Microsoft Denies WMP Vulnerability

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Microsoft Security Response Center blog says that rumors of a Windows Media Player vulnerability are flat out false. The MSRC team says that the only thing the proof of concept code is able to do is crash WMP (which can be restarted immediately) and has no impact on the rest of the system.

If you haven’t seen it, there was a report about a possible issue affecting all versions of Microsoft Windows Media player. The security researcher making the initial report didn’t contact us or work with us directly but instead posted the report along with proof of concept code to a public mailing list. After that report, other organizations picked the report up and claimed that the issue was a code execution vulnerability in Windows Media Player. Those claims are false.
 
Ok so according to MS the "proof of concept code" can't perform bad stuff...but it can still crash Media Player? That still sucks ass, no?
 
Ok so according to MS the "proof of concept code" can't perform bad stuff...but it can still crash Media Player? That still sucks ass, no?

Yea but vulnerability != bug even though the other way around works. This issue will no doubt turn into a semantic pissing contest.
 
Why use anything other than VLC? WMP is a pile of junk, especially in the codec department.
 
Why use anything other than VLC? WMP is a pile of junk, especially in the codec department.

That's your opinion. I'm sure many disagrees with you. WMP11 is just flat out awesome.

As for the codec department, you can thank those who tried to drag Microsoft through monopoly lawsuits. Microsoft purposefully left out many codecs so third party can sell theirs.

Install CCCP and you won't have to worry about it anymore.
 
That's your opinion. I'm sure many disagrees with you. WMP11 is just flat out awesome.

As for the codec department, you can thank those who tried to drag Microsoft through monopoly lawsuits. Microsoft purposefully left out many codecs so third party can sell theirs.

Install CCCP and you won't have to worry about it anymore.

Plus according to many people trying out the leaked Beta's of Windows 7 WMP now includes a lot if not all of the codecs needed.

I use WMP for some things and MPC for other's. All depends on what I'm doing.

Back on topic though this bug will be fixed. MS won't leave it there especially with it in the open. What they're stating is that it isn't a security hole that will let somebody take over your PC.
 
If my media player crashes when I am in the middle of pleasuring myself to some sweet
lesbian furry hentai, there will be hell to pay.
 
in some ways MS is right since this "vulnerability" is pretty much just a DoS of that application, extreamly minor

I just find it amusing that they are coming out to say that this kind of code bug isn't a vulnerability WHEN a couple of years ago they went on a bughunt compare of windows,OSX and Linux to show that Windows is patched faster and has less vulnerabilites ((basically the VAST majority of the linux bugs were app DoS bugs just like this one in WMP)

fix it when there it time, but don't pull dev's off other more critical projects/problems to fix this benign problem
 
2nd tuesday of the month is when patches come out unless it is detrimental to the information on the affected pc's.
 
Why use anything other than VLC? WMP is a pile of junk, especially in the codec department.

VLC? LOL... if you want to talk about junk in the codec department, VLC is horrible. It has flawed multicore support which results in random lag, flawed dxva hardware decoding support or lack thereof, it allows remote execute of vulnerable code in almost all it's builds, it's subtitle implementation is flawed for various media types, it reads mkv containers wrong whenever it feels like it, it doesn't give you selectability for multiple audio tracks whenever it feels like it, it's playlist functionality is still buggy even in the newest version, the video playback customization is a trainwreck, etc, etc, etc.

MPC > *
 
VLC? LOL... if you want to talk about junk in the codec department, VLC is horrible. It has flawed multicore support which results in random lag, flawed dxva hardware decoding support or lack thereof, it allows remote execute of vulnerable code in almost all it's builds, it's subtitle implementation is flawed for various media types, it reads mkv containers wrong whenever it feels like it, it doesn't give you selectability for multiple audio tracks whenever it feels like it, it's playlist functionality is still buggy even in the newest version, the video playback customization is a trainwreck, etc, etc, etc.

MPC > *

^--- Sums it up pretty well.

The only reason I even have VLC is because it's a nice self-contained piece of software I can leave on my USB key in case I need a (mediocre) player immediately, or can't install codecs on the current system.
 
in some ways MS is right since this "vulnerability" is pretty much just a DoS of that application, extreamly minor

I just find it amusing that they are coming out to say that this kind of code bug isn't a vulnerability WHEN a couple of years ago they went on a bughunt compare of windows,OSX and Linux to show that Windows is patched faster and has less vulnerabilites ((basically the VAST majority of the linux bugs were app DoS bugs just like this one in WMP)

Source? Because I don't believe you.
 
Source? Because I don't believe you.

http://letmegooglethatforyou.com/?q=windows-secure-linux

... kids these days with their short memories, rudeness and inability todo anything for themselves

There have been many a study of the years, every single one thrown up SEVER anomalies, inconsistencies, prejudice and assumptions as well as stretches of the actual truth.

such studies have even been posted on these forums over the years and each one has been torn to bits from both sides

so how about you learn to use the machine you are sitting infront of next time...
 
If my media player crashes when I am in the middle of pleasuring myself to some sweet lesbian furry hentai, there will be hell to pay.

Post of the thread. Nobody's topping this.
agreed.. I almost LOL'ed at work.

^--- Sums it up pretty well.

The only reason I even have VLC is because it's a nice self-contained piece of software I can leave on my USB key in case I need a (mediocre) player immediately, or can't install codecs on the current system.
That is its only saving grace. I typically use a combo of winamp/mpc w/ klite codecs. winamp for most of my stuff and MPC for anything else that doesn't run or anything that needs codecs or dual-audio.
 
Back
Top