if that is the case why are you not on MS's payroll when they went to court. I am sure they would have appreciated your expertise in defending themselfs since you obviously know something that all MS lawyers didn't

but hey don't worry looks like you are just in time to help MS in this EU case so hurry along to help MS in court. I am sure with your expertise in corporate law will help MS win this case
 
Who said we've forgotten? This is a case of two wrongs not making a right. The US courts were fucktards too, just as is the EU courts.

We "yanks" as you're fond of calling us (in just about every EU posts too) aren't the government. Try and remember THAT.

Amen.

We "yanks" know that you're defending your precious EU's trashy decisions on the premise that even our own courts found MS "guilty", in some horrible attempt at defending the EU. Well, guess what? The whiny little bitches here are no better than the whiny little BITCHES on your end of the map, buddy. You'll come to realize that. ;)
 
This whole topic is rediculous!

Most of the HardOCP readers probably know that every OS out there bundles a browser with the OS.
Microsoft is not using a monopoly to compete in another market because it's the same market.

Further more the whole idea of competing in a browser market is ludicrous. Who buys a browser? It comes free! If you don't like the one in your OS, you go get another one. You don't buy netscape. You don't buy Firefox. You don't buy Safari. They are either free with the OS, or they are free downloads. That is not a "market"

Just because US courts come out with a verdict against somebody does not mean it is right. That's why there are appeals. That's why there are settlements. That's why innocent people go to jail. That's why guilty people get off on technicalities.

It is interesting that Apple and Mozilla are trying to gain access to documents that are not publicly available, as "third parties".

Perhaps all we'll ever know about this is that it's a big waste of taxpayor money, but clearly it is not really about who has the right to give away a free browser, and who doesn't.
 
Microsoft is not using a monopoly to compete in another market because it's the same market.
If you watch the Gates deposition in the US trial, you'll see that this does indeed come up. Ultimately it was decided that a web browser does not constitute an integral part of an OS.

So legally speaking, you are incorrect. Obviously the reality of the situation is not necessarily the same, and we can all make our own judgements on the matter.
 
...but I mean, who in their right mind (who's not a moron) would think this is an antitrust issue? Seriously? Is MS supposed to ship THEIR OS without a way to surf the web? Why is it an antitrust issue? I mean, without Windows, these other browsers really wouldn't have any type of user base. What exactly is the "market" in this situation? Microsofts very OWN operating system? Why should they have to include products from other companies/organizations in THEIR own product?

I really don't understand. If Mozilla just happened to create an OS of their own, should one expect them to include a copy of IE, or would one expect them to include their very own Firefox?
 
so I take it if you think the MS vs US case was wrong you can prove that? if that is the case why are you not on MS's payroll when they went to court. I am sure they would have appreciated your expertise in defending themselfs since you obviously know something that all MS lawyers didn't

but hey don't worry looks like you are just in time to help MS in this EU case so hurry along to help MS in court. I am sure with your expertise in corporate law will help MS win this case

You could try not being a jackass in every post you respond in.
 
What about YOUR expertise in corporate law? Is it gonna help MS lose the case, smart guy? ;)

NONE!!! and thats the point
I accept that experts in these fields (read the solicitors defending MS, solicitors from the US, solicitors from the EU not to mentions the judges that got to be a judge by becoming experts in their field over a number of years) know their stuff

I don't go around saying "they are wrong" because I am not in a position to say that, I do however accept the rulings simply because the people who are best to make the rulings are

so if you think the EU and US gov'n are wrong then do something about it (ie go and be a MS lawyer) instead of geekraging on a internet forum where you don't have to actually back up your statements
 
You could try not being a jackass in every post you respond in.

And you could start accepting that if a company breaks laws its gonna get taken to court
And if a company is accused of breaking laws then they will be investigated

these laws are open and MS knows of them
 
NONE!!! and thats the point
I accept that experts in these fields (read the solicitors defending MS, solicitors from the US, solicitors from the EU not to mentions the judges that got to be a judge by becoming experts in their field over a number of years) know their stuff

I don't go around saying "they are wrong" because I am not in a position to say that, I do however accept the rulings simply because the people who are best to make the rulings are

so if you think the EU and US gov'n are wrong then do something about it (ie go and be a MS lawyer) instead of geekraging on a internet forum where you don't have to actually back up your statements

Classic definition of the word Sheep. I wonder how you'd react if your precious Linux came under fire. Seeing how you react when the EU comes up, I think it's fairly predictable ;-)
 
Classic definition of the word Sheep. I wonder how you'd react if your precious Linux came under fire. Seeing how you react when the EU comes up, I think it's fairly predictable ;-)

So what was my views on the MS vs TomTom legal action discussion on this FrontPage news (RE TomTom using linux and the FAT filesystem)

You will find my views in that thread
 
Haha.

If you post a EU thread, you will ALWAYS find eeyjmr and the other EU trolls in it. Without fail... every single time. It reminds me of the BluRay HDDVD days when you always could count on the certain trolls showing up.
 
...breaking laws...

I stopped reading there, and won't read any of your posts from now on, and will even be unsubscribing from this thread. Who would ever have thought that including a piece of software with THEIR OWN software would be breaking a law?

Yeah. Enjoy everyone else who realizes how ridiculous your posts are. At least me leaving the thread will be one less person for you to attempt to poorly defend yourself against. Tootles! :p
 
I stopped reading there, and won't read any of your posts from now on, and will even be unsubscribing from this thread. Who would ever have thought that including a piece of software with THEIR OWN software would be breaking a law?

Yeah. Enjoy everyone else who realizes how ridiculous your posts are. At least me leaving the thread will be one less person for you to attempt to poorly defend yourself against. Tootles! :p

That isn't the issue and if you and others still think that you do not know the problems at hand
Have MS been taken for bundling MSPaint? for Notepad?
NO! but if they started using these apps to leaverage their monopoly THAT is illegal in all western countries

NOw go read up how MS used IE to hold onto their marketshare and then try and say that again...

Monopolies are not illegal but some means to gain or hold a monopoly are.
 
The whole thing is like saying it's unfair to have ford seats in a ford truck. We should have the option to put Toyota seats in the ford truck.

MS sells the Windows software and IE is a feature of that software. It's just more EU socialist BS in trying to screw the big guy in hopes of making the little guy feel better about himself.
 
Back
Top