Microsoft Defends Against Antitrust Case with Apple Examples

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
While Apple and Microsoft certainly have no love lost between the two companies, it certainly doesn’t stop MS from using Apple as an example in its ongoing defense against an Xbox antitrust case against Datel. Check out the summary of the argument in the quote. Do you agree?

If Apple can prevent another computer maker from selling unauthorized Mac OS X machines, then Microsoft should be able to stop another accessory vendor from selling unauthorized Xbox 360 plugins loaded with video-game cheats.
 
While this isn't a good example, I've often thought that Apple tends to get away with practices as bad or worse than anything commited by Microsoft. I imagine it'd be VERY easy for Microsoft to use the Apple defence in the future. Apple have created a vast catalog of shocking examples that make Microsoft look like Mother Teresa.
 
If this was just a case of a company selling a memory stick at a better price, I'd be sympathetic, but all the cheats lead me to believe that MS probably should win for that alone.

I'm less certain that their defense based on the Psystar case is relevant. Psystar is installing software on non-apple hardware. This case seems like more like Apple preventing someone from writing/installing an app on their Apple computer. Alternatively, it's like Apple saying you can't install an app on your iPhone/iPod touch.....sure apple does that, but there's no case, that I'm aware, of that says that apple can or cannot do that.
 
I think this is an excellent example of why MS cannot be prosecuted unless Apple is as well. It's funny that an great company like MS that promotes open development and community interaction is seen as the evil giant. While Apple places extremely strict regulations on all their hardware and software, and individually decides if an app is allowed to be distributed. Apple is an evil tyrant, that thrives on the non-power users of the world. Made for the stereotypical college kids and stay at home mom's who need a $2,000 laptop to shop online and surf the net. I always laugh when I see someone who spent $2,000 on $1,000 worth of hardware.
 
anyone here remember the great "you can't make a IBM clone" lawsuits? or the "hey! that mouse is mine" I think it all comes down to the Jury, Judge and what phase the moon is in, no consistancy in the results of these lawsuits at all
 
Hmm, while I think Microsoft is well within its rights to restrict the sale of unlicensed goods, its kind of an apples-and-oranges case here (no pun intended) when comparing the 360 with the Mac. You can use any hard drive, memory card, monitor, printer, whatever accessory you want with a Mac. There is no license required, it just needs to be able to plug into a USB or Firewire port.

Microsoft has the XBox locked down tight, you need a license to produce anything for it, period, and third parties are 1000% locked out of producing hard drives and memory cards. Microsoft are well within their rights to defend that since they are in control of the license for accessories. That said, using the Mac as an example as a closed-end system doesn't really work as it isn't closed to accessories, which is what the case against Microsoft is all about.

The big restriction with the Mac is that OS X needs to be used on Apple hardware. This is something Microsoft could make a case for if people were selling third party hardware with the XBox 360 OS installed on it (oh boy would they have a case), but this isn't happening, nothing close to it is happening because nothing like the triple-core PPC CPU it uses is on the open market.

Its not really a 1:1 case here since Microsoft is using the OS/hardware example to back up their case, which has little to do with locking out third party accessories. I would think that holding the license on the 360 would be enough of a defense for them, but maybe not.
 
And I'll be honest, while I do defend Microsoft's right to control their platform, I hope that this results in a more open platform. The 360 is locked down tighter than any other device I own. The main place this bothers me is 360 hard drive expansion, its crap, 120GB for exorbitant prices. At the same time I can put any 2.5" SATA hard drive into my PS3, not to mention use any BT headset, any wireless keyboard, any wireless mouse, etc etc.

In the end Microsoft and Sony can choose to do business in any way they wish. I don't put it past Microsoft to milk as much as they can from the 360 teat with their accessory sales, but as a consumer it would be nice if they treated the 360 more like Sony does the PS3. :)
 
I think Microsoft would have been better to go after the company for selling something they didnt want them selling and seeing if they could win rather than disabling it completely. This causes problems for the people who already own them. These things are likely sitting in shelves still, and wont sell now, where as if Microsoft had gone to the company or taken them to court to stop them, it could have been much smoother.
 
I think this case is a 99% chance of a win for MS. I wonder if it was MS funding Psystar lawyers. It may have been using Psystar as Devil's Advocate for the case against Apple, where they were to try out every defense imaginable(it they were pretty good defenses if you followed the case). If it was, I think it was money well spent by MS.
 
Back
Top