Microsoft Gets Big Patent Verdict Overturned

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Microsoft is no doubt celebrating a federal court decision that just overturned a $388 million judgment against the company for patent infringement.

Tuesday's ruling is the latest twist in a case that has had plenty of them. Microsoft initially won a summary judgment ruling, which would have ended the case in its favor, but Uniloc appealed that ruling and a federal appeals court last year ruled that the case needed to go to trial with regard to two counts.
 
I think this is a good victory for MS.

Now they have the Canada's I4i XML crap left. BTW, is that an I or a L in that name, i'm reading that as eye4eye. I think someone was hurt by MS and wants revenge
 
As long as you have a legit patent and a working demo and stay with in the rules for filing, defend it to your death!
 
This is great news! I'm pretty sure everyone knew that this was going to get overturned anyway, or at least was fairly positive.

Patent trolls should be driven into the ground, but sometimes there are "legitimate" software patent infringement cases. A lot of these patents however should not have been granted in the first place. Software patents are very tricky and for the most part they are all too vague or broad to actually be patentable. Even those that are very detailed and specific sometimes shouldn't be awarded since they are not novel or don't really "invent" anything.
 
As long as you have a legit patent and a working demo and stay with in the rules for filing, defend it to your death!

Patents shouldn't even be granted without a working prototype, else anyone can just make wild designs and hope that one day it is moderately close to something patented.
 
Patents shouldn't even be granted without a working prototype, else anyone can just make wild designs and hope that one day it is moderately close to something patented.

Thats the ENTIRE point of having patents.
 
The problem I had with this was that XML / Word has been out for more than a decade I assume and they never bothered to bring it up until now. It's not like Microsoft was an unknown company. Just trolls looking at big targets hoping they would bend over backwards and pay up. Good ruling though.
 
The problem I had with this was that XML / Word has been out for more than a decade I assume and they never bothered to bring it up until now. It's not like Microsoft was an unknown company. Just trolls looking at big targets hoping they would bend over backwards and pay up. Good ruling though.

Wrong case. This one was about WGA.
 
Thats the ENTIRE point of having patents.

Which is why, patents are stupid.

"Oh I'll patent everything on earth, I don't know how to do it. But if someone figures it out, I'm off to make profit!"
 
I think this is a good victory for MS.

Now they have the Canada's I4i XML crap left. BTW, is that an I or a L in that name, i'm reading that as eye4eye. I think someone was hurt by MS and wants revenge

Yes it is pronounced eye4eye.
 
Back
Top