Microsoft Discusses Windows 7 Security

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Paul Cooke, the director of Windows Client Enterprise Security, took some time out of his busy schedule at the RSA Conference to blog about Windows 7 security enhancements. Pretty interesting stuff for those of you waiting on Windows 7.

We’re really excited about Windows 7’s new security features. This next OS is built upon the proven security technologies in Windows Vista and provides a fundamentally secure computing platform. We not only utilized enhanced Security Development Lifecycle (SDL) process during planning, development and testing but we also have worked to make the security features more discoverable, usable and manageable.
 
When is this coming out? I've been on the beta for months and I love it. Would probably be the first one that I actually buy (from my bookstore of course :)).
 
Every time I read things like this I always think how MS consistently fails to keep it simple. I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes. Why can't MS do the same? (Oh, and I use Vista as my main OS if it means any thing to you)
 
" I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes."

Security through obscurity is not security.
 
" I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes."

Security through obscurity is not security.

Not to sound like a d**k, but I don't see how your comment relates to my post. Are you saying that MS is implementing security through obscurity?

(And I've definitely been around long enough to know the principles of security, I just get tired of the never-ending debate)
 
I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes. Why can't MS do the same? (Oh, and I use Vista as my main OS if it means any thing to you)

No you don't. There is no other OS deployed as widely as Windows as with as many people trying to hack it. Until all other OS's have a billion deployments with a community of hackers working not for fun but for money there's no way to make this claim.
 
No you don't. There is no other OS deployed as widely as Windows as with as many people trying to hack it. Until all other OS's have a billion deployments with a community of hackers working not for fun but for money there's no way to make this claim.

+1.
 
No you don't. There is no other OS deployed as widely as Windows as with as many people trying to hack it. Until all other OS's have a billion deployments with a community of hackers working not for fun but for money there's no way to make this claim.

(and thus the debate begins)

This above argument is naive. Yes it is a contributing factor, but it to it the reason MS is attacked as often as it is excluding the myriad of other factors that play into this.

If the answer (or definition of the problem) were so clear cut, then we wouldn't have spent the last 10+ years arguing ways to "solve the problem". Unless there is a paradigm shift in the thinking in the way the products are produced/coded/etc, then we will continue to try to solve the problem for another 10 years.
 
Every time I read things like this I always think how MS consistently fails to keep it simple. I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes. Why can't MS do the same? (Oh, and I use Vista as my main OS if it means any thing to you)

Well, first of all, not all problems are simple. Not all solutions may need to be complex, but what if some are? In the end, it boils down to engineering: what works, and what doesn't. I'll let Microsoft try what they think might work, and if it doesn't, we'll know.
 
Well, first of all, not all problems are simple. Not all solutions may need to be complex, but what if some are? In the end, it boils down to engineering: what works, and what doesn't. I'll let Microsoft try what they think might work, and if it doesn't, we'll know.

I agree this isn't a simple problem. The point I was trying to make is that I've read (and used when released) these solutions for years, but I don't see any of the solutions making significant progress when it comes to security, yet the "solutions" keep getting more and more complicated.
 
I agree this isn't a simple problem. The point I was trying to make is that I've read (and used when released) these solutions for years, but I don't see any of the solutions making significant progress when it comes to security, yet the "solutions" keep getting more and more complicated.

maybe hackers are getting more and more better....

lol
 
(and thus the debate begins)

This above argument is naive. Yes it is a contributing factor, but it to it the reason MS is attacked as often as it is excluding the myriad of other factors that play into this.

If the answer (or definition of the problem) were so clear cut, then we wouldn't have spent the last 10+ years arguing ways to "solve the problem". Unless there is a paradigm shift in the thinking in the way the products are produced/coded/etc, then we will continue to try to solve the problem for another 10 years.

Why is it naive to think that if you have more brain power working on hacking Windows than other OS'es that Windows is harder to secure?

One could argue that lax Windows in the past has bought hackers to Windows. But if the same amount of resources focused on Windows were bought to bare on say OS X can you honestly say that OS X would stand up well?

One other point. The install base of Windows is simply an order of magnitude larger than all other desktop OS'es combined and a lot of those users simply aren't tech savvy. In my experience tech savvy folks just don't have issue with malware on Windows. Not saying it doesn't happen but it just rare as hell. I've not had ONE issue with malware in 15 years on any of my personal systems. Plenty of others can say the same with their Windows systems.
 
Every time I read things like this I always think how MS consistently fails to keep it simple. I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes. Why can't MS do the same? (Oh, and I use Vista as my main OS if it means any thing to you)

Preventing non-admin users from Installing and running certain applications on a company PC/Laptop will be a good feature. This is not convoluted. And with secure wireless, VPN, and unsecure Wi-Fi connections, having multiple Firewall policies that can be pre-set is also a nice feature. Network security is not a simple task to implement, and I don't see these changes as too complicated, or convoluted.
 
Preventing non-admin users from Installing and running certain applications on a company PC/Laptop will be a good feature. This is not convoluted. And with secure wireless, VPN, and unsecure Wi-Fi connections, having multiple Firewall policies that can be pre-set is also a nice feature. Network security is not a simple task to implement, and I don't see these changes as too complicated, or convoluted.

I agree, I don't see anything here that is complicated. What I see are features added to help system admins not anything to do with normal everyday users. Replacement for VPN, sounds good to me. More than just 1 firewall, again sounds good to me. As it is now, when I am at work I have one settings when plugged into the network, when I go outside the network I manually switch turn on more stuff. I want my machine to be seen on the network, I want to be pingable, I want to have remote desktop to it. When outside the network I would rather been hinden. If that can be automated then great.

Better ability to lock people from installing programs they shouldn't, sounds good to me and is a feature that a few secruity programs such as symantec endpoint protection (replacement for symantec antivirus corp. ed) have added awhile ago.

Ability to encrypt usb flash drives instead of just a harddrive or folder, again sounds good and isn't anything new.

BrancheCache isn't really for security but helps speed up things in remote offices to make it easier for people to do their jobs.

Back to directAccess. If a machine will "automatically" connect to the network when it is turned on and be accessable just like any other machine on the network from anywhere, as the article states that allows admins to mantain these machines a lot better. They can always ensure they have patches and up-to-date virus defs just like any machine that is always on the network. I will say that is one problem that I have now that I would like to use this feature to solve. I work for a small telco and we have many people with laptops out in the field that we can't manage. We have just have to hope that autoupdates do what they are suppose to and that any scans that we set to run will find anything that might get on the machine.

I don't see any of these being an end all for security concerns by any means, but I don't see them being complex for any system admin. On top of that I think they sound like some great new features.
 
Windows is only as secure as the users operating it. Why do brainless people constantly click on shit that they shouldn't? I don't remember they last time I actually had to clean off a virus that was actually destroying data like the good old days. Now it's all about the malware. I have to run a combofix malwarebytes combination to clean machines weekly because numnuts just have to click that damn popup or email. Come to find out our Antivirus server was about a year out of date and the barracuda was all jacked up... This is what happens when you let OSX Admins handle security.
 
Windows is only as secure as the users operating it. Why do brainless people constantly click on shit that they shouldn't? I don't remember they last time I actually had to clean off a virus that was actually destroying data like the good old days. Now it's all about the malware. I have to run a combofix malwarebytes combination to clean machines weekly because numnuts just have to click that damn popup or email. Come to find out our Antivirus server was about a year out of date and the barracuda was all jacked up... This is what happens when you let OSX Admins handle security.

We moved away from Barracuda a few years ago as we didnt' feel it was doing that good of a job. I was having to manually add rules to our mail server to manually block stuff. We moved to a different solution and our spam dropped down a lot. Before I started manually blocking stuff and was just letting the barracuda do it thing everyone was getting about 100 - 200 pieces of spam a day. After moving to current solution that dropped to about 4 - 6 a day.

As for the antivirus software being a year out of date. That is something that no admin should ever let happen. It isn't that hard to check at the very least once a week or so to ensure you have current definitions.
 
Every time I read things like this I always think how MS consistently fails to keep it simple. I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes. Why can't MS do the same? (Oh, and I use Vista as my main OS if it means any thing to you)

What's so convoluted about, say, UAC? You get a prompt asking you to confirm intention whenever anything tires to do anything. Rather than use complex algorithms to determine if an action is safe or malicious, it just asks you, "did you do that?". Sounds pretty simple to me.

Also, security solutions sometimes need to be convoluted - to confuse the hackers. Simple solutions also have simple workarounds.
 
When is this coming out? I've been on the beta for months and I love it. Would probably be the first one that I actually buy (from my bookstore of course :)).

It look like Release Candidate 1 will be made available to the general public in the first week of May.

The latest rumors I've seen say that MS is pushing for full retail release in October, but I think the official target MS has given is still just q4 '09/q1 '10 (obviously October is at the beginning of that timeframe).

There will be a lag of several months between when it goes "gold" (rtm) and when it hits retail, because they have to wait for the OEMs to get up to speed and shit like that :(.
 
We moved away from Barracuda a few years ago as we didnt' feel it was doing that good of a job. I was having to manually add rules to our mail server to manually block stuff. We moved to a different solution and our spam dropped down a lot. Before I started manually blocking stuff and was just letting the barracuda do it thing everyone was getting about 100 - 200 pieces of spam a day. After moving to current solution that dropped to about 4 - 6 a day.

As for the antivirus software being a year out of date. That is something that no admin should ever let happen. It isn't that hard to check at the very least once a week or so to ensure you have current definitions.

Yea Barracuda is gone after this month and I have taken ownership of our AV server.
When I ask these guys wth they were thinking letting that box expire, they just pointed fingers at each other.
 
Every time I read things like this I always think how MS consistently fails to keep it simple. I see other OSes manage to stay secure without implementing convoluted and proprietary security schemes. Why can't MS do the same? (Oh, and I use Vista as my main OS if it means any thing to you)

Could you name a few that are as widely used?
 
Back
Top